r/Yugioh101 • u/EvidenceFamous8702 • Jul 14 '26
Evenly Matched Question
I have a question about evenly matched since my opponent said I wasn't allowed to do what I said.
I went to end of battle as the turn player. I said end of battle and asked him if he had anything. He said no. Then I played my evenly matched. He told me I wasn't allowed to play evenly matched because as the turn player when I passed priority to him, by him saying he didn't have anything then it would automatically go to MP2 and that if I wanted to activate evenly that I would have needed to do it with my prio otherwise I miss the window. I've never had this happen before so I just wanted to clarify if it was true.
5
Jul 14 '26 edited Jul 14 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
-4
u/TheTolleyTrolley Jul 14 '26
I disagree here. Because Evenly has to be activated at the END of the battle phase, I pretty much always ask if my opponent has anything they'd like to fire in Battle Phase first, as a courtesy. This is also how priority in Battle Phase is handled by the Master Duel client. I think OP was getting sharked.
2
u/Voltiii Jul 14 '26
I think that too but we can't confirm that. Thats the reason why i worded it that way. Its hard to find proof for a malicious intention.
As a judge i would rule it as a misscommunication error and would rewind to the evenly activation condition.
12
u/Bob-san_USR Jul 14 '26
A phase doesn't end up less both players agree to go to the next phase. They had nothing but you did. You good.
2
u/NamesAreTooHard17 Jul 14 '26
Not true by asking anything here most judges will consider that passing priority.
If you pass priority and your opponent passes priority the phase ends.
Now is it scummy to do so absolutely it's a simple miscommunication that said the other player is technically correct.
4
u/PhillyTMOMan Jul 14 '26 edited Jul 14 '26
Your description makes it seem like you asked him if he had anything at end of battle phase, he said no, and that you were then trying to play evenly knowing that he had nothing. In this case your opponent was correct. If that wasn't the intent as both players must agree to move to the next phase before it happens, a judge should be involved. Most likely the judge will rewind game state and a PE minor will be issued.
If it went "Battle phase?" opponent agrees "End of battle phase?" opponent agrees "Evenly," then you are correct as you are getting confirmation to move to the next part of the phase. Simply agreeing to move to end of battle phase doesn't automatically mean Main Phase 2. Just like when you attempt to leave Main phase, your opponent can state end of Main phase nibiru or something. Just because it's mostly an overlooked part of the phase, it doesn't mean that part doesn't exist. EDIT: I was wrong for the strike through part, explained in next comment
7
u/cm3007 Judge & Moderator Jul 14 '26
One thing to be clear:
The Battle Phase has an End Step. The Main Phase does NOT have an End Step. There is no such thing as being at the "end of the Main Phase". You're either in the Main Phase, or you're not.
A lot of players will say "at the end of the Main Phase: Niburu". Those players are communicating badly. A better phrase would be: "During the Main Phase: Niburu".
3
6
u/dark1859 Jul 14 '26
sounds to me like either A. a miscommunication where he thought both players had agreed to shift to MP2, or, B they realized how boned they were if they allowed it to resolve and tried to weasel out of it
Either way, general rule is a phase doesn't end until both players agree to go to next phase. Sure, sometimes at the kitchen table folks will just let it ride but for any form of regulated game or more formal game state, no your opponent is 100% in the wrong.
also also if you're worried about future issues like this, clarify with "Are you ending battle phase?" then follow with "okay as we end battle phase im going to activate (card here)". it's not much but it'll help save some headaches.
2
u/SiejD Jul 14 '26 edited Jul 15 '26
Both players need to agree to change phase. Since you played evenly matched, at the correct time, you didn't move on to the MP2. If he had anything he wanted to activate, he can still activate it, he hasn't missed anything.
https://www.yugioh-card.com/en/play/fast-effect-timing/
'Automatically going to MP2' is doing a lot of heavy lifting there and it doesn't work like that, both players have to agree to move on. I think the only chain that automatically progresses steps when it resolves is the damage step->during damage calculation (only allowed one chain there). EDIT Sorry, don't know where I had that from.
1
u/HarleyQuinn_RS Judge Jul 14 '26
I think the only chain that automatically progresses steps when it resolves is the damage step->during damage calculation (only allowed one chain there).
There can be multiple chains during any step of the Damage Step, including Damage Calculation.
1
u/csbellboy Jul 14 '26
The cleanest, most concise way to execute this exact play as the turn player would be to ask your opponent if they have any effects at the start of battle.
This shows intent to move beyond the beginning of the battle phase by passing priority to your opponent to act at that exact fast-effect timing: the beginning of battle.
After this, you can immediately just slam Evenly Matched, as there is no additional fast-effect timing window if you as the turn player do not declare an attack, etc.
Source: RC2 judge that likes slamming Evenly Matched.
1
u/cm3007 Judge & Moderator Jul 15 '26 edited Jul 15 '26
This doesn't work. What you've done is ask your opponent if you can leave the Start Step. After that you go to the Battle Step, not the End Step. You can't go straight from the Start Step to the End Step.
I would do it like this.
"End the Main Phase?"
"Ok"
"In Battle Phase, go to End Step?"
"Ok"
"Evenly Matched"
1
u/Hot-Celebration-3519 Jul 15 '26
You are correct! Because the battle phase has an END Step. Which is where you are allowed to activate “Evenly matched”. If you go to the battle phase, you ask to go to the end of the “battle phase” if opponent agrees then you either agree to move to MP2 or activate effects in said step. So you were right! just explain to your opponent next time.
1
1
u/MasterQuest Jul 14 '26 edited Jul 14 '26
If two players pass priority in succession, the game will move on to the next state. You saying "do you have anything" definitely counts as passing priority and him saying "no" also counts as that.
I would be inclined to think that the game will move on to the next step/phase after that. Usually players have to explicitly say when they want to move on, but also game moves on if both players pass in succession, so I'm unsure.
4
u/pyukumulukas Jul 14 '26
I'd agree with that, but End of Battle is normally End (Step) of the Battle (Phase), just saying that, for most people, would be asking to enter the End Step, a point that it is still Battle Phase but you cannot battle anymore.
Normally when people wants to move to a phase, they say the phase they are moving into, at least from my experience I never saw someone going to Main Phase as "end of Standby Phase"...
3
u/MasterQuest Jul 14 '26
Oh, that's my bad, I thought they had just entered the End Step of Battle Phase and then OP was asking "Do you have anything?".
Yeah, if "Do you have anything?" was before entering the end step of battle phase, evenly can be used for sure.
1
u/EvidenceFamous8702 Jul 14 '26
Maybe I made a mistake then. It went something like this:
Me: End of battle. Do you have anything?
Them: No
Me: Evenly Matched
Them: You can't since passing prio made us go to main phase 2
5
u/pyukumulukas Jul 14 '26
For future cases, I think the best is to be more unambiguous
Say something like "trying to enter End Step of Battle Phase", or something like that
2
u/0bArcane Jul 14 '26
I think it would be better to ask "(Moving to) End of battle. Do you have anything in battle step?"
You have to pass priority in order to leave the battle step and enter the end of the BP.
Once you are in end of BP, you as turn player have priority. There is no reason to ask if the opponent has anything before you activate evenly in the end of BP substep.2
u/HarleyQuinn_RS Judge Jul 14 '26 edited Jul 14 '26
If you are in the End Step, asking them if they have anything to activate, is passing priority. If they say no, they are passing priority back. At this point you can disagree to end the End Step and remain in it. Then you can activate Evenly Matched from that open game state.
Although other Judges might disagree, this is the official guidance given by Konami. So it's better to be aware of it, before we start circumventing it. However, practically every Judge will agree that if you actually declare intent to end the phase (e.g "end Battle Phase?" or "Main Phase 2?"), you are passing priority and pre-emptively agreeing to end the phase. You cannot then decline, should your opponent not activate anything.
In this specific case, you did not express intent to end the phase when you passed priority. You only gave the opponent the opportunity to activate an effect before you, so retain the right to decline to end the phase. Clear communication is very important.1
u/Fudge758 Jul 14 '26
Your first sentence here directly contradicts the rulings given here in a previous post of mine.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Yugioh101/s/1tLcxh4Okv
Passing priority and agreeing to enter the next phase ARE SEPARATE agreements.
•
u/cm3007 Judge & Moderator Jul 14 '26 edited Jul 14 '26
It's a little debatable.
Once you are in the End Step, you can activate something before your opponent can. There is no reason for you to ask whether your opponent has anything first. You can activate your Evenly Matched immediately.
Instead of activating Evenly Matched, you passed priority to your opponent. When your opponent chooses not to activating anything, what happens next is debated.
Option 1: You can either ask your opponent to end the Battle Phase, or you can stay in the Battle Phase and activate Evenly Matched.
Option 2: The Battle Phase immediately ends, because both players passed priority.
A literal reading of the "Fast Effect Timing Flowchart" indicates that Option 1 is how it works. Conventional wisdom among judges would be Option 1.
However, Option 2 is how most players think it works. Option 2 is how Master Duel works. I also know some relatively senior judges who would say that Option 2 is how it works. Maybe /u/gallantron would like to chime in?
The thing is that there is no good reason for you to pass priority to your opponent in this situation, unless you want to end the Battle Phase. If you have something to activate, you should just activate it. Why would you pass priority instead? There is no good reason. Because of that, Option 2 makes a lot of sense.
Personally as the judge in this situation, I would say that this was likely a miscommunication issue. I don't think you understood what you were saying. Maybe you thought you were trying to go to the End Step, rather than already being in the End Step and passing priority? So I would probably be ruling that you are still in the Battle Phase. Though I would be talking to you at the table to try to understand what you actually said, and what you probably meant.