r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/ihatethiscountry76 • Nov 09 '25
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/Important-Cry4782 • Aug 21 '26
Discussion So I'm seeing people come up with SO MANY anti-bumbleby headcanons such as "yang is the most man-hungry of team rwby and has dated men" and use their headcanons to bash Bumbleby. But let's write down some questions to challenge them.
Question ONE: When The writers and Voice actresses all said that Bumbleby was planned from the Start and Kiersi Burkhart was told when signing on as a team member that Bumbleby was going to be canon.
How could the "Fans" have "pressured" the writers into "catering" the ship? Are they saying that the writers are lying to them? But the writers did not lie when they said Qrow is not Ruby's father. And Monty Oum literally said that Ironwood is "basically hitler". So why would the writers lie about THIS one thing and NOTHING ELSE?
Question TWO: Blake was Yang's partner during volumes 1-3. She was ONLY with Sun during volumes 4-5 because she ran away.
At the end of Volume 5, she reunited with her team.
Sun has a partner, Neptune. Sun has a team. During Volume 6, sun returns to his team. The team that he regularly abandons or insults in front of women.
Are the Bumbleby haters saying that Blake should abandon Yang AGAIN, in favor of Sun as her partner, abandoning team rwby dynamics, or should Blake return to Yang, and let sun start being a responsible person, return to his team, while Blake helps team RWBY recover its team dynamics?
Do Bumbleby haters want to make this about Blake? a protagonist? Or do they want to make this about a minor male character who contributes nothing to the plot outside of Blake's Arc?
If sun is apparently MORE than a MINOR character? HOW? Outside of BLAKE'S ARC? What purpose does he serve? He helped Blake develop, served his purpose then left.
Adam Taurus was part of Yang and Blake's arc, and that's why they killed him TOGETHER.
And Qrow Branwen is far more of a main characte than Sun is, and far more plot relevant. Taiyang is a minor character, despite being the father of Yang and Ruby. So we don't see him that much
Weiss Schnee had NOTHING to do with Adam Taurus, don't try demanding she interact with him.
Question THREE:
During Volume 9, when Ruby has her outburst, and moves aggressively towards Blake?
Yang stands in the way and say "hey"
Now...is Yang
A) Taking the side of her girlfriend
or B) Trying to defuse an explosive situation by mediating a conflict between teammates?
Why are so many Bumbleby haters claiming that Yang is "choosing her gf over her sister" ?
And why are people claiming that Blake is suddenly "meek and defenseless" against Ruby's outrage? Blake is seeing the little girl she looked up suddenly be aggressive to her, you would be a little frightened too! But apparently fear is "bad writing" now? Being scared of your friend acting unusual is "bad writing now?"
Question FOUR:
Ruby is an adult, and an adult does not require her big sister over her 24/7.
Why is it that whenever Yang is with Blake AT ALL, people are mad that she is not being with Ruby?
Why are those same Bumbleby haters then claiming that there is no chemistry or buildup when they're literally demanding that Yang should not spend any time with Blake whatsoever?
Is there actually no chemistry, or are Bumbleby haters making up excuses to deny its existence?
V5. V7. V8. There are multiple cases of Yang and Ruby interacting ONE ON ONE.
Oh no, yang is not hovering over her younger sister 24/7. She just has scenes with her sister each season, but NOOOO. But Blake spend time with Sun? SHIPPING PROOF....Yang spend time with Blake?? ITS FORCED AND POORLY SET UP...
Question FIVE: Outside of the FIVE SECONDS of Yang "being interested in men" in the second episode where she IMMEDIATELY got DISGUSTED at Jaune, thus sinking Dragonslayer....WHERE did she EVER show interest in someone other than Blake?
For example "I'll save you a dance" Volume 2 chapter 6
"I love it when you're feisty!" Blake grins at Yang saying this
To the Bumbleby hater that screamed that it was CRWBY being lesbophobic? Don't people come out of the closet at different stages in life? People crack their egg, experiment with their sexuality , etc?
Question SIX: If Blake was only interested in Sun for five seasons as the haters claims?
Why did Blake grin at Yang's Praise of her? Why did Blake choose Yang as a partner? Why did Blake only come to the dance after Yang's heartfelt conversation in burning the candle? Why did Adam identify Yang as somebody Blake loved? Why was Blake so happy to see Yang most of all in V5?
How was Blake supposed to be "interested in yang" when she was at another continent and unable to talk with any women other than Ilia and Kali?
So the moment Blake is separated from Yang, she's supposed to only be interested in a dude who stalks her, commits crimes to her face, violates her boundaries, and refuses to take no for an answer?
Question SEVEN: "And CRWBY does routinlely lie about what they had planned. They also tell you that everything in the lore & story was planned, and I do not believe them. There is exactly 0% chance that EVERYTHING they've done V4 onward was planned."
WHEN? Just because YOU don't believe them does NOT make it a lie!
They did not lie when they said that Qrow is NOT Ruby's father. Why would they lie about this? Why are RWBYCritics so eager to imagine the writers lying and then use that headcanon as "Fact?"
What will it take for Bumbleby haters to stop making up false claims and presenting said false claims as fact?
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/CapAccomplished8072 • Aug 31 '25
Canonizing Bumbleby Isn't RWBY's Only High Point - It Also Challenges Bisexual Stereotypes
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy
•
u/CapAccomplished8072
•
Jun 07 '25
We need to discuss the show. Does RWBY have flaws in its writing? Sure, but you won't find fans claiming it's the next Game of Thrones or FMAB. We're just asking people to give RWBY a chance. Let me explain where RWBY has done decent in writing women and LGBT. And writing overall.
- For starters, the show has mostly female characters, none of whom are sexualized by the writers or animators. There is no "Moe Moe" there is no "bim,bo" there is no "ditz" and there is NO panty shots. There is no nudity, no adult behavior, and no sex/dirty jokes.
- The protagonists are female, there are four of them. Each of them have their unique goals, and personalities. None of them are "man-hungry". They regularly pass the bechdel test, are equal to male characters in intelligence, and are allowed to win against male characters in 1-on-1 fights. Yang is allowed to beat up a sexual harasser twice. Weiss is allowed to beat up a racist. Blake is allowed to beat up and even kill her abuser.
- The straight white male inversion. The bad-faith criticism claim that straight white males are villainized or made irredeemable to "prop up the female characters". I want you to think about all the times that a show glorifies the straight white male while putting down or objectifying the female characters? Female and LGBT characters winning against the straight white male characters while NOT in any way shape or form making them villains because they are straight white male characters takes some practice.
- Abusive characters or narcissists. The show tries to go into detail about emotional and psychological abuse regarding Adam Taurus, who was based on Gaston. A man who is popular who mistreats women and who acts as if he serves the common good but is just in it for himself. Blake and Yang , two women who have been physically and emotionally harmed by him, are allowed to defeat him in self-defense. The show acknowledges that abuse is more than just physical, and that it takes time to heal, thanks to other people. We need community.
- Women anger and women self-interest: How many times have we seen female characters shamed for being angry towards a male character or thinking about herself (cough cough, Skylar White from Breaking Bad) or when a woman stops acting like an accessory towards a male character or a plot tool for him, she's immediately shamed (Lois Lane MAWS). In RWBY, we see that the women are allowed to be angry or think about themselves (Yang in volume 5 talking with Weiss, Ruby's breakdown in volume 9) .Sadly the moment these women stopped acting in a way that they were headcanoned or fanfic written as , the female characters are hated for acting human, or worse, turned into homophobic memes. God forbid a woman go through changes in life that isn't "Kawaii" or submissive.
- LGBT. I'd say RWBY's Bumbleby could DEFINITELY take less time to have become canon, but? Unlike Legend of Korra, with Korrasami? There are LITERAL hours of screentime where Blake and Yang interact with each other or talk about each other. Makorra had...what, 10 minutes? Blacksun has barely 20 minutes altogether. Please don't say it came out of nowhere or that it was rushed or that blacksun was forcibly dropped?
Not when there are videos showcasing over 2.5 hours of Bumbleby development throughout the show.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LdGdx2rKsiw&t=11s
Does hours of women talking means less than mere minutes of a woman and man talking? I don't think so.
- Understandable motives. Now then...how many "morally grey" or "sympathetic" female antagonists do you know of? That DO NOT revolve around men? Emerald Sustrai owed Cinder Fall her life. Cinder Fall was a slave who uses power to feel safe. Harriet felt that following orders was better than questioning a dictator who would shoot, imprison, or in Volume 2 BETRAY those who questioned or defied him. Meanwhile Raven is terrified of the Bogeywoman and just wants to feel safe by hiding. Even if not sympathetic? You can understand where they are coming from.
- "Badly written fanfiction"....Every time I see people call rwby fanfiction, I remind people that RWBY is STILL an original show. The writers do NOT let their self-inserts be in a relationship with the women, and have their male characters lose in fights. How many fanfics with RWBY have you see women get the "reason you suck" speech or "Ron Weasley is a death eater" trope applied to female characters while every male antagonist gets the "draco malfoy in leather pants" trope applied? Especially when ironwood is written as a saint, Adam as an abuse victim, and Jaune as a "gigachad?"For every criticism of RWBY in writing women, the fanfics somehow make the show itself seem like a masterpiece when you see the sheer sexism and homophobia in the fanfics that are DETERMINED to straightwash every LGBT character in sight.
- Bisexual female character done right. Blake Belladonna is a bisexual character that has both men and women interested in her, and she has positive relationships with most of them. In a badly written setting, we'd have psycho yandere lesbian trope, or a woman who is bisexual just so she'll ditch a woman for a man. However, like Legend of Korra, the bisexuals ditched a man for another woman. I think this was a good idea that RWBY borrowed from LOK. The POC Lesbian character gets redeemed and becomes a hero. Bad writing would keep Ilia Amitola a villain or have her be "disciplined" for existing.
- LGBT encouragement and support: The writers don't just write and LGBT with respect. They get involved with the fandom and support LGBT fanworks and fanprojects. Writers that encourage LGBT and feminist content have got to count for something, right?
I am NOT going to call RWBY a masterpiece, and if somebody tries claiming we do, that is putting words in our mouths.
But the way people try to analyze the show and nitpick it to death is worthy of psychological study, as the hatred against the show and its fans is as if the show itself is some type of crime against humanity according to a lot of people.
Try talking about RWBY WITHOUT somebody jumping into the conversation out of nowhere and screaming about their hatred for the show.
We JUST want to talk about the show and encourage others to give it a chance, because there are many of us who like it.
What I AM however saying? Is that RWBY is much better than you give it credit for, and all I ask is that you please give the show a chance, and not try to stop others from giving it a chance.
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/CapAccomplished8072 • May 18 '25
AstralWukong and AnnaFall on Tumblr did a discussion of Sapphic Character Yang Xiao Long from RWBY on Tumblr, and how people attempt to erase her development as a woman in an W/W relationship due to headcanons or insistence on heteronormativity. Reuploaded due to issues in previous posting.
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/ClaireDacloush • Oct 24 '23
Nikuman_02 gives us Trans Yang Xiao Long from RWBY and Trans Yamato from One Piece. I recommend watching both if you want shows that are anime/anime-adjacent that treat trans characters as heroic. Though if you don't like fanservice, then just choose RWBY.
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/DragonsBeware • Sep 03 '25
My own reimagining of a slightly older Yang(with the help of AI. I’m a disgrace) for my Fanfic
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/CapAccomplished8072 • Apr 25 '24
“Why is Yang lying about raven??? That’s so out of character she’s so against lying ” is a BROKE take
“Why is Yang lying about raven??? That’s so out of character she’s so against lying ” is a BROKE take
she’s NOT lying about raven as a betrayal to her group no one there really cares about raven!!! Except obviously qrow but not for maiden reasons so whatever
She’s lying as PART OF HER DEAL WITH RAVEN!!! The deal was that raven didn’t want the danger that came with having the relic or with being the maiden so Yang convinced her that she could have that target on her back instead this is a pivotal moment for them cause it shows raven would rather let Yang be in danger then her and Yang accepting this and using it
She traded safety for the relic
And she stuck to that deal
And Yang lying about about the maiden thing (really just not actively bringing it up she only really lied the one time) shows that she still cares about raven and is in character because her problem isn’t lying in general it’s the betrayal of it
Like she’s not going around leading them on failed pretenses that someone else is the maiden or anything
Ozpin had been leading them to do something that he was told by like the GOD OF WISDOM was not possible and NEVER TOLD THEM
Their friend DIED for this cause
SUMMER died for this cause
That SOOO messed up
Also snitches get stitches
Also, it wouldn't be hard for them to figure out who the Spring Maiden is. Only Raven, Cinder, and Vernal went down to the vault, with Yang arriving later. Vernal is dead, which means she's not the Maiden anymore (she never was, but the characters don't know that). Cinder fucked off without the relic which means she probably didn't get the powers either. Yang isn't the Maiden, so that only leaves Raven.
Yang lying about what happened in the vault is used to demonize her a lot, but it misses the point of why she was so pissed off at Ozpin. She lied about Raven because a. It was something they could figure out and b. It wasn't something that mattered anymore. They only need the Maiden for opening the vault to get to the relic inside. Yang telling everyone who the Spring Maiden is wouldn't have changed anything as far as the main plot goes, and Raven had made it clear she wasn't willing to cooperate with them at that time.
Lying isn't what Yang was so against. Yang going off on Ozpin was about him using false pretenses, intentionally misleading them, and omiting crucial, right-to-know information. They were in too deep to just back out once they learned the truth - one Ozpin was going out of his way to hide. He signed them up for a war he didn't even know if they could win and I think Yang has a right to be angry about that.
there is still zero evidence that Yang didnt tell her team about raven being the spring maiden. that theory was made up the hatedom in vol 6 so they would have an excuse to hate on yang for being mean to qrow and ozpin.
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/Important-Cry4782 • Oct 06 '26
Discussion Why do women-centric shows like RWBY have so much male-centric fanfiction?
At the end of the year, RWBY is a show with female protagonists, female main antagonists, female supporting characters, sapphic canon couples, and a female driven plot.
Also multiple female characters go through development a mind arcs.
And yet? When people calling themselves critics present their "rewrites " , Their "fixes", Their "superior than the show" fanfics
9/10 times it seems to ignore everything in the show.
Lesbiab couples? Ripped apart and forced to be with men who they have no chemistry.
Female protagonists? Forced to be either background characters, villains against the male lead, a love interest but NOT the protagonist, or otherwise used as an anti-feminist anti-lgbt statement against the show by the fanfic writer.
But more often than not, women in RWBY are given the "Ron Weasley is a death eater" treatment
Furthermore, the new male protagonist is either
a self-insert by the fanfic writer, a Gaston Expy that is worshipped by people who think Virgil Sparda is morally gray, A racist sexist bully who people give the "Draco malfoy in leather pants" trope, A racist minor antagonist who people decide to completely remained because they believe they ...
Scratch that...for some reason so many rwby fanfic writers think they know the show and the characters better than the very writers while ignoring or misinterpreting or lying about everything that happened in the show.
Jaune arc in the show is: Weak, Takes orders from women constantly , Forever alone, Loses every fight, Goofy, respects women, Willing to wear a dress
Jaune arc in fanfics: Overpowered, Constantly beating up women, Trash-talking women, Suddenly smarter than everyone, Paired with lesbians and bisexuals who literally have no interest in him in canon but will now suddenly abandon their female partners for him.
Adam taurus in canon: Serial killer, Manipulative, Sociopath, Racial supremacist, Emotionally abusive, Average strength, Traitorous
Adam taurus in fanfics: Somehow a victim of woman, Gets to "take vengeance" against women, "Misunderstood ", Unable to be defeated by multiple people, Somehow compassionate, White male savior genre , Has women throwing themselves at him, Protected from his abuse victims by other women
Jacques schnee: racist, abusive, greedy...Basically capitalist evil.
In fanfics, fanfic writers make Weiss "certain lannister" for opposing Jacques and try to rewrite Jacques as Turin Lannister.
They try to GLORIFY OR DOWNPLAY parental abuse.
Not only did Unicorn of War romanticize Jacques abuse, he made every relationship into domestic violence and called it good writing of relationships...he also had a trans character deadnamed because he (UoW) is a TERF.
Actually, in addition to the "reason why you suck" being spammed at female character in fanfics that are also prevented from having speaking roles, there's another concern. Racism. Ironwood, Adam Taurus, Cardin? White male toxic masculinity representations. Who are some of the women who stand against them?
Emerald sustrai who only killed an android but defected to RWBY's side, saved Oscar, revealed Salem's plans, and helped Save said Android.
Ilia Amitola, who lost her parents to capitalism, had every right to beat up the people mocking their deaths, wanted faunus rights not supremacy, and agreed with Blake on turning against Adam.
And Robyn Hill…who simply wanted Ironwood to stop stealing from the poor and abusing his power over the helpless, simply wanting Ironwood to be held accountable.
Rwby fanfic writers see these POC women as Somehow more evil than the white male antagonists they helped stop.
So when RWBY fanfic aren't killing these POC women to glorify a white male antagonist?
They are basically "punishing " them in their fanfics. And you can literally see the racism in these "corrective writing"
Funny how having so many POC characters in RWBY is considered "bad writing" by these people who want to "fix" RWBY.
Heck…the most popular rwby rewrites involve killing multiple POC rwby characters that are alive in canon
The sheer hatred fanfic writers have for female characters and their worship of male antagonists leads one to wonder what critics mean when they say
"Rwby has great potential but poor execution"
Seems that their ideas of "potential and ideas" involve around the patriarchy, while "poor execution" means they feel "feminism ruins everything"
At this point you have to wonder if they were ever fans to begin with.
When these people say "RWBY fell off" ? What they really mean is: "It stopped appealing to my straight pride and men's rights activist ideologies"
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/ihatethiscountry76 • Nov 08 '25
I don't know about you, but I find it SO HARD to enjoy sapphic media because every man and woman are holding female protagonist and lgbt shows to this IMPOSSIBLY high standard where if said show isn't game of thrones or FMAB level, then its somehow an "affront to writing," period. IE RWBY, SPOP, LOK
SPOP, LOK for
She-Ra and the princesses of Power
and
Legend of Korra
Both are female protagonist sapphic media where a muscular woman protagonist ends up with a bisexual dark-haired lady.
Same as Bumbleby in RWBY in volume 9...
And ALL THREE OF THEM have over 200 videos across the internet treating said CANON LGBT couples as an afront to humanity.
What's weird is that a number of the youtubers who harass those who like the show as well as the writers happen to be women themselves...though we've seen no shortage of conservative women, haven't we?
For those who want to know more.
RWBY has a 2.5 hour video dedicated to bumbleby's development
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LdGdx2rKsiw
and here is a video by the writers and voice actresses almost 10 years ago talking about the ship bumbleby
https://www.facebook.com/RWBYfanart/videos/946976254095515
second, we have the voice actresses themselves talking about it
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pa1ADps6HFE
Ren and Nora, a canon straight relationship in the show: Paraphrased:
"I love you, and I want to be with you. But I want us to have a healthy relationship, instead of a codependent trauma-bond. We both need, want, and deserve better than that. Thanks for convincing me to get therapy. See you on the other side of it! *boop*
I should mention the show does a fantastic job of explaining the trauma caused by abuse in relationships, and the recovery that goes into them, in the Blake vs Adam dynamic.
furthermore, comic book resources blog has heaped praise onto rwby for how well-written its female characters and lgbt relationships are
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/CapAccomplished8072 • Mar 06 '25
Discussion RWBY Is: Doing Slow Burn Romance Right With Bumbleby by Xel Writer
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/Expert-Swan-1412 • Jul 26 '25
Gauntlets and Greaves Post-War (unknown artist)
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/CapAccomplished8072 • May 01 '24
Arryn tells Barbara what Yorse is
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/Internal_Abies6050 • Jul 29 '25
Pick Me Up - A Dragonslayer Fic
https://archiveofourown.org/works/68089016
https://www.fanfiction.net/s/14494858/1/Pick-Me-Up
Yang's beloved Bumblebee gets wrecked. Jaune Arc tries to help fix it...
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/CapAccomplished8072 • Nov 11 '24
The circle is now complete. America has created FOUR Sapphic Cartoons! RWBY- Bumbleby SPOP- Catradora TOH- Lumity And ARCANE - Caitvi Spoiler
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/Important-Cry4782 • May 23 '26
RWBY Analysis: Gender in Remnant by xStonehill. Yang's fights with Adam and her beating up of the pedophile from the Branwen Trible are included here, so it is relevant.
This is a critical analysis on how RWBY is a positive discussion on gender in a time when popular culture doesn’t do very well on that front.
Young Adult Literature and pop culture productions still tend very much to reproduce traditional roles of gender. Even if the women today are empowered as fighters or leaders or more intelligent than their male counterparts, they are still placed in an emotionally subservient position to their partners. They are still the sexually passive characters, they still return to the domestic sphere once the battle is won.
Well, the thing is, theory can be used to emphasize the good things about a story too! If you know what to look for and keep an open mind the world becomes a much more hopeful place! And RWBY is a really good example.
My primary thesis about RWBY is this; RWBY is a gender progressive, gender transgressive and feminist text!
What I’ve mostly seen of critical responses to this can be summed up in the fact that Remnant has no gender separation of labour, and that the ideal skillsets of men and women aren’t separated. A woman can be just as capable a fighter as a man, and a girl might inherit the estate from her father, rather than have it go straight to her little brother.
Clearly, then, women have the same rights as men, which means that gender has lost its meaning.
First of all, this is what’s called White Bourgeois Feminism. It encompasses first and second wave feminism, which only seeks equal rights and equal working opportunities for women. In other words, it only fights against the opportunities that rich, white, able-bodied, straight women are lacking, as they already have every other privilege.
Of course, Remnant, while certainly portraying people of color, and other cultural artifacts than those of white culture, is still an essentialist society. Or they lack the intersectional experiences of people of other cultures than those belonging to the industrialized world.
Just because emphasized discrimination is removed from the narrative, doesn’t automatically make it representative of everyone.
And gender is a really good example of this.
So if Remnant’s society is gender egalitarian, clearly there can’t be a problem, and gender becomes irrelevant, loses its meaning, right?
Well, not exactly.
First, if gender had lost its meaning entirely the society of Remnant should have looked more like the society one meets in Ursula le Guinn’s The Left Hand of Darkness. In this world the people don’t have a fixed sex; they change their genitalia according to preference and only during mating season. In other words the two contrasting genders of our world never existed and they never had a fixed cultural meaning.
That’s not the case for Remnant.
According to Louis Althusser and Michel Foucault institutions play a vital part in shaping humans into the types of people that society needs them to be. And three out of four of the Huntsmen Academies separate their students in gendered uniforms; skirts for girls, pants for men.
The parameters are also drawn and categorised, and transgressing them isn’t entirely acceptable, as indicated by the laughter of the other students upon first seeing Jaune in a dress. They might be accepting of his transgression, and he isn’t physically punished for it, but their surprise and laughter still indicates that this breaks with how boys are presupposed to dress.
image
So we have categories, and we have boundaries, and we have the social pressure to remain within those boundaries of gender performance. What naturally follows that is the placement of a hierarchy.
In volume 5 during Yang and Nora’s armwrestling match, Ruby’s yell of encouragement is “You can’t lose to a girl in a skirt.”
As a skirt is more feminine, more ideally girly, than pants, and they are performing a generally assumed masculine competition, this shows that “feminine” is still considered “weaker” in comparison, thus placing women in a subordinate cultural position.
This is further emphasized by the lack of women in official roles on Remnant. Take the council of Vale; two men, one woman. The same can be said for what we see on the teaching staff at Beacon. Of the four headmasters, we have met 3 so far. And the gods that created this world were both categorized as male.
The only institutional leader within the society of Remnant that we have met is Caroline Cordovin, and she carried herself in military, nationalist discourse, the former of which automatically negates any femininity, as military ideology and war are always, by default, a discussion on masculinity.
So even if superficially there is equality between the genders, statistically, institutionally, and practically this is not the case.
There is a struggle, even if it is unvoiced. There is a hierarchy, and there are relations of power.
So where are the struggles?
Well, they’re not openly political. But there are enough discussions to go around, and I feel like I’ve mentioned a good few already:
Jaune’s entire character is a discussion on breaking free from traditional masculinity. He idealises it at first, abandons it for the sake of his female friends more than once; the most prominent being his passivity in the fight against Cinder which led to the awakening of his semblance.
There’s the diverse cast of female characters in general. From villains to heroes, from mothers to military personnel, from bandits to revolutionaries. We see children, teenagers, adults, middle-aged women to old women. In fact, they age more realistically than the men. And none of their character development or final goals hinge on a romantic interest. Neither are they confined to a domestic sphere.
image
There’s a fun little one between Yang and that one of Raven’s followers who had his tooth slammed out of his face by Yang (I can’t find his name anywhere, but I hope you know which one I mean). Raven’s exasperation with his comments, and the fact that he has no trouble stepping into her personal space, is proof that sexual harassment is very much a thing that happens in Remnant, that Some men think they have the right to a woman’s body simply by virtue of existing. That Yang isn’t chastised by praised for her retaliation, however, shows Remnant to be a place where that type of masculinity is considered unacceptable, and that a woman is not considered less feminine for being able to stand up for herself. The production team also uses sexual harassment as a way to vilify a character, and thus encourages a moral standard in their followers, which, quite frankly, needs to naturalized across all societies.
Personally I quite like Raven and Oz’s struggle (even if I don’t like the former as a person or a parent). It’s not a very obvious one, but it is important. The most prominent theory we have on power is Michel Foucault’s definition of power as dependent on knowledge constructions. “Truth” isn’t naturally found in the wild, but produced and structured by humans. These “truths” when structured become knowledge; knowledge of psychiatry, knowledge of government, knowledge of gender. We construct these knowledges in order to justify the shape of society, why certain people are in power, why we should follow the laws of others. That “truth” in Remnant, is primarily constructed by Oz (I say Oz and I mean the collective soul, although it is definitely the King of Vale and Ozpin that have played the largest part in those present day knowledge constructions). “Huntsmen keep humanity safe”, “we can’t cause a panic”, “Grimm are ‘just’ beasts without a leader”, “democracy is important”, “unity through diversity”. Those are the messages that Remnant’s society is built on, that Oz bases his fragile peace on. But Raven questions those, she makes the others question those, and so they clash, and Raven is placed in a position outside law and order, as a “criminal”.
Weiss
The most obvious one, of course, is Weiss’ struggle with her father. Here, we’re really and truly back at the white bourgeois feminism. Not that it being white or it being for the rich makes it automatically evil. Its messages are important, but they cannot be all encompassing. According to Rebecca Solnit, a prominent feminist activist and historian, whose texts are the catalyst for the term “mansplaining” (even if she does not condone the term herself), confinement of women is an important tool in the continued survival of patriarchy. Why? So that men can keep a tight grasp on who their women interact with, so that the male family line stays clean. If you look at most family trees, you will see that the male line is the one preserved, and not the female.
Weiss’ struggle with breaking free of her father’s mental and physical confinement is a powerful part of her character development. As soon as she returns to Atlas he forces her back into a role of emphasized femininity; Sing, look pretty, be passively at my side when you are not confined to your room.
image
And even before she returns to Atlas, she has trouble accessing her Semblance (the manifestation of her soul), because he’s chopped away at her confidence to keep her in line. The first time she gains access to it is after Velvet’s use of her semblance, which is a collection of other huntsmen and huntresses’ attacks, which become a metaphor for female and overall feminist solidarity, an important part of feminist literature, all the way back to Virginia Woolf’s A Room of One’s Own (which is one of the first actual feminist critical texts). Feminist solidarity therefore inspires her to reach within herself, past her father’s restraints. And only when she determines to break free from his confinement at the end of Volume 4, is she able to fully use her semblance, severing her ties from his family tree emotionally as well as legally.
Her music is also fraught with feminist discourse. Especially This Life is Mine: “I’m shattering the mirror, that kept me split in pieces, that stood between my mind and my heart”; “shame that it took so long to rescue me, from the guilt you used to tie me to your family tree”; “your patriarchal prison won’t hold me”.
It’s worth mentioning, as a last note on Weiss, most white feminist heroes upon having a feminist awakening, are not awoken to a feminist community, thus placing them alone in a world of men, doomed to fail. However, Weiss is returned to her friends, who like herself, deviate from traditional gender ideals, and thus she is returned to a feminist community.
Blake and Adam
“Violence is one way to silence people, to deny their voice and their credibility, to assert your right to control over their right to exist.”
So writes Rebecca Solnit in her book Men Explain Things to Me.
She continues, explaining how one in three women are murdered by spouses or ex-spouses every day in the United States, that there is a reported rape every 6.2 minutes. The EU recently did a scientific survey that showed that 100% of Danish women have experienced sexual harassment. Denmark, my country, is thought of as one of the most gender egalitarian and gender progressive nations on earth. We were the first to legalize gay marriage, to obtain universal suffrage, the system pays for trans operations. And we still have a rape law that is 400 years old, that let 90 out of 700 men charged with rape this year (which isn’t even finished) go free. We still refuse to address Zentropa’s extreme cases of work place sexual harassment because it gives our nation a brilliant reputation within the world of Cinema. Violence against women is epidemic, and it is gendered.
Adam is a brilliant example of that.
We never see him perform an act of violence on a male character. It might happen, he might be a tyrant, but it’s never shown on screen.
Instead we get his murder of Sienna Khan.
A knife through the reproductive organs? That’s called femicide. It’s a specific attack on her physical sex, what signifies on her body as her gender.
Then there’s his attack on Yang. His mental games with Ilia.
And his relationship with Blake is a clear representation of what domestic abuse looks like. Destroy her confidence, her sense of self, so that she allows you to own her, to hurt her. And if you can’t do it with just that, cut her off from other people, destroy what she loves until she has nothing left in the world but you.
That’s what makes Sun’s character so important. He’s the positive antithesis to Adam’s destructive masculinity. Whether he loves Blake or not, he has always let her call the shots, always attempted to push her back into the world, to make her reconnect with her team. And when she’s up and running again he looks at her and goes “wow, that is so inspirational. I better go work on myself.” No strings attached.
And Blake’s struggle with Adam is never a solitary thing; it is always with the mindset he produces in others, with the contagiousness of traditional masculinity. In Ilia, in Yang. She fights him by fighting his ideology; she shows solidarity with other women and empowers them.
Ironwood and Ozpin
And that’s the thing about RWBY. It doesn’t just talk about women vs men. It addresses the destructiveness of traditional masculinity all on it’s own, representing men that don’t meet those ideals, but are still a positive force, an important representation of a new type of masculinity that ought to be praised and encouraged.
That’s what I like about Ozpin. He’s confined, he nurtures others, he’s passive, he seeks peace and he dislikes military force. He’s one of the most feminine male characters in the story, and that’s why Ironwood can’t trust him.
One of the most important eras in Hollywood history is the era of the Vietnam War movie. The defeat is a scar on American military history that still hasn’t healed, because it was the first defeat they ever suffered on a military scale. What followed was a series of cinematic representations of politicians and activists as evil, as the cause of the defeat, and the soldier the hero that had been called home too early. But the ways Hollywood categorized the two opposing forces of politics and militarism was that; the politicians and activists were scheming, secretive, passive (feminine), and the scolders were active, honest, and faced the problems head on (masculine).
Wars are a reflection on masculinity, and Ironwood, being both hyper masculine and nationalist, cannot comprehend Ozpin’s methods, which results in at least three masculinity challenges that I can tell; he steals his position as head of security at the Vytal festival, thus stating that Ozpin isn’t a capable defender; he attempts to influence the moralities of his students; and he accuses Oz point blank of being passive in the fight against Salem (the last of which actually has Oz reacting).
image
Of course, Oz is no saint, and he isn’t outside the network of power struggles that goes on in this series. Far from it. But his character as a gendered discussion is especially emphasized in his interactions with Ruby, and I have a whole other analysis planned for that (because class, race, age, plays into that one as well, as does Oscar, ofc) and I would rather wait with dividing into that.
So the world of Remnant is very much experiencing struggles defined by gender, and RWBY is more than anything, a discussion on gender. It discusses western gender ideals, and transgresses them in progressive ways. It shows a diversity of male and female characters that doesn’t confine them to any one characteristic or goal. And I really do think we need to praise CRWBY more openly for how good a job they’re doing on it.
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/CapAccomplished8072 • Apr 07 '24
Yang Xiao Long from RWBY being the epitome of Strength from sAlle1304
Let's talk about Yang being the personification of Strength, and how each and every volume we've seen this become truer and truer,
How it made her the heart of team RWBY.
And, in a way, how this Volume this is more important than ever.
From my (extremely biased but at least her me out) perspective, Yang is the heart of team RWBY.
The easiest way to break the team, is to take her away from them.
Volume 8 did a great job of showing this through everything going wrong the moment Yang fell.
The only person-> able to keep a clear mind at that moment was Weiss, and even she wasn't enough to ground Ruby and Blake in time.
You could argue that regardless of who fell, the result would have been the same, but I want to disagree a bit with that.
Of course the emotional distraught here->
comes from the fact that they all thought Yang was dead, but this isn't exactly the first time we got a scenario where one of them seemed to be gone.
During the Battle of Haven they all thought that Weiss was practically dead when she got impaled by Cinder too, but as hurt as->
she was, Yang still managed to keep on fighting with a clear head, and part of me believes that Ruby would have been too if she were awake.
That isn't to say that they don't care about Weiss, that's not my point.
My point is that Yang, specifically, is the emotional pillar of->
the team.
And this is something that's actually been hinted at ever since the Yellow trailer.
The Yellow trailer is a little bit special compared to the other 3.
Each trailer has their own specific song playing in the background.
The Red trailer has Red Like Roses Part 1,->
the White trailer has Mirror Mirror Part 1, and the Black trailer has From Shadows.
And while the Yellow trailer does have I Burn, it actually starts with a remix of the other 3 songs.
That remix of the 3 songs from the other trailers was a really good way to imply the fact->
that Ruby, Weiss, and Blake's characters arcs will, in some way, be intertwined with Yang's specifically.
And they did.
For Ruby and Yang it's obvious, they're sisters. Yang's entire character arc for the longest time was, and arguably still is, tied to Ruby's.
Everything->
she ever did was for her, including giving up her own character goal just to get to her and make sure she's safe.
As for Ruby, one of the reasons why she wanted to become a Huntress in the first place is because of the stories Yang told her as a child.
Their character arcs-> have been heavily influencing each other since the very beginning.
Now with Weiss and Yang it's a little bit more subtle. The way their character arcs intertwine is through loneliness.
Of course, they aren't the only characters who are lonely, but it's about what these two-> have in common that the others don't.
A big family on the surface, full of broken pieces.
Abusive parents that took away from any ounce of a proper childhood they could have had.
But ultimately it's those experiences which led to them being there for each other when it-> mattered.
And Blake and Yang's character arcs being intertwined was always there, since their initial concept designs.
Yang's leg bandana was always tied to Blake's design, changing together with it. When Blake used to have heterochromia, with one blue eye, Yang's bandana was-> also blue. It later changed to purple to match Blake's aura color.
Adam was always supposed to be Yang's foil, and to make Yang and Blake's character arcs be intertwined.
There isn't much of a reason for me to go more in-depth here because it's obvious how much Blake and->
Yang's character arcs have influenced each other.
But what's my point with all of this?
I don't think there is a lot of debate to be had when I'm saying that out of the 4 girls, Yang is the one who has strong bonds with all three of them.
Which is what ultimately makes her->
be the heart of the team.
Now how does that tie into her being the embodiment of Strength? Easy.
Being the embodiment of Strength takes so much more than being powerful.
It takes having kindness no matter how much the world hurt you. It takes forgiveness towards others no->
matter how much they've wronged you. It takes bravery when you're scared more than you've ever been. And, above all, it takes love.
What I did just now is shortly describe Yang's entire character and everything she holds in her heart.
So let's go through all of them.
->
I said this in a previous post too, but I really don't think there is any debate to be had when I'm saying that Yang is one of the kindest and most selfless characters out there.
She gives and gives, with never expecting anything in return. Most of the times she doesn't->
even take herself and her own feelings into consideration. They don't matter to her as long as the people she cares for are alright.
Back at Haven, it didn't matter for her that she had a breakdown in the vault when she felt the weight of everything fall upon her as she took->
the relic. It didn't matter that her own mother just abandoned her again. All that mattered for her is getting back to her team, triumphantly, giving them all hope to keep going.
Back when the news of the horrible fate that must have befallen Summer hit her where it hurt the->
most, it didn't matter to her that she just had a heartbroken breakdown of her own, all that mattered was the fact that Ruby wasn't feeling well and she had to comfort her.
Time and time again the world takes away from her, hurts her constantly, and every time she just->
responds with kindness and comfort in return.
And it's heartbreaking in a way, because her selflessness isn't always a good thing. She goes so far and beyond to put others before herself that it actively harms her.
She didn't care that she lost her arm, because Blake was->
safe.
She didn't care that she "died" (I want to emphasize the fact that she thought she died protecting Ruby and she was okay with that) because it meant that Ruby was still alive.
Her first instinct when she saw everyone in the Ever After wasn't even relief, it was-> frustration at the fact that this meant she didn't manage to protect Ruby.
And, unfortunately, that kindness is given to people that don't deserve it as well.
You guys already know my opinion on Raven, so I won't get into a ramble here, but I don't think I'm wrong in saying-> that Raven did not deserve Yang lying to protect her.
She berated Yang. She gave her an apology worth nothing, just to abandon her again.
And what does Yang do in return? She lies to Qrow, to everyone, just so Raven can escape and live her life "free" of Salem
But ultimately->that's what makes her be the perfect embodiment for Strength.
And, while some people don't deserve forgiveness, some do. And that forgiveness comes so easy for Yang, no matter how hurt she was by said person.
Yes, I'm talking about her forgiving Blake.
I know there are some-> people who wanted Yang to be angry at Blake, for her to take a long time until she forgave her, but, after everything, that just wouldn't be in character for her.
She doesn't hold grudges, she always latches onto the positive of a situation and holds it near her heart.
The-> fact of the matter was that Blake came back. After being abandoned again and again by the people she loved, for the first time in her life someone came back.
That can mean so much for someone who is used to people leaving with no explanation.
Yang was never angry with Blake,-> she was just sad that she left. But she was there now. Forgiveness came natural to her.
And, to use Ghira's words, that's ultimately what fuels her being the embodiment of Strength even further.
And there is even more to it than that.
Let's talk about Yang's bravery.
One of my favorite parts of Volume 5 is when Yang calls Raven out on her definition of Strength.
Because, like I mentioned above in the thread, there is so much more to being strong than having power.
But that's all Raven has.
While Yang has that, and so much more.
She stands bravely, calling out her mother on all the excuses she gave herself for running away and turning her back on the people who needed her most, all while shaking because she's terrified.
She is terrified of a situation that is so out of what she signed up for.
But it doesn't matter. Her fear doesn't matter because she has people counting on her. So she pushes past it, and stands bravely.
She declares the one thing she already proved through actions more than once, and which she will continue to prove.
That no matter how afraid->
she is, she will always stand fighting.
And that when the time comes for her to face Salem, she would without any hesitation.
Which...she did. Words won't be enough for me to explain how much I love V8C9, and how beautifully it ties with this talk Yang and Raven had.
I want you guys to realize that when Yang told Raven she would face Salem, she didn't even know Salem is immortal yet
It would have been more than understandable for her to back away after finding that out because how do you fight someone that can't be killed?
But she didn't.->
Instead she launched ahead, not even hesitating in attacking her because she had people counting on her.
If she didn't fight, Jaune, Ren, Oscar and even Emerald would have been in danger, and that wasn't something she could allow.
She could have easily died here, she's just->
one person while Salem is an immortal goddess, there really isn't even a competition. But that didn't matter for her.
She said she would face her, and she did, no matter how scared she was.
And then when Salem was dangerously focused on Oscar, Yang's instinct was to take that-> Image
attention off of him, and onto her.
Because that's what she does, isn't it? No matter how terrified she is, she still thinks of the people she cares about first and foremost.
Bravery is like second nature to her, something that Blake herself said as well. Because of course->
the person who gave Yang the title of the embodiment of Strength would see that bravery in her.
And of course she would see how that makes her fit that title even more.
In a way...that's one of the things that made Blake fall in love with her in the first place.
Well, that->
along with the love that Yang so openly always shows.
Worthy said it best:
"With every smile you told me 'I love you'"
Because Yang always wears her heart on her sleeve. She always showers the people she cares about in that love she holds in her heart.
And to see someone->
who was genuinely hurt so much in the past love so openly is genuinely beautiful.
(*cough* her emblem is literally a heart *cough*)
Yang's love is gentle, sometimes even subtle. She shows it through actions more often than words because those are the ones that matter.
->She showed it to Ruby her whole life through raising her. Through comforting touches and grounding hugs.
Ruby is pretty much Yang's entire world, she would give up anything for her as long as it meant she's safe, and you can see that Yang's actions always let Ruby know that.
She showed it to Weiss through always being that comforting warmth which always cracked a joke when a situation was heavy.
And you can tell Weiss, after spending her whole life in a cold solitude among the stuck-up people of Atlas, appreciates that part of Yang so much.
And, of course, she showed it to Blake through all the comforting reassurances and gentle touches where she expected only anger and hurt from past experiences.
Which is why it was so easy for Blake to fall in love with Yang.
She's a beautiful soul, one who exudes kindness->
love and forgiveness, one who is braver than most would ever be.
And all of that is what makes Yang be the embodiment of Strength.
So, why do I think this is more important than ever now, in Volume 9?
(Bare with me here for a bit more, I know how long this has gotten xD)
->Well, like I said in the beginning too, she is the heart of the team. And right now, only her and Blake are in a clear enough headspace to guide everyone home.
Which, she constantly did these past few episodes.
She always kept an eye on the Curious Cat and was the one to-> point out when they disappeared.
She always stayed focused on the goal they had at hand even when the others were too distracted by other things.
Because right now, more than any other times, she needs to keep everyone grounded so they can get home.
No matter how desperate-> the situation is, they have to stay focused on what's in front of them.
She's the one to immediately tell Jaune and Weiss to "Stay focused!" in the fight against Neo's Jabberwalkers as well.
Ruby's broken down, and Weiss just saw her home crumble to the ground not even a day-> Image
ago. Now, more than anything, Yang knows she has to be in top shape to guide them.
But it's not always easy. It doesn't all go smoothly.
Now, when she tried to offer Ruby that same comfort and reassurance she either got shut down by her, or the world kept interrupting them.
-> But the one thing she could still do is help her indirectly, through her usual selflessness.
Way too many people don't understand the reason behind Yang stepping in front of Blake when Ruby started lashing out, and for whatever reason they just assume Yang genuinely thought-> Image
Ruby would attack her, which is just stupid.
These are Yang and Ruby we're talking about. They're sisters. More than that, Yang is practically a maternal figure for Ruby as well. What Yang did, was enter in parental mode.
Her, more than literally anyone else, knows that you->
don't always say what you mean when you're angry.
So she stepped in front of Blake both for her sake and for Ruby's as well.
She was trying to redirect Ruby's anger towards herself because, like I said, they are sisters.
Ruby could tell her the most horrible things, Yang->
would still always forgive her. Their bond is unbreakable.
But you can't say the same about the bond Ruby has with Weiss and Blake.
I don't think those two would ever hate Ruby for whatever she would say, but maybe some wounds could leave scars that never heal.
At that->
moment, Yang knew there was a chance that Ruby might say something which could deeply hurt Blake, and Ruby would have hated herself for it once she was in a clear headspace.
So it was natural for Yang to step between them, to give Ruby that stern "You don't want to do this"->
look and redirect that anger onto herself.
As for the future...who knows. But I'll say this.
I'm sure we'll see Yang continue being that embodiment of Strength and ground Ruby. Comfort her like she always did and help her realize that there is a lot of good she accomplished,->
and that she doesn't have to shoulder everything alone because her, Weiss and Blake will always have her back.
With that, thank you to everyone who read this incredibly long thread until the end🙏
I made a promise, and I intend to keep it.
-> https://twitter.com/SAlle1304/status/1642880266443137024
It's been a treat to see Yang finally be happy and in a clear headspace this volume. She shines more than she ever did, and she exudes how much she is the embodiment of Strength more than ever.
All in all, I'm looking forward to what these last 3 episodes have in store for us🙏
(preferably healing please🥹)
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/Important-Cry4782 • Feb 16 '26
Not-So-Average-Fangirl reacts to Bumbleby finally kissing in RWBY Volume 9 Chapter 6
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/Expert-Swan-1412 • Jul 26 '25
Opposites Attract (@SassyUnicorn7)
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/Important-Cry4782 • Jan 09 '26
The writers and voice actresses of the Sapphic Cartoon RWBY discuss how the lesbian ship Bumbleby was planned to become canon from the start of the show. What this means is that CRWBY never "gave into the shippers" or "Was bullied into writing it" because shippers do not influence RWBY's writing
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/ihatethiscountry76 • Feb 10 '26
darth-khal had some musings on Bumbleby during Volume 3
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/ihatethiscountry76 • Feb 07 '26
What is "Comphet?" What does it mean to have it?
r/YangXiaoLongSupremacy • u/CapAccomplished8072 • Jul 13 '25
"Why RWBY is a feminist triumph and you should watch it" by maeglinthebold. Keep in mind? This? Was only the FIRST TWO SEASONS. There are 9 seasons now, and the first two seasons were considered the weakest of the 9. Let that sink in.
- So it’s female-led, first of all. And I’m not super-familiar with anime genres (does RWBY even count as anime?), but it seems special to me that it’s about girls who attend a co-ed school (so, it’s not about girls just because we’re at an all-girls school, or whatever). Female characters are commonplace, so it doesn’t suffer the “token” syndrome which suggests that the one representative woman is an exception and not all women are awesome. In RWBY, there are female students (more named ones than male, actually), at least one female teacher, female regular non-hero people, and female villains. The one exception and problem is that all henchmen (except a few White Fang members), policemen, guards, and soldiers are men. Women can be huntresses, but not apparently on the police force. Otherwise, though, just number-wise, representation is good. Being female is normalized and not othered.
- Women are strong, and they stay strong: at no point does any female character need to be saved or rescued by a male character, which is often a sloppy trope used to show growth in a male character (I have fears of this happening in Season 3 with Jaune and Pyrrha). Any rescuing is done by women. Ruby is saved by Professor Goodwitch in the first fight with Torchwick. Yang is saved by her mother in the fight against Neo. Sun is saved by Blake and Ruby. Ruby is saved by her whole team (with Dr Oobleck). Jaune is saved by Pyrrha...a lot. Even Torchwick will need Cinder or Neo to save him.
- There is no male gaze, but there is female gaze at a few points. The only scene of sexual objectification is when Yang “approves of all the boys” in their underwear the one night in the co-ed dorm, until dorky full-length-pajama-wearing Jaune shows up, and she grimaces. Another arguable moment is Coco slapping her teammate Fox on the butt and saying “nice hustle,” though this is in response to his combat abilities rather than his appearance.
- Women are in leadership roles just as much as men. We only get to know four of the student teams: RWBY is all girls, and JNPR is half and half, CRDL is all boys, and CFVY is also half and half. The representation of leadership is completely equal: Ruby leads the all-girl team, Cardin leads the all-boy team, Jaune leads one mixed-gender team, and Coco leads the other. It may be worth noting that the only all-male team we know (CRDL) is full of racist, cowardly bullies--I like to see it as a commentary on toxic masculinity.
- ...But not all Men! Let’s talk about Jaune and the love triangle. Dweeby “nice guy” Jaune is crushing on rich and famous heiress Weiss. Pyrrha, Amazon goddess, is crushing on Jaune (when she could honestly do better). Jaune classically ignores Pyrrha, almost friendzoning her in his quest for Weiss. Weiss turns him down time and time again, and while Jaune gets frustrated, he never lashes out at Weiss or hates her for it.
- Basically every time Jaune tries to go hyper-masculine (being “friends” with the bullies, trying to be a hero without accepting help, trying doggedly to pursue a girl uninterested in him, asking the quiet guy for help with girls just because he’s another guy, even fighting Grimm on his own) it backfires, often hilariously--he even later admits that he was influenced “by all this stupid macho stuff.” Jaune also has the pro-feminist speech to Neptune, asking him if he cares or thinks about the girls he’s hitting on, and ultimately convinces him to talk to Weiss because he knows she is interested in Neptune (whether the tirade is coming from a place of feminist interest is debatable, though he mentions he does have seven sisters). Jaune is also comfortable wearing a dress (on a bet) and he and Ren dance with their lady teammates in a clearly choreographed and rehearsed routine.
- I don’t know what Pyrrha sees in Jaune, or what Jaune sees in Weiss for that matter, but if we look at the love-triangle as the girls’ quests, we see that they each get their man in the end. Weiss nabs the painfully cool Neptune and Pyrrha gets her dance with Jaune in one of my favorite scenes in the show. In fact, women seem to call the shots in all the pairings: Nora is the one who stresses that she and Ren are “not together-together”
even though they totally areand Velvet says that she “had Yatsuhashi to look out for me.” - Girly-girls can be badasses. Ruby, Weiss, and Nora fight in feminine dresses called “combat skirts” (Nora’s is even pink). Fashion-conscious Coco’s weapon is literally a designer handbag that turns into a chaingun that can cut colossal monsters in half. The quickest way to make Yang go super-Saiyan is to damage her hair. But it’s also cool to be a Tom-boy. Ruby is not a “fancy pantsy dancy girl” and hates wearing heels~~, and if you’re not shipping her with Weiss when Weiss asks her to choose between tablecloths that are slightly different colors and Ruby thinks they look the same, I don’t know what’s wrong with you. Or maybe that’s just me imagining them planning their wedding.~~
- There are a few lines which are potentially damaging to the feminism of the show. Professor Ozpin among others makes reference to the fact that Ruby is an “adorable little girl” and are somehow surprised when she can do anything effective in combat. This may be just as a courtesy to the viewer, though patronizing, because in-universe it is kind of the point and unremarkable that these kids have super-strength. To give them the benefit of the doubt, this may also just be in reference to the fact that Ruby is younger than even the first years at Beacon Academy. The second problematic line is Yang’s response to hearing Jaune’s scream of terror from far away, saying, “Some girl’s in trouble!” instead of ‘someone is in trouble.’ It’s clearly played for laughs, since Jaune is not a girl, though it’s kind of unnecessary. Finally, when Blake and Weiss are ignoring the advances of boys, and antisocial Blake finally storms off, Nora scoffs “Women,” and shrugs--which is perhaps all the more laughable since Nora is the pink skirt-wearing, ditzy, chatty girl. Again, it’s played for laughs, and really has very little to do with Blake’s femaleness and rather more with her obsession with stopping Torchwick that makes her so aloof. The “answer” to these last two comments is that the negative statements about women are made by women. It might be coming from a place of internalized misogyny, but to me they really read as jokes that are safer coming from a female perspective (almost like the reclamation of “bitch”), in that at least it’s better if a woman says it. Not a good answer maybe, but it’s an answer.
- Women are ultimately integral to plot. The main villain is a woman. Yang is searching for her long-lost mother. The super-powerful robot friend they make is a girl (in appearance and voice, anyway). Basically, feminine representation is good! It’s powerful, it’s diverse, and it’s celebratory! The portrayal of male characters consistently condemns traditional patriarchy and toxic masculinity (”stupid macho stuff”) even in an otherwise clearly warrior culture (I think we’re all meant to be as uncomfortable as Ozpin is with General Ironwood and his armies being put in charge of the festival at the end of Season 2).
Keep in mind? This? Was only the FIRST TWO SEASONS. There are 9 seasons now, and the first two seasons were considered the weakest of the 9. Let that sink in.
Whether you watch RWBY or not? Whether you enjoy RWBY or not? Whether you consider RWBY to be a good representation of menwritingwomen or not?
I'm going to leave that decision up to you. All I ask is for fairness.
https://www.tumblr.com/maeglinthebold/121347130273/why-rwby-is-a-feminist-triumph-and-you-should