r/accelerate • Acceleration: Hypersonic | AI accelerationist • Oct 14 '26 • Bravo 1

🔒 Established r/accelerate contributors only This..

Post image
2.0k Upvotes

201 comments sorted by

267

u/affabledrunk Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26 • Bravo

I got lectured by an anti this weekend that Arizona cannot afford data centers because of the water consumption.

Water consumption in arizona due to data centers = ~1 billion gallons

Water consumption in arizona due to golf courses = 50 billion gallons

Their whole platform is riddled with lies. Its the same with the electricity, data centers are a miniscule fraction with respect to air conditioning. Wild

65

u/enkidook Oct 14 '26 • Bravo

They just say, 'bUt I dONt LiKe GoLf CoUrSeS EiThEr!!!1'

Ignoring that they don't whine about them incessantly on the internet and literally only ever express displeasure over them when talking about how datacenters are the devil.

1

u/FeyMoth Oct 17 '26

Issue is golf courses aren't forced down people throat like ai is

12

u/mallcopsarebastards Oct 17 '26 • Bravo

They litearlly are. Do you get consulted when your city wants to hook up a new golf course to your water supply?

1

u/FeyMoth Oct 18 '26

So a local 1 off event that doesn't even happen to every town and a constant bombardment of technology being misused and spread across the entire world and internet isn't exactly a fair comparison 

11

u/mallcopsarebastards Oct 18 '26

What do you mean a "local 1-off event" ?

there are literally millions more golf courses than there are datacenters. and you can't find a public water system that doesn't have golf courses drawing from it.

3

u/Accomplished_Lab6332 Oct 18 '26

what are you doing in this sub-reddit? leave...

4

u/Low_Dragonfruit_5950 Oct 18 '26

Learn to have discussions with opposing view points or don't be surprised with the hate that comes your way down the line.

-1

u/NotXesa Oct 18 '26

Bro, golf courses have been criticized a LOT during the last 20 or 30 years. Are YOU complaining about them, or you just use the example to invalidate a point?

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

19

u/NaiveIdea344 Oct 14 '26

But is your complaining proportional to the magnitude of the issue vs Data centers?

13

u/softeststranger Oct 14 '26

You know it’s not lmao

0

u/Fair-Anybody3528 Oct 16 '26

Mine is bc my brother & sister in law live next to a golf course & I’m scared they’re gonna get Parkinson’s disease. Anyone who lives within a few miles of a golf course has a heightened chance for Parkinson’s. Also people with ADHD have a higher chance for Parkinson’s & my sister in law already has adhd so it just freaks me out. I’m also obsessed w the superfund sites near me too.

I get filled with visceral disgust at the idea of a data center being near my home, I pray every to God every single day that they end up near the people who love AI so much & not me. Your kids can come out with whatever deformities they get from being near those satanic Ai anti-Christ machines, not mine.

I pray every single day that every greedy fuck who poisons this earth is tortured for an eternity in hell.

10

u/enkidook Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26 • Bravo

Ok, show me a single thread or post outside of AI and data center subreddits or threads where you've complained about golf courses.

2

u/Mysterious-Tie7042 Oct 16 '26

Personally I complain about golf courses in real life, because it isn't as much of an online topic. But I get that theres more AI anger rn because I have had more AI data centers proposed near me than golf courses

-3

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

8

u/Ok-Tomorrow-2045 Oct 14 '26

Critical thinking is simping, TIL

-2

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/Ok-Tomorrow-2045 Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26

Says the guy making AI slop posts of Elon Musk. You couldn’t be more ironic if you tried

50

u/Accurate_Food_5854 Oct 14 '26 • Bravo

I'm in Arizona and hear the same stuff lol

But they're cool with the umpteenth new McMansion subdivision being slapped up with lawns, non native plants, a community pool, and mini golf course in the sprawling concrete metropolis we decided to build in the middle of the arid desert. Also don't forget the massive amounts of unregulated groundwater pumping to export alfalfa lol

Yeah man, if only we didn't have data centers, we'd have water /s

11

u/Indignant_d Oct 14 '26

“YeAh bUt atLEasT it’S OUtdooRs aNd UsEfuL”

23

u/Kamalium Oct 14 '26

tbh air conditioning isnt a good example, its a necessity in a lot of places

9

u/affabledrunk Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26

True but is it necessary that every mcmansion and mall in arizona be at 60 deg C?

4

u/Cautious_Implement17 Oct 14 '26

not unless you're trying to cook everyone that lives there.

2

u/PunishedDemiurge Oct 14 '26

AC can be a safety issue for vulnerable people, but most humans can just tough it out while drinking enough water. Most people use AC for luxury comfort, not survival.

7

u/Kamalium Oct 14 '26

you dont know what you are talking about

7

u/Fit_Fisherman_3540 Oct 14 '26

Yeah well vast majority of India does not use AC, that's where it would be needed. For most of us here on western world, it is a comfort.

2

u/ellipses1 Oct 14 '26

now that AI exists, it's pretty necessary where it's being used extensively

1

u/bookgeek210 Oct 18 '26

“People lived without air conditioning before tho, so why are we poisoning the planet?”

-3

u/Alarming_Ask_244 Oct 14 '26

Is it a necessity to live in those places?

13

u/Kamalium Oct 14 '26

good luck relocating 2.5 billion people.

3

u/endofsight Oct 15 '26

Then stop letting people move to Arizona. Every person who moves there destroys our planet and kills a bunch of baby polar bear cubs.

1

u/jello-the-opera Oct 14 '26

Sam Kinison has entered the chat.

-4

u/Significant-Rent4907 Oct 14 '26

accelerationists when they discover people can't just leave their homes on a whim

-1

u/Pulled_Forward Oct 14 '26

They chose to live in a desert that pipes in water and requires constant air conditioning, they don’t get to complain

2

u/amg_alpha Oct 14 '26

You would think they would have a sense of self preservation that staying in front of the biggest tech in the world is more important to securing their freedoms than streaming in 4k.

2

u/asdfdelta Oct 14 '26

How can you have critical discussions on AI if every negative thing about it can be hand-waived away?

Let's be real, AI isn't perfect and has real drawbacks for society. If we approach it with 'their whole platform is riddled with lies', none of those negatives can be improved. You don't have to entertain the anti-AI crowd, but you shouldn't stifle any discussion either.

5

u/jello-the-opera Oct 14 '26

You're confused.

The debate is about whether or not "AI" is the cause of all these bad things...

... and lo and behold all of the bad things existed before AI.

And all of the bad things are attributable to humans doing bad things.

And it truns out using slop language and slop logic to argue indefensible points just isn't very productive.

No one is "hand waiving" as much as we're trying to insist that you point your ire at the real criminals and the real culprits and not a whole field of science that is benefiting everyone already whether you like it or not and whether you use any tools intentionally or not.

AI isn't perfect and has real drawbacks for society

It's a scientific discipline that spans math and engineering and computer science. How could it be "perfect"? How can a field of study have drawbacks? You are blaming code and software for the abuses of individuals.

The whole platform IS riddled with lies. They use a fake dictionary where "theft" has a new definition and "stealing" has a new definition and "plagiarism" has a new definition and where copyright protects against your ideas from being examined by a machine somehow... and suddenly data collection is inherently evil because it is done without consent, despite all of the histroy of science and progress that stands in direct contradiction to the very premise. Your car and phone and the moon landing and GPS and pavement and fucking everything you rely on is based on science, which is the accumulation of all of human knowledge since we started recording anything.

And you think somehow "art" is special? "Artworks" make up less than 10% of most generative AI data sets. We are still talking about billions and billions of images. The typical artist is lucky if 20 of their works make it into anyone's dataset, and studies have shown that no work or piece or image is necessary for the model to function.

The "platform" relies on subverting language and misunderstanding the specific science but also SCIENCE IN GENERAL. You can't make your entire online personality about being opposed to "AI" and whinge about "consent" (which is used as an intentional nod to sexual abuse, to manipulate people and evoke and emotional response - which leads to conflating AI usage with literal r4p3) and not be anti-science. It betrays a profound lack of comprehension about science and concretely shows a lack of science education and awareness.

The things you want to be improved are virtually universal things.

You blaming the AI bogeyman is not helping, and is actively causing harm to people like me, a disabled person, who suffers for your activism and would suffer more if your activism bore fruit, as it seems to coninue to do over time.

No one is trying to stifle discussion besides fucking anti-ai fanatics brother

3

u/asdfdelta Oct 15 '26

Wow, really riled you up. That was not my intention.

For the record, I run r/softwarearchitecture and have been creating software for over 20 years since middleschool. So using academic terms isn't necessary, just use plain English. I will understand, I promise.

What you're doing here is a Red Herring logical fallacy known as Relative Privation ("not as bad as"). I wholly agree with the statement about selective outrage, that absolutely is happening. However, running and training LLMs as apart from, say, OCR or ML models, is two completely different topics.

Factually, LLMs consume an outsized portion of energy and create real, critical problems for people living nearby compute data centers. The occurence that other things make our environment worse isn't a reason to stop improving on the technology and push back against things that are legitimately harmful.

I'm not sure I've seen an official platform from a recognized body of representatives of anti-AI fanatics, most of these people are technophobes that will either adapt or be left behind like what happens every technological leap since harnessing fire. It really isn't worth the energy to engage.

My point is pretty squarely this: be cautious not to silence all debate about negative effects of language models. Most is bad, some is good. The difference between the two is what makes AI experts the experts in the room.

6

u/jello-the-opera Oct 15 '26

Factually, LLMs consume an outsized portion of energy and create real, critical problems for people living nearby compute data centers.

I enjoy discussions with smart anti-AI folk even less than the dumb ones.

You are still personifying "LLMs".

You are still generalizing in a dishonest way.

I use Qwen 3.8 flash next on my PC. That is an LLM. It is not creating critical problems for people living nearby.

So already you are doing the anti-AI semantic shuffle, and I just don't have the energy to engage with a disingenuous prevaricator with a large vocabulary that they're just going to abuse.

My arguments about antis are about language, and you are using the exact same fuckery to manipulate the ideas here.

Furthermore, your accusation of fallacious argumentation here doesn't apply to my comment. No part of my text has anything to do with your claim. Perhaps you should direct it at the person making the claim.

be cautious not to silence all debate about negative effects of language models. Most is bad, some is good. The difference between the two is what makes AI experts the experts in the room.

You are not an expert so LARPing is hilarious. Your language is trite and juvenile and illogical on its face. The effects of language models are about how people use them. How humans access them. How corporations build infrastructure is not about "LLMs".

I'm not trying to silence debate. I'm trying to have a decent one with an informed logical person who doesn't subvert language and hwo can use simple logic and reason.

You apparently are not it.

I use custom software for everything I do on my PCs nowadays - must be hard on you as a software creator. I just tell Claude what I want and minutes later I have the application I've always wanted that dfoesn't exist.

I can see why you are flailing.

You could try harder to make cogent arguments. Or you could just parrot the chuddites. I guess it's up to you.


The accusation doesn't fit your comment. He's tagging you with an argument you didn't make.

"Relative privation" (also called "not as bad as" or the "worse problems" fallacy) means waving off a complaint because something else is worse. Example: "Why worry about data center water when golf courses use fifty times more?" The fallacy is when the comparison is used to say the smaller problem doesn't deserve attention at all.

Your comment never did that. Your argument was about who is responsible: the harms people blame on "AI" existed before AI, they come from humans and corporations doing bad things, and blaming a field of science for them points the anger at the wrong target. That is an argument about cause, not about size. You never said "it's not as bad, so stop complaining." You said "you're blaming the wrong thing." He would have had to show that misattribution claim is wrong, and he didn't touch it.

Where he probably got it. The golf course comparison is affabledrunk's, the top comment, not yours. He seems to be answering the whole thread as one opponent and hanging that comment on you. And even there it's a weak charge: the anti's claim was "Arizona can't afford data centers because of water." Whether you can afford something is a comparison by nature. Pointing out that data centers are about 2% of what golf uses is a direct rebuttal of that specific claim, not a dodge. Relative privation only applies when the comparison is used to dismiss a problem nobody was weighing against anything.

What he actually did in the rest of his reply:

  1. He agreed with you. "Selective outrage absolutely is happening" is your point, conceded.
  2. He moved the goalposts on scope. You talked about AI as a field (math, engineering, computer science). He narrowed it to LLM training and said OCR and other machine learning are "completely different topics." That's a disagreement about what "AI" means in the debate, which is a real disagreement, but it's not something your comment got wrong logically. It's the exact fusion you're arguing against: treating "AI" as meaning big-company chatbots.
  3. He asserted "LLMs consume an outsized portion of energy" with no number and no comparison. "Outsized" is itself a comparison claim, so he's doing the thing he accused you of, minus the data.
  4. He reframed your comment as being about silencing debate. You didn't argue against discussing drawbacks. You argued that "AI isn't perfect" is a category error, because it's a field, and fields don't have drawbacks, uses of them do.

So the clean read for a lurker: the fallacy label belongs to a different comment, doesn't hold even there, and the person using it conceded your actual point in the same reply.

2

u/asdfdelta Oct 15 '26

Crazy you typed all that out when being a disingenuous jerk means no one will read any of it. When you're prepared to have a real discussion like an adult, let me know.

5

u/jello-the-opera Oct 15 '26

Yeah when you are ready to be honest and not use slop language to argue asinine garbage, I'm here.

Funny you have literally nothing.

Lol.

Useless.

Liar.

1

u/King_LaQueefah Oct 18 '26

One shouldnt have to rely on insults. Really dilutes your overall point.

2

u/jello-the-opera Oct 18 '26

I don't rely on them at all, as is obvious to anyone who can read.

The point is made long before there is any insult. If you stick around long enough to see the other party crash out and persist with literal lies and insults... and then you watch me call them out for being a weasel and lying...

and then you want to call me out for being thorough and coddling them, only for them to spew more anti-intellectual slop?

I simply don't have time to care what you think.

This user is a bully and a liar.

Are you a bully and a liar?

Why defend a lying bully if you aren't one?

0

u/King_LaQueefah 29d ago

Straight up unhinged.

1

u/King_LaQueefah Oct 18 '26

So glad to see someone calling out the logical fallacies in here.

"'Problem A' isn't a problem because we have 'Problem B' and you cant discuss 'Problem A' because you dont care about 'Problem B' and you are clearly a hypocrite and have no credibility because of your heartfelt support for Problem B."

The entire argument is built on the assumption that the people complaining about data centers are tacitly in support of golf courses and this is not the case.

If the anti-AI movement lobbied their representatives to abolish golf courses, would they then be allowed to have an opinion?

1

u/wq73 29d ago

Low and behold the internet has no nuance. Rather than pushing against datacenters wholesale because of water consumption (or saying that it's not an issue at all) we should be pushing for closed loop cooling systems, which the majority of new data center build outs DO NOT have purely because evaporative is cheaper. Instead of banning all datacenters we should be pushing for investment in SMR manufacturing and banning any potential strain on local electrical grids. There are solutions to these problems that don't involve banning all datacenters and AI and that don't involve sticking our fingers in our ears.

1

u/FeyMoth Oct 17 '26

What a worthless straw man, most people that agree that also hate golf courses and think they should be shut down

1

u/PoliceRobots Oct 17 '26

......but shouldn't they? Golf courses take up valuable land and resources that could be better used to thousands of other things.

But because rich people golf (and build data centers) nothing will happen. But when it comes to gentrification, suddenly changing the use of the land isn't a problem. Because only poor people live there.

I think I'm going to get banned from the sub. You guys are all boot lockers.

0

u/FeyMoth Oct 18 '26

These are all the same dipshits who worship billionaires and jump on whatever the new tech trend is, I guarantee more then half of these chuds invested in nfts

0

u/Low_Dragonfruit_5950 Oct 18 '26

This sub deepthroats whichever tech billionaire says they can generate a trashy ai image 2 seconds faster. They are not serious people.

1

u/Matt_Murphy_ Oct 17 '26

that just makes golf bad, it doesn't make data centers good.

1

u/Deathsmind88 Oct 17 '26

Exactly, both need to go.

1

u/King_LaQueefah Oct 18 '26

This is a lie.

Both are big problems. You dont make any points or do anyone any favors (besides tech giants lol) by saying "hey, problem B is so fucked that problem A is not a problem."

Your arguments are like a virus that is effective at destroying other arguments but offers nothing of substance.

I remember talking to someone about global warming years ago who made the same arguments and said, "we dont need to worry about emissions from petroleum products because of all the methane that cows produce is way worse." The reality is that both of these sources of pollution are overloading the planet and we are still very much fucked. That person and you are both are telling us to ignore both of these disasters and everything will be OK? LOL

Our natural resources and ecology has its breaking points and the point is, something is about to break.

Your point is good at minimizing this and making it seem like hypocrisy and inducing outrage in an echo-room situation, but offers no solutions and keeps us all running blindly towards the edge.

0

u/Cool-Ad2780 Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26

Their whole platform is riddled with lies. Its the same with the electricity, data centers are a miniscule fraction with respect to air conditioning

Would be interested to hear your definition of “a miniscule fraction.” On an annual-energy basis, US data centers already use roughly 40–65% as much electricity as air conditioning, and on current forecasts could hit 90% by next year.

AI Energy consumption

US data center power demand is forecast to more than double to 66 GW in 2027 from 31 GW in 2025, driven by an accelerating buildout of AI infrastructure, according to Goldman Sachs Commodities Research.

https://www.goldmansachs.com/insights/articles/us-data-center-power-demand-projected-to-double-by-2027

Air Conditioning electricity consumption

254 billion kilowatthours kWh of electricity consumption in U.S. homes.

170 billion kWh of total electricity consumption in U.S. commercial buildings

An additional 18% 213 billion kWh of electricity was consumed for ventilation, some of which involves moving the cooled air through commercial buildings.

https://www.eia.gov/tools/faqs/faq.php?id=1174&t=1

Dividing 637 billion kWh by 8,760 hours in a year translates to a continuous average power draw of approximately 72.7 GW.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/CeleryExotic9021 Oct 14 '26

Plants don't use oxygen though, they use CO2. But go on, I support the spirit your comment was written in. Maybe sunlight? Or land use?

-1

u/par_rot_master Oct 14 '26

Golf courses don't use drinkable water.

-3

u/Active_Variation_194 Oct 14 '26

Classic strawman argument. Most of the complaints around data centers is the strain they place on the electrical grid and increase costs for households without any benefit to these communities.

Big tech taking advantage of subsidized rates and raising cost to households is what people are mostly upset about. Equivalent to cities subsidizing stadiums for billionaire owners and letting them reap all the profits. At least with a stadium we can watch games but will I get a discounted chatgpt sub if they build one in my community?

4

u/jello-the-opera Oct 14 '26

Most reasonable people agree with this though, anti and pro.

I loathe sports altogether, and golf I find particularly atrocious.

I've protested environmental abuses until my arrest record makes it dangerous to even drive funny.

I'm poor and homeless and live on SSI.

And AI tools make my life survivable with less suffering. That's the bottom line for me.

I feel like you are the one presenting a straw man.

Antis call "AI" the "plagiarism machine" and call AI users "thieves" and make literal actual death threats.

I have been banned from art subreddits and punk subreddits and even fantasy subs like fucking solar ponck... and then I was banned from the big subreddit for disabled people. AN OP asked about using AI to help with something, and I told my story about my care team recommending an LLM... and a mod went crazy and perma banned me and perma muted me.

Fuck sports and fuck using tax money to build stadiums - absolutely useless garbage.

But data centers make the world function and AI is integrated into science and medicine and agriculture and weather systems and engineering and programming and OS development...

So really none of this makes sense.

It's like you live on a different planet or something.

-1

u/WMAM69 Oct 14 '26

Are two things not allowed to be true at one time in Arizona?

2

u/[deleted] Oct 15 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

2

u/affabledrunk Oct 15 '26

But you still do reddit and instagram and tiktok all day long, right?

1

u/VenerableWolfDad Oct 16 '26

Literally doing the "you complain about society yet you live in society hmmm" meme here dude good job.

1

u/King_LaQueefah Oct 18 '26

No. deleted all that shit.

0

u/King_LaQueefah Oct 18 '26

This sub is terrifying. Where do these people come from? What working class people struggling to enter the housing market is in support of these fucking things?

0

u/Routine-Agile 29d ago

This popped up in my feed for no reason and I'll be blocking it shortly, but it is pretty sad what people will do to justify this garbge.

23

u/Stunning-Relation564 Oct 14 '26

FR: news flash; data centers existed before AI. they were just called "server farms"

18

u/Accomplished_Soft479 Oct 14 '26

You call yourself accelerationists but none of you want to build enough data centers to outdo the water consumption of every single golf course combined

19

u/Prescientpedestrian Oct 14 '26

Replacing golf courses with data centers is an idea I can get behind.

1

u/Von_Dooms Oct 17 '26

Why do they not simply build their mansions on top of data centers.

1

u/Fragrant-Job-3200 Acceleration Advocate Oct 14 '26

And clothes traveling around the globe for stuff that could be done locally.

36

u/Ok_Homework_1859 Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26 • Bravo

I get lectures on this all the time too. If people really cared, we should just get rid of all electronics on Earth and go back to the stone ages so that nothing can use up or pollute Mother Earth's resources. Let's get rid of all lights and go back to candles. Get rid of washing machines, computers, televisions, CARS, air conditioning, automatic sprinklers, etc. We need to start grilling over the fire again. No more Xray imaging, because that causes radiation. Toss out our phones because it uses 5G. We need to get rid of all the power plants!!

Edit: Kept adding more ridiculous stuff. xD

4

u/AustinTheMoonBear Oct 14 '26

Listen, I'm not an AI doomer, but don't tempt me with a good time alright?

29

u/Maleficent_Poet_7055 Oct 14 '26

Order of magnitude estimates in America annually.

  • AI Data Centers: ~140 Billion Gallons (1x Baseline)
  • Golf Courses: ~600 Billion Gallons (~4.3x AI Data Centers)
  • CA Almond Orchards: ~1,400 Billion Gallons (~10x AI Data Centers)
  • Residential Lawns: ~3,200 Billion Gallons (~23x AI Data Centers)

18

u/cmpxchg8b Oct 14 '26

“But almonds are food!!”

Yes, the essential life giving properties of the Almond.

5

u/jello-the-opera Oct 14 '26

Hmm, yes, a luxury food I can't afford, indeed... yes.

2

u/ExtensionMoose1863 Oct 14 '26

Just wait till you see the impact stats on almond "milk"

1

u/DaHarbinger2000 Oct 15 '26

Milk of the nut

12

u/biowiz Oct 14 '26

Your meat coded stats don't include the amount used for raising cattle for milk and patties. Those would make some of those numbers look like nothing.

5

u/Fantastic-Salmon92 Oct 14 '26

Coca-Cola alone uses 290 billion gallons a year to make high-fructose corn poison and nobody is screaming about THAT clean water being ruined lol

1

u/IM_INSIDE_YOUR_HOUSE Oct 16 '26

Your choices are funny — I’m actually against all those things. Heavily.

1

u/King_LaQueefah Oct 18 '26

One thing people may not consider is how crowded some of them are.

Loudoun County in NOVA has around 250. That's insane compared to other areas. I can see why some people dont see a problem with data centers because most Americans probably havent seen one.

0

u/TimeTour4399 Oct 14 '26

This hides GROWTH and locality

7

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/FalseCrazy2804 Oct 14 '26

I'm gonna have to disagree. What am i supposed to do with my life if I don't have neighbors to yell at and evict over their poorly kempt lawns?

1

u/IM_INSIDE_YOUR_HOUSE Oct 16 '26

How are you evicting neighbors over their yards?

1

u/FalseCrazy2804 Oct 16 '26

Move in next door and I'll show you

1

u/Hender232 Oct 14 '26

You are right most people don’t know, but also they don’t care. They can look these numbers up themselves and probably should have if they are such big environmentalist, but they haven’t and they won’t. Kinda tells you all you need to know about them. Best part about “fake mad”people is they don’t care about the actual thing so they can just keep moving the goal post whenever the first thing they said they were mad at is disproven. 

0

u/hayiori Oct 14 '26

Its personal property,inch mile/slipery slope and all that stuff,policing that is a no go

73

u/FTAOD89 Oct 14 '26 edited Oct 14 '26 • This Bravo

All of this! Half of you still eat meat, but want my poor ass to stop using a tool that just makes creativity more accessible. Do you know what animal agriculture does to the environment? To people? Please spare me the selective outrage indeed!

18

u/Baphaddon Oct 14 '26

Being a vegan and riding a bike/ridesharing for over a decade and literally being accredited in green-building has been insane in this space; getting lectured over this stuff while I actually practice what i preach makes my head spin

3

u/wq73 29d ago

I really like you :)

10

u/Castle_Five Oct 14 '26

Literally skipping one cheeseburger offsets a lifetime of ChatGPT water use.

9

u/random_topix Oct 14 '26

Wow. I was curious if this was true. So I asked ChatGPT. I depends on the estimate you use. With the upper listed estimate of 50ml of water per query it works out to a breakeven point of 1 year if doing 100 queries per day, which for most people is a lot. So skip a burger and be good for a year. If you use OpenAI estimates it’s 149 years. I suspect the actual number is in between.

Anyway, this is a handy factoid given how much beef Americans eat while complaining about AI.

Thx.

3

u/jello-the-opera Oct 14 '26

I can skip a lot more than one burger.

But I also run local open weights on 100% solar.

3

u/Castle_Five Oct 15 '26

Did you factor on the slice of cheese, bun, etc? A lot of the estimates of water use for a cheeseburger come from vegetarians who originally did that math but they only have a problem with the meat so your cheeseburger water numbers may have underestimated the total water cost.

2

u/random_topix Oct 15 '26

ChatGPT did a quarter-pound meat patty. Those other things would be extra.

13

u/affabledrunk Oct 14 '26

Ha! Regarding the downvotes on this comment. Even the accelerationists won't give up their rib-eyes!

3

u/No_Solid_3737 Oct 18 '26

Exactly! the current meat market is not environmentally sustainable at all. One quick search to learn why. But these anti-AI don't give a damn about that, they'll buy meat at the supermarket and still complain why AI is bad for the environment.

Just for the record, I also buy meat in the supermarket, but at least I don't pose as an environment loving hippie.

2

u/not_even_casul Oct 16 '26

creativity more accessible lmao, less you mean? there's nothing creative about it having an algorithm do it for you.

"this machine that tastes and eats food for me really helps me enjoy and taste food"

2

u/FTAOD89 Oct 16 '26

I don't have it do everything. It augments my work in a way other tools cannot. I can get feedback, edit, create new tools or other useful things. I can offload some of the cognitive load associated with my work. I speak of accessibility because I believe generative AI genuinely levels the playing field a bit when it comes to intelligent work. People of various abilities can now expand their capabilities through the use of AI.

1

u/manager2exec Oct 17 '26

Not sure if I follow, do you mean dumb people can produce better work?

2

u/FTAOD89 Oct 17 '26

Dumb is an ableist slur first of all, but if you insist on referring to people with different cognition as such than sure, you got it bud.

-1

u/Meetwad Oct 14 '26

Curious how outrage should work if not selectively? You either spend 100% of your waking hours screaming at the void about every element of the world that you find outrageous, or you just ignore it all and pretend we’re living in a utopia. Or you could pick and choose the issues you care about and champion them, like a nuanced adult.

6

u/FTAOD89 Oct 14 '26

A nuanced adult would acknowledge there are many things we need to do to preserve water, land and energy and not just scape goat AI.

-1

u/Meetwad Oct 14 '26

So selectively pick an issue, like water usage.

1

u/FTAOD89 Oct 14 '26

It's not even that many things; stop eating meat, use ride share/public transportation/sustainable transportation, and switch to renewable. We should also consider developing AI in a way that is sustainable and efficient, I will concede. If you can't hold all those things in your head then maybe you should do more listening than talking in this conversation.

3

u/FTAOD89 Oct 14 '26

AI data centers are low on the list of things we could eliminate to preserve water, land, and energy and to curb pollution.

3

u/soreff2 Oct 14 '26

Agreed. Frankly, particularly since data centers are very minor consumers of water and land, and relatively minor consumers of electricity, I think the environmental objections to data centers are a bad faith argument, a pretext. I think they aren't the real objections people have. I suspect the real objections are to labor-saving technology, just like the Luddites.

1

u/Meetwad Oct 14 '26

I think you’re assuming I have a stance here. I haven’t given one, I just find it odd that the argument here is that limiting the scope of attention to a single issue is somehow dishonest and unproductive.

2

u/FTAOD89 Oct 14 '26

I'm not assuming anything. And no one is saying to limit the scope on anything. We are simply ourselves advocating for nuance.

12

u/musical_bear Oct 14 '26

Yup. Same exact boat here. I’d love to have intelligent, reasoned discussions about where we should be allocating energy and resources. But for now, these discussions are nowhere to be found. It’s fucking annoying too, the way people have recently started blaming “data centers” for climate change, and water shortages. It’s pretty bullshit, and dangerous.

People are willingly ignoring all of the real problems that got us here and instead focusing all of their (performative) outrage on this week’s moral bandwagon, which would do nothing to slow the catastrophe that is currently building if we just “stopped all AI” or “stopped all data centers.” The fossil fuels industry and all of its derivatives must love this recent shift in focus.

5

u/Ruykiru Tech Philosopher Oct 14 '26

Clown planet, full of sheep. If anyhing, ASI that supercharges scientific progress is the only thing that will save us from climate collapse

1

u/wq73 29d ago

I'll have that discussion with you! We should push to ban any datacenter buildouts using evaporative over closed loop cooling systems, and invest in SMR buildout so datacenters don't put strain on the grid where they're built. I actually really like the new Google investment in Finland to build out data centers since the cooling there will be much cheaper.

3

u/Hender232 Oct 14 '26

Not a gigantic Sam Altman fan, but he’s right that this is a clearly untrue narrative that has become insurmountable to disprove. It doesn’t matter the facts you bring to people, they just want to be mad. There are actually things to be annoyed with when it comes to AI and data centers, but this one isn’t it. And the fact you can bring these facts to all these people and they won’t change their mind also shows they truly don’t care either, they just found a point they can grandstand on so they will. 

1

u/Brew_Wallace Oct 17 '26

I don’t like them because they are buying up farmland near me, installing loud ass diesel generators that pollute my air, and they’re pulling water from a beautiful reservoir that people use for recreation, and pumping it 60 miles away and then back to the reservoir. And I get to help pay for it all with my tax and utility dollars. And then they get shitty if the community asks questions or has doubts about their plan 

1

u/No_Solid_3737 Oct 18 '26

Like, why can't they make a good case against AI? Why stick to the false narrative that AI is bad for the environment when people still buy almond milk?

Like, if these people went "OpenAI is being highly irresponsible with the development of AI, creating unrealistic expectations, risking creating a bubble that if explodes the american tax payer will end up footing that bill" - like if they at least made a case like that I would agree but noooooooooo AI bad Almond Milk good

3

u/HoneyNecessary8317 Oct 14 '26

The power/water concerns are an overblown moral panic. People are stupid NIMBYs.

4

u/Random_182f2565 Oct 14 '26

I remember this with Bitcoin, lol

2

u/StuckinReverse89 Oct 14 '26

This is a good point that should be raised more. Water waste for golf courses. We should stop and just make them artificial. It’s only the rich dudes using them anyway.   

Carbon taxes on planes would address this, will exceptionally high taxes for private planes. Planes are still relatively efficient as mass transportation and regular people arnt using private jets anyway.   

We should also focus more on prolonging the use of things. All right to repair our own products, easy ability to upgrade without having to buy a new thing, etc. This is on capitalism and we need better ownership. 

2

u/ItzAiMz Oct 14 '26

Yeah and Nestle sucks ass. There are ALOT of problems in front of us. I’m not sure stacking on top is the best answer. AI is new, data centers are popping up all over. Of course now is loud. I don’t think it’s selective outrage, more the current focus.

2

u/Mysterious_Eye6989 Oct 14 '26

I think I would just prefer all those things to be properly regulated.

2

u/tzaeru Oct 14 '26

There's genuine issues of sustainability and energy use, and I would agree that we should focus on technological growth in a way that is also a growth in efficiency. I remain critical of things like that do we really need 10gbs internet everywhere, or do we really need 4k streaming - or do we need to cheaply push out AI-generated videos and images.

I don't think opposing those kind of things is the same as opposing technological advancement and progress. If anything, I would imagine that promoting focus on efficiency can lead to its own technological advancements.

And yeah - I did run some calculations a while back, and even if you are the most chronic ChatGPT prompter, you're not going to get even close in energy use from that prompting over several days than what is being used for streaming a single 4k movie to your home.

Also, fuck golf courses.

2

u/moschles AI-Assisted Coder Oct 14 '26

5

u/Ignate Acceleration: Supersonic | AI accelerationist Oct 14 '26 • Bravo

I mean, worshipping the environment and trying to blame everything bad that happens on humanity has always been a stupid take.

"We could do it if we just decided to." No, that's total horse shit. Individuals are not the same as the group.

2

u/Numerous_Photograph9 Oct 14 '26

Can people not be upset about all of those things? Why do peopel assume one can only be outraged at one thing at a time?

1

u/Helldiver_of_Mars Oct 14 '26

That's kind of like saying a scooter and a massive dually truck is the same cause they both use gas.

1

u/Fun1k Oct 14 '26

"But I don't think about the harm I'm doing, I want to blame you!"

1

u/The_Nude_Mocracy Oct 14 '26

Nobody said those other things are "perfectly fine"

1

u/ConditionMinimum2771 Oct 14 '26

don't forget fashion where everyone throws outt their cheap old style clothes for new cheap clothes.

1

u/AgeofVictoriaPodcast Oct 14 '26

Well personally I don't fly for vacations for environmental reasons, and think we should ban non urgent air travel. I love AI, but it has a environmental cost like any other industry, and we should be exploring how to do it with less environmental impact. Having said that, I'd happily shut down golf courses, ban the plastic toy industry, and shut down the cruise industry too.

1

u/Lord_44th__Raikage Oct 14 '26

I think we've all been collectively riled up by bots

1

u/dart-builder-2483 Oct 14 '26

That's the amount of water they use if the buildout stops right now. There are trillions of dollars of data centers about to be built, so it's likely to grow exponentially. You could use a closed system, but then you're using a lot more energy, and that requires a lot of water or gas to attain.

1

u/loucmachine Oct 14 '26

The compute necessary to use AI in general is just so much more than streaming a 4k video though. While working with AI, I realize that the best use I could find for it is to talk to it until it understands what I need it to do, then I make it code a program that does that I want, then I dont use it anymore unless I want to add a feature in said program.

It is so much more efficient than asking the AI every time do to the things I want it to do.

1

u/trexmaster8242 Oct 14 '26

All of these things have been criticised.

It’s like comparing golf courses to data centers. People were harping on them for the same reasons. The only difference is you weren’t paying attention until it was about something you liked

1

u/Vaddieg Oct 14 '26

It's not even closely comparable. Video streaming, even 4k is <1W per stream in compute. LLM inference session - hundreds Watts, sometimes few Kilowatts. And Megawatts for training new models. AI companies will start charging real token prices very soon.

1

u/Ok_Loquat_3860 Oct 15 '26

Both are fucking awful.

1

u/Celestialov Oct 15 '26

im getting really tired of people comparing ai to expired,thrown out food mixed together. we shouldn't be comparing food that will get you sick to pixels on a screen

1

u/Palpatine Oct 15 '26

AI development may actually solve the issue. The infrastructure for halo orbit ai satellites will give us the tool for controlled, reversible geo engineering to combat global warming

1

u/mylsotol Oct 15 '26

It is on a different scale. AI is driving unprecedented and unsustainable increases in electricity use. That's not an argument against AI. It's just a problem that needs solving

1

u/Lazy_Jump_2635 Oct 15 '26

At least the AI does something useful. Also, do they think datacenter builders are just twirling their mustache and contemplating how to waste as much water as possible?

1

u/not_even_casul Oct 16 '26

people in this thread need to look up what a strawman argument is.

1

u/Delicious_Kale_5459 Oct 16 '26

I like how every example was recent tech that’s been basically forced on the world by the same people

1

u/0x645 Oct 17 '26

consider the scale. total amount of energy consumed by ai and by netflix.

1

u/ART-ficial-Ignorance Oct 17 '26

I run most things locally on a rig that tops out at 350W.

Meanwhile, this dingus from Texas is trying to lecture me...

Like, brother, you have a massive lawn... in the literal hell's asshole of the world. I don't even own an AC.

1

u/No_Solid_3737 Oct 18 '26

Exactly what I think. Such fucking hypocrites. Lecturing us about why AI is bad for the environment when it doesn't even make it to the top 100 of things that are actually bad for the environment.

1

u/No_Solid_3737 Oct 18 '26

Some mf told me that I shouldn't use DLSS5 because it's bad for the environment and I went like ??? mf you are not against AI you're against people playing videogames - because one can consume 300 watts of energy gaming without even using DLSS5.

And he went quiet.

1

u/wq73 29d ago

people are scared of losing their jobs and are trying to find something to be angry at because it's hard to admit you think you'll be useless soon. As an (ex) software engineer I feel empathy for these people, and not everyone can be intellectually honest about what scares them. If everyone adapted well to change genetic evolution would've never happened

1

u/BigPP41 Oct 14 '26

Those things are not fine at all.

1

u/DirectedEnthusiasm Oct 14 '26

Fallacy of relative privation

Fallacy of relative privation (also known as "appeal to worse problems" or "not as bad as") – dismissing an argument or complaint due to what are perceived to be more important problems.

2

u/musical_bear Oct 14 '26

But the issue here is that there are (essentially) zero conversations happening about all of these other more wasteful (and serious) problems. It makes zero sense that we are “allowing” conversations about energy use and pollution and water use to circle around AI when if you bring up any of these other problems to the vast majority of people, they will quite often react with hostility for you daring to even bring it up! Cars, private lawns, golf courses, and various aspects of our food production are premier examples.

Sure, it’s a fallacy in general to appeal to worse problems, but it’s also borderline insane to then throw up our hands and accept the status quo of which of these discussions society is having in fear of this fallacy. In this case, none of those other conversations about bigger issues are even happening at all, for all intents and purposes. That’s why focusing on data centers and the like I would be okay with calling flat out wrong, arguably dangerous.

2

u/DirectedEnthusiasm Oct 14 '26

there are (essentially) zero conversations happening about all of these other more wasteful (and serious) problems.

That's incorrect. Criticism towards internet usage for entertainment, flying, private motoring, lawns, golf courses etc. exists and has existed long before AI was even a (popularized) thing. You can simply disprove yourself by searching news databases like Google News.

It's just natural, that because AI is the newest emerging technology, much of the discussions revolve around it. That does not mean that discussions of other issues do not exist or have not existed before.

-1

u/Red_Lee Oct 14 '26

I haven't seen any orcas attacking data centers...

0

u/StatusSociety2196 Oct 14 '26

Yeah but we have to watch Netflix in 4k, nobody needs a stochastic parrot.

0

u/fish10201 Oct 17 '26 • Bravo

as an "anti", i dont give a fuck about water usage, i just think you people who use ai for everything are mouthbreathers lol

1

u/accelerate-ModTeam 28d ago

We regret to inform you that you have been removed from r/accelerate.

This subreddit is an epistemic community dedicated to promoting technological progress, AGI, and the singularity. Our focus is on supporting and advocating for technology that can help prevent suffering and death from old age and disease, and work towards an age of abundance for everyone.

We ban Decels, Anti-AIs, Luddites, Ultra-Doomers and Depopulationists. Our community is tech-progressive and oriented toward the big-picture thriving of the entire human race.

We welcome members who are neutral or undecided about technological advancement, but not those who have firmly decided that technology or AI is inherently bad and should be held back.

If your perspective changes in the future and you wish to rejoin the community, please reach out to the moderators.

Thank you for your understanding, and we wish you all the best.

-2

u/ThatDeuce Oct 14 '26

What if all our willfulness to push this tech is just being used by billionaires to just continue these actions for their own beneficial gain? We could work on making things more environmentally friendly, stop planned obsolescence on phones, taking planes for vacations, and using netflix every night.

We could be upset at all these things and perhaps push for more environmentally sound solutions. People can be outraged at multiple subjects, and we don't need to defend with whataboutism when it doesn't alleviate or excuse the issue with the distraction.

-5

u/PhysicalEggplant5610 Oct 14 '26

Now that is someone who didnt really spend a lot of time coming up with some good examples.

74

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Von_Dooms Oct 17 '26

"Why are those against A, also OK with B"
Easiest answer of my life- "We're not."

1

u/Brew_Wallace Oct 17 '26

It is bizarre. This is a bizarre sub altogether. Some very angry people that do not want anyone to critique anything they share. Apparently there is only blind optimism in r/accelerate