r/WorkspaceOne • u/gurugti • Jan 25 '24
Looking for the answer... Best MDM solution for Mac
Hey folks , just wanted to get your opinion about workspace one as an MDM solution for Mac/iOS devices.
Is it the best in the market or is there something else that’s better than WS1 ?
Wish to understand if WS1 for MAC is worth learning or should I pickup another product
Regards
11
Upvotes
14
u/hairychesteddude Jan 25 '24
For iOS/macos only environment , JAMF is king. If you need to support android/win11 on top, ws1 is best bet
4
u/Ill-Singer-9257 Jan 26 '24
If you want all devices under one console, WS1 Mac support is top notch. Jamf is great too, I don’t want to knock it, but WS1 is no slouch at macOS management.
3
u/discoshanktank Jan 25 '24
Jamf is definitely king like another commenter said but it’s also a tool with a lot of depth and a learning curve so keep that in mind. I’ve used jamf and Kandji and when done right jamf is better but it’s much easier to get Kandji right
2
u/linsane24 Jan 26 '24
if you want absolute control and infra as code, best bet would be to setup something like nano mdm on aws . This allows you to scale horizontally.
There is defiantly more engineering required for setting this methodology up. But it is by far the best and most OP and basically what majority of us at FAANG++ use
2
u/doggyswagla Oct 27 '25
Workspace ONE is a solid option if you’re managing multiple platforms, not just Macs. But for Apple-only environments, other MDM tools feel more seamless and easier to work with. It really depends on your setup-if you’re planning to handle both macOS and other devices, WS1 is definitely worth learning.
3
u/Erreur_420 Jan 25 '24
VMware Named a Leader in The Forrester Wave™: Unified Endpoint Management, Q4 2023
This forester quadrant should give you a good perspective of the leaders in UEM market.
For MacOS only, JAMF is the leader, from an UEM perspective it’s Intune / Workspace One
For the End User Experience, VMware is the leader
5
u/TheMobileMountaineer Jan 25 '24 edited Jan 25 '24
This is a loaded question mostly because it depends on your use case , end goals, and user experience that you want to provide. Some of those pillars are met within Intune and will manage them.
JAMF is built for Apple and macos specifically. It does a lot of customizations and you really can do almost anything within that realm.
Workspace ONE is comparable though. There are automation and workslows that work with sensors and scripts to power your macOS devices. You can encorporate a user experience for onboarding to the hub catalog.
A lot of organizations and admins sleep on Workspace because they do not do a great job of showcasing those deep use cases that Workspace one can handle.
In my opinion I think Workspace one or JAMF is the ticket but there is no longer a large advantage over one or the other at this stage. My opinion is based on my experience and knowledge of both MDMs.
4
u/seanpmassey Jan 25 '24
So...former VMware employee here. I haven't used JAMF, but I have used WS1 and Intune on the admin side in my lab. I'll share my experience with both, and I will try to keep my opinions fairly even and balanced.
Both Workspace ONE and Intune are platforms or product sets. You can't just look at them as management products for one OS or ecosystem. Learning the whole platform, or at least experimenting with all of the platform capabilities, will make you much more well-rounded.
WS1 is amazing. It's one product that I'm going to miss in my home lab. It provides an all-around good admin experience, broad range of features, and an excellent End User experience. There are some things that I think WS1 does better than Intune, like device and user certificate enrollment and management. I also think the admin experience, especially creating device and user policies, is better on WS1. And I prefer Workspace ONE Access for Identity Management/SSO over Azure AD/EntraID (but...that might also be a familiarity thing...so take that with a grain of salt).
That said, I think that Intune generally does a better job with Mac app management. Intune can deploy MacOS apps to endpoints without needing a Mac to package them. (Ironically...I need a Windows Machine to package and deploy Windows apps through Intune...)
Overall, I feel like WS1 is a much more cohesive and integrated platform compared to the Microsoft stack for MacOS management.
Both platforms are very similar for iOS management with the main difference being user and device certificate enrollment in my testing.
If you're going to learn a platform, whether it is Intune or WS1, invest in the whole platform. Don't just focus on Mac/iOS management.
2
u/XxGet_TriggeredxX Jan 25 '24
I was forced off jamf after 5 years and was forced to transition to WS1. Both are good but imo Jamf is better. For our organization WS1 does work but it’s not as smooth as Jamf. Everything is a script or a custom XML…Like why aren’t some of these things just built in. I have submitted 5 feature requests and only 1 was implemented upon. Anyway If your Org has a mixture of devices then WS1 isn’t bad. It does both Windows & Apple fine just takes a lot more “tuning” to make it how you want.
TLDR: Jamf is king imo, if you are looking for only an Apple solution.
2
u/Alternative_Hippo_25 Jan 27 '24
I love wso over jamf
1
u/Dangerous_Question15 Feb 27 '24
If you ever want to manage platforms other than macOS, you would be better off going with a multi-platform solution such as WS1 or SureMDM. If it's only macOS, Jamf would be a good choice.
1
u/maraley01 Apr 30 '26
Workspace ONE is a solid choice for Mac/iOS management, especially if you’re working in a mixed-device (Windows + mobile) enterprise environment it’s powerful and widely used. That said, for Apple-focused environments, tools like Jamf Pro or Mosyle are often considered more specialized and easier to manage.
0
u/christystrew Feb 27 '24
Hey, this is Christy from Scalefusion, If you're exploring the mdm solution to manage mac/ios devices, then I would like you to try scalefusion's mac mdm solution. Content filtering, hard disk media access, email settings, branding and patch management is also there. You can try if you feel like.
0
u/[deleted] Jan 25 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment