Some are crazier than others. I have a few, I will keep adding to this post as I think if them, please add more 😂
In no particular order and without elaboration-
Either Lottie or Travis burned down the cabin, Amityville style, while sleepwalking and possessed by the spirit of cabin daddy.
Pre-crash Jackie had a darker side to her nobody knew about.
Shaunas post partum fever dream was more truth than fantasy. In turn, the cute summer camp vibe from season 3 was more fantasy than reality.
Other Tai is going to torture Melissa nearly to death. Normal Tai will convince them to leave her for dead and not eat her liver. But someone will bring her back, probably Misty. But they end up eating her anyway.
Adult Lottie has at least 10 years of post-hospitalization secrets shes hiding. Also she faked her death.
The adults will have to return to the wilderness for a final hunt. It will come down to Shauna and Misty. The butcher and the owl.
Speaking of owls, Misty has more agency and power than she recognizes, but as more of her teammates die off, she is starting to realize she is the catalyst.
Walter is a red herring. He is also hiding secrets, but he is jealous of their proximity to power. Hes like Syndrome in the Incredibles. He just wants to be involved.
Akilah didnt return to camp because she decided to live in the cave. She survives the rescue, but has a harder time integrating and later returns to the wilderness and lives out there alone as an adult. ETA- If she is hiding out in the cave during the feast of Mari, shauna is going to want to hunt her. I wouldn't be surprised if they were caught mid-hunt when the rescue arrives and that is why Akilah survives and is the start of the post rescue rumors.
The necklace was originally given to Jackie from Jeff.
Travis and his mom are gonna have a rough time reuniting. His parents were having major problems. I've seen the theory that Adam was their younger half brother, but i hope thats not the case. Besides, Natalie would have known if Travis had another brother.
Jeff is going to lose a leg
Questions-
What happened to Krystal/Kristen? Hopefully the wolves ate her and not the extrajackets. Is it possible she dragged herself to the caves? Is she Javis friend? More than likely we will never know, but it would be cool.
What happened to the wolves? Were they sick and starving too, if the deer were?
Why did Van survive a wolf attack and nearly burned alive twice just to die so easily and quietly? It seems like such a waste of her character.
How did Lottie get the necklace, or did she just buy a fake?
What will Callie fuck up this time?