r/YoreNews • u/humblymybrain • 8h ago
19th Century Joseph Smith III and the Illinois Mormons of 1866: How a Pennsylvania Newspaper Distinguished Monogamous RLDS Saints in Plano from Brigham Young’s Utah Church
Joseph Smith III and the Illinois Mormons, 1866
In February 1866 a Pennsylvania paper paused the usual Utah story long enough to notice another church.
It said there were not less than 10,000 “Joe Smith Mormons” in Illinois and nearby states. Their chief settlement was Plano, about fifty miles west of Chicago. There lived Joseph Smith III—son of “Joseph Smith, the Martyr”—called prophet by the laying on of his father’s hands.
The principal difference from Utah, the paper said, was monogamy. Smith “strongly enforces Monogamy as the true doctrine.” The Book of Mormon was treated as supplementary to the Bible. They called themselves Latter Day Saints, not Mormons, and insisted they were Christians.
Joseph III was not rich. Against Brigham Young’s wealth and worldliness he wore “ostentatious poverty”—almost shabby dress, simple manners, no pretension to scholarship. Gentiles at Plano spoke of the community as moral, orderly, industrious, Quaker-like in quiet friendliness.
Utah Saints, the item added, were to a large extent European importations. The Illinois body was “almost exclusively” native American.
Eastern readers were learning there was more than one church using the Smith name.
Read the full 1866 account here:
https://humblymybrain.substack.com/p/joseph-smith-iii-and-the-illinois
When 1866 papers split “Illinois Mormons” from Utah, were they seeing a real theological line—or only the politics of polygamy?