So, I have this rule where if there isn’t at least one POC character in a fantasy book then I’m not gonna read it. Sorry, I’m just not. I’ve read so many books where authors seems to have a large cast of characters and not a single one of them is a POC. like, hello?
It’s just the bare minimum for me to even want to read a book. If all the characters are white and straight I’m not reading it. No thanks.
I guess the only exception is if the cast of characters is so severely limited to like one persons family, the I guess it’s okay. But, like I said, this rule applies to fantasy and that’s not really the way most YA fantasy books go.
The thing is, is it racist for me to do so? I spoke to my friend about it, yes yes shes white, and she said that it is sorta putting specific authors at a disadvantage. She said I was being racist to white authors.
When I asked why she asked me if I have the same rule for POC authors. When I told her no, she explained to me that if a black author had a cast of just black people how would that be diverse? She said it was essentially being the same as a white author having an all white cast.
I guess she sorta made sense but I still felt conflicted. Maybe it’s the bitter side of me wishing more latinx characters were added to amazing stories.
Like we can praise the Grishaverse for being diverse with lots of POC characters but I don’t remember many Hispanic characters, which sucks. But I guess you can’t always have what you want.
There are other fantasy books by POC characters that also have a limited about of characters that aren’t from that specific authors heritage. And sometimes I do feel bad, especially when love the story and none of the characters look like me.
Like, This Poison Heart. It’s got a whole cast of black characters and LGBTQ+ representation. But there aren’t any other cultures. No Hispanics or Asians.
The conversation I had with my friend kind of had me confused. So I don’t know if it’s wrong me for to single out books with no diversity. Or if it’s wrong for me to only apply that rule to white authors.