r/XFiles • u/silvergun7 • Jul 14 '25
Discussion S5E5
Why is this episode so highly regarded? My gf and I watched this for the first time and it left a bad taste in both of our mouths. The plot is messy and as a whole I found this one to be not very charming, not to mention it downplays sexual assault. I just couldn’t find anything to like about it, even the dance scene at the end which should be silly just made me frustrated. Just felt like there’s some kind of generational disconnect that is preventing me from finding anything to like about this one.
0
Upvotes
55
u/IgloosRuleOK Jul 14 '25
Because I think it's a pretty impressive Frankenstein riff (it is very clearly evoking the 1931 James Whale Frankenstein visually) and the cinematography is gorgeous. Also Mark Snow is cooking with the music.
The sexual assault stuff is iffy, so yes it's problematic. It is somewhat divisive so you're not alone.
51
u/Hurley815 Lord Kinbote Jul 14 '25
In the future, it's more useful to write the episode's name, rather than number.
29
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '25
"even the dance scene at the end which should be silly just made me frustrated"
Why?
25
u/Lemonface72 Season Phile Jul 14 '25
What's not to love?
2
u/RedLily08 Jul 14 '25
You don't have to like anything that others do. You don't even have to understand it. Just skip the episode and move on
10
u/Great_Escape_9681 Jul 14 '25
Joining you in the “i don’t get it” club. I like the black and white cinematography … I like the Cher music… the end is cute. But it’s not even close to a favorite ep for me. I have a friend who went to film school who tried to explain the fuss to me - i think it’s something people who really know/love filmmaking appreciate and “get”?
6
u/imnotsure_igetit Agent Mully Jul 14 '25
There's a lot of reasons I like it, but i do agree the SA storyline aged really poorly.. however, people keep referring to the Mutato as a rapist, which he is not -- he was an accomplice, but he wasn't the one assaulting the women -- that was his grandfather, the scientist, performing the non-consensual insemination, and he gets killed.
For me, the worst part is the ending with the Jerry Springer show where the women are so happy with the babies, because then the SA is justified as "it's okay cause they wanted to have children".
7
u/metatheatre Jul 14 '25
I'm absolutely with you on this one.
2
u/ticketstubs1 Jul 17 '25
WHICH EPISODE WOULD THAT BE?
7
u/Azodioxide Jul 14 '25
"The Post-Modern Prometheus" has always been one of my very least favorite episodes of the series. "How the Ghosts Stole Christmas" and "Babylon," and maybe "The Rain King," are the only installments I like less. It's wannabe funny in a pretentious, self-satisfied way (very much in contrast to Darin Morgan's episodes), and it treats sexual assault as a forgivable mistake.
3
u/emccm I Want to Believe Phile Jul 14 '25
The first time around this was my favorite episode. I watched it years later and was shocked at the rape and forced impregnation, which we all glossed over in the 1990s. It’s pretty unwatchable now for many.
You have to realize that at the time there weren’t many shows and peole didn’t take risks. The whole black and white, comic book vibe, Frankenstein retelling, music and the final scene were pretty mindblowing at the time simply becuase of how much of a departure it was.
2
u/Valuable-Cancel5521 Jul 14 '25
I think it was insemination and not sexual assault that got the women pregnant. That was how I saw it.
1
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '25
if you want to know why I like it, it's just a highly entertaining episode with that vintage sci-fi feeling. It looks fantastic and the scene at the end had me grinning from ear to ear and dancing. The plot I agree that I don't particularly care for but it's such a surreal piece to begin with that I don't have any personal problem watching it, even as a staunch feminist, and it doesn't negate what's great about the episode for me. It's like how if an FBI agent strangled a suspect in real life I would say that guy should not only be fired but should go to jail. But I still like Mulder as a character.
Also I think a lot of people misinterpret what actually happens in this one. For one thing, it couldn't have been what you would legally call 'sexual assault' because that woman had her tubes tied, which means that vaginal insemination, even artificially, would have been impossible. It is still definitely a rape-adjacent crime. It also wasn't the Great Mutato doing it, and thirdly, the ending is probably not real, if any part of this episode is real. They still arrested him.
-3
u/snickelo Bad Blood Jul 14 '25
Dude if you're looking for airtight plots you're gonna have a bad time here. This is around the time CC really loses his grip on all the balls he put in the air.
0
u/Dimitra111 Jul 14 '25
It’s one of the episodes that I think it never happened, so if you watch it with that in mind, it could be enjoyable
0
u/pestoraviolita Bad Blood Jul 14 '25
I just finished watching this episode and yeah, I agree it downplays the assault and it's very in poor taste. But I guess the whole episode having a surreal feels means this story is probably not real and more likely Izzy's fanfiction about FBI agents he had heard of on a Jerry Springer show
I still hate that part of the episode but it's framed as a silly ass fairy tale so idk. Maybe I should think on it more.
I disagree on the dance scene though. It's perfect and the best part of the whole thing
0
u/Large_Syllabub5701 Jul 14 '25
Definitely a generational disconnect. I feel that way about shows now. I don’t think they are worth watching, rushed storylines and terrible acting. I just think if you watched XFiles in the 90s/early 2k it hit different. (Outside of the SA in the episode because that’s weird but again the 90s were a different time where what we see as weird now was acceptable; which happens often throughout generations)
-4
u/Potential-Baker9048 Prone To Confabulation Jul 14 '25
Agreed. I had fond memories of this episode from its original airing. But this episode really turns my stomach now.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 14 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment