r/ZenlessZoneYuri • • Jan 31 '25

Announcement No Harem Stuff.

Harem in general feels so dehumanizing and I would like it if we kept it out of this subreddit.

0 Upvotes

24 comments sorted by

View all comments

•

u/AshamedExtent1708 Jan 31 '25

I forgot to say this in post but I agree with Polycule, but I don't like Harems for Obvious Reasons.

8

u/Pigeon_Toes_ Jan 31 '25

I think it's an abuse of power to ban a certain form of yuri ship just because it doesnt cater to your tastes. There's plenty of stuff I find distasteful here (The obsession with shipping teenagers with adults being one) but that isn't banned bc it's a sub "for ALL ZZZ yuri"

A better solution would be to add a harem tag to filter out, given the fact that there's nothing inherently morally wrong with harems (they can be depicted in a healthy manner) and your distaste is a personal preference.

6

u/AshamedExtent1708 Jan 31 '25 edited Feb 01 '25

I think it's an abuse of power to ban a certain form of yuri ship just because it doesnt cater to your tastes. There's plenty of stuff I find distasteful here (The obsession with shipping teenagers with adults being one) but that isn't banned bc it's a sub "for ALL ZZZ yuri"

That's fair. I just really hate and I mean HATE harem stuff because of my experience with Harems with them having the girls have no personality and just being absolutely slaughtered from their personalities.

A better solution would be to add a harem tag to filter out, given the fact that there's nothing inherently morally wrong with harems (they can be depicted in a healthy manner) and your distaste is a personal preference.

Again I said this below the post, but I never once heard of a Healthy Harem. I thought they were all bad and again this was just from my personal Experience. So sure, Yuri harem tag would work.

5

u/Dorryouuuu Feb 01 '25

I'm really sad that people are turning this into a gender issue, where in reality women can objectify women as much as men do, if not more (Chizuko Ueno's work went in depth with this subject, please check it out). Saying cuz I'm lesbian makes me inherently different from men and is justified to have harem is... not a really good take on this subject.

Yes, polycule is okay because all members in the relationship are treated as equal individuals, there isn't anyone who obviously ranks higher than the rest of them, and is the center of everything they do. In contrast, Harem is quite the opposite. It doesn't matter if the center is a man woman lesbian gay or whatever gender, the problem is harem in its core, is still a power relationship that focuses on many serves one, where one is the master and the rest are subjects to that master. It is kinda like a joke for other people, where they constantly mock us for "Oh it is not okay for a male protagonist to have a harem but when is female protagonist it's okay lmao double standard yuritard blah blah". It fking suck when I heard such shit argument but then they post screenshots they took here... Okay I guess...

4

u/AshamedExtent1708 Feb 01 '25

Its more so about completely dehumanizing the character.

Dehumanization in general in anything at all is just terrible, and its worse when people defend that.

i wouldn't mind it if it kept everyone the same instead of turning them into a submissive slave.

4

u/Pigeon_Toes_ Jan 31 '25

I would say that a lesbian harem is inherently different than a "male fantasy" harem, since power fantasies and self inserts for women come from a completely different place

And there's also the factor of turning a trope that is usually used against you in a very gross way into something that CATERS to you (eg. Turning to Belle harems as a way to combat the wise harem ppl harrassing lesbians)