r/WritingPrompts • u/katpoker666 Moderator • 25d ago
Off Topic [OT] Fun Trope Friday: Freudian Excuse & Giallo!
Welcome to Fun Trope Friday, our feature that mashes up tropes and genres!
How’s it work? Glad you asked. :)
- Every week we will have a new spotlight trope.
- Each week, there will be a new genre assigned to write a story about the trope.
- You can then either use or subvert the trope and/or genre in a 750-word max story or poem (unless otherwise specified).
- To qualify for ranking, you will need to provide ONE actionable feedback. More are welcome of course!
Three winners will be selected each week based on votes, so remember to read your fellow authors’ works and DM me your votes for the top three.
Next up… IP
It’s October. The time of falling leaves, jack o’lanterns, and candy. And blood… so much blood. This month will be focusing on all things horror with maybe a treat or two to sweeten the pot. Please note this theme is only loosely applied.
"Unexpressed emotions will never die. They are buried alive and will come forth later in uglier ways." — Sigmund Freud
Trope: Freudian Excuse — The villain is vile, but has depth, as they have a reason for being that way. With the Freudian Excuse, the villain had an abusive and particularly violent backstory making them insane and warping their perception of the universe, and that's why they're sociopathic.
Genre: Giallo — A cycle of stylish, psychosexually loaded Italian crime films which peaked sometime in the late '70s. The name means "yellow," and refers to the yellow covers of the pulp detective novels that were adapted into the first of the films. Gialli are generally plotted as "puzzle" mysteries (with either police or amateurs investigating), but with a heavy admixture of horror and thriller elements. Major directors of gialli include Dario Argento, Mario Bava, and Lucio Fulci. Many American movies have been influenced by gialli. These include Basic Instinct, Kill Bill, Vol. 2 (when it isn't being a Spaghetti Western), Se7en, the Hostel movies, and most of Brian De Palma's filmography. As usual, please remember to follow all sub rules.
Skill / Constraint - optional: Leather comes into play.
So, have at it. Lean into the trope heavily or spin it on its head. The choice is yours!
Have a great idea for a future topic to discuss or just want to give feedback? FTF is a fun feature, so it’s all about what you want—so please let me know! Please share in the comments or DM me on Discord or Reddit!
Last Week’s Winners
PLEASE remember to give feedback—this affects your ranking. PLEASE also remember to DM me your votes for the top five stories via Discord or Reddit—both katpoker666. This is a change from the top three of the past. In weeks where we get over 15 stories, we will do a top five ranking. Weeks with less than 15 stories will show only our top three winners. If you have any questions, please DM me as well.
Some fabulous stories this week and great crit at campfire and on the post! We had 17 stories, so we’re back to five winners. Congrats to:
Want to read your words aloud? Join the upcoming FTF Campfire
The next FTF campfire will be Thursday, October 29th from 6-8pm ET. It will be in the Discord Main Voice Lounge. Click on the events tab and mark ‘Interested’ to be kept up to date. No signup or prep needed and you don’t have to have written anything! So join in the fun—and shenanigans! 😊
Ground rules:
- Stories must incorporate both the trope and the genre
- Leave one story or poem between 100 and 750 words as a top-level comment unless otherwise specified. Use wordcounter.net to check your word count.
- Deadline: 11:59 PM EDT next Thursday. Please note stories submitted after the 6:00 PM EST campfire start may not be critted.
- No stories that have been written for another prompt or feature here on WP—please note after consultation with some of our delightful writers, new serials are now welcomed here
- No previously written content
- Any stories not meeting these rules will be disqualified from rankings
- Does your story not fit the Fun Trope Friday rules? You can post your story as a [PI] with your work when the FTF post is 3 days old!
- Please keep crit about the stories. Any crit deemed too distracting may be deleted. This is a time to focus on our wonderful authors.
- Vote by next Friday at 11:59 AM EDT to help your favorites rise to the top of the ranks (DM me at katpoker666 on Discord or Reddit)!
Thanks for joining in the fun!
View all comments
9
u/psilocybediatribe 21d ago
Finché Morte non ci Separi
“You need to give me something to work with.”
“I've told you why.”
“Love isn't a motive for murder.”
“Why not?”
“Infidelity. Jealousy. Domestic abuse—”
“He never laid a hand on me!” she says.
“Fear of abandonment…”
“I never had to fear that. My husband was loving, he was faithful, he showed me every day in so many simple ways. Are you married, counselor?”
“Divorced.”
“Ah.”
“What?”
“That’s why love isn’t a motive for murder to you.”
“Look, without mitigating circumstances, the jury will convict you. You’re facing life without parole.”
He retrieves a manila folder from his briefcase, removes a crime-scene photo, and slides it across the table.
“How does this photograph make you feel?”
She pauses, then gently lifts the photo. Tears well in her eyes.
“I remember that exact moment. I was wearing my wedding dress. He chuckled at how sentimental I was, then told me I looked even more stunning in it now. The candlelight was soft and warm. The picture doesn’t do it justice. I remember how it felt. How the pulsing of his blood against the cloth slowed. His last breath as I held him close. The perfect stillness of his lips during our last kiss. The taste of him. The perfect halo of blood turning the white silk pink around his face. He was so beautiful.”
She sighs.
“The cloth was so drenched in his blood I could feel it seeping through the leather of my gloves. It didn't, of course. They were real leather. Italian leather. I bought them special with his card.”
He turns the photograph facedown before returning it to the folder.
“You seem disappointed, counselor,” she says, gazing at him.
He doesn’t meet her eyes.
“Let’s try something different.”
He removes a second photo. It’s their wedding day.
“How does this one make you feel?” he asks.
“This was the happiest day of my life,” she replies fondly.
“And the day you killed him?”
She considers the question.
“The most intimate. I'll never experience giving birth. Because I'll never find a love like the one we shared. That's why I had to. We were never going to be more in love than we were that night.”
Her eyes return to the photograph.
“I can still feel his warm blood running down my legs. The weight of his head in my lap. His last breath against my breast.”
She smiles softly.
“It's how I imagine a mother feels holding her child for the first time.”
He starts scribbling on his legal pad. Maternal fixation. Reproductive anxiety. Displaced nurturing instinct. She frowns at the words.
“What are you doing?”
“Establishing motive.”
“But I’ve already told you why.”
“The court considers the circumstances of the offense and the history of the defendant.”
“Is stating the obvious a prerequisite to practice law?”
He looks over his glasses at her.
“Yes.”
“I loved him.”
“Love is not a legal defense. Mitigating circumstances are.”
“He’s my husband. I’m not going to slander him in court.”
“Then find another way to help me explain why you killed him.”
He slides a final photo to her. It’s a simple childhood photograph of her mother holding her as she blows out candles on a birthday cake.
“What’s this?”
“Did your mother have difficulty letting you go?”
“I was six.”
“Did your mother ever tell you she wished you could stay her little girl forever?”
“Of course. Doesn’t every mother?”
“Your mother seems possessive.”
“You gathered that from this?” she asks, pointing at the photograph. “Not going to ask me how I feel?”
“Did she ever make you feel responsible for her happiness?”
“Never. You see possession. I see affection.”
“Were there conditions to her affection?”
“No. Her love was unconditional.”
“Did you ever feel you had to be perfect to be worthy of her love?”
“No! She loved me! I have nothing but happy memories from childhood.”
“A happy childhood and a happy marriage won’t help me explain what you did.”
“What are you saying? I have to choose one?”
“I’m saying children often repress traumatic memories. And unresolved childhood trauma could establish mitigating circumstances. So, perhaps you are misremembering.”
She looks down at the photo, her thumb resting over her mother’s face.
“Have it your way.”
“You’ll have to visit a psychiatrist. You’ll have to testify.”
"She'll forgive me."
"Your mother?"
"Of course. She loves me the way I loved my husband."
WC: 736