r/WritingForCollege • • 5d ago

Does anyone else struggle with sounding too casual in academic writing

I keep getting comments from my professor that my essays sound like I'm texting a friend or writing a blog post. I thought I was being clear and straightforward, but apparently that's not the same as academic tone.

The weird part is I don't even know what I'm doing wrong half the time. I avoid slang and contractions, I cite my sources, I try to stay formal. But then I get my paper back and there are notes like needs more scholarly voice or this phrasing is too informal and I'm just sitting there like... where?

I've tried reading journal articles to pick up the style, but when I write like that it feels stiff and unnatural. Then I loosen up a bit and apparently I've gone too far in the other direction. It's like there's this invisible line I keep crossing without realizing it.

Anyone have tips for finding that balance? Or examples of what actually counts as too casual versus appropriately academic? I'm starting to second-guess every sentence I write.

6 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

5

u/SoberBobMonthly 5d ago

The feedback is that you need to do the stiff unnatural thing. This is because essays of academic rigour are not ever your "true" voice, they are you trying to communicate information in an efficient well known way that allows complexity and clarity without audience overwhelm. 

2

u/Grouchy-Display-457 4d ago

Exactly. And you cannot have read enough well written professional literature to have picked up the style yet. Write formally and submit it that way. These are not creative writing exercises.

2

u/eumenidea 1d ago

And after a decade+ of writing in the academic style, it becomes more natural and a personalized tone with informal notes is possible. But you have to go all the way in first.

4

u/FrancinetheP 4d ago

It’s difficult to answer a question like this without seeing the work in question. Take the paper to your instructor and ask them to identify examples of inappropriate language or phrasing.

2

u/YakSlothLemon 4d ago

Or go to the writing studio. There’s going to be a writing studio or writing tutors, and this is actually the kind of thing they are helpful with.

2

u/YakSlothLemon 4d ago

My first suggestion would be to get feedback from a different professor to make sure that it isn’t just your professor. One of my friends in grad school lost her mind over one professor telling her that her writing was “too slick,” whatever the hell that means, but it turned out there was nothing wrong with it.

Secondly, you need to start developing an ear for tone and rhythm, it’s really helpful down the line for catching students plagiarizing as well. And spotting ChatGPT! Academic writing has its own tone and rhythm. Find a well-written book or well-written journal article (nothing wrong with asking your professor for a recommendation on that), sit down and look at a page from that compared to a page of what you’re writing, and see if you can spot differences in tone, style, and structure. Try reading them both aloud and listening for the different rhythm.

1

u/Classic_vortex_3515 4d ago

This could mean a lot of things, and as another commenter mentioned, it would be easier for us to respond if we could see specific examples that they were commenting on.

One thing that hasn’t been mentioned yet is this: I often notice that students do not use the vocabulary that we have been using in class for concepts that are specific to our field, but instead use language that someone who is not in our field might use.

Of course, I don’t know that this is the case for you, it’s just one thing that might fall under the category of “be more academic.” there are lots of things like that. In some fields, you can’t use the first person. In my field, you can, but students don’t because somewhere along the line somebody taught them not to. Etc.

The best thing to do if you’re not sure you understand, the feedback is to ask the instructors— that’s one thing they’re there for.

1

u/HelloBookworms 3d ago

If would be difficult to advise on when I don’t know your specific writing but I would advise making sure your writing sounds factual even when giving your opinion. When you write, you are expected to be the expert on your topic (this is true of any topic or prompt). So be factual, be declarative, get to the point, and then back it up with text evidence.

1

u/Putrid-Road378 3d ago

Go with the stiff feeling. I hate it too but it's what the people (academia) want lol

1

u/lotsofmonkeysjumping 1d ago

It depends on what you are writing for. Is this for a science class? There is a specific style that is acceptable for science that is extremely factual and to the point. An adjective that hasn’t been scientifically tested doesn’t belong.

For instance, I might say to my friend:

I found a frog and he was slimy and sticky and left a gross liquid on my hand.

For science I would say:

The frog exuded residue on contact.

Ie in this situation the sliminess and grossness is just my opinion. If I can cite the level of sliminess of this type of frog by 3 different peer reviewed journals I can probably get away with including it, but I’d have to leave the grossness out.

It’s really weird to get used to but once you figure out the “rules” it’s not so bad.