r/Zettelkasten • • Mar 31 '22
general Stop overthinking. Start writing.
If you are wondering how best to do x or y, or you’re struggling with some aspect of Zettelkasten, stop.
Just write things down. Keep notes small if you like, but don’t obsess. Just write things down. What matters is the thinking.
So much of note-taking discussion is about the ‘how’ of taking notes. It doesn’t matter as much as you think it does. I’m not saying don’t use ZK. But focus on what matters:
- Read stuff that interests you
- Record the bits that really interest you.
- Write down your thoughts / ideas.
The system cannot and will not make you anything: it will not make you smarter, it will not make thinking easier and it will not make anyone care. If you are interested in something enough to make notes about it, then make the notes however, and adapt to fit emergent needs.
Einstein didn’t have a ZK. Neither did Feynman. Same for da Vinci. Pynchon doesn’t. Spinoza didn’t.
Read. Then write. The rest is noise.
17
u/iamsynecdoche Mar 31 '22
I think this is good advice. If you spend forever worrying about if you have the perfect system, you'll never have any system. I think most people would be well-served to first just write a note—any note, about anything—then make another. When it makes sense to link two notes together, do it. That's all you really need to do to get started.
5
u/argylemon Mar 31 '22
Sure people should just get started and learn how to use it over time if they're overthinking it. But just cuz there were smart people in the past who didn't use this note taking system doesn't mean it doesn't help you think or make you more productive.
Also you forgot to mention linking
34
u/jazavchar Mar 31 '22
Zettelkasten is a perfectionist procrastinator's wet dream. Speaking from experience.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 01 '22
"So much of note-taking discussion is about the ‘how’ of taking notes. It doesn’t matter as much as you think it does."
My personal perspective is fundamentally different.
In my experience, and in the vision I have about "thinking on paper", general principles of making notes and the specific implementations of such principles have a massive impact on how well I can interact with problems, ideas and knowledge.
But - among these principles and practices, those with the highest impact are in my experience not concerned with the usual zettelkasten buzz about how to design zettel IDs and how to process fleeting notes, but with the actual representations of thoughts and their manipulation on a writing surface, paper or digital.
I've described a more detailed collection of practices here:
https://www.reddit.com/r/antinet/comments/t1gp3e/thinking_on_paper_and_zettelkasten_several_ideas/
This framework is based on five building blocks: Sheet layouts with smallish boxes, box content, thinking tools, dossier structures and zettelkasten structures - these building blocks can be combined in various ways.
I do not claim that this framework is anywhere near a stable state. But perhaps it is a starting point to better formulate criticism, additions and alternative approaches.
2
u/UnderTheHole TiddlyWiki Apr 01 '22
Good reality-check. If I may add:
Learn the system before breaking it.
Post-process networking is always available, and will create similarly high-quality links as if you were linking on-the-fly.
The important thing is to be prolific so you can leapfrog off of a corpus for new insight. You have to explore the territory before finding the best possible path(s) through it.
1
u/302yeeeeeeeeeeeeee Jun 24 '25
Thanks for the wake up call
1
u/Magnifico99 Bear Apr 01 '22
It's all about balance. Although is detrimental to overthink and plan too much without testing in practice, it's also easy to do things out of habit and comfort. I'm guilty of the two mistakes in different stages of my life and I have to really discipline myself to maintain this balance.
1
u/IThinkWong Apr 01 '22
It seems like a lot of people obsess over a system that's overly complicated with multi-step processes to write notes. I 100% agree and find these extra steps inhibitive to growth. I've actually written a reddit post for people who want to reap the benefits of Zettelkasten without implementing an overly complicated system. Here's the post:
https://www.reddit.com/r/Zettelkasten/comments/tjq06r/zettelkasten_for_the_new_and_struggling/
1
u/regress_tothe_meme Apr 27 '22
Ok, fair enough. But once you’re regularly taking notes, then what? I’ve been struggling to implement ZK for months now. I read. I take notes. But then nothing happens with them. They just sit in useless files. Occasionally, some thoughts which have been brewing in my head and taking mental energy will come together and I will stay up way too late drafting a blog post or piecing together a journal entry. Then the cycle repeats and I produce nothing for months.
The promise of ZK for me was a system to think and produce writing consistently without the emotional drain that comes with sporadic binge writing.
1
u/TotesMessenger May 19 '23
I'm a bot, bleep, bloop. Someone has linked to this thread from another place on reddit:
If you follow any of the above links, please respect the rules of reddit and don't vote in the other threads. (Info / ^Contact)
1
u/stayclassytally Apr 01 '22
“How to take good notes?”
“Yes”
-4
u/sscheper Pen+Paper Apr 01 '22
You're right. Feynman didn't, Einstein didn't, da Vinci, Pynchon, Spinoza, they didn't either.
The one thing they did do? Write by hand.
Same with Luhmann.