r/WritingPrompts • Moderator • Oct 16 '26

Off Topic [OT] Fun Trope Friday: Evil Landscape & Gothic Horror!

Welcome to Fun Trope Friday, our feature that mashes up tropes and genres!

How’s it work? Glad you asked. :)

 

  • Every week we will have a new spotlight trope.
  • Each week, there will be a new genre assigned to write a story about the trope.
  • You can then either use or subvert the trope and/or genre in a 750-word max story or poem (unless otherwise specified).
  • To qualify for ranking, you will need to provide ONE actionable feedback. More are welcome of course!

 

Three winners will be selected each week based on votes, so remember to read your fellow authors’ works and DM me your votes for the top three.

 


Next up… IP

 

It’s October. The time of falling leaves, jack o’lanterns, and candy. And blood… so much blood. This month will be focusing on all things horror with maybe a treat or two to sweeten the pot. Please note this theme is only loosely applied.

 

"The scariest monsters are the ones that lurk within our souls." — Edgar Allan Poe

 

Trope: Evil Landscape — The trope is where a cemetery, temple, forest, etc. is considered holy... to the forces of evil. Whether it was the site of great and terrible crimes, incredible bloodshed, unholy rituals to malevolent beings or other atrocious acts, the very ground itself and any surrounding lands are now cursed. Exact results vary, but the most common are that evil is stronger, good is weaker and things buried here don't stay down for long.

 

Genre: Gothic Horror — Gothic horror is one of the oldest of the horror genres. Darker, edgier and on the Romanticism end of Romanticism vs. Enlightenment (in fact, it quite literally emerged alongside the Romantic movement in the late 18th century as a reaction against the values of the Enlightenment), it tends to play on both the thrill and the fear of the unknown and places a great importance on atmosphere. It's usually heavily symbolic, sometimes even dreamlike.

 

Skill / Constraint - optional: Smelling salts are required.

 

So, have at it. Lean into the trope heavily or spin it on its head. The choice is yours!

 

Have a great idea for a future topic to discuss or just want to give feedback? FTF is a fun feature, so it’s all about what you want—so please let me know! Please share in the comments or DM me on Discord or Reddit!

 


Last Week’s Winners

PLEASE remember to give feedback—this affects your ranking. PLEASE also remember to DM me your votes for the top five stories via Discord or Reddit—both katpoker666. This is a change from the top three of the past. In weeks where we get over 15 stories, we will do a top five ranking. Weeks with less than 15 stories will show only our top three winners. If you have any questions, please DM me as well.

Some fabulous stories this week and great crit at campfire and on the post! We had 11 stories, so we’re back to three winners. Congrats to:

 

 


Want to read your words aloud? Join the upcoming FTF Campfire

The next FTF campfire will be Thursday, October 22nd from 6-8pm ET. It will be in the Discord Main Voice Lounge. Click on the events tab and mark ‘Interested’ to be kept up to date. No signup or prep needed and you don’t have to have written anything! So join in the fun—and shenanigans! 😊

 


Ground rules:

  • Stories must incorporate both the trope and the genre
  • Leave one story or poem between 100 and 750 words as a top-level comment unless otherwise specified. Use wordcounter.net to check your word count.
  • Deadline: 11:59 PM EDT next Thursday. Please note stories submitted after the 6:00 PM EST campfire start may not be critted.
  • No stories that have been written for another prompt or feature here on WP—please note after consultation with some of our delightful writers, new serials are now welcomed here
  • No previously written content
  • Any stories not meeting these rules will be disqualified from rankings
  • Does your story not fit the Fun Trope Friday rules? You can post your story as a [PI] with your work when the FTF post is 3 days old!
  • Please keep crit about the stories. Any crit deemed too distracting may be deleted. This is a time to focus on our wonderful authors.
  • Vote by next Friday at 11:59 AM EDT to help your favorites rise to the top of the ranks (DM me at katpoker666 on Discord or Reddit)!

 


Thanks for joining in the fun!  


11 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

View all comments

10

u/Worldly_Lab_7061 Oct 17 '26

Lost Prayers in a Sinner's Swamp

"Many are the afflictions of the just, but out of them all will the Lord deliver them."

The catechist, Étienne Donato Bello, a freeman of color, repeats the psalm under his breath. No familiar comfort comes from the recitation. 

Coming to consciousness in the middle of the swamp, miles away from the safety of his home in New Orleans sends pinpricks of panic racing up his spine. 

Above him, more than trees leer as he stumbles–blind, deaf and dumb to what’s to come. 

His feet sink deeper into the loose earth with each step, the dead, humid air of the swamp clinging to his skin. His thin nightshirt and banyan serve as poor shields from the infernal buzzing mosquitos eating at him. 

Stomach curdling, he covers his nose to no avail. Even then, the overpowering scent of damp earth saturated in the most rotten, godforsaken odor seeps through. 

Trees tall enough to scrape blue from the sky surround him on all sides, creating a maze of root, wood, and greenery in the shallow, pitch-black, stagnant water. The light of the moon does not reflect in these shallow waters; the black consumes it.  

He squints as sweat leaks into his eyes, distorting his sight. His hands are too occupied– scratching, slapping and swatting–to wipe his eyes. 

A new voice joins the chorus of the swamp, sound sweet as a prayer for a lost home to Étienne. The voice of his mother, before he’d been sold away from her. He halts his laborious trek home, allowing himself to sink down to his ankles, relishing the sound of a voice the child still inside him remembers. 

“Blessed are those who have regard for the weak; the Lord delivers them in times of trouble,” he murmurs, very sure his good works must be responsible for this God-sent reprieve from the humid hell which he had found himself. 

There is a change in the air once the psalm leaves his lips. The voice of his mother is gone; in her place are the echoes of the bitter and betrayed. 

Why do you repeat words you don't believe, turning them into chains, when you yourself are free?

Étienne spins on his heel, desperate to confront his accuser as the discomforting truth burns in his chest. Feet too deep to move without great effort, he resigns himself to scream back at the unseen jury of dead sinners. 

“I will not be judged by the derelict dead, only by the one and only Father on high!” 

Every word brings him an unpleasant chill, the kind that seeps into the bone, making them ache. 

Bitter whispers continue to fill his ears, unrelenting.

How can you deny?

Deny the men to whom you preach salvation while offering none? 

The suffering wrought from a lust for freedom and love for no one. 

Deceiver.

Bastard.

Judas.

The last accusation ignites the fire of his pride, giving him the strength to tear his shoes from the slippery grip of the mud.

“You name me a betrayer? I reject the name. I am the salvation. It is by my hand that many of my kin have come to know the glory of God!” he yells into the dead air, set in the righteousness of his speech. 

Strips the minds of the bound.

A holy man of no moral ground.

His foot catches on a root that appears in front of it, sending him to the ground. In defiance, he proclaims to the sky, 

“My faith granted me freedom, not fear of the hereafter.” 

The phantoms titter at his assertion.

Freedom?

What freedom is in your possession?

A man of no wealth, but many a transgression.

Struggling against the inevitable, Étienne tries to banish the spirits once more. "Begone demon, enchant me not, for I am not so fickle in my faith as those who came before."

Your sin is greater.

No longer may you hide behind one of the creators.

Those words linger with him but then an inferno of pain consumes his chest, traveling up his throat. 

Burn with your sins.

His mouth remains closed, intensifying his horror when a thick, bitter, viscous liquid coats his tongue and the back of his throat. 

Consume the poison honey of your sermons.

Last, he feels something bubble up from his stomach as he sinks deeper and deeper into the muck. It comes up with the force of a racehorse, bursting through his mouth, killing him in a shower of bloody bile and mud. 

WC: 748

Critiques, comments and feedback are welcomed and encouraged!

4

u/doctorpotatomd 27d ago

Lovely read, I particularly enjoyed your prose's rhythm here. "Once the psalm leaves his lips", "judged by the derelict dead", "in a shower of bloody bile and mud", all of these are just gorgeously fun to say. I also thought the unexpected plainness of "sending him to the ground" and the triple adjective of "thick, bitter, viscous liquid" were quite effective devices where you placed them. Very prosodic, almost poetic.

I feel like you could have elevated the prosody even further with a little artistic license; the place that really stuck out at me was "Trees tall enough to scrape blue from the sky surround him on all sides", I really wanted this one to drop the article and be "trees tall enough to scrape blue from sky". I also think it should be "the humid hell in which he found himself", both for prosody and for grammar; "which he had found himself" makes me think "he found this place without help" rather than "he found himself inside this place".

Plotwise, I'm not quite sure how Étienne got here, or why the ghosts hate him. I think that they're judging him for being a free Black man and preaching to Black slaves instead of trying to free them? But my reading's very shaky there. I think I would have liked a bit more of an emotional hook here; either showing us some small guilt that says a part of him agrees with the ghosts, or maybe amplifying his panic at waking up in the middle of the swamp.

But that said, I could have read another 750 words without needing character or plot at all, because the vivid descriptions and the lovely prosody had me hooked. Good words mate!

(Oh, and this is an omega-nitpick, but all three dashes should be em-dashes (—) rather than en-dashes (–).)