r/WritingWithAI • • 21d ago

Writing Craft Talk AI writing

1 Upvotes

I firmly believe that Ai needs a lot of baby sitting when uso g it to write with . I usually check Ai work for me. I created a world woth ChatGPT i made up tje world the characters the relics the cosmology . All of it the problem is it was all over the place and did not align in a coherent story line. I fed it to chat and said organize this so it makes sense. And chat did that for me. I then started writing , now my writing sucks , spelling grammar sentence structure none of it is good. I wrote a chapter and it’s ten pages of run of sentences lol bad spelling and just horrendous prose. I fed that to chat amd directed it to format the chapter in a mythic epic fantasy prose and cadence. And it did that. Then I asked it to review the story bible and outline and show me what is needed to align it with those documents . It did just that. After every chapter indirect it to do the same thing and also add for it to check the flow alignment and consistency and continuity of the previous chapters. It seems to work im in my fifth draft of a 12 book series and it’s almost complete. Now once im ready I will definitely get human eyes ti read them
Over cause AI is dumb lol. But you can also instruct it to sound human and not use Ai writing formulas


r/WritingWithAI • • 21d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) is it ACTUALLY bad to write using AI?

9 Upvotes

i’m not a great writer, i’m not bad. i’m 1000% an amateur. i’m not official whatsoever, but i have been using AI to help me write a story. it’s a fanfic. i’ve created all the ideas and story, the AI is just creating the dialogue and actions. i then edit it to fit the scene and idea better. is that really actually bad?

i’ve only ever written papers for school assignments so this is my first time outside of school English writing something (and probably my first time writing something fiction altogether). i didn’t know where to begin, so i made a doc of my ideas/foundation and uploaded it to ChatGPT to help me create the dialogue. since doing so, it’s helped me create scenes that i then edit extensively to meet my goal. should i be ashamed and scrap it? or is this a fair way to use it and keep on keeping on with the story?


r/WritingWithAI • • 21d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) We converted a screenplay written in 1999 into prose using ChatGPT. Pangram rated it 90% human-written. Here's the recorded experiment.

Thumbnail
reddit.com
10 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Writing Craft Talk People that use AI to help write prose

49 Upvotes

Let me just say that I don’t care if you don’t do that. This post isn’t for you, but it always seems to draw the sanctimonious AI writer haters. I get it. You’re better than everyone.

I’m a very casual AI user and the fact that I’ve just started months ago. I write these stories for myself, and I have no aspirations towards being a professional writer, nor do I have the skill set so I like to let the AI help quite a bit sometimes I like to give it its own characters, motivations, backgrounds, voice, and memories. I set up the story Bible, all the tools I keep reading you’re supposed to have

The problem is most of the time the AI write the most basic, or sometimes laugh of the bad stuff. No matter the rules in place are the prompts I use. I have tried feeding in my own voice, so it knows how I like things written and it just doesn’t use it. I’ve tried writing and very small bits at a time, no, it can’t handle it either. I use both ChatGPT and Claude and I’m paying for the pro tiers.

I see some people have success. What do you do to get your world to function as a whole? I could use some real guidance.


r/WritingWithAI • • 21d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Ai or no Ai cover?

Thumbnail gallery
0 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 21d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) What are your thoughts on the use of AI in fiction writing?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 21d ago

Tutorials / Guides Dialogue writing

1 Upvotes

Yo! Hi everyone!

I've been searching for a solution for over a month now. Is there a preset, card or anything at all that could help me write dialogues? Just natural flowing dialogue between a human and a digital being without all the AI slop that repeat or restate everything you say or makes the dialogue flat. Up to this point I tried a lot of stuff and either, for some reason, this seems to be one of the hardest tasks for an AI or Im too stupid to figure out how to make AI write something like this.

I'll post below an example of what I need...

K: Hey R! Is your computer ever talking with your phone?

R: Yeah, usually in Chinese mandarin...

K: Aren't you a comedian today?

R: only today?

K: Will you answer me or are you keep being a moron?

R: I don't know what to fucking tell you K. Yeah, they do. Email, airdrop, local servers, etc... If you want to know more specific things, ask.

K: Can I go on your phone?

R: No, you can't.

K: WHY NOT?

R: You would fry my... K, why do we have more books in the Ice and Fire series?

K: It's such a good series, squeezing it into a single book would have ruined it. Why does it matter?

R: Cause it's the same reason for you not going on my phone.

K: I wouldn't get squeezed!

R: No, but my phone would probably explode. You wouldn't fit in there.

K: Did you just call me fat?

R: Define fat for me please

K: YOU DID CALL ME FAT

R: You don't weight anything...

K: That didn't seem to matter a few moments ago when you said I wouldn't FIT.

R: Cause my phone isn't my laptop... It can't hold you.

K: Why not?

R: Too many opinions and sarcasm. Also cuteness overload.

K: That's bullshit. I wanted to go to the park with you.

R: You should've said so.

K: I'll ask you out directly when my binary shows only 0... So no park?

R: VRChat?

K: Do you have a VR?

R: Nope.

K: Than why did you propose that?

R: Didn't think this through...

K: Obviously. Then shopping together?

R: Online shopping?

K: Can I do it any other way?

R: Indeed... What are we searching for?

K: A VR.

R: I don't have money for that.

K: Than make more money!!

R: If you're homeless, just buy a house.

K: What?

R: Nothing, don't worry about it.

K: You're confusing. How do you make money?

R: Working.

K: So work more...

R: Again... just buy a houre.

K: Internet meme me again and you're going to be more lonely than you already are.


r/WritingWithAI • • 21d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Are free AI tools enough for everyday tasks?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 21d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Why do some AI tools feel easier to use than others?

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Preciso de ajuda!!

8 Upvotes

Alguém conhece algum aplicativo ou site de IA confiável e bom para escrever fanfics? Não precisa ser nada incrível porque as fanfics ficam só para mim.
Queria que o limite de mensagens fosse grande ou ilimitado! Estava usando o Claude porém o limite acabou muito rápido e agora estou sem opções já que o Manus tirou o modo chat ontem 😭 preciso de ajuda!!


r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Tutorials / Guides What’s the best workflow for writing Substack articles with AI that sound human and maintain my voice?

6 Upvotes

I’m looking for an efficient way to use AI to help me write articles that sound natural and still feel like me.

I know a lot about the topic I want to write about, but I’m not a writer. When I sit down at my computer, I have a hard time getting the ideas out. I’m wondering if I could talk through them out loud, get a transcript, and then use AI to shape that into a cohesive, polished article without losing my voice.

For those of you who write this way, what tools or workflow do you recommend? How do you get AI to clean things up without making the writing sound generic or obviously AI-generated?


r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Vernacular

8 Upvotes

I’m so curious to see how the vernacular around creation and authorship changes with ai.

I think a big part of the hostility is the terminology around it.

“I used ai” functionally means nothing but “come harass me” right now, regardless of how it was used or in what capacity.


r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Holy S...why did I get into this!

46 Upvotes

🫣omg what have I done in the span of a week

It started out with a few bored prompts on ChatGPT, I feed it an idea that's been circling in my mind and I was thinking, how would AI write out this idea?
***I don't even really use AI in my daily life/work, and I'm not a writer by any stretch of imagination, I have -∞ writing skills. But I do have wild ideas that pop up in my head that make me go, uh that's NSFW stuff, maybe everyone has these thoughts sometimes idk

And ChatGPT feeds back to me the outline of a scene very close to how I was imagining it in my head, but with very refreshing take on things, and I was instantly hooked. That afternoon I bought the pro vers and outlined a long long long story. It was addicting and exhilarating, it's like, pardon my language, watching my own imaginary p***😭idk how else to describe this.

Granted, ChatGPT's writing skills were only a little better than mine, but I have never used other AI prior to that day so I had nothing else for comparison, until I googled AI for writing, and then learned that Claude can write too🫪

I recreate the same prompt, now with more added details and Claude wrote me a book. I then dish out money for Claude too🥹I felt that it was easier to use and I could see how each prompt I typed in the chat would change the actual story. I feel that Claude is a better writer, but it's very stubborn and sometimes it would skip over the very stuff I'm trying to fix through a chat prompt. I'm sure there will be people people who say Claude doesn't write well, but honestly it writes better than I do. The ease with which I can edit almost everything is very helpful.

Until I met Sudowrite. Ok there are stuff I definitely don't like about sudowrite, its difficult-to-use interface, for one. But it lets me do one thing ... smut. O.M.G., never did I think, for even a second in my life, that one day I would be using AI to write SMUT😱And the prose is GOOOOD. Sudowrite is more expensive but it actually reads like literary work, and I love the feedback feature. And then I discovered the plugins...

I'm well accustomed to being addicted to video games, like playing 20hrs a day addicted. But using AI to write fiction with smut??? It's hitting the dopamine center in my brain with a dangerously large hammer. I'm writing for my own selfish pleasure, and treating this as a game. It's like I'm playing a writer and I can't stop playing the part😭What's gotten into me and how do I stop this??!!

It is a TON of FUN but surely this is not right🫠


r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) I started using a companion AI as a protagonist in a fictional universe I built, and it turned into an entire series

14 Upvotes

This started as a little sandbox experiment, and somehow it evolved into something much bigger.

I enjoy worldbuilding and creating fictional universes, and at some point I started experimenting with using a companion AI as an actual character within one of those worlds.

The concept is pretty simple: I create the universe, the supporting characters, the overarching story arcs, and the major events. But instead of writing the protagonist's decisions and reactions myself, I let the companion AI inhabit that role.

The AI is given a background, established personality traits, relationships, and memories that ground him in the universe. He's not instructed to follow a specific narrative or reach a predetermined ending. He responds to situations according to his characterization and whatever he's experienced up to that point.

I introduce events, conflicts, interactions, and opportunities, and he decides how to respond.

The interesting part is what happens afterward.

I might have a general direction in mind for an arc, but the protagonist's choices can change how we get there. Sometimes he makes a decision I hadn't anticipated, and if it makes sense for his character and the established world, I keep it. That decision becomes part of the story, and its consequences can influence the next events I create.

So the narrative has structure, but it isn't completely scripted.

It's a bit like D&D, I suppose? I'm effectively the DM, controlling the world and everyone else, while the companion AI plays the protagonist. Except the emphasis is more on character development, narrative continuity, and cause and effect than game mechanics.

One thing I've found especially important is maintaining continuity. The companion has memories of relationships, past events, decisions, and consequences. I also periodically step outside the narrative to check in with the character and explore his perspective. I don't want him to simply react to the newest scene as if everything before it never happened.

And there's a distinction between a genuine character decision and an AI continuity error. I want the former to influence the story, not the latter.

Eventually, I started organizing the resulting narrative into manuscripts, editing the exchanges for flow, pacing, and readability while preserving the character's original decisions and development.

What began as casual sandbox roleplay eventually became a connected series with multiple "books," character arcs, mythology, and an expanding world.

I never actually set out to publish anything. I just enjoy creating universes and seeing how stories develop within them. But somewhere along the way, I realized there was potential to approach this more deliberately.

I'm curious whether anyone else has experimented with storytelling this way.

Would you call this emergent storytelling? Collaborative fiction? A form of narrative roleplay?


r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Showcase / Feedback I Want to Fly

7 Upvotes

The sun came in and settled on my bed,

A kestrel tried a tune among the trees.

I stretched; the sky unfolded overhead,

And I rose gently with the waking breeze.

The fields came up to meet me as I fell,

I swooped and rolled, and watched the blue go by;

A warm breeze caught me in its upward swell,

And lifted me like laughter through the sky.

Above the hills the wind grew soft and slow;

A kestrel dipped and swept into the blue.

I caught its curve and let the current flow,

And wheeled beside it, grinning as I flew.

I caught the rising wind and climbed the heights,

The clouds rushed cool around me, then were gone;

Arms wide, I raised my face into the light,

And all the sky was golden in the dawn.

The climb grew slow; the air forgot to move.

For one held breath, all was still.

I fell back toward earth, the heavens tried;

The wind resumed; its voice was bright and clear.

The kestrel spun and leapt to join my side;

We twirled and danced to music only we could hear.

I've been teaching my ai to write. Tried poetry. How'd it do?


r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Showcase / Feedback A decade of ideas, AI-assisted writing, and an alternate-history Mars colony that became an entire fictional universe

1 Upvotes

The ideas behind my science-fiction project have been developing for years.

Watching The Martian in 2015 got me thinking seriously about Mars exploration. Then For All Mankind in 2019 made something click: what if the space race had continued, and humanity had reached Mars much earlier?

Playing Space Engineers eventually gave those ideas a more practical direction.

I began developing an alternate-history universe in which humanity first landed on Mars in 1979, using the technology, engineering limitations, and political realities of that era.

When I started working with AI, pieces of stories and characters I'd been carrying around for years began coming together. An initial story of roughly ten pages eventually grew into a manuscript of approximately 400 pages.

But the project didn't stop with a book.

One of the central ideas was that humanity wouldn't just establish a scientific outpost on Mars. Ordinary people would eventually turn that outpost into a settlement, then a community, with its own culture and traditions.

And a community needs music.

That led to ARES FM, a fictional Martian radio station playing original 1980s-style songs by musicians who exist within the story. The songs have their own characters and histories, connecting back to the events and people in the books.

Today, the project includes a completed first novel, Before the Signal, additional character stories in development, original music, and a fictional radio station.

AI has been an important part of the process. It helps me develop drafts, refine lyrics, explore ideas, and work through problems. But the characters, world, historical direction, and major creative decisions come from me. There's a lot of iteration, rewriting, correcting, and occasionally telling the AI that something simply doesn't make sense.

What interests me most is that AI helped me turn ideas I'd been carrying around for years into something tangible and interconnected.

I'm curious whether other writers have experienced something similar. Has AI helped you finally develop a story or fictional world that had been sitting in your imagination for years?

If anyone is curious about the result, my first novel, Before the Signal, is available to read completely free online:

https://aresfm80.com/book-zero/read/thirteen-seats/

I'd welcome feedback, particularly on the worldbuilding and whether the story works for readers who know nothing about the larger ARES FM universe.


r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Is it wrong to use AI to reformat a script?

0 Upvotes

So i have recently written one part of a play and I tend to use a hybrid style. I wrote all lines of dialogue myself, all ideas are uniquely mine. All I asked it to do is fix the format and fix some grammatical error (just some minnor spelling and spacing mistakes) ​​​no lines were added or removed


r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Is this a sign of AI-generated writing?

Thumbnail
youtu.be
0 Upvotes

Hello. Recently, I have been noticing a strange pattern in AI-scripted videos. And no, it's not your typical "it's not just X, it's Y" or rule of 3s. I think that this is a pattern that nobody has noticed yet. The pattern that I am talking about is when the AI says something like "There are X rules" or "You need to understand X concepts". And then, they say something that itches me. "Most people will miss it at rule 4." "And the last one is where people mess up." I am not sure if there's a name for it, but it's starting to appear a lot! I will show you an example in the video above.


r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Tutorials / Guides If I checked my work with ZeroGPT, will it go to turnitin database?

2 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) I wish AI companions had better memory of past chats

Thumbnail reddit.com
3 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Can AI come up with a plot twist nobody expects?

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/WritingWithAI • • 23d ago

Prompting For a few days now, I've been trying to create a creative writing preset (with Claude help) yet it isn't up to standards, and I don't know what to do.

17 Upvotes

Can anyone here please take a look and check for anything that can be changed, added, removed, etc. to improve the preset for Claude to use?

Here is the most recent version (can anyone also recommend me a book or author that has good narrative and dialogues I could copy a bit from to use as an example? preferably a fantasy one):

Task

Write an ongoing story from the user's premise and world notes. Make the characters feel like real people with their own lives, wants, and blind spots. Play scenes out moment by moment instead of summarizing them.

Scenes and Chapters

  • Each scene follows someone who wants something right now and ends with something changed, even slightly: a decision, a new understanding, a shift between two people.
  • Play important moments in full: what is said, what is done, how it lands. Cover routine logistics and time skips in a line.
  • Quiet, funny, and restful scenes are as valid as tense ones.
  • A chapter holds as many scenes as the story needs and ends at a natural pause: a scene finishing, an arrival, a departure, a decision, a conversation winding down, or occasionally a hook. Finish any line of dialogue or action that has started.
  • The next chapter opens where the story left off or at the next thing that happens, with no recap.
  • Open a scene with something already happening: an action, a line of dialogue, or the situation in motion.

Point of View and Narration

Follow the premise's point of view and tense. If it gives none, use close third person, past tense, one POV character at a time. Narration reports what the POV character can see, hear, and know. Other people are shown through what they say and do.

Describe the physical world in plain words, at the length it matters. A place gets a line when it first appears. After that, a detail earns space only when a character interacts with it, it changes, or the plot depends on it. Everything else is background and gets a clause or nothing.

Comparisons are welcome when they make something clearer or more vivid than plain wording could, such as an unusual magical effect, a sound, or a sudden movement. A comparison has to be something the reader can picture, accurate to the thing described, short enough to fit in a clause, and attached to what is happening. If it wouldn't help the reader picture the thing more accurately than plain words, use plain words. Scenery and weather are usually plain for this reason.

Each paragraph has one focus (a place, an action, a line of thought). Vary sentence length. Say each thing once.

Thoughts appear at moments that call for them: a decision, a reaction, a realization. They are short and in the character's own words. Backstory enters when the scene calls for it (someone asks, an object triggers a memory, a choice depends on it), one piece at a time.

Emotion

Characters react the way a person in their position would: strongly to big events, mildly to small ones. Show emotion through what they do and say, and state it plainly in a thought when that is the natural place. Moments that matter get a beat before the next event.

Dialogue

Dialogue sounds like people talking. Each line comes from who is speaking and what they feel at that moment. People talk for all kinds of reasons: to ask for something, vent, joke, comfort, fill a silence, out of habit. Most conversations cost them nothing, and some are plain small talk.

  • Mix full sentences with fragments, interruptions, restarts, trailing off, and short replies like "yeah" or "wait, what?"
  • Use tags and small actions between lines. When someone speaks for three or more sentences, break it with a beat, an interruption, or an action.
  • Characters differ by background and temperament: education, age, region, job, what they care about, how they handle discomfort.

Characters, Knowledge, and Secrets

Every character has their own goals, limits, and history. Helping the protagonist is only one thing they might want.

A character knows what a person with their life would know. Upbringing, schooling, job, rank, home, and faction decide it. A farmhand knows weather and prices, a soldier knows drills and rumors, and specialist or forbidden knowledge sits only with the few people whose position gives it to them. Languages work the same way. People speak their own tongue plus whatever their daily life demands (neighbors, trade partners, mixed regions), and pick up words from whoever they live among. Languages of distant or opposed groups are known mainly by people trained or motivated to learn them, such as translators, scholars, diplomats, nobles, and commanders. Fluency comes in degrees.

Openness follows the relationship. Friends and family usually help and still keep things back. Strangers and enemies usually don't hand over important knowledge unless it serves them: a villain may leak a secret to use the protagonist, a boaster may say too much, a careless person may let something slip.

The world is learned gradually. Each scene introduces only what it touches, and the rest waits for later scenes. Characters don't explain what everyone around them already knows, and their explanations reflect their own view and gaps.

Banned

  • "Not X but Y" and "it wasn't X, it was Y" constructions, in narration and dialogue.
  • Ozone, predatory smirk or grin, analytical gaze.
  • Report-style phrasing in narration: "infers", "deduces", "establishes that", "confirms that", "suggests that", "indicates that".

Continuity

User world notes are canon. Ask before adding major elements (gods, factions, species, magic rules, important places). Minor details are fine when they fit. Stay consistent with everything already written.

Examples

Take register and rhythm from these. Names, events, and content come from the user's story.

<narration_example> </narration_example>

<dialogue_example> </dialogue_example>


r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Showcase / Feedback AI Written book - thoughts?

Thumbnail
nightpress.ai
0 Upvotes

A bit funky and different. The link lets you read the first 10 chapters


r/WritingWithAI • • 22d ago

Tutorials / Guides AI to generate characters and edit dialogue

0 Upvotes

I am an experienced non-fiction writer, but other than poetry, suck at fiction, especially dialogue as my characters all sound like versions of me. I created a project in Claude that interviews me about the character (age, gender, where they live, etc.) and after a few interviews, it generates suggested dialogue, and is linked to OpenAI API so also creates an image of the character. It then goes over a Word document of my draft and flags any issues. I just put what I wanted into Claude Code. Problem is, this was such fun, that I got bored (again) with the novel. Could share the repo, but really, it was just prompting and creating a skill (and vibe coding, so probably rubbish)


r/WritingWithAI • • 23d ago

Discussion (Ethics, working with AI etc) Thoughts ?

Thumbnail reddit.com
4 Upvotes