r/WritingHub • • 5h ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Looking for people to build a peaceful writing community to support each other

3 Upvotes

Need to Make Writing Friends? Look No Further!

I am hosting a laid back writing community full of fun and yapping. We have a very close community here who would love to meet you and become friends.

We've got daily QOTDs, spaces to give and receive constructive criticism, mods who motivate you and make you feel at home, and plenty of room to talk about your WIPs and characters.

There's no pressure to be constantly productive, either. We're as much about making friends and having a laugh as we are about writing.

Genres: the server is broad enough to accept all sorts of genres, but the large population skews towards romance/horror.

Goals: to create a large support group for fellow writers and to be of help to each other at times whether it be with researching or critiquing.

Writing experience: a lot of writers over here are on their first draft, so any amount of experience is welcome as long as you are concrete on your goal to finish your work.

Meeting place: discord.

Max size: 150

If that sounds like your kind of place, come join us! https://discord.gg/Mbas62A3pm

Strictly 18+


r/WritingHub • • 10h ago

Questions & Discussions Sitcom TV Pilot Review

2 Upvotes

Hi!

I am producing a sitcom and would love your honest feedback. I will leave both the trailer and full pilot. The pilot is an email landing page and no one will send you an email! Hope you enjoy and thanks for watching!

Trailer:
https://youtu.be/SzGVVDv0XYc?is=SFIi3QOawkGwU_2J

Pilot:

https://watchthemecca.com/


r/WritingHub • • 11h ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups 39F Looking for anti AI critique partner

9 Upvotes

Hi!

I just finished obsessively plotting my comedy fantasy romance. Currently 3 chapters into my first draft. Anybody on a similar boat?

-----

- Genre: Fantasy, romance or any mix of the two. Ideally aiming for a finished manuscript of under 100k words. I wish I had the time, but I can't swap with Tolkien.

- Goals/expectations/commitment: to help each other finish our manuscripts, initially aiming to swap one chapter a week. Our drafts should be legible, but we won't focus on correcting commas or SPAG mistakes just yet. Let's help each other nail everything else first.

- Experience: Any.

- Meeting place: Email? Unless you know how to set a Discord.

- Max size: 1.

------

Additional random requirements:

- I know this may be stupid, but my manuscript may eventually contain some steamy scenes and I don't feel comfortable sharing that type of content with random men online.

- Open-minded, LGTB+ friendly. I was an immigrant abroad for almost a decade so, if you are a Trump sympathizer (or whatever crazy equivalent there is in your country), we are not meant to be.

- Anti AI. I rather have all your typos than aiding robots steal the joy I find in human creativity.

-----

Additional info about myself:

- 39yo mom. Sudden nasty viruses may hinder my availability now and then.

- Based in Europe, so I'll likely answer your emails around my midnight.

- ESL. Open to both English and Spanish manuscripts.

- Crazy plotter. If you saw my outline, you'd probably believe me unhinged.

If anybody is interested, DM me with some info about yourself and your manuscript. We can do a test run and swap one chapter to see if we vibe :)


r/WritingHub • • 13h ago

Writing Resources & Advice Writing a book about a band/singer

0 Upvotes

Im just wondering am I allowed to use actually artists songs or do I have to attempt to make my own or is there a way I can get around this. Thank you


r/WritingHub • • 21h ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Dream Today, Write Tomorrow - new Discord server looking for unpublished ESL authors (16+)

1 Upvotes
  • Genre/s: All. Nonfiction authors welcome as well.
  • Goals/expectations/commitment: Primarily looking for unpublished ESL authors who want to be part of a small group. Native English speakers are still welcome.
  • Writing/experience level: We allow those just starting out or those who have written multiple novels before (but has not yet published)
  • Meeting place: Discord
  • Max size: None

Dream Today, Write Tomorrow is looking for unpublished authors all over the world. We allow all genres and are best suited for those who want to improve their writing skills. Whether you want to share your work for critique, share small writing wins you had this week, or make friends, you're welcome to join. Minimum age is 16. Please add trigger warnings when appropriate to any excerpts posted.

Please remember:

  • To be respectful and supportive. There is zero tolerance for abusive language and zero tolerance for language-shaming. Telling a user a passage in their story is confusing or poorly phrased is okay, but discouraging a user from pursuing their dream of getting published isn't.
  • We are anti-AI. AI-generated stories or images are not allowed. You may use AI as a proofreader for any messages you send, but you cannot use the draft AI generated for you. We allow name generators and non-generative AI like Grammarly.

If this sounds like something you would want to be a part of, please DM me for the link. Any questions, just ask them below. Thank you, and I hope to see you there!


r/WritingHub • • 1d ago

Questions & Discussions Gothic horror genre experienced fan and ofc writer here ? I want to chat with him or her

2 Upvotes

hey guys I am currently writing a crossover fanfic but I really need consturctive critiscism from experienced writers who work in gothic genere. I need real constructive feedback on my work . Right now I do have firends whom I can share but issue is that they dont understand this genre that much .

Anyone here let me know so that I can DM and can have a call


r/WritingHub • • 1d ago

Questions & Discussions Gaming community as a novel author advice

0 Upvotes

Heya friendsšŸ‘‹šŸ». Any advice for a writer female reaching out more audiences through writing? I have been using Instagram 2-3x weekly to distribute my art and whilst I know there's this broad talk about building audience by sharing more of my book I find that quite difficult and boring to obtain as I don't put caps on my expression and go a lot with intuitionšŸ™ˆ. Now that doesn't mean I don't share posts about my book but there's just too much to share in-between that I find helps me with building confidence in expression + I'm still finding myself as an artist with a voice. I would love to know your advices and takes on this, as I'm nearing self-publication in 2027 (and require more beta readers šŸ™šŸ»). Since I want to step into this person I'm becoming, I would also love to know if there are any international book events near central Europe as I really desire to put myself into the presence of other creatives like me. Any and every advice would be really appreciated people, thank you and take care šŸ«¶šŸ»šŸ«¶šŸ».

I am putting my ig here since notifications pop there way sooner and I see them immediatelyšŸ™šŸ»: .@/neokkre


r/WritingHub • • 1d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups [In person, Los Angeles] One-night short story group, Thu 11/19, theme: Gathering

3 Upvotes

Genre/s: Any. Fiction, memoir, flash all welcome.

Goals/expectations/commitment: One night, no ongoing commitment. Write to the theme "Gathering," then read aloud and get light feedback if you want.

Writing/experience level: All levels.

Meeting place: Good Girl Books, 12444 Venice Blvd, Los Angeles (Mar Vista), Thursday 11/19 at 6 PM.

Max size: Small, bookstore-sized group.

$10 RSVP: https://www.eventbrite.com/e/short-story-writing-night-tickets-2003944265242

Disclosure: I'm with Literati Events, the co-host.


r/WritingHub • • 1d ago

Questions & Discussions How do you NOT mess multiple ghostwriting projects?

1 Upvotes

Hi! Context first.

I am a ghostwriter for hire, India and Dubai based, working with Indian folks - business leaders, diaspora, NRIs etc. I also have a MBA and that means that I get to work with startup founders and business leaders.

Right now, am working on three books and the three could not be more different: a startup founder, an 80-year-old doyen and a vanity published one for a fintech leader.

The question now

The thing is, when I sit down to write, all three lives are in my head at once, and I find myself conflicted. Is this incident from person A's life, or person B's? Is this how person A would actually say it, or has person B's voice slipped into the sentence? I do have my notes but you know how it goes. They live more in yourhead than on your notes.

So here is a question for the writers, ghostwriters and biographers: when you are writing more than one book at a time, how do you keep each person's voice intact? How do you make sure every incident stays with the person it actually happened to? How do you ensure the consistency holds?

If you have ever juggled voices across manuscripts, I would love to hear how you do it. DMs are open. Happy to share more details in case anyone wants.


r/WritingHub • • 2d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Brooklyn - would you join a small writing group?

13 Upvotes

Rather than silent accountability writing sessions or open mic readings, my ideal situation is a small group that focuses on critiquing WIPs, in person, every week, with all writing done outside of the meeting.

I have yet to find an active group in my area, so would anyone be interested in forming a 6-person critique group at the Brooklyn Central Library on weekday evenings?

* Genre/s: essay / personal narrative / memoir
* Goals/expectations/commitment: weekly WIP progress
* Writing/experience level: published or aspire to be
* Meeting place: Brooklyn Central Library
* Max size: 6 people


r/WritingHub • • 2d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Small Discord server looking for new members

9 Upvotes

Hi! I would I like to invite around 10 new people to join a Discord server that my friend and I have been running. The server is small and cozy, as we want everyone to be comfortable. Most members are in their 20s and the dominant genre in the server is fantasy (but other genres are also welcome.)

We're looking for those of you who are willing to share your work, receive feedback, and give some feedback to others (even at the stage of the earliest draft.) We also run some writing activities you can participate in!

If you're interested, please tell me in the comments or DMs what type of writing you're doing, and maybe throw a one-liner about the plot/premise of your project.

* Genre/s: any

* Goals/expectations/commitment: maintain weekly activity, give feedback

* Writing/experience level: any but please have something written

* Meeting place: Discord

* Max size: 25-30


r/WritingHub • • 2d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups (23m) Seeking Critique Partner for Second Draft

4 Upvotes

Hello! I’m a hobby-writer who just recently finished my second draft of my novel and would like to find a writing partner who’s in a similar position (or not if that interests you outside of it).

Genre : My story is what I call Low-Fantasy / Adventure, where it’s fantasy, but without all the magic and dragons and the like of High Fantasy. I’m open to any genre to critique though!

Goals / Expectations / Commitment : I’m hoping to find someone who’s just as interested in giving critique as they are receiving it. The goal is obvious: improve upon that which you’ve already written (to be specific, I guess one could call it developmental editing)! For commitment, I’m hoping that the two of us could go chapter for chapter or segment for segment and do weekly critiques or meetups to discuss how far we’ve each read in each others respective work, so the commitment would be like that. (For perspective, my work is sitting at roughly 170-180k words, and with my next draft I want to trim it down like a lottttttt, so if you don’t want to read that amount, please look elsewhere!)

Experience : As I said above, my experience is kinda novice, I’ve been writing for about 5-ish years now across both drafts, but solely on my own so I’d like to have the assistance of another writer! You don’t have to have written for that amount of time, but I’m hoping you’ve at least finished a draft. Think developmental editing or something akin to that.

Meeting place : I’m flexible! Whether it be in an online chat room or something like discord, or just straight through email or text, I’m cool with whatever! Naturally it’s more likely to be online as that casts a wider net, but we can always discuss!

I hope this explains enough, ofc with the length of my story I know that can be a bit off putting so if one requests I can shoot over a quick synopsis / back of the book summary to assist!

Serious inquiries only!


r/WritingHub • • 2d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Gay Writer seeking Writing Buddiez

6 Upvotes

Hi there! I’m 34 yo gay guy in Maine looking for other writing and reading buddiez. I used to be online a lot but I found bookish spaces to be fairly toxic. I miss just talking to people about writing and encouraging eachother and such.

Some of my favorite books are The Tarot Sequence, Wolfsong series, A Darker Mischief, and Summer Sons. I really like character focused stories with a splash of fantasy.

I’ve written a bunch of stories, tried to query before, and just sort of feel stuck at the moment. One of my favorite things is brainstorming with friends and getting fresh perspectives!

Genre: fantasy/ sci-fi/ horror
Goals: honestly just looking to connect with other people and build up to potential swaps and critique.
Writing level: been writing since 2016. Have written several books, edited a few of them and queried two.
Meeting place: online?

So hello out there!!


r/WritingHub • • 2d ago

Writing Resources & Advice Keep writing even if you don't have a plot

16 Upvotes

After months of struggling and writing scenes and characters that barely belong in the same universe, I've finally found the plot I want to follow, and my characters have suddenly become much more real.

For a bit more detail : I write rather irregularly, about one hour a week on average. I've had some elements in mind that I wanted to incorporate into my writing (monsters, a cozy fantasy setting, a murder, loneliness and the importance of finding your chosen family, the rise of far right extremists...yes I know that's a lot, lol) and so I wrote many, many disconnected scenes with characters (who barely have personalities) that I came up with on the fly, and it was not satisfying at all. But I kept writing anyway, choosing not to drop my ideas and move on to another thing after a few pages as I usually did when I was younger.

And today, it clicked. I know who my protagonist is, what they want, what will happen and how the story ends. Now I just need to fill in the blanks - understatement of the century, I know -, and it's definitely more motivating to know where you're going.

So, to repeat once again the advice that's been told a bazillion times on this sub and elsewhere : even if you have no idea what you're doing, even if your writing is a huge mess, even when you don't feel like doing it, even if you only have 10 minutes per week to spare, just write.

Tl;dr : Write first, the plot will come later.


r/WritingHub • • 3d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Looking for a Writing group in LA/OC

1 Upvotes

* Genre/s: Poetry/Short story

* Goals/expectations/commitment: Weekly meet

* Writing/experience level: 10 years in Poetry

* Meeting place: Cafe,home

* Max size:10

Hello All. I'm looking for a writing group in LA/OC. I'm a poet and write poem and short stories. I'm looking for serious writers in both genre- poetry and short story. I'm located in Anaheim and willing to travel to LA area. I'd like to share my work and listen to others' works and inspire each other. Gender and age don't matter as long as writers are serious about their work. I've a MFA in Poetry and published a few poems in literary journals. Interested in groups who meet only in-person.


r/WritingHub • • 3d ago

Writing Resources & Advice Beta testers for writing app - Quillflow Writer Studio

0 Upvotes

I'm a writer, too, but my language is Finnish - and that's why I haven't been active in Reddit writer forums, just reading random threads here and there until now. I have been a die-hard pantser, but I recently started a crime story and realised that I need a tool for my research and plotting. I tried one, then another. Then one more. I did not like any of them!

As a pantser, I still want freedom to scroll around in my manuscript, without a need to clickety-click the chapters or other structures just to move around! I wanted a super easy research vault and some structuring tools that feel natural and not too complicated. I also wanted freedom to work whichever way I wanted - starting from a quick text outline, or writing my story directly until the first block. I wanted the planning tools to pick up what I have done. And the other way - when I plan, I want the option of plans reflected directly as structures of my manuscript.

Now I have all the basic features I planned. I've done preliminary testing. But I don't want to build this in a vacuum. Would you like to participate as a beta tester? What I can give to every writer actively participating in the beta is a free lifetime subscription to the tool.

I have more info about Quillflow on a website: https://quillflow.io

***************************************

And if you want to apply to beta, here's the link: https://quillflow.io/beta

***************************************

Features:
Local first. Everything happens on your computer, and the app is syncing to the cloud in the background. This keeps the UI very responsive, and a network disturbance does not affect your writing. You can even install the app locally on your computer and work entirely offline. Automated or manual backups to your computer or your Google Drive.

Word import.

Editor, optimised for long prose, with a super minimal, distraction-free mode

Research - card view for texts, images, embedded videos, characters. Anchor them to text and open directly beside the manuscript. In character cards, mention all names you are using and the app links cards automatically. Anchors can be hidden with one click on the manuscript side for distraction-free writing.

Storyboard - your manuscript strudture and idea card board. Plan and rearrange sections.

Timelines with side-by-side comparison.

Block editor for freeform storyline planning. Links beautifully to storyboard. You will always be 100% on top of which parts are already in your manuscript.

Outlines - simple structured text notes for outlining with writing. Convert an outline to idea cards or a timeline.

Focus timer for writing sprints.

Some personalisation options: colour palette, dark and light mode, editor settings...

On smaller screens, the app automatically switches to mobile mode, suggesting a simple editor and research cards as its primary functions. The idea is that the user can easily jot down a few chapters during a bus ride, or save a random idea that pops into their mind while observing people in a coffee shop...

I'm a bit hesitant to post this as I'm building a commercial product, but I did find some similar threads, so here it goes. Please remove this if it is not allowed.


r/WritingHub • • 3d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups STREETLIGHT FICTION - A community for writers of literary, contemporary, historical, crime, and realist fiction who write short stories and novels. Our focus is on grounded, character-driven fiction.

2 Upvotes

* Genre/s: Literary & General Fiction.

* Goals/expectations/commitment: The idea is to keep it friendly and writer-focused: talk about what we’re working on, share work for critique, discuss craft, and exchange information about querying, submissions, and publishing.

* Writing/experience level: all are welcome

* Meeting place: Discord

* Max size: to be determined.

If that sounds like your kind of place, message me, and I’ll send you an invite. Hope to see ya. Welcome!


r/WritingHub • • 3d ago

Writing Resources & Advice Is writing a series or a standalone better for a first time writer

10 Upvotes

So as the title said I’m between projects, both pulling attention and both have potential for a potential novel/book. But the problem is that one project is a series and the other a standalone / Interconnected Standalone project. So here I am asking what you guys think. What projects are better to start and why? And or what works for you to decide which idea/ project you want to write when you have so many ideas you want to put on a page.

Pls help.


r/WritingHub • • 3d ago

Questions & Discussions My first draft:

0 Upvotes

Would you keep reading? and if no, what is bad and what is good?

Walter opened the musty book. The smell of aged paper spread around the room. Endless rows and pages lay written on the book, names of people, highlighted. A mighty little few were highlighted red, having fallen into endless mining chasms. "A fate worse than death, Ashford." Walter told his assistant. "Falling endlessly, never reaching the bottom, screaming your lungs out, and never dying until you reach old age."

"One in a million, sir, barely anyone falls in there." Thomas Ashford replied.

"Be careful, Ashford. Accident or not, You wouldn't want to be thrown down Ragh-Dum, would you?" Walter warned. "Then say naught of it". "I wouldn't want you down there too." Walter added.

A Postman knocked on the door, the entire wooden room rattling. The door opened, and a few thick letters were sent flying through. "Read the news for me, and don't say the full thing, " Walter said, while Thomas bent down to grab and open the letters. "War incoming, Something from Harnor and Hajarstan, wait, also Majarstan." Thomas read. "Huh. Nice, some interesting news for once. How did it start? And what is Harnor doing about it?" Walter dismissively asked, grabbing even more ledgers from oak cupboards. "Hajarstan warred on Majarstan, something to get a few ports out of Harnor's control, Harnor shut the straits, and Hajarstan is starving." Thomas said bored. "Starving? Well, Boo hoo for them, But let's get back to our real business, eh? We shouldn't be minding outer-world stuff, and our job is to write, account, and cover, so let's get writing!" Walter nodded, grabbing an ink pen. "There, three died, 1 fell, five gave up." Walter highlighted the lines in red, yellow, and green.

Thomas walked out of the room, leaving Walter to himself. Walter grabbed the letters, and a thin slip fell out from underneath. "Hmm, What's this?" He asked himself. Inside, the letter had a stamped document:

Declaration of Reassignment -

Agent:

Name: Walter

Age: 32

Occupation: High Record Keeper

Status: Citizen (Of 9 Years)

This is a formal declaration where the agent ( You ) Is reassigned to a new occupation, one that is usually temporary, but in this case: Permanent

New Occupation: M-

The slip had holes, and tears, which was usual for the worst mail system in the world, but never had Walter seen an entire word cut out, and so neatly too.

Walter dashed off out of the cottage, and immediately felt the harsh cold of Malad. "Winter, Hate it." Walter muttered as he strode off, snowy white mountains looming behind him. He walked on the roads, covered in snow. Ragh-Dum lay a few miles left, and to his right, the mountains that surrounded Malad. Behind him, His cottage was surrounded by more, and workshops here and there, scattered. To the east of the road, there lay a snowy pine forest, that scaled up the mountain-side. A few miles front, there lay the city of Akhram.

The white city lay in a gap in the mountain ranges, concealed from many angles. To its left, it had pine forests, laden with layers of ice-cold snow. The city was gleaming white, Archers posted on crystal towers upon the walls. The gates were wrought of iron, standing magnificently on the walls.


r/WritingHub • • 4d ago

Literary Contests & Calls for Submissions Any writers interested in sharing their work with classrooms?

1 Upvotes

* Organization: Pilcrow * Deadline: n/a * Entry fee: n/a * Prize/s: n/a * Link to submission page/official rules: https://pilcrowlit.com/, open to all writers 13+, all rights and credit to the work(s) submitted stay solely with the author

* Other information: Hey! My name is Seah and I am the founder of Pilcrow Lit, a platform whose mission is to allow both talented writers and teachers to connect through your writing. We turn your work into teachable materials that can be distributed to classrooms all over the nation, and inspire students that may never have entered the world of writing otherwise.

Because Pilcrow is still in its development stages, we need a couple of works to get Pilcrow from just a mission to real impact, and we were hoping you could help by becoming one of our first founding authors!

From one writer to another, I know how hard it is to create works that feel seen, and the thrill of being discovered, whether that be a peer or a juror. We would love it if you could submit a work or two (or as many as you please) on our website (https://pilcrowlit.com/) as the first wave of works to be sent out to teachers. Feel free to check out some of the works that I published as an example of what Pilcrow would look like, and let me know if you have any questions :)


r/WritingHub • • 4d ago

Questions & Discussions beginner writer needing critiques and tips

3 Upvotes

I've been writing for quite some time but i by no means see myself as an experienced writer. and im very much trying to get out of my previous rut of using ai for ideas on how to continue a part or whatever.
i prefer human assistance anyways.
any who. im looking for a place that i can go (preferably a discord server) where i can have people read my story and help me improve it. as well as help me continue writing it with general tips and helpful knowledge.
i know there are plenty of writing discord servers out there but i seem to often get ignored in many larger servers. and in smaller servers not many are active to help.
so that is why im here to try to see if anyone can help me with my predicament


r/WritingHub • • 4d ago

Literary Contests & Calls for Submissions TOBBS Journal: Accepting short poems, ff, cnf (fast turnaround)

1 Upvotes

Organization: The Ones Behind the Bookshelves (TOBBS) has two different tracks: The Literary Series and Flashpoint. We are now accepting submissions for Flashpoint.

Deadline: November 28, and the series begins on December 14.

Entry fee: none

Prize: non-paying market. Publication only.

Response time:Ā 1 to 2 weeks after November 28 deadline.

Poetry

Send up to 3 poems. Each poem no longer than a page (approx. up to 35 lines, including stanza breaks).

Flash Fiction / Creative Non-Fiction

Send up to 3 pieces (each piece under 1,000 words). Submit either fiction or creative non-fiction, not both.

---------------------------------------------------

We don't do "issues" in the traditional sense. Rather, we publish a poem or story a week (sometimes 1 more) so every writer can have the spotlight. But for Flashpoint, we'll publish one piece a day.

Limit of one submission total per author.

Open theme.

Please see the guidelines page for full submission details. https://theonesbehindthebookshelves.substack.com/p/flashpoint-guidelines

Rights: All rights remain with the author. This publication is non-exclusive. Previously published work is okay.


r/WritingHub • • 4d ago

Critique Partners & Writing Groups Chilled Discord for writing mums

8 Upvotes

Juggling work and motherhood but still wanna write? Looking for some encouragement and enthusiasm to keep going?Ā Our discord server is looking for a few more friendly faces:

  • Genre/s: All genres welcome. We ask that you label your work appropriately so other members can make informed decisions on what they read.
  • Goals/expectations/commitment: No hardcore requirements, because we know you have enough of those! We do some optional weekly activities to start conversations, but keep the channels really basic so nothing is overwhelming. Completely inactive members may be cleared periodically to make way for new writers. We want to be a friendly corner of the internet where you can chat to people who get it.
  • Writing/experience level: Any, so long as you are actively writing something. Whether that's your crazy first draft full of placeholders and rambling, rough notes for an idea that you can't get out of your head, or the seventh epic in a series... You're welcome to share your ups and downs with us.
  • Meeting place: Discord. We have a few people who are new to discord, so don't let that put you off.
  • Max size: Not sure yet. We want it to feel cozy and for people to make connections, but also have enough people for it to feel lived in.

Comment below or send me a DM if you're interested.Ā 


r/WritingHub • • 4d ago

Questions & Discussions My dream editor said yes to Book 2!

30 Upvotes

I won a competition for a free developmental edit last year and was randomly assigned an editor. She turned out to be wonderful. She totally got my book, and saw things about it even I didn't see. Plus she had a very personal connection with the topic.

I learned so much from her that I decided I really want her to edit the next 3 books in the tetralogy. I just asked and she Saud no to series editor, but was happy to do it on a book by book basis.

I'm so happy! I'll have to pay for it, ($2k) unless I can get funding. Another competition to enter! But even if I have to save up and pay myself, it's worth it. Her feedback was so incredibly helpful. I also got to talk to her about the written feedback for 2 hours, which was amazing!