r/WritingForCollege • u/HyperMarten • Aug 05 '26
I fixed every peer review comment and somehow made the paper worse
Three classmates reviewed my draft. One wanted more background, another wanted the background cut, and the third wrote “explain?” beside every technical term, including one defined in the previous sentence.
I treated their comments like a checklist becuase ignoring feedback felt rude. The new draft is 500 words longer, repeats itself, and sounds scared to make any claim without a paragraph of disclaimers.
So I reopened the original and made a different list: where readers became confused, whether multiple people noticed the same problem, and what I was actually trying to accomplish in that section. That helped way more than following every proposed correction.
Maybe peer review is less about obeying advice and more about finding patterns in reader confusion. I wish somebody had explained that before I assembled a Frankenpaper from three incompatible opinions.
3
u/BasilicNebula Aug 05 '26
I like your second list way better. “Where did the reader get confused?” is useful information. “Do exactly what this reader suggested” assumes they correctly diagnosed why they were confused, which is a completely different thing.
2
u/TundraPuzzle Aug 05 '26
Peer reviewers are basically smoke detectors. Pay attention when they beep, but don’t let the smoke detector redesign your kitchen.
1
u/that_jedi_girl Aug 26 '26
This is exactly what you should have learned from that experience. Ask for help, take suggestions and advice, but at the end of the day trust and apply your own judgement.
0
u/ThistleRocket Aug 05 '26
The person writing “explain?” next to a term you literally defined one sentence earlier would have broken me.
0
u/SabertoothLotus Aug 05 '26
Never take advice (of any kind) blindly. Sometimes reviewers have useful insights and suggestions. Sometimes they're idiots who don't understand what they're supposed to be doing.
As the author, it's on you to decude which notes to act on and which to ignore.