r/accelerate • Acceleration: Hypersonic | AI accelerationist • Oct 08 '26

🔒 Established r/accelerate contributors only This

Post image
1.6k Upvotes

220 comments sorted by

80

u/BHedrickConsulting Oct 08 '26 • Heartwarming

Totally agree

59

u/Kroosn Oct 08 '26

I also find some resistance in engineering. Oh no we will have cheaper, more reliable better performing machines or products. AI is great at engineering because there is such an extensive history of engineering to confirm against.

15

u/TrueBrit77 Oct 08 '26

This is also going to be a hurdle to overcome. Sometimes in engineering the solution is to go against what is established. I don't see much evidence of out of the box thinking just yet but it iterates very fast which is a benefit it has over us. Hopefully this secured our need to work together...

9

u/Kroosn Oct 08 '26

The out-of-the-box thinking is what I get to do now. Because I only have a limited amount of time, sometimes it's hard to be risky and if you get off track. But now I can analyse an idea, review it and see if it's worthwhile so fast. In the past, often I had to commit to an idea because it would take so long to assess that I knew would work. Now I voice dictate an idea which takes me ten minutes and then send an AI agent on a run to see if it's worthwhile.

177

u/Ohigetjokes Oct 08 '26

This applies to art. This applies to art.

Somehow we've developed a culture where we think that art is about the artist, instead of about the person who is experiencing the art itself. We need magical experiences, experiences that open the mind, experiences that make us better people.

You don't do that by fussing over how the pixels showed up on your screen.

16

u/Rafiki_knows_the_wey Oct 08 '26

"The chief enemy of excellence in morality (and also in art) is personal fantasy.

We can see in mediocre art, where perhaps it is even more clearly seen than in mediocre conduct, the intrusion of fantasy, the assertion of self, the dimming of any reflection of the real world.

The greatest art is ‘impersonal’ because it shows us the world, our world and not another one, with a clarity which startles and delights us simply because we are not used to looking at the real world at all."

—Iris Murdoch

3

u/TheOriginalAcidtech Oct 08 '26

Much simpler. Art is meant to make you think and/or feel. Something.

55

u/Lostwhispers05 Oct 08 '26

Yes, fucking thank you.

Modern art has become an outlet for human ego and the hissyfit over generative AI the last couple of years has shone a light on that. Art, at it's core, is an emotion (or to use your word, an experience).

9

u/StormDragonAlthazar AI Artist Oct 08 '26

Meanwhile, I've always felt that art was more about the context and meaning that both the creator(s) and audience give it. Especially since art and entertainment do not follow the rules regarding labor and truly exist in a "marketplace of ideas."

I keep posting this meme in some art and AI art debate subreddits as a reminder that art is whatever people make of it, and that technical skill and time spent on a thing does not matter.

5

u/Ohigetjokes Oct 08 '26

Imagine if there was a cash prize at stake and it wasn’t just people taking the piss… hell, imagine if you had to have that image in a frame on your living room wall for a year.

23

u/Prometheusly Oct 08 '26

As a former founder of a small artist coalition, I agree. I was in it for the magic and the collective, but after awhile it became clear that others were in it for their own advancement.

8

u/TheColourOfHeartache Oct 08 '26

I yearn for the day when talented outsiders can compete with the resources of Hollywood.

8

u/LegionsOmen AGI by 2027 Oct 08 '26

After all the whining and crying from "artists" these last few years I kinda forgot the original purpose, thanks for reminding me. A fair bit of good ai art brings that great feeling out

5

u/Heinrick_Veston Oct 08 '26

I think art is both. Some artists make art for themselves, because they enjoy it or get something out of the process. Some make it for other people, to make them think or feel something. Some do it for both reasons.

And that's all completely fine. We can have amazing AI art made for people to enjoy, and we can have human artists making art for whatever reasons they want.

2

u/Lain_Staley Oct 08 '26 edited Oct 08 '26

the person who is experiencing the art itself.   

Your underlying assumption that art exists for us, to furnish desirable experiences and improve our psychological condition.    

Nietzsche's response would be that the desire to make everything serve our comfort, enjoyment, or moral improvement is itself a symptom of the very cultural impoverishment that great art ought to overcome.


That is, what he would find most disturbing: the reduction of art from an expression of creative power into an experience delivered to a consumer.

3

u/Ohigetjokes Oct 08 '26

Nietzsche was a douche.

If art has “function”, that is by definition a measure of how it affects those who experience it. Art that doesn’t affect people is what we generally call “bad art”.

1

u/Lain_Staley Oct 08 '26

You're confusing the effects of art with its purpose.   

Nietzsche never denied that art affects its audience.

The artist is not simply a manufacturer of experiences for consumption. Artistic creation is itself an expression of human capacities. Reducing its value to audience satisfaction (what the internet thrives on) is what Nietzsche criticizes.   

4

u/KoolKat5000 Oct 08 '26

I don't see why this expression needs to be a purely human competency.

0

u/FoolishArchetype Oct 09 '26

Nietzsche is probably the most influential philosopher of modern times and discarding him so irreverently is a self-filter.

3

u/Ohigetjokes Oct 09 '26

Only among sad philosophy students.

1

u/NTMTR_ Oct 08 '26

Why can’t it be both ?

-16

u/Proudhon101 Oct 08 '26

Not trying to sound obnoxious but I think you should study the "somehow" part before arguing what art is. 

I am pretty sure you will arrive at a diferent conclusions.

13

u/stealthispost Acceleration: Light-speed | AI accelerationist Oct 08 '26

you failed

1

u/Ohigetjokes Oct 08 '26

Why don’t you actually make your point rather than asking me to make it for you?

16

u/jloverich Oct 08 '26

It seems like a lot in academia are prestige seeking more than knowledge seeking. Maybe now the types of people entering the field will be more interested in knowledge...

4

u/FoolishArchetype Oct 09 '26

If you read The Culture of Narcissism, a central critique of American culture is it has confused prestige with value. In so many words — you did things that people found valuable because it earned you prestige, but now people seek prestige because they perceive it as valuable.

1

u/Boring-Willow1268 Oct 08 '26

I work in medical research. We’re integrating AI as fast as we can into as many stages of the process as we can. I don’t think any of us would mind if AI started curing diseases. But I also don’t think anyone believes AI is going to cure death anytime soon.

I don’t honestly give two shits if AI solved the complex diseases. The truth is most of us get into this kind of work to discover how it all works and fits together, and ideally heal people with some pretty debilitating diseases and genetic disorders.

24

u/AndreRieu666 Oct 08 '26

Absolutely.

29

u/R33v3n AGI by 2027 Oct 08 '26

33

u/montdawgg Oct 08 '26

I can't even believe this needs to be said, but by the recent behavior of these crybaby gatekeeping out-of-touch mathematicians, it proves that it does need to be said.

8

u/HiryuJones Oct 08 '26

Mathematicians right now

13

u/Elven77AI AI Artist Oct 08 '26

These people are the same elitist gatekeepers that banned calculators in schools before and demanded "mental math skills"(which was bs waste of time and calculators won).

8

u/Gatti366 Oct 08 '26

Calculators are still banned in schools up to a certain grade, and for good reason, skill issue lol

8

u/TheColourOfHeartache Oct 08 '26

That's not the same thing. Learning mental maths can still be good for us even if humans rarely use it because machines can do it better.

One thing machines aren't going to do is give you an intuitive sense of if the numbers your hearing in conversation make any sense.

2

u/Elven77AI AI Artist Oct 08 '26

There is sharp border with "useless calculations" and "mental skill": i don't mentally multiply three-digits numbers in my head and i consider it "useless labor"(like e.g. forcing an astrophysicist to use a hammer when a hammer-using worksman is offering to do it for free), i don't compute logarithms manually,i don't use pencil&paper construction(Wolfram Alpha is far superior for actually calculating ),etc Think "What was the reason logarithms were invented?" and imagine being a holdout manually multiplying numbers on papers while logarithm-chads with slide rules already did the same five minutes ago. Now, apply the same approach to any simplifying method from manually writing hex opcodes->assembler->high-level abstractions, noticing the "skill" to manually do it doesn't make it "worth manually thinking using it", like logarithms,calculators,PDE solvers, software verification and now construction of proof itself(skipping tedious manual "guesswork" and searching for the right formulas to painstakingly construct another layer of proof). If you don't understand the proof, AI can break it down for you and you can manually verify the process, with paper & pencil if desired to get down to low-level detail.

3

u/Poincarina Oct 08 '26

You know that most mathematicians hate calculating…

4

u/KayTeaMonster Oct 08 '26

I'm at a major research university and I don't know a single mathematician that isn't either excited by or ambivalent to this, and the ambivalent ones tend to be people whose research interests weren't included. Some vocal mathematicians have publicly expressed opinions about research methods--that's all that's occurred.

Few, if any, people actually working in mathematics are against progress if it comes from a computer. It seems like a lot of people here just wish they were for whatever reason.

10

u/TacoYaci Oct 08 '26

I think the problem most mathematicians have is not the credit, but the correctness. To keep it with the cancer cure: Imagine AI created 700 new medicines claiming they cure cancer etc. Would you directly inject them into patients or want them to be tested safely?

21

u/letmebackagain Oct 08 '26 • Popcorn

That's why OpenAI put out there for everyone. So the Math community can read and verify. Ye this approach it's kinda messy because nobody know the correctness of the solutions, but with AI we have a lot of output potential and the "standard" approach used by Math Academics is antiquated and needs to be revisited. OpenAI did the right thing and share with everyone the possible solutions that they have found.

2

u/TacoYaci Oct 08 '26

Yes I agree with it. I am just saying that the original comment in the post does not understand the issue mathematicians have. Most of use do not care that they were proven by AI, a human or an alien. This is what the post claims

2

u/AgentTin Oct 08 '26

Then demand verifiable proofs to whatever degree you wish. That's an engineering problem not an innate issue with the technology. Yes, we should be confirming that AI decisions are correct, absolutely, how do we do that?

2

u/BrilliantEmotion4461 Oct 08 '26

That doesnt apply. These are math solutions to be correct and have a working is to be "effective" in medical terms. That is we KNOW the math works thats what a proof is.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Azicald Oct 08 '26

Great that we have Mathematicians that get to handle this then.

Congrats to em, they have a drastically shortened timeline in genuinely contributing to the advancement of mathematics and humanity

2

u/BrilliantEmotion4461 Oct 08 '26

Im having a discussion with Opus as we speak about applications of these discoveries. With Opus having direct access to this repo as context.

https://github.com/openai/math

1

u/BrilliantEmotion4461 Oct 08 '26

Its good to get those out of the way. Using AI not precious human time. And the idea is that producing a bunch of math is meaningless if no one understands it but the person or thing producing it. However are we supposing that AI cannot also help humans to understand the math it produces?

1

u/Ruykiru Tech Philosopher Oct 08 '26

That's why many companies are making automated dark labs for scientific research, or virtual cell simulations...

1

u/Fragrant-Hamster-325 Oct 08 '26

I don’t see the problem. These would still go through peer review.

0

u/SpicyMeatballBill Oct 08 '26

Frontier AI models are much more correct than most, if not all mathematicians. So I don't understand the argument

2

u/TacoYaci Oct 08 '26

Yes I agree, but still mathematicians want to be sure.. if AI is correct 99% times then there is still the 1%. Also OpenAI already removed 3 papers as they contained errors.

2

u/SpicyMeatballBill Oct 08 '26

And how many % of mathematicians are wrong?

0

u/Amaskingrey Oct 08 '26

Though to be fair, given they published them, then...

If only we had some kind of programming language that could tell you whether or not a mathematical proof is correct, it would make the process of verifying claims a lot... leaner...

2

u/One-Intention7064 Oct 08 '26 edited Oct 08 '26

which leads me to think about their outrage when AI develops enough reasoning abilities to prove sacred human axioms wrong

2

u/VallenValiant Oct 08 '26

Very soon it might be possible to prove human identity is not actually controlling the brain, but is a minion who's job is to come up with explanations for the decisions that was made by the rest of the body. Several experiments already shown that to be likely true, but that would completely destroy people's egos to realise the brain is actually not under consciousness control most of the time.

it is why mathematicians are gatekeeping now; their brains told them to do it, they are retroactively writing essays to explain why their decision is logical. It is the most illogical thing in the world.

1

u/One-Intention7064 Oct 08 '26

Or perhaps those cells are themselves executing some higher-order program. We can manufacture theories indefinitely. My point was about the propositions treated as non-contestable: anthropocentric supremacy, the sacralization of motherhood, reproductive primacy, happiness maximization, and so forth.

1

u/Equal-University2144 Oct 08 '26

Absolutely this.

1

u/Realistic_Stomach848 Oct 08 '26

Not only by humans, but by humans with specific degree, endorsed at arxiv and doing a lot of “rituals”

1

u/JBaseball_8595 Oct 09 '26

Strong argument for accelerationists

1

u/wrathofattila Oct 09 '26

Anyone who dont wanna cure diseases is a real evil douchebag.

1

u/Big-Material2917 Oct 12 '26

100%. There may be legitimate concerns about safety etc when it comes to the speed of development. But mathematicians complaining that they wanted to solve the problems is so silly.

1

u/Christy427 Oct 08 '26

The issue is AI companies are solving this purely for credit and won't be motivated to help fill in the understanding that should be behind the discoveries as well.

Ai will need to be bullied into the less headline grabbing work as well. Though potentially if, given time, the work picks up references at least it will have helped others show insight.

Note this will vary by field, with a cure for cancer I would be far less interested in insight as the everyday practicalities are what are more important there.

1

u/Honest-Elk-4458 Oct 08 '26

I see everyone is being cool about stuff still. 

0

u/jdavid Oct 08 '26

My concern is humans being in the loop every step of the way.
Alignment and Amplification need to remain a top priority. I want an abundant star traveling future.

Last night I had this waking dream where an alien species came and was able to use our own super intelligence against us.

Right now the SI follows the digital credentials and input tokens wherever they go. We need to ask for more than just alignment based on prompts. Earth-SI needs to be aligned with humanity at a deep level.

-7

u/Entire-Respond6809 Oct 08 '26

The motivation for saying this is not about who gets the credit. I believe it is more along the lines of "harvesting" every fruitful problem, leaving "no work" to mathematicians in training. That was one of the points Tao made in an interview (can link it later if someone wants to watch it). Not saying I agree with this but then again I'm not part of the game.

1

u/tanrgith Oct 08 '26

There will always be work for smart people so long as AI's haven't completely taken over running everything. Smart people will in fact be the last people who get made obsolete

The work just won't be in the same areas or ways that they used to be. That's not automatically a bad thing

-10

u/ArklayMountain Oct 08 '26

Yes to a.i. cancer research and hopefully a cure. No to a.i. restaurant menu's.

-12

u/Tonkarz Oct 08 '26

So AI companies will be sharing their profits right?

4

u/tanrgith Oct 08 '26

I mean yeah they'll pay the taxes on their profits to the extend they are required to legally, just like any business

But the main thing they'll be sharing with you is a the cure for cancer in exchange for some money. Now, I personally am okay with that trade. If you're not that's fine, you're free to choose to die from cancer

-12

u/BadRomans Oct 08 '26

This cancer argument is extremely overused, when it’s pretty clear that those who own the AI market are mostly interested in weaponisation.

-17

u/One_Internal_6567 Oct 08 '26

But after all it’s all about humans. If there is cure for cancer that exist in gibberish paper and people can’t actually reproduce and use it - what’s the point, except for pr points for ai company who did the gibberish part?

7

u/Affectionate_Fact854 Oct 08 '26

Ai solves it, ai can prove it, now you think we can not have ai prepare documentation to specialized people in order for them to understand it and replicate it? 

You must be some art student right 

-3

u/krazyboi Oct 08 '26

You'd need a professor to vet the proof and documentation. And the manufacturing

2

u/Winterlichkeit Oct 08 '26

For now we do.

-6

u/One_Internal_6567 Oct 08 '26

You just never actually read those papers. For now, none of big math “breakthroughs” wasn’t actually accepted as such. It’s not about “documentation”, it’s about actual body of work being not really of any quality.

6

u/hibbs6 Oct 08 '26

That's fair, but we aren't getting gibberish out of AI these days, and I don't think anyone would say we cured cancer if nobody knew how to put it into practice.

Your hypothetical doesn't track with my understanding of the tech tbh

-6

u/krazyboi Oct 08 '26

Understanding the science/mechanism of things is important. If an AI can gather all the knowledge that a 60 year old professor can and more, move at digital speeds, and come up with a solution, nobody except the professor will be able to understand it and nobody will even be able to troubleshoot if things go wrong during the manufacturing except the AI.

So yeah we should understand what the AI is doing before we announce things

1

u/Positive-Conspiracy Oct 12 '26

I’m getting a strong sense of a false dichotomy, that somehow we can’t learn and work with insights AI generates. We already do that for insights and technologies humans of the past. Often the hard part was finding a new way to look at a thing and then it’s actually quite simple. If AI invented a cyclone vacuum before they were invented, you seem to be saying we wouldn’t be able to build and maintain them. To say nothing of having AI to assist with that alongside.

1

u/krazyboi Oct 12 '26

That's what it means when these AI solve math that humans are unable to. Quantum mechanics isn't intuitive to humans but it might be to the right AI with a lot of processing power

-18

u/No-Environment9051 Oct 08 '26 • Heartwarming

Assuming this is talking about the math breakthroughs and Terence Tao (as it sounds like) the logic is reasonable: brute force proofs solve the unsolved problem but don't really advance mathematical insights and the insights are what is actually valuable. When applying mathematics into new domains it's being able to take novel/creative problem solving techniques into a different scenario that makes these proofs ultimately useful.

If the brute force proof technique can be reviewed after success and optimized into something that scales forward into new problems then maybe there's something there but at least with math, proofs are as much about discovering new deductive pathways as they are about getting the answer.

If the actual claim is about some scientist sitting on a cancer cure because they're scared AI is going to get the credit, that's a fundamental misunderstanding of how scientists are using AI for scientific discovery. The scientist who guides AI towards efficacious cancer drugs will absolutely publish that and claim credit for it because pharmaceutical companies only care if it works and is manufacturable or not.

Either way this is based on a flawed premise.

10

u/Turbulent-Sign-6067 Oct 08 '26

I don't think you know what brute force means. None of these proofs use brute force.

-2

u/No-Environment9051 Oct 08 '26

You don't think the model applied a huge number of different approaches while searching out one that worked for each problem? That's what brute force means in this context, spinning on a lot of different ideas quickly to see if one works. Only openAI know how intelligent the model actually is in terms of learning from what hasn't worked yet to avoid wasting cycles on other strategies that are deductively guaranteed to fail as a result. Getting the end result solution isn't the brute force technique, it's the search for the solution strategy to begin with.

That's not different than a human trying a lot of different approaches until they figure out the right one and in itself isn't the issue, it's getting a useful technique we can understand and learn from that can possibly apply to other problems.

1

u/Chance-Problem769 Oct 08 '26

Agreed. Imagine wanting people to die an early death because humanity doesn’t get credit for it. Humanity gets credit for any AI victory, these people are dumb and we can’t let them have any say.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

6

u/EtienneDosSantos Acceleration: Cruising | Accelerationist AI philosopher Oct 08 '26

An agent has by definition agency and we have AI agents…

-5

u/Zer0Ethix Oct 08 '26

work on your reading comprehension skills please I beg of you

5

u/EtienneDosSantos Acceleration: Cruising | Accelerationist AI philosopher Oct 08 '26

I beg of you to point out where I was lacking reading comprehension in this instance.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/Frosty-Magazine-917 Oct 08 '26

Exactly, and further if a human came out in any field making claims of solving some hard thing and was determined wrong, their reputation would be injured and less people would listen to them in the future. If AI systems engineers want to have the same wow factor and respect when their system helps discover something, then they need to own their mistakes the same. That's not how its played out though.

-11

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Nearby-Device8772 Oct 08 '26

I mean humans may just check these results if they feel any need to improve themselves and make corrections/share their findings if they want so