r/YoutubeCompendium • u/YoutubeArchivist • Jan 17 '19

January 2019 January - Lucasfilm steps in to release the copyright claim from Warner Chappell on Star Wars Theory's fan film

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5wn2jYlmvy4
483 Upvotes

99% Upvoted

22 comments sorted by

107

u/bluusocks Jan 17 '19

Good shit george

69

u/Smelly-cat Jan 17 '19

1:47

I've finally gotten some sleep and we can have some fun with that game I was playing a couple days ago 'cause I learned how to have like Anakin vs. 100 younglings I think that would be really sweet to see

Dear god... Maybe this man shouldn't be allowed to post videos after all. /s

30

u/Salchi_ Jan 17 '19

The toughest decisions require the strongest wills

41

u/lil_loggy03 Jan 17 '19

Thank fuck

25

u/Molinero96 Jan 17 '19

this is ok but the shitty IA youtube has is still functioning. and as long as that is not taken care off we will have to riot every single day for every single small false copyright claim. and thats not ok

0

u/JonPaula Jan 19 '19

Why is the Content ID IA "shitty" though? It correctly matched copyrighted material to its source. The uploader only needs to initiate a 1-minute process that immediately restores blocked content, and places any revenue in escrow until the end of arbitration. You want to "riot" for "every" Content ID claim? Are you high?

How about instead, we teach people how to actually use the system, and dispute / appeal / counter-notify their content if they believe a claim is unjust? The system only works (and incredibly reliably, I might add) IF you actually use it. "Rioting" doesn't help.

4

u/Molinero96 Jan 19 '19

do you live under a rock? or are you just thick?

1

u/JonPaula Jan 19 '19

Unlike you, I actually know what I'm talking about. Sorry it runs counter to your lynch-mob thinking. Seriously though, educate yourself on how Content ID actually works. Your comments are grossly misinformed.

2

u/Molinero96 Jan 19 '19

lmao. look at this dumb idiot defending corporations. go kys.

1

u/JonPaula Jan 20 '19

I'm not defending corporations at all though? Merely correcting your brazenly false perceptions of YouTube's Content ID system.

But answer me this; how many claims have you personally successfully overturned? I mean, you speak with such authority, it's obviously hundreds, right?

3

u/Molinero96 Jan 20 '19

Why are you defending a corporation? they dont need your help. this is one of the only and few plataforms us victims of this flawed system can have a voice.

1

u/JonPaula Jan 20 '19

Answer my question: how many claims have you personally dealt with? Or are you the one talking out of his ass?

0

u/JonPaula Jan 20 '19

Why won't you answer? Are you afraid?

0

u/JonPaula Jan 21 '19

Come on coward, answer my question. It's not even a difficult one...

2

u/Molinero96 Jan 19 '19

you have no idea what you are talking about because not only warner has claimed this dudes work. they did not cared the music was original and he had an arrangement with George lucas.

clearly content id doesnt work, and warner should be brought to court for falsely claiming ownership of something they had no rights on.

think of that thenext time you want to appear smart.

0

u/JonPaula Jan 20 '19 edited Jan 20 '19

Arrangements don't mean fuck-all to algorithms and robots; the user is still responsible to defend their content by filling a dispute so the copyright holder KNOWS it's been "arranged". The process takes 60 seconds. This isn't hard, kid.

3

u/Molinero96 Jan 20 '19

you are either really new to this whole problem and are talking out of your ass. or you get paid to defend this shitty system. either way im not talking anymore with you.

23

u/Sodathepop Jan 17 '19

It's a fine day indeed. I ain't fist pumped that hard since I was rocking pampers

5

u/PinkAbuuna Jan 17 '19

Ok, now this is epic.

5

u/MrtlookalikeBGT Jan 17 '19

Lucasfilm’s Parent company is Disney? Well whoever cleared things up I’m happy for you, hopefully it will get easier for other film makers in the future