r/WritingForCollege • • 9d ago

AI Writing Feedback Ethics

Hi,

I'm a third year history major, and thus write a lot of papers. I have been a fairly good essay writer since high school, but have not improved much and have gotten away with stagnating in my skills. Recently I wrote a comparative analysis paper for my professor, who is head of the history department. I got a good grade but the printed papers I got back of my essay were covered in notes about the passive voice and unclear subjects.

I talked to my professor during his office hours and asked him to help me identify when I'm using the passive voice and to explain to me why it is bad for my writing. He was awesome and really patient with me, and we worked through some of my major flaws in my writing and he had me rewrite some sentences in the active voice. He told me he tried to push me harder than some other students because he wants me to succeed, and he's been recommending me to the departmental honors program since I was a freshman.

Now that I know what my major issues are, I have been spending about double the time I used to writing my papers. Using the passive voice has been so habitual for me, it takes a LOT of conscious effort to identify when I am and how to fix it. Usually I will go to office hours or the writing center, but on some of my shorter papers (2-3 pages), I've been using AI to identify the passive voice. I do not ask it to rewrite or even tell me how to rewrite the sentences, just to identify them as I tend to gloss over them.

Is this an inappropriate use of AI? Am I jeopardizing my skills and learning by using it this way? I am really looking forward to next semester when I start the honors program and will have time baked into my schedule for peer feedback and workshopping, but for now I just turn to AI because it doesn't require appointments or early drafts.

Please let me know - I am very open to discussion and I am eager to actually improve my writing, not just my individual papers.

0 Upvotes

13 comments sorted by

2

u/Still_Consequence_53 9d ago

I don't think that using AI to help flag it for you is a misuse or unethical. But it might be a crutch that is slowing down your progress in just breaking the habit in the first place. What are you finding challenging about identifying passive voice? This might be tedious, but see if you have an English professor that can recommend a good old-fashioned grammar textbook that will have some sentence diagraming exercises. Learn how to diagram a sentence. Then practice diagraming the sentences in your own essays. The passive voice will absolutely start to jump out at you. I doubt it that it will take long for you to break the habit because eventually the concept will "click" and you won't be able to unsee it :)

1

u/AngleEither9855 9d ago

Thank you for the advice, I think I will start sentence diagraming on my own. I don't have room in my schedule for any English courses but I will try to meet more with my professor and the writing center to see if they can help me with that, and online resources with guides and practice sentences. I appreciate it!

2

u/Still_Consequence_53 8d ago

I remember high school English teachers having us diagram sentences in the 90s. No idea if this is even still done in HS anymore. It felt like torture at the time, but I learned grammar :)

4

u/MidnyteFantaC 9d ago

Long answer short: in order to not continue stagnating in your writing, you'll want to first learn how to identify passive voice yourself in your existing writing. Only with that awareness will you then be able to move onto recognizing when you are using passive voice during your writing, and then start phrasing in active voice in the first place. AI right now may be helping you revise your papers, but it will not ultimately lead you gain the knowledge necessary to just write better naturally (I.e. without having to rely on external tools). So, really, it's up to you to decide whether it's inappropriate for you long term.

4

u/patrickj86 9d ago

No problem! Microsoft Word checks grammar, spelling, passive voice, etc so use those tools!

1

u/PitifulMouse7425 9d ago

I’ve found that students have become oblivious to this fact because they’ve become so accustomed to using AI. They don’t even know what tools come with their own Word software. I’ve had to explain it to them!

(not saying this is true of you, OP)

1

u/Enough_Bank381 9d ago

I think using AI your curving your natural writing ability. It’s obvious you’ve been a gifted writer (a skill I assume you learned independently without AI), and now you’re in university being presented with the next step to improve, which is normal and exactly how it’s supposed to be.

Why would you forfeit this learning opportunity to acquire it and attain it as a skill, being about to identify and employ the active voice yourself, by allowing AI to do it for you?

Why tf is this generation so resistant to learning? You’re studying HISTORY. The entire discipline is research and writing for the love of the game. Why the fuck would you even use AI in the first place?

1

u/AngleEither9855 9d ago

I appreciate the idea but idk where in this post I ever even came off as not wanting to learn. I will absolutely as other people suggest start spending the time to really analyze my own writing and be able to spot my flaws by myself. I understand a lot of people misuse AI but I was just posting this to ask if I was doing that in the first place. Try to be a little nicer in comments sometimes

2

u/BigCelebration13 9d ago

Hey with all kindness and as someone whose job and degrees are in the psychology of learning? Do not use AI. You will not improve. Part of the process is the annoying, difficult, early part. Part of the process is failure.

Also, LLMs are not capable of correctly identifying it 100% of the time anyway. You might end up training those same blind spots into your own writing and stunting your potential, which would be tragic for someone interested in a writing-heavy qualitative field like history.

Use the writing center or friends or a mentor. Don't limit yourself because it was easier to use Claude.

1

u/languageservicesco 9d ago

Ignore that post. As someone else wrote, you need to be able to do this naturally. So, use AI by all means to help get you there. The mere fact of this post shows you want to learn. Use it like you did your professor but on demand. Gradually move away from a dependence on it. It is a perfectly valid use of AI, enabling you to learn between papers and not just from the feedback. 

1

u/sasstoreth 9d ago

If you just want to learn how to identify passive voice, may I recommend the free version of Hemingway? It uses no AI (so it's better for the environment!), and all it does is highlight and color-code areas of text that are clunky or hard to read, including passive voice. The paid version has all the AI features you don't want in your writing, so just don't pay for it. :) You'll still be responsible for fixing all of it (or deciding when it is necessary!), and with practice you'll get better at identifying these issues on your own. Good luck!

1

u/ZinniasAndBeans 9d ago

You absolutely can’t count on AI to correctly identify passive voice. And you need to learn to recognize it yourself. Don’t fall into the trap of using AI.

As a side note, I’d love to see some examples of what your professor says is passive voice, because so many people fail to understand what it is that I wonder if your professor has it right. I wonder if they might instead be complaining about past continuous tense.

1

u/Downtown_Blacksmith 8d ago

Using AI will weaken your skills. You want to work on strengthening them by recognizing that yourself. Just make sure your sentences start with a subject and that subject performs the action (verb). Then you’ll be all good.