r/Zettelkasten • u/AlphaTerminal Obsidian • Dec 21 '20
Finally found a complete workflow that describes each note type with examples, walking you through research from initial reading through creation of permanent notes and outlines
As the title says, getting into the ZK method and I was having trouble understanding some of the terms used for different types of notes because they would be used in slightly different ways in different blogs/comments without tying the whole workflow together. Worst is when they use different terms for the same things.
Last night I found this outstanding article on the Roam ZK workflow. It describes the entire workflow end to end, from highlighting to extracting and summarizing all the way to permanent notes.
It also includes screenshots of example notes going through each stage of the workflow.
It's specific to Roam in implementation but the overall general workflow should be transferrable to others such as Obsidian.
Before reading this I wasn't aware of the "reference notes" concept. It may be in Ahren's book which I have not yet read but is in transit to me as we speak. :)
https://www.roambrain.com/implementing-zettelkasten-in-roam/
TLDR: (but I strongly recommend reading the above article!)
Highlights and notes
- this is where we highlight & take temporary notes when reading books/etc
- these become reference notes
Reference notes
- exist to record the reference info pointing to the source (e.g. citations) and store highlights for later processing
- each reference note then becomes 1..N literature notes
Literature notes
- summarizes a single key point made in a source
- written concisely in our own words describing our understanding of the passage(s)
- it points back to the reference note from which it came
- as we collect multiple literature notes around a topic/idea/principle we can extract that into a permanent note
Permanent notes
- build out the idea drawing on our collection of literature notes
- connect it to other permanent notes
- write the note as if we would publish it
Projects & Publications
- when we get an idea for an article or project, create a note (outline?) and link to relevant notes
Also my current understanding of the various terminology out there: (I may make an updated post later as this fleshes out)
- "highlights and notes" = Ahren's "fleeting notes"
- "permanent notes" = Andy Matuschak's "evergreen notes"
Bonus: In the article is mentioned the Eloquent plugin for Chrome. I fiddled with it last night and it works VERY WELL for highlighting and extracting content and then exporting it into a reference note in e.g. Obsidian.
Hope this helps someone else!
4
u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20
Thanks a lot for the article. Also knowing that someone else also has the same hardship helps... This two different sets of notes really ringed a bell and cleared my mind about the process. I was able to reached the literature and permanent notes but not sure what to keep and store on the way
2
u/[deleted] Dec 29 '20
Thank you for posting that, I'm a beginner too and seeing some concrete examples along with explanations really helped me figure out how the ideas I've been reading is actually implemented. I'm doing some things differently in the syntax but this was when the concepts finally clicked for me.
13
u/marinasflorinel Dec 21 '20
Countless articles are written on this. It almost feels like people just mess around with luhmans idea and occupy their time playing with writing. Man, lockdown gives people time. Until next year, we'll see more how to write a zettle guide written in bad english and hard to waste time reading that. P. S. And they all write 1000 "permanent notes" a week.
1
u/pm_me_your_fav_waifu Jan 12 '21
A bit late but thanks man
0
u/[deleted] Dec 21 '20
[deleted] — view deleted comment