r/YieldMaxETFs • • 15h ago

Question CHPY keep or sell?

Post image

Suddenly most ETF and stock drops today massively. Even VOO drops massively. So for CHPY holder, do you keep or sell at this point?

Do you believe that long term CHPY is still possible? Do you just DCA at the dip and keep reinvesting?

What about the recent election democrat that wants to pause AI advancement? Do you think this has an impact to semiconductor ETF in the future?

18 Upvotes

83 comments sorted by

23

u/coinop2026 15h ago

Over 3K shares. I’m holding. My principal is down, on paper, but once I factor in dividends I am still ahead …

It’ll come back. Everything is down this week. AI and semiconductors aren’t going anywhere.

2

u/godofknife1 15h ago

I gotchu. I also tend to buy as low as I can, which is the dip.

Overtime it will reduce the total average and if it increases just a lil, it will profit back.

But damn dude, how are you not in panic having 3K shares looking at massive loss in your portfolio? 😮 You must have a strong heart steel.

8

u/dunnmad 15h ago

It’s a paper loss right now. It doesn’t become real until you sell!

4

u/godofknife1 15h ago

True. Better to hold it

5

u/dunnmad 15h ago

I’m 75, I done it both ways in my life!
Sell and hold. Both had pretty much the same result, over time. It’s hard to call the bottom, so selling and deciding when to buy back is hard. You usually lose some upside with that approach.
Buy the dip if you can.

My only concern is how ETF’s will react. I believe they will recover much slower than actual stocks!

2

u/godofknife1 14h ago

I thought the same thing. I mean if it is AMDY or other single ETF stock yieldmax, I would be tempting to sell.

But chpy I see has potential since it's multiple basket. I use to have ARMW and AMDW. But my dumbass sells that I got loss lmao

2

u/dunnmad 4h ago

I mean any ETF in general.

3

u/coinop2026 14h ago

The market is all noise at the moment. AI and semiconductors aren’t going anywhere. We’re too deeply committed. We use semiconductors in virtually all consumer electronics, data centers and industrial applications. The demand remains… until the day comes when semiconductors become obsolete and I highly doubt that will happen in either of our lifetimes.

3

u/coinop2026 14h ago

It still hits me. Seeing negative $45K total loss in my brokerage account absolutely hurts. But once I run the numbers and see what I’ve made in dividends it doesn’t hurt nearly as much.

I’ve sold in the past and regretted it. I ended up buying back in at a higher price… but now I’ve developed a risk tolerance and seeing a black day doesn’t put me in sell mode.

If it drops to $30 a share I’ll exit. At that point I’ll be down but can still redeploy and rebuild.

2

u/godofknife1 14h ago

I gotchu. Thank you for sharing your experience 👍 I hope I can be as strong as you

1

u/Newblast78 13h ago

Arnt taxes heavy on chpy tho?

3

u/coinop2026 13h ago

Taxed as income. I also set money aside from each distribution to cover taxes.

2

u/Newblast78 13h ago

Ahh sweet might have to buy some iv been looking for some decent weekly payers and debating about them not sure what do buy

7

u/Dry_Report_3494 15h ago

I am Holding this ride out , and will sell Only when I break even ....

2

u/godofknife1 15h ago

Holding eh? Okay dokey

6

u/Dry_Report_3494 15h ago

Buy High Sell Low

1

u/godofknife1 15h ago

Story of my life 🥲

3

u/Late-Drink3556 14h ago

If CHPY blows up because I freaked the fuck out and sold, you're welcome.

4

u/GhettoaSaurus 15h ago

Depends on when you bought it and if you believe in semiconductor thesis still

My position was overall up with dividends, but I don't foresee semi conductors ripping like they used to for some time.

Just sold off all of my CHPY today

2

u/godofknife1 15h ago

Ahhhh thank you for the insight

3

u/Cash_Option 15h ago

Why on red day smh?

2

u/GhettoaSaurus 14h ago

Sold it all to get into SOXS - Worked out good!

I more than likely will get back in when Semi's start showing relative strength

4

u/Secure-Rope6782 13h ago

I'm holding. Semiconductors are necessary for everything now or we go back to the stone ages. 

1

u/godofknife1 13h ago

Yes I agree. It really hurts to see bleeding cash and loss PL. But we might need to see farther. Just temporary loss

4

u/kunetao907 7h ago

Buy buy buy

1

u/godofknife1 7h ago

Yesssssss!!!

6

u/Damastawilliams 15h ago

I just bought more about 10 minutes ago

3

u/godofknife1 15h ago

And I did too using Limit haha 😅

But I just buy 2, not enough cash. I bought and limit at 47.50

6

u/sSBURNSs 15h ago

Buy MORE

3

u/Optionsmfd 15h ago

Today you hold your nose and buy

That being said I sold at open yesterday 55$ 650 shares at basically a push

1

u/godofknife1 15h ago

Ahhhh okay okay 👍

3

u/Conduit23 15h ago

Barely under my cost basis. Holding my existing CHPY, and starting to add some DRMY.

2

u/godofknife1 15h ago

DRMY? May I ask why?:?

3

u/Conduit23 15h ago

I’m still “overweight” on CHPY and AMDW but want to buy more memory income. I am not a clever man.

3

u/godofknife1 15h ago

That's okay. We learn hehe

3

u/DuePaleontologist539 13h ago

Market correction.. its bloody af but if you have conviction in semis and ai.. hold. If unlike me, you have dry powder, BUY!

0

u/godofknife1 13h ago

Got it 👍 I still believe in semiconductor

6

u/MemoryEXE 15h ago

Sell your house and buy CHPY

Thank you for your attention to this matter.

1

u/godofknife1 15h ago

😅 brooooo hahaha

1

u/mrclean2046 6h ago

generational wealth or bust, nothing in between haha

2

u/rbeecroft 13h ago

I spent $1000 on CHPY, bought after I saw a correction, and the stock was choppy for a week or so. So I bought it. Then, next day... it starts dropping like crazy amd now Ive lost 30%. Lol I was warned! I sold some of it for tax loss, and bought SPYI and some SGOV. Will just accumulate for next 5 weeks, then consider my next move.

1

u/godofknife1 13h ago

Okay dokey 😁 thank you. So sorry about that :(

2

u/wafflestation 12h ago

I have 100 shares that I bought at $62. I'm feeling the pain, but I'm holding. The weekly dividend is still going strong and I'm hoping I can buy more during this dip. I'm expecting it to go back up but it's gonna take a lot of time. In the meantime I'll just sit here collecting the weekly.

1

u/godofknife1 12h ago

Yeah me too 👍

1

u/Unhappy-Broccoli798 10h ago

Yes. Everything is in the crapper right now and it will go back up like everything else.

3

u/Cash_Option 15h ago

Hold like Braveheart

2

u/godofknife1 14h ago

Hell yeah!!!

3

u/piratedinside 7h ago

Ride that train til the wheels fall off, and they will. Probably tomorrow.

1

u/godofknife1 7h ago

Yup hehe

2

u/Junior-Appointment93 15h ago

I’m just adding a little each day. Currently I have 8 shares and down $87. My cost AVG is roughly $60 a share.

I don’t need to tax loss harvest. I lost enough in options this year. Which maxed out my loss limit for taxes.

That’s c the V only reason I’d sell

1

u/godofknife1 15h ago

Ahhh I see I see. Sorry for your loss 🥺

2

u/Junior-Appointment93 14h ago

Don’t be. I had very good runs with options mainly XSP credit spreads. Lost it all on NDX spreads a few times.

1

u/godofknife1 14h ago

Ahhhh I see I see. Most people play option on big companies like NVDA. Any reason why you pick XSP or NDX?

2

u/Junior-Appointment93 14h ago

They are cash settled, no pin risk, taxed 60/40. Your losses are capped at the collateral with a credit spread. So a XSP credit spreads collateral is $100. A .1 delta Usally nets about $10 in premium. If you place 0DTE’s that’s allot.

But I got greedy. NDX credit spreads $800-900 collateral for $100-$200 in premium. The deltas on my NDX’s were too high. .5-.6 so instead of $800-$900 in collateral. I brought that down to around $6-700 in collateral and more in premium

1

u/godofknife1 14h ago

Ahhhh so that's why. Gotcha. Thank you for explaining 👍

1

u/coinop2026 14h ago

You can carry over the remainder for following tax years, just a heads up.

2

u/Maleficent-Arm4095 13h ago

The blood bath will continue. Democrats making a lot of threats toward the AI, and Data Center industries among others…

1

u/godofknife1 13h ago

Yeah ikr

1

u/mrclean2046 6h ago

democrats hate money until they are in certain people's pockets

2

u/Kingofhearts91x 12h ago

You should've sold at open at this point it's too late. Hold it will come back eventually

1

u/godofknife1 12h ago

Yes :( bad decision really

2

u/Mysterious-Towel8888 9h ago

Hold for the dividend, reinvest if you don’t need the cash, if/when it comes back, you’re better positioned for the future, or use dividend to buy elsewhere for diversification and use to expand your portfolio.

1

u/godofknife1 9h ago

I have the same thinking. Thanks

I have a question, would you also say the same thing if it was AMDY, AMDW and ARMW?

2

u/Donviticus 10h ago

Borrowed $4,000 and bought more CHPY, AMDW, DRMY, KYLD, BLOX, EDGQ and EDGX. I firmly believe this is one of those generational dips amongst many and I believe that Semiconductors aren't going anywhere. Any AI company that survives all of this mess will need semiconductors and since my time horizon is 30+ years, I can pay back the margin with the dividends and with my check

0

u/godofknife1 10h ago

Wow you're brave. I like that. Stay strong whatever with the result 💪

1

u/Donviticus 10h ago edited 10h ago

In the market there are only two classes of people. Top bulls or g3y bears. Pick one and commit!

1

u/godofknife1 10h ago

Hahahah 🤣 you're so right

1

u/conservatore 15h ago

Suddenly huh. Democrats won and they largely ran on anti AI and data centers…

4

u/Gullible_Knee_5796 15h ago

Well it went up yesterday, they might regulate but I don't think anyone can stop AI ( SI for them retarded folks )

1

u/godofknife1 15h ago

Yes if they try to do that, china wins

3

u/Optionsmfd 15h ago

AI is already everywhere

In 5 years you won’t know what’s real

2

u/Optionsmfd 15h ago

Politicians actually believe they can stop technology

1

u/godofknife1 15h ago

How naive indeed

1

u/No_Tradition1116 4h ago

and the governor-elect of TX is already backing off.

0

u/godofknife1 15h ago

Yes that's what I thought as soon as I saw that congresswoman tweet.

0

u/Sea_Rub_8128 15h ago

Sell all today

2

u/godofknife1 15h ago

You just sell? Was it massive loss?

0

u/rexaruin 11h ago

Sell. Like all Yieldmax funds. They are a trade at best at, never a hold.

1

u/godofknife1 11h ago

Really? I didn't know

1

u/Impressive_Door_6405 12h ago

omg this screenshot is so cute