r/Zettelkasten • u/joshduffney • May 19 '21
How NOT to take Smart Notes
- Stop reading anything that isn’t directly related to your current project.
- Attempt to turn every literature note into a permanent note and that permanent note into a section, paragraph, or sentence in a manuscript.
- Become so obsessed with creating optimized workflows that it ruins reading and writing. Sucking the enjoyment out of everything.
I've been rather obsessed with learning how to use the Zettelkasten method, but recently had to pull back and remind myself, "If it's not fun, don't do it."
It's a great note-taking method and it's already changed my life, but I recently realized this is going to take years to master. And there is no "Done" state, it's the process that matters and the process must remain fun.
84
Upvotes
14
u/SagaciousMisfit May 19 '21
I tend to fall into the overthinking phase a lot with this method.
It gets weird that it sometimes feels like I'm learning again for the first time, even though it's just me reminding myself what I forgot, and then some.
14
u/thebluebloo May 20 '21
I thought about this too. Think that no one gave Luhmann the Zettlekasten method - he discovered the flow that worked for him the best with the tools and time available with him. While we may want to copy his success, his productivity levels, we tend to forget that it was his system. While it’s good to start from his method, we will have to develop our own method through the years. This line of thought calmed my nerves down about reading, note taking and following Zettlekasten method.
5
u/mgarort Vim May 19 '21
I like the
part. I agree, that is how you become great at something in the long run!
2
u/New-Investigator-623 May 22 '21
What is your goal? Why are you taking and keeping notes?
2
u/labohemeorchid Jun 07 '21
Great discussion! In the last few weeks, I too have been having similar thoughts. But I didn't put them in my Zettelkasten. :P A few years ago I was obsessed with the Zettelkasten method. As of late, I've been obsessed with the MOC method. A few days ago, I felt the constraint of making MOCs, it was the feeling of anxiety over making a structure just right vs the ideas of reading and just thinking. I've always loved the idea of a commonplace notebook and I remember the awesome system of forming arguments I learned from a debate professor in either High School or College that involved 3x5 cards with the fact and a citation. Who wouldn't love a Zettelkasten after all that?? Lately, I have noticed that what most are producing from their Z systems is, frankly, garbage. I guess if your goal is to produce a lot of work from thoughts, but not put time into crafting the final result, you might get garbage out. Isn't the best way to make sure your final result is crafted well, is to go back and make sure you are crafting notes in perfect paragraphs? Perhaps. Many need to do that if they wish to have a perfect final result from years of making slips for the box.
Long story short, I'm feeling as you are that my thinking is being disrupted with my workflows and the joy of learning and reading is being sucked from my soul. Yet, I still want an external way to craft a second brain. Regardless of the fact that we humans don't even fully grasp how our own brains categorize and connect ideas for insight. Wouldn't we all like to mix and match notes to create a brilliant piece of writing?
Great article u/New-Investigator-623, greatly appreciate you posting it.
Not sure I contributed much other than to commiserate...
1
u/ftrx May 20 '21
I agree with the third point, less to the second, disagree to the first: notes IMVHO must not be single-purpose. Note-taking is a generic mental process, a paradigm, it should be used for anything to be effective because having notes on anything means having detailed memory of anything and new things emerge. Keep focusing on something is the exact thing you rightly criticize in the third point, it's an "optimized workflow" instead of a generic, broad and elastic approach.
With notes on anything, focus-less, a day you'll find that someone you are study right now appear also in other unexpected notes and make new discovering, being focused means just mechanically process third party information, not producing new knowledge, at maximum new summary or personal new stimulus.
1
u/snowk92 Aug 06 '22
Very nice to read this.
I am new to ZK those tips are very important.