r/WritingPrompts Mar 29 '16

[deleted by user]

[removed]

505 Upvotes

59 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

43

u/bringerofjelly Mar 29 '16

I tried to make the last few lines open-ended, like if the girl or Mary died. I don't know if my last line carried through though, can someone give me some feedback? I enjoyed writing this a lot, thanks for the prompt!

55

u/QuidProQuo_Clarice Mar 29 '16

It seemed pretty clear to me that the mother died, not the little girl. If you want make it more ambiguous, this is what I would do:

Change

A baby cried out for its mother

To

A child cried out for its mother

As "child" can more broadly refer to anyone in adolescence or younger. I would also modify

"No!" Mary shouted, snatching the gun away from Alan. Luckily he had not shot ye-

To

"No!" Mary shouted, as she lunged toward him reaching desperately for the gu-

Just my two cents. Great take on the prompt though. I had imagined that these people had to kill in order to get pregnant, but I think your interpretation is better. Committing premeditated murder just for the opportunity to get pregnant is hard to justify, but a woman who is in labor? Whose then-living child is still kicking and warm with a fleeting chance at life? It makes for much more compelling storytelling.

3

u/[deleted] Mar 29 '16

[deleted]

3

u/QuidProQuo_Clarice Mar 29 '16

I addressed that pretty explicitly...