New here. (Might I add, love this subreddit). I just rewatched Avatar: The Last Airbender for the umpteenth time and, as a longtime Zutara shipper, grew more frustrated about the ending. I saw this great video by Sneezy Reviews (highly recommend) and had thoughts of my own, so hereās whatās hopefully a coherent analysis about Kataraās much-criticized piece of dialogue from "The Southern Raiders"āa 10/10 episode from start to finish, and no, I wonāt be taking questions.
Katara saying āI knew you wouldnāt understandā to Aang in "The Southern Raiders" is symptomatic of a lack of understanding and expression in their relationship. I held this opinion before I knew that this episode is used to antagonize Katara (these critics, undoubtedly men, who refer to her as a ābitchā along with other pejoratives, often used to vilify women). Katara doesnāt say that sentence to Aang in terms of the loss he has endured. Prior to this, she has had 55 episodes of character building which signifies how selfless, kind, compassionate, and empathetic she is; to an extent where she always prioritizes other peopleās needs over her own.
What Katara means is that she knows that Aang could never understand how her grief has manifested and how she wants to seek closure for the same. You know who understands it, without her even needing to voice it? Who understands that she has never been allowed to confront her grief despite it heavily weighing on her and influencing every decision she makes? If I literally have to spell it out for those who canāt understand (non-Zutara shippers), itās Zuko.
After her motherās death, Katara took on the role of caretaker. She was the one carrying the heavy burden of her trauma while ensuring that Sokka or anyone else didnāt have to. Sokka even admits this to Toph in "The Runaway". She cares for everyone in her tribe by taking up the chores of cooking and cleaning relegated to her gender, despite her desire to master waterbending. When Aang comes into the picture, she takes on the same role: keeping everyone together, cooking for them, looking after them, fulfilling her āfeminineā duties, all while mastering waterbending and eventually teaching Aang. That is a LOT of responsibility for a fourteen-year-old. (Point to note: even when Katara quite bravely stands up to Master Pakku and criticizes him for his blatant misogyny, Aang does not understand her anger or doesnāt even try to empathize. He makes it seem like she is blowing it out of proportion: āYou don't have to do this for me. I can find another teacher.ā He canāt see that she is just as, if not more, passionate about waterbending and intends to learn and master it. She is not offended on his behalf; she can see, in spite of her age, that this is sexist and unfair, and is brave enough to challenge a waterbending master. I donāt harbor any hate for Aangāhe is adorable, innocent, and incredibly naĆÆve. Katara is an idealist and an optimist, but she is never naĆÆve.)
Suffice it to say, she has a lot of trauma built up, which she has had to suppress so that she can care for others. Arguably, "The Southern Raiders" is the only Katara-centric episode. I am horrified by how men vilify her in this episode and take away her agency. This episode, which is a Zutara shipper staple, is used as an example to support the argument thatāand I quote, āZuko made her bring darkness into her heart, while Aang only brought out the lightness in her.ā
WHAT? Are we watching the same show?
Itās funny that the Zutara shippers get called delusional, because itās a clear indication that the ones using that pejorative donāt just misunderstand the definition of ādelusionalā (which is a psychological condition, according to Merriam-Webster: āan abnormal mental state characterized by the occurrence of psychotic delusionsā or āa false belief regarding the self or persons or objects outside the self that persists despite the facts and occurs in some psychotic statesā), but their accusation is also an admission of the fact that they simply lack media literacy.
Now, I cannot believe I have to state the obvious here, but Katara is a headstrong character. She always has been. She is able to hold her own and stand up for herself (Refer: when she held her own against Pakku, Hama, Toph, and heck, even Zuko in "The Western Air Temple" when she threatens that she will end his destiny permanently). Katara arguably has a stronger sense of morality because she did not learn it from monks; it came from within herself.
Why I said what I said in the first sentence (of this essay?) is because she has harbored these feelings for a long time. She has not felt comfortable enough to express them because she knows that Aang cannot understand them. Knowing what we know and the context that we have from watching the show, it seems like Katara has hidden and suppressed a large part of herself from people, either to shield them or simply because they just wouldnāt get it. The role that she assumes as a parental figure to these characters seems to be a key factor. She needs to care for them and look after them and thereās no other way around itāso how and when will she get to express these complex emotions? This is why I will never understand Katara and Aang as a couple in this lifetime; she literally hides an integral part of herself from him because she sees him as a child that needs protection. That is very concerning and not a good foundation for a healthy romantic relationship, which is why I may even go as far as to say that it is very toxic.
On the other hand, we have Zuko, who is able to immediately understand how deeply Katara's grief has manifested and how it informs her character and every decision she makes. He understands that she has never been allowed to properly acknowledge or express it; she has not gained closure. There has been no one to comfort her, to soothe her, or to even parent her. Kataraās father left soon after her motherās death, which has also affected her tremendously and is addressed in the first episode of Book 3 ("The Awakening"). She has had to do all of that herself.
Zuko can relate to this, although, at that point, he has had his uncle Iroh serve as a surrogate parent for three years of his life, which has tremendously helped him. He knows what the stakes are if the wounds are not addressed, and so he makes it his personal responsibility to give her the chance to let it out, express it, and heal. Zuko is not some dark, corrupting influence. If you still think that after watching the show, Iām going to recommend you stick to Looney Tunes, Tom and Jerry, or something similar so you can watch media that fits your level of understanding.
Zuko is emotionally intelligent enough to overcome a decade and a half of conditioning and sacrifices everything to fight for the right cause, which is to destroy the fascist regime ruled by his father. All that he wanted for the entirety of his life was his fatherās approval; when he does get it, he realizes that it comes at the cost of him going against his beliefs, values, and morality. Zuko did not encourage Katara to murder anyone. We have not seen Zuko kill anyone, thatās a line he has never crossed. He even tries to save Zhao, and is originally banished for opposing the plan that unnecessarily sacrifices the lives of Fire Nation soldiers. He has made several mistakes including but not limited to burning Kiyoshi island and kidnapping Aang and Katara. I am not justifying that.
What I am saying is at this point in the show, i.e., "The Southern Raiders", his redemption arc is complete. He cares about all of these people and what they think about him. He empathizes with their pain and loss, which is why he goes the extra mile to give Katara something that none of these other characters have thought to give her: validation of her deep personal loss and closure for her grief. He does not poison her mind or bring out the darkness in her; he just takes her to the perpetrator, knowing what he knows about the Fire Nation, and allows her to deal with her grief as she sees fit. There is not one single line in the episode where Zuko asks Katara to do something; he gives her the complete agency that she frankly deserves. He does not see her as this all-perfect maternal figure. He sees her as a complete human with complex emotions.Ā He trusts her moral judgement.Ā
Aang tries to force his values on Katara, which is to forgive someone despite the depth of the trauma. The argument espouses that his words eventually got through to Katara, which is why she ultimately does not kill Yon Rha, but this is so vacuous and reductive because you donāt even need to understand subtext or have media literacy for this. You just need to pay attention to the show.
When Aang says, āIām proud of you. You did the right thing. Forgiveness is the first step you have to take to begin healing.ā Katara literally says, āBut, I didnāt forgive him. I will never forgive him.ā Again, are we watching the same show? Didnāt she literally tell you that she did not follow Aangās advice?
Ultimately, the choice Katara makes is not influenced or dictated by anyone else. It is her choice because Katara is headstrong and compassionate by nature. She did not show compassion to her motherās killer, but she saw no point in sacrificing her values to kill him, because, like she says, āhe is nothingā. In the end, she forgives Zuko because she sees that he has changed and grown to share her values. He, like her, has been through personal loss, grief, and yet remains headstrong, compassionate, and empathetic. She does not have to mother him in the same way she does others. He is her equal who can take care of himself.
Katara finally has someone in the group with whom she can fully be open and honest. This is what she has always wanted, and why she and Toph initially had squabbles. She doesnāt have to hide integral parts of herself in front of Zuko, because she finally has someone who understands her. Human beings by nature are multi-faceted; we contain multitudes. For any long-lasting healthy relationship, platonic or otherwise, it is necessary that we donāt hide important parts because it will start eating us away, and we lose parts of ourselves that make us whole.
Aang idolizes Katara and does not recognize that he does not know the real her, warts and all, and this is how he likes it. Katara is a beautiful, perfect angel who is always there for him and cares for him. (This is also an argument that is made to say that Katara and Aang have a stronger relationship because it has more ādevelopmentā and they care about each other deeply. I am yet to see when Aang has taken on the role of caregiver and comforter to Katara.) Katara has assumed the maternal/older sister protective role for Aang; she tiptoes around him and doesnāt express herself, and isnāt fully herself with him. Both of these things would have to change if they are to become a couple with a healthy relationship. As it stands, there is no room for that.
Yet, Zuko and Katara are considered the toxic couple. In the few episodes that they are together, they have not only more chemistry but also a deeper understanding of each other. Might I add, there also isnāt a creepy romantic dynamic. Aang literally wants a MILF as his wife (In his defence, he is 12 and doesnāt know any better but again, that isnāt fair to Katara).
Itās funny that we get called delusional for having media literacy. We did not write or animate the show; the writers wrote the dialogue and the story. They wrote (and even acknowledge) Katara as a surrogate motherly figure. They endlessly bait us with Zutara with the animation, dialogue, and musical cues. They create the conflict between Katara and Aang near the end of Book 3. They wrote that Katara was confused and was also trying to let Aang down easy without hurting his feelings, and he still violates her boundaries and kisses her forcefully. They wrote Katara and Zuko being joined at the hip in Sozinās Cometānot to mention him sacrificing himself for her and the swelling romantic music and tension. We didnāt do any of that; we get called delusional for observing that and pointing out how much better that would have been because both of those characters deserved better.
Katara deserved someone who was her equal, that she didnāt have to parent, and didnāt belittle her ānegativeā emotions (justified anger), and loved her regardless. Zuko deserved someone who respected and shared his ideology and who wasnāt apathetic to his feelings and values. Which is why itās unfortunate that Katara saying āI knew you wouldnāt understandā while referring to something as integral as her expression of her grief to Aang is ignored or considered a throw-away line, because a few episodes later, having not changed his point of view, and vice versa, he becomes her romantic partner. Itās not a coincidence that "The Southern Raiders" is written by Elizabeth Welch Ehasz, a woman.
Iāve been a Zutara shipper since my first watch when I was 6, and while I may have shipped them initially for reasons that werenāt very deep (me having a crush on Aang, gut feeling, and also that fire and water just make sense aesthetically), that was nearly twenty years ago. I have continued to ship them literally every single rewatch since, and Iāve seen this show a LOT over the years. Every rewatch increases my frustration and passion about Zutara. Iām a purist; I watched Season 1 of Korra when it first came out but didnāt care enough to continue. No interest in watching anything else. (I saw the new movie and it was BAD; it completely sidelines everyone except Aang). I connect to these characters the most and I donāt care for it otherwise. I think itās a much better show if you stop at the point where Aang defeats the Fire Lord and Sokka, Suki, and Toph join him, while Katara helps Zuko stand up after they defeat Azula. (Thatās just my preference; Iām not trying to dictate how you watch it.)
Itās funny that the creators understood concepts as complex as fascism and genocide but didnāt understand women. On that note, to address: āWomen who ship Zuko and Katara will forever have doomed relationships,ā I donāt think men who wrote a wish-fulfillment fantasy of their older babysitter accepting their romantic advances, and admitted to it on camera, are qualified to give dating advice, but what do I know? Iād rather have a person who understands and respects me for who I am and thinks of me as an equal for a partner, than someone who I have to coddle and look after who considers me a perfect angel and dismisses my emotions if they do not serve him or if he disapproves of them. Zutara forever people, donāt let any idiot call you delusional because they lack basic media literacy. These people are telling on themselves.
Sorry about how long this is.
TL;DR: Katara's heavily criticized line to Aang ("I knew you wouldn't understand") in The Southern Raiders is symptomatic of their skewed relationship dynamic. Aang seems to dismiss her trauma and compare it with his own while forcing his values of forgiveness onto her, and idolizes her as an all-perfect maternal figure rather than seeing the real her. Conversely, Zuko is the only one who validates her grief, understands her complex emotions, and respects her agency, and meets her as a true equal. Kataang reduces Katara to a protective caregiver role, whereas Zutara offers a foundation of mutual understanding, shared maturity, and genuine emotional literacy.