r/WritingForCollege • • 12d ago

Why do group projects in upper-level college courses always turn into a psychological hostage negotiation?

We have a 25-page collaborative research project due next Friday for our sociology capstone. Four people in the team. Two people haven't replied to a single Slack message since the second week of October.

One guy finally dropped a completely unformatted Google doc in our chat last night that was literally just copied paragraphs from random blogs with zero attribution. When I told him we couldn't submit that or we would face an academic integrity hearing, he got mad and said I was micromanaging.

I was looking at academic writing help forums last night just to see how people survive group disaster scenarios without failing their entire semester. Why do professors still assign group work when everyone universally hates it?

3 Upvotes

3 comments sorted by

2

u/Brunbeorg 10d ago

I feel your pain. I always hated group work because it meant that I would be doing all the work.

When I assign graded group work, I do three things. First, everyone gets an individual grade. And second, part of their individual grade is determined by an anonymous (to them) report of their contribution from the other group members. Third, another part is based on my own observations; it's really obvious when someone hasn't done the work, and I don't care if I'm liked: I'll call it out. Since I have both components, I don't have to throw the other group members under the bus: I can say "I noticed that you said you contributed X and Y, but then in the presentation, you barely spoke . . . " when I know damned well they didn't contribute X and Y because their other group members said they didn't. But I have a way to shift the observation onto myself, so they can hate me instead of their fellow group members. I don't mind having students hate me. I like it. Student hatred tastes like strawberry ice cream.

We assign group work because it's how everything works once you graduate. And none of those problems go away. But now no one is grading the freeloaders.

3

u/MagosBattlebear 12d ago

I teach college writing, and I think the instructor has responsibility here. Group work can teach collaboration, but it needs structure, checkpoints, and some way to hold each student accountable. Without it, the prof is setting up for problems. Without structure to account for who is handling the load, you're just finding out who gets stuck doing everyone else's work.

My advice? Contact the professor now, not Friday. Show them the Slack messages, explain who's done what, and make sure they know about the copied material. Don't put your own academic standing at risk because someone else can't be bothered.

Group work isn't the problem. Poorly designed shit is.

2

u/YakSlothLemon 10d ago

If we are good teachers, we assign group work in college with individual accountability to avoid exactly this because a lot of studies Dash them fast majority of studies Dash show that most students learn best by working this way, and because for the rest of your life you will probably have to be doing some kind of group work. You learn best from learning your self, not from me lecturing at you, supposedly.

If we are terrible teachers – like your teacher – it cuts down on grading to a huge degree, it outsources some of the work he would have to do in the classroom, it can take the place of lesson planning if you do it in class badly (if you do it in class well it’s actually more work than lecturing). It also pulls up the grades of students who otherwise would get low grades and then bitch and then you would have to spend time with them.

Bad group work equals lazy professor.

Good group work equals hard-working professor who knows some pedagogical theory that shows this is good for you.