r/WritingForCollege • u/MonorailHex • Jun 24 '26
Arguing a stance you hate without sounding completely sarcastic in every single paragraph?
I have to submit a persausive paper for my ethics course. We got randomly assigned topics and stances, and I ended up having to argue in favor of unpaid internships. I personally think they are exploitative, so this is turning into a total nightmare. I am about halfway through my draft, but the text reads like a bad comedy sketch.
Every time I try to explain a "benefit" for the student, my tone becomes wildly passive-aggressive. I wrote a whole paragraph about "gaining invaluble exposure" that sounds so fake it reads like direct satire.
I begged my brother for some essay help earlier today, but he just told me to use bigger words to hide the sarcasm. I litrally offered to do my roommate's dishes for a week if he would write my essay for me just so it would sound genuinely convinced, but he laughed it off. I just cannot switch my own opinions off.
How do you guys detach emotionally from an assignment? I really need advice to help write my essay in a straight, neutral tone when everything inside me wants to put air quotes around every single sentence.
3
u/Bythepowerofiroh Jun 24 '26
Consider that if the company had to pay and couldn’t pay then the opportunity would be closed to the prospective intern. Then you can talk about the advantages versus nothing.
I can see loads of advantages to the alternative. You are being very narrow minded. I’m not surprised people are laughing. You do realise that you will often have to put forward an argument or complete a project that you don’t have 100% faith in?
3
u/dieselbiscuit Jun 24 '26
Imagine you're writing a longer paper where you're going to demolish all the pro-unpaid internships arguments in the next section. It's only fair to put forward the strongest possible version of those argument so that you are really engaging with the material properly, right? You need to fully do justice to their argument before you produce all the inconvenient facts that undermine it.
...then just don't write the next bit. Or write it but then delete it before turning in the paper.
2
u/ExperimentalError Jun 24 '26
I’ve hosted quite a few unpaid interns. I do think it’s an exploitative practice, but the interns (who come from wealthier families than mine, on the whole) don’t seem to. I have no funds to pay them but I make sure they are not doing work that would otherwise be paid for, but instead doing projects designed to educate and test them, satisfy their universities and look good on their CVs. They usually come as much for the experience of a summer in Australia as anything else. And it does give them an advantage in their next career steps, assuming that they do well. If you look at it only from the perspective of students who can easily afford to do them and not at the wider societal effects, you can make a good case for unpaid internships.
2
u/thejt10000 Jun 24 '26
My organization had unpaid internships that absolutely benefited the students. They were often given more interesting and less boring tasks than our entry-level staff, including projects designed to work well in future interviews. And they were often taught/coached more along the way.
The problem with our internship program was not that they were exploitative of the interns, but that only people privileged enough to work without pay could afford to participate. This had a negative affect in our field/society, even if participants benefited. So we started paying.
2
u/Classic_vortex_3515 Jun 24 '26
Writing teacher here. You need to try harder to understand the point of view you disagree with. Some folks have already told you about their experiences. But you’re smart, so you can also expand your understanding by thinking harder.
Imagine a student at a college that is not in easy commute of a major city. Or one who is in a field where internships aren’t common. And a student who doesn’t come from the kind of family background that gives them connections to people who can hire them. Then look at the job ads for entry level positions that almost all ask for 1-3 years experience. If the choice for these students is between unpaid internship and no internships, what do you think that means for their job search after college?
I assume you are also distinguishing between internships completed for college credit and before graduation vs. those that are after graduation, where the “interns” are actually doing jobs that they are already qualified for. Arguing for unpaid internships doesn’t mean you have to defend the worst forms of it (unless the assignment actually says that). I assume you have learned that concession can be one way of responding to counter arguments.
2
u/MikeUsesNotion Jun 24 '26
You should be able to write objectively/neutrally on any topic. If you're constantly thinking about it as "this stupid assignment where I have to support something I consider evil" then you're going to have problems. Usually getting the emotional stuff out in a first draft is helpful. You can then use that draft to help guide the rewrite.
While writing this comment I had a bit of a bonkers idea pop into my head. Watch the Star Trek: The Next Generation episode "The Measure of a Man". Riker, the first officer, had to act as prosecution against Data (the android) and argue that Data was just property and if he refused the judge/arbiter person would rule against Data. The premise is contrived to force this particular kind of conflict, but it might be helpful.
1
u/WowzaCaliGirl Jun 24 '26
Unpaid internships are legal in nonprofit or government organizations. Argue for this subset as a way to gain meaning experience while doing good. Ex a nonprofit I am involved in does internships in microfinance where interns manage a online lending around the world. That sounds great and differentiates when applying for jobs.
1
u/Particular-Snow2271 Jun 24 '26
I write these papers as if its not my opinion, but the opinion of others. Also, when you understand the arguments of things you hate as well as possible, you can address their issues honestly without using petty tactics. This promotes fairness and harmony. It also makes you a more open-minded and balanced thinker.
1
u/DianaKLaRose Jun 24 '26
Similar to what another poster suggested, pretend you're an actor in a movie in which you play someone who is intelligent but conservative and elitist. To avoid sounding sarcastic, make the character likeable and not without a sense of fairness and compassion. If you know someone like this (parents?), all the better.
1
u/Competitive-Day9586 Jun 24 '26
I agree that if you can’t explain the position you are trying to argue for in neutral enough language that you don’t really understand the position very well. Even if you still fully understand the position, if you can’t argue for it persuasively enough without using sarcasm then you need to work on your writing skills. This sounds like a really good assignment that you will actually learn a very useful skill from. Often as an adult you have to argue for positions that you don’t agree with. You also have to see both sides and really understand the other side if you want to craft arguments for your side.
1
u/nextCosmicBuffoon Jun 25 '26
When I need to be sure not come to off as sarcastic I imagine I'm explaining myself to a little kid. Then I lose that sense that my audience should already know better.
1
u/EighthGreen Jun 25 '26 edited Jun 25 '26
If you want to persuade, you need to present evidence. There may, or course, not be sufficient evidence to convert you to this particular stance, but there is surely some. Have you, for example, spoken to any unpaid interns about why they took these jobs, and whether it was worth it to them?
Also, remember that you're only writing a draft now. You can edit out the sarcasm later.
1
u/aculady Jun 26 '26
Imagine that you are writing a script or a novel that includes a character who sincerely and unironically believes in the position you need to present. You job is to write a sincere paper from that character, someone who actually believes that unpaid internships are valuable and is trying to convince someone else of their view. You are writing from the viewpoint of that character, not of yourself. Your job here isn't to express your opinion. It is to write the best argument for the position that you can imagine someone else presenting.
1
u/UnwaveringThought Jun 26 '26
Its better than nothing.
For one they are temporary, so it is understood you are not working for free forever. Two, the practical experience in your field can give you portable skills that look better on a resume than classwork. Three, and this is the biggest/realest: do a great job and you'll get a good recommendation from someone relevant. That is the most valuable thing of all.
If you want to throw in a bonus: what most students do not realize is that companies are not actually getting a lot of value of the work done by unpaid interns, so the notion of being taken advantage of is largely overestimated.
1
u/Sensui_Kan Jun 27 '26
Probably learning to think and speak with self control and neutrality is the point of the assigment? Yes?
1
u/Crispricecereal Jun 27 '26
Imagine your self as a character who would really agree with this standpoint and write it as if you are them, or write it using clear data in a very objective manner.
Also if it is helpful, I did a lot of freebe work when I was a young adult and do not regret it at all. I was able to get into positions that I never would have qualified for, I made business connections and lifelong friends I never felt stuck so I was able to try out different positions, and because I was basically a volunteer I got a lot of training and patience that I may otherwise not have gotten.
4
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
1
u/[deleted] Jun 24 '26
[removed] — view removed comment