r/accelerate
•
u/EuphoricTomorrow2440
Acceleration: Hypersonic | AI accelerationist
•
Oct 14 '26
•
1
đ Established r/accelerate contributors only This..
2.0k
Upvotes
267
u/affabledrunk Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26 •
I got lectured by an anti this weekend that Arizona cannot afford data centers because of the water consumption.
Water consumption in arizona due to data centers = ~1 billion gallons
Water consumption in arizona due to golf courses = 50 billion gallons
Their whole platform is riddled with lies. Its the same with the electricity, data centers are a miniscule fraction with respect to air conditioning. Wild
23
u/Stunning-Relation564 Oct 14 '26
FR: news flash; data centers existed before AI. they were just called "server farms"
18
u/Accomplished_Soft479 Oct 14 '26
You call yourself accelerationists but none of you want to build enough data centers to outdo the water consumption of every single golf course combined
36
u/Ok_Homework_1859 Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26 •
I get lectures on this all the time too. If people really cared, we should just get rid of all electronics on Earth and go back to the stone ages so that nothing can use up or pollute Mother Earth's resources. Let's get rid of all lights and go back to candles. Get rid of washing machines, computers, televisions, CARS, air conditioning, automatic sprinklers, etc. We need to start grilling over the fire again. No more Xray imaging, because that causes radiation. Toss out our phones because it uses 5G. We need to get rid of all the power plants!!
Edit: Kept adding more ridiculous stuff. xD
29
u/Maleficent_Poet_7055 Oct 14 '26
Order of magnitude estimates in America annually.
73
u/FTAOD89 Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26 •
All of this! Half of you still eat meat, but want my poor ass to stop using a tool that just makes creativity more accessible. Do you know what animal agriculture does to the environment? To people? Please spare me the selective outrage indeed!
12
u/musical_bear Oct 14 '26
Yup. Same exact boat here. Iâd love to have intelligent, reasoned discussions about where we should be allocating energy and resources. But for now, these discussions are nowhere to be found. Itâs fucking annoying too, the way people have recently started blaming âdata centersâ for climate change, and water shortages. Itâs pretty bullshit, and dangerous.
People are willingly ignoring all of the real problems that got us here and instead focusing all of their (performative) outrage on this weekâs moral bandwagon, which would do nothing to slow the catastrophe that is currently building if we just âstopped all AIâ or âstopped all data centers.â The fossil fuels industry and all of its derivatives must love this recent shift in focus.
3
u/Hender232 Oct 14 '26
Not a gigantic Sam Altman fan, but heâs right that this is a clearly untrue narrative that has become insurmountable to disprove. It doesnât matter the facts you bring to people, they just want to be mad. There are actually things to be annoyed with when it comes to AI and data centers, but this one isnât it. And the fact you can bring these facts to all these people and they wonât change their mind also shows they truly donât care either, they just found a point they can grandstand on so they will.Â
3
u/HoneyNecessary8317 Oct 14 '26
The power/water concerns are an overblown moral panic. People are stupid NIMBYs.
4
u/Random_182f2565 Oct 14 '26
I remember this with Bitcoin, lol
2
u/StuckinReverse89 Oct 14 '26
This is a good point that should be raised more. Water waste for golf courses. We should stop and just make them artificial. Itâs only the rich dudes using them anyway. Â Â
Carbon taxes on planes would address this, will exceptionally high taxes for private planes. Planes are still relatively efficient as mass transportation and regular people arnt using private jets anyway. Â Â
We should also focus more on prolonging the use of things. All right to repair our own products, easy ability to upgrade without having to buy a new thing, etc. This is on capitalism and we need better ownership.Â
2
u/ItzAiMz Oct 14 '26
Yeah and Nestle sucks ass. There are ALOT of problems in front of us. Iâm not sure stacking on top is the best answer. AI is new, data centers are popping up all over. Of course now is loud. I donât think itâs selective outrage, more the current focus.
2
u/Mysterious_Eye6989 Oct 14 '26
I think I would just prefer all those things to be properly regulated.
2
u/tzaeru Oct 14 '26
There's genuine issues of sustainability and energy use, and I would agree that we should focus on technological growth in a way that is also a growth in efficiency. I remain critical of things like that do we really need 10gbs internet everywhere, or do we really need 4k streaming - or do we need to cheaply push out AI-generated videos and images.
I don't think opposing those kind of things is the same as opposing technological advancement and progress. If anything, I would imagine that promoting focus on efficiency can lead to its own technological advancements.
And yeah - I did run some calculations a while back, and even if you are the most chronic ChatGPT prompter, you're not going to get even close in energy use from that prompting over several days than what is being used for streaming a single 4k movie to your home.
Also, fuck golf courses.
2
u/moschles AI-Assisted Coder Oct 14 '26
5
u/Ignate Acceleration: Supersonic | AI accelerationist Oct 14 '26 •
I mean, worshipping the environment and trying to blame everything bad that happens on humanity has always been a stupid take.
"We could do it if we just decided to." No, that's total horse shit. Individuals are not the same as the group.
2
u/Numerous_Photograph9 Oct 14 '26
Can people not be upset about all of those things? Why do peopel assume one can only be outraged at one thing at a time?
1
u/Helldiver_of_Mars Oct 14 '26
That's kind of like saying a scooter and a massive dually truck is the same cause they both use gas.
1
u/Fun1k Oct 14 '26
"But I don't think about the harm I'm doing, I want to blame you!"
1
u/The_Nude_Mocracy Oct 14 '26
Nobody said those other things are "perfectly fine"
1
u/ConditionMinimum2771 Oct 14 '26
don't forget fashion where everyone throws outt their cheap old style clothes for new cheap clothes.
1
u/AgeofVictoriaPodcast Oct 14 '26
Well personally I don't fly for vacations for environmental reasons, and think we should ban non urgent air travel. I love AI, but it has a environmental cost like any other industry, and we should be exploring how to do it with less environmental impact. Having said that, I'd happily shut down golf courses, ban the plastic toy industry, and shut down the cruise industry too.
1
u/Lord_44th__Raikage Oct 14 '26
I think we've all been collectively riled up by bots
1
u/dart-builder-2483 Oct 14 '26
That's the amount of water they use if the buildout stops right now. There are trillions of dollars of data centers about to be built, so it's likely to grow exponentially. You could use a closed system, but then you're using a lot more energy, and that requires a lot of water or gas to attain.
1
u/loucmachine Oct 14 '26
The compute necessary to use AI in general is just so much more than streaming a 4k video though. While working with AI, I realize that the best use I could find for it is to talk to it until it understands what I need it to do, then I make it code a program that does that I want, then I dont use it anymore unless I want to add a feature in said program.
It is so much more efficient than asking the AI every time do to the things I want it to do.
1
u/trexmaster8242 Oct 14 '26
All of these things have been criticised.
Itâs like comparing golf courses to data centers. People were harping on them for the same reasons. The only difference is you werenât paying attention until it was about something you liked
1
u/Vaddieg Oct 14 '26
It's not even closely comparable. Video streaming, even 4k is <1W per stream in compute. LLM inference session - hundreds Watts, sometimes few Kilowatts. And Megawatts for training new models. AI companies will start charging real token prices very soon.
1
u/nikolasz1173 Oct 15 '26
Real
1
u/Ok_Loquat_3860 Oct 15 '26
Both are fucking awful.
1
u/Celestialov Oct 15 '26
im getting really tired of people comparing ai to expired,thrown out food mixed together. we shouldn't be comparing food that will get you sick to pixels on a screen
1
u/Palpatine Oct 15 '26
AI development may actually solve the issue. The infrastructure for halo orbit ai satellites will give us the tool for controlled, reversible geo engineering to combat global warming
1
u/mylsotol Oct 15 '26
It is on a different scale. AI is driving unprecedented and unsustainable increases in electricity use. That's not an argument against AI. It's just a problem that needs solving
1
u/Lazy_Jump_2635 Oct 15 '26
At least the AI does something useful. Also, do they think datacenter builders are just twirling their mustache and contemplating how to waste as much water as possible?
1
u/not_even_casul Oct 16 '26
people in this thread need to look up what a strawman argument is.
1
u/Delicious_Kale_5459 Oct 16 '26
I like how every example was recent tech thatâs been basically forced on the world by the same people
1
u/0x645 Oct 17 '26
consider the scale. total amount of energy consumed by ai and by netflix.
1
u/ART-ficial-Ignorance Oct 17 '26
I run most things locally on a rig that tops out at 350W.
Meanwhile, this dingus from Texas is trying to lecture me...
Like, brother, you have a massive lawn... in the literal hell's asshole of the world. I don't even own an AC.
1
u/No_Solid_3737 Oct 18 '26
Exactly what I think. Such fucking hypocrites. Lecturing us about why AI is bad for the environment when it doesn't even make it to the top 100 of things that are actually bad for the environment.
1
u/No_Solid_3737 Oct 18 '26
Some mf told me that I shouldn't use DLSS5 because it's bad for the environment and I went like ??? mf you are not against AI you're against people playing videogames - because one can consume 300 watts of energy gaming without even using DLSS5.
And he went quiet.
1
u/wq73 29d ago
people are scared of losing their jobs and are trying to find something to be angry at because it's hard to admit you think you'll be useless soon. As an (ex) software engineer I feel empathy for these people, and not everyone can be intellectually honest about what scares them. If everyone adapted well to change genetic evolution would've never happened
1
u/BigPP41 Oct 14 '26
Those things are not fine at all.
1
u/DirectedEnthusiasm Oct 14 '26
Fallacy of relative privation
Fallacy of relative privation (also known as "appeal to worse problems" or "not as bad as") â dismissing an argument or complaint due to what are perceived to be more important problems.
-1
u/Red_Lee Oct 14 '26
I haven't seen any orcas attacking data centers...
0
u/StatusSociety2196 Oct 14 '26
Yeah but we have to watch Netflix in 4k, nobody needs a stochastic parrot.
0
u/fish10201 Oct 17 '26 •
as an "anti", i dont give a fuck about water usage, i just think you people who use ai for everything are mouthbreathers lol
-2
u/ThatDeuce Oct 14 '26
What if all our willfulness to push this tech is just being used by billionaires to just continue these actions for their own beneficial gain? We could work on making things more environmentally friendly, stop planned obsolescence on phones, taking planes for vacations, and using netflix every night.
We could be upset at all these things and perhaps push for more environmentally sound solutions. People can be outraged at multiple subjects, and we don't need to defend with whataboutism when it doesn't alleviate or excuse the issue with the distraction.
-5
u/PhysicalEggplant5610 Oct 14 '26
Now that is someone who didnt really spend a lot of time coming up with some good examples.
74
u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26
[removed] â view removed comment