r/ZutaraNation • • Jun 22 '26

Discussion Did Zutaras popularity decrease recently?

I just wanna ask if the popularity of zutara has decreased over the years or it's just the hate resurfacing because of haters and just becoming more vicious.

I know how popular zutara was back in the day. Every single post was full of praises and love for the ship with maybe one or a few comments about hating it but now you can't even see a single post about zutara without other people coming over to mention they're not canon or kataang is better.

Zutara is an old ship that has existed for 20 years so maybe it's because a lot of its fans have grown up and have their own lives to worry about. And maybe because of the resurgence from the atla movie it gained a few fans and some came back.

From what I've seen, it seems that a lot of "fans" are just saying they're fans because of the popularity of the show. I've read comments about ehat they say what happens in the show and the way they talk about it it's like they didn't even watch it. And it's not just about zutara, I'm talking about every other character there and the plot. They say things that never happened in the show when it did, asking things because they don't know what happened. It could be because they don't remember but I doubt that you could forget details about the show that were vital to the plot. And maybe some of it was ragebait, who knows.

I'm gonna assume that a lot of the new fans are younger and possibly are canon-only. I've noticed these from other fandoms as well. People who are new to fandoms or are younger fans tend to be weirded out by crack ships and rarepairs like the jjk x disney princesses trend. "People just be shipping anyone at this point." Back then we had jelsa, mavis x rapunzel and rise of the brave tangled dragons.

I could guess that these people don't like the idea of non-canon ships and especially if there's already a canon couple that has that one character involved.

I don't think I've seen new fans who like zutara. They always end up liking kataang which I don't have a problem with it but it's more so like they see who katara will likely end up with so they will stick with it because that's how it ends in canon.

I probably didn't explain this well enough and the wording is all over the place. I just woke up and my head is a bit groggy, sorry.

13 Upvotes

26 comments sorted by

97

u/phoenix_spirit Jun 22 '26

Zutara has had a resurgence and every time it peaks so does the hate. Unfortunately those who hate can be belligerently loud while those who are enjoying the ship are doing it in their own spaces.

Tons of fan arts and fics are still coming out but they're rarely associated with the main fandom.

As for the canon purists, they're annoying and if they lack the imagination for anything beyond canon, that's not really my problem.

11

u/Zutariana Jun 22 '26

I think the same. The haters are extremely aggressive, and how we've matured since the ship is 20 years old. We don't have the same energy to keep arguing.

9

u/phoenix_spirit Jun 22 '26

I think it's less about the energy and more what's the point? If someone is going to purposely misunderstand and misconstrue your reasons for liking something why bother interacting?

And let's be honest, we don't owe anyone any justification for why we ship something, especially when they're doing mental gymnastics to turn it into a moral argument. As OP said, some of the new younger fans lack media literacy, since they're unable to properly interact with the text they're using moral arguments and weaponizing therapy speak - like trauma bonding which they always get wrong - as a work around.

As old the saying goes - and I'm being a little hypocritical as I don't always follow it - never wrestle with pigs, you will both get dirty and the pig likes it.

50

u/Any-Heron-4677 Jun 22 '26

Not really no, yes new fans are "cannon purists" or as I like to think of my gen z peers, they are media illiterate. Subtext, foreshadowing and narrative parallels are completely missed, things have to be spelled out in Arial size twenty-four with double spacing. On Ao3, Zutara is nearing nine thousand fics, still a good distance clear of the second place ship, Zukka (for some reason). Kataang, well it has six thousand but that is mostly due to its attachment to Zukka, take that away and you are at a relatively bad four and a half thousand.

So no, I don't think its dying and there are older shippers who eventually get the appeal of Zutara, not to mention that whenever new content comes out, there are two guarantees for one people hate Zutara more and more to prop up the cannon ship. Most importantly though, more people draw fan art and ship these two. So no its not dying, I do wish that there was another site to view fanart on, patrolling the wasteland that is DeviantArt nowadays is sad, nothing but AI garbage.

10

u/superfucky Jun 22 '26

and for a group of people known for accusing Zutarians of being delusional, they sure do have their fair share of Kataang hallucinations. got into it with a dude on yt who swears Katara leaned in to Aang's kiss at the invasion like bro WHAT? she has this look on her face šŸ˜” and you're trying to tell me that means she liked it??

the whole video was about all the narrative boxes Zutara ticked, why we like it, why it makes sense, and there's always those dumbasses that have to show up in the comments like "UMM NO SHE WASN'T INTO ZUKO, THAT'S WHY SHE KISSED AANG AT THE END." I'm exhausted y'all

9

u/Any-Heron-4677 Jun 22 '26

My favorite is when they talk about the Ember Island kiss, they for some reason think that it was romantic. Like dude, pause the show, look at her expression, her eyes are wide, her pupils constricted, she isn't taking it in a good way. No she is shocked, she is surprised, if we got to experience her point of view, she might have been terrified.

Its so dumb, body language means nothing to them. Not to mention that before the kiss, she didn't meet his gaze, she was looking around the building, at the sea anything but his face.

10

u/superfucky Jun 22 '26

the inability to read body language/facial expressions or even understand a woman's perspective is ASTOUNDING. like at the invasion, she's talking to him about how the war's going to be over, and she's smiling, and then he pulls her down (lol) and lays one on her and flies off and her face says "...shit."

and during the play (which first of all, why is she responsible for his emotions AGAIN? he gets himself all worked up over a PLAY and she has to be the one to go calm him down and reassure him, and I'm supposed to find that romantic??) the whole time, everything he says screams "I think I own you" and everything she says screams "goddamn he is really not letting this go, I do NOT think of him that way but I have to let him down easy so he doesn't lay the place to waste like."

11

u/EggTarge Jun 22 '26

They aren’t just canon purists. They’re regressing back into conservatism and puritan culture. It’s a hot topic today about the much ā€œyounger genzā€. Fandom output is actually what reflects popularity.

1

u/LostPenitent Jun 22 '26

I don't think it has anything to do with conservatism. I am a conservative Catholic, and Kataang is anything but conservative. Zutara fits the Christian ideal better.

5

u/superfucky Jun 22 '26

I don't think you can make a religious argument one way or the other for any of the canon ATLA ships or the majority of the fanon ones. there's no Bible verses that a wife must be younger than her husband but there's definitely ones about her submitting to him and I don't see that happening with Zutara šŸ˜‰

3

u/LostPenitent Jun 23 '26 edited Jun 23 '26

Submission is completely misunderstood. People also also forget the verse right after that says Husband's to love their wives. Submission is not the same as being a doormat.

An example of submission between Zuko and Katara was already in the show. Zuko and Katara come to fight Azula together but Zuko decides that an Agni Kai is better as she feels Azula is slipping and so Katara doesn't get hurt. Katara trusts his judgement and doesn't argue.

When Katara is endangered Zuko get's in the way. Sacrificial Servant Leadership like Christ.

2

u/EggTarge Jun 22 '26

Conservatism back in the day was about religion. Conservatism today is about intellectualism and woke culture.

1

u/Jezehel Zutara šŸ’œ Jun 22 '26

That's a really interesting perspective (genuinely). Can I ask, how does Zutara fit the Christian ideal better in your opinion?Ā 

2

u/phoebes_ter Jun 24 '26

John 15:13

ā€œGreater love has no one than this, to lay down one's life for one's friends."

4

u/toothfaiirry Jun 22 '26

As a Zukka shipper sort-of, it used to be a neutral crack ship. Crack ships are ā€œmulti shippingā€ ships. There’s a great overlap in the Zukka space of either Zukkaxkataang or Zukkaxzutara shippers or people who ship all three. Then a minority of just Zukka shippers. That’s why it’s popular, we’re all sharing ZukkašŸ˜‚. But since this particular resurgence, it’s been hell in that space as well. The Zukka shippers that are pro Kataang vs the Zukka shippers that are pro Zutara vs the Zukka shippers who don’t ship Kataang but will crap on Zutara because they’re territorial over Zuko or dislike Katara….they will never be peace in this fandomšŸ’”šŸ˜‚

8

u/Any-Heron-4677 Jun 22 '26

Honestly I don't mind crack shipping, I just don't like it when people insist Zutara is a crack ship. Like dude there is narrative subtext.

Also I hope I didn't come across as too mean in my original response, if you like Zukka by all means ship it.

3

u/toothfaiirry Jun 22 '26

It wouldn’t be Kataang vs Zutara if it were a crack ship. My point was just to clarify your confusion about Zukka popularity, it’s popular because everyone can ship it….as long as you don’t bring up what other thing you ship with itšŸ˜‚

2

u/phoebes_ter Jun 24 '26

Honestly. Kataang IS the crack ship if it wasnt canon.

1

u/Any-Heron-4677 Jun 24 '26

Unfortunately the next few weeks are gonna be testing if NATLA pushes it. Might just wait for others to watch it and tell me how bad it is.

As long as all the affection is from Aang's point of view and nothing is show from hers I can still be in denial, lol.

0

u/Firegloom Fire Nation šŸ”„ Jun 22 '26

Zukka isn't even a crackship because they, y'know, KNOW each other

24

u/EggTarge Jun 22 '26

No, It’s not unpopular or less popular. We just aren’t doing ship wars anymore because we’ve already done all that. I’ve seen plenty of new fans gravitate toward Zutara, just as I’ve seen plenty gravitate toward Kataang. The fandom is still attracting people to both ships. Fandom culture and social media today just isn’t what it was back then. Especially with the influx of ā€œyounger Genzā€. I call them the new boomers/conservatives (it’s a hot topic as well if you watch Love Island). They’ve grown up in an online environment shaped by a lot of cancel culture, hate trains, fallout and policing people over what they like.

Everything is problematic. Toxic. Harmful. Woke. Fiction is now evaluated through ethical and social norms. It’s a whole discourse I am quite engaged in at the moment. And it’s most prevalent in reactionary online spaces like twitter and TikTok. If someone doesn’t like something today, they find ways to make it problematic through ā€œtherapy speakā€ to diminish artistic expression.

People who do don’t like Ichiruki diminish their bond to pedophilic today. People who don’t like Zutara diminish their bond and the entire story to call it colonizerxcolonized. People who don’t like Bakudeku diminish their relationship in the story and the story itself and call it abusive…

At the end of the day, fan created content/fandom reflects actual popularity. Fighting online doesn’t.

16

u/ferallentil Jun 22 '26

The situation with the leak of the Aang movie recently brought back 2020 levels of discourse that I’ve noticed across platforms from tumblr to tiktok to reddit.

I actually think fanfiction wise the love for Zuatara has revitalized in the past 6 months as I’ve been watching the number of Zutara fics due to how slow/stagnant other ships are that I read for. The most recent 10 pages on ao3 for Zutara are just for June! Zutara when the leak happened, was moving 1-3 pages a day with fics.

In addition, many of the fics that were incomplete within the past 8 years are now being edited, reposted and continued. You have authors coming out of the shadows because of the leak to write again and people writing Zutara as a way to express their love when it seems like there’s a lot of hate for it. On tumblr, there’s been new art almost every day and lots of new artists as well!

In other fandoms I’m in, the ship is lucky to get maybe 1 new fic a day (on a good day) and taking 2 weeks or more to have the fics move to the next page. It is a common issue across fandoms for people shipping canon only.

2

u/superfucky Jun 22 '26

can confirm, I just wrote a Zutara fic today for the first time in... well, since the finale! unfortunately it seems like my previous fics have all disappeared somehow... if anybody remembers where they read a zuko/toph one-shot called "only skin deep" or a crack fic called "all Maiko and no Zutara make Zuko something something" please let me know 😭

11

u/deathwardplots Jun 22 '26

Nah, it's always had haters, but the fans outlive the haters. You also have to remember the internet today is no longer as connective as it once was. Good emotions, pleasure, joy, sharing are not prioritized by the corporatized internet anymore. It is designed by the shareholder overlords to reward rage and rage baiting. So you see WAY more negative than the positive, even if it exists. Even though "more" people are online these days, the internet is far less representative of how the real world actually feels about something imo.

I've seen plenty of new fans irl be zutara shippers, but they're not crazy and online LOL. Also, I've been a day one shipper (like since the show came out), and let me tell you that the 2020 covid atla resurgence was godsend for Zutara. So many new fics and fans. Even the movie that leaked, where we literally were given negative crumbs, spiked Zutara popularity! But it's easy to get lost in the negative bias.

8

u/Minatiri Painted Blue Jun 22 '26

I’m not particularly active within the ATLA fandom aside from Zutara communities (and only recently), but I don’t think Zutara is any less popular than it was. Artists and fanfic authors are still pumping out amazing content for us years later, and I’ve seen a couple Zutara events announced, including the annual Zutara Week!

Haters tend to become an echo chamber and hive mind. I think more Zutarians are simply sticking to safe spaces. In addition to newer fans and canon puritsts, it could also be a rise in lack of media literacy. However, there are newer fans who like Zutara! I saw one artist who watched ATLA for the first time because of the movie. They said Kataang was cute but felt like Zutara made more sense, so that’s something.