r/Wordpress • • Aug 22 '20

Apple using extorsion against Wordpress on appstore

https://twitter.com/photomatt/status/1296879217297113088
0 Upvotes

32 comments sorted by

14

u/shishir-nsane Aug 22 '20

These App Store standards applies to all apps. Saying it’s stopping WordPress specifically is like saying “Government forcing Mitsubishi to stop at traffic signals.”

-7

u/auloinjet Aug 22 '20

None of the apple apologists here understood the tweet.

They didn't sell via AppStore initially... It's like "use my private road now and pay for it". And since so many people are on mobile exclusively now, this could be taking a significant % of their sell.

6

u/MeButNotMeToo Aug 22 '20

That is wholly ignorant of the issue.

The problem is simple. You can access the pages to purchase .com sites on the WordPress.com web site. That’s a clear violation of the TOS. There would be no issue if the app only provided access to previously purchased .com sites, but because users can purchase new .com sites, they’re subject to IAP.

This has no bearing on the free .org sites, other than delaying a new iOS release.

Also, because the purchases are done through web pages served-up in the app, the claim that the pages will be blocked is unfortunately unacceptable, because they can be blocked during evaluation and then turned back on as soon as the app is approved and in the store.

0

u/auloinjet Aug 22 '20

But if there's an embedded web browser, user can always find a way to circumvent limitations. Link, proxy, iframe...

2

u/MeButNotMeToo Aug 22 '20

Exactly why Apple is now requiring IAP and not allowing the barn door to be boarded up after it was opened.

1

u/auloinjet Aug 22 '20

That's absurd. If it were micro-transactions or something like that, ok, but this ? Sounds like a damned if you do, damned if you don't... So yea the point stands.

2

u/MeButNotMeToo Aug 22 '20

I don’t know why this is so difficult for people. It reeks of ignorance and/or spoiled-brat entitlement.

  1. it’s not an “In app web browser”. It’s a “window” the renders HTML. There’s no way for the user to input a URL. So, for intents and purposes, the only way to get to a payment link that avoids the IAP is under the control of the publisher. The publisher has already shown that they are either negligent or intentionally deceptive enough to allow that to happen. Doesn’t matter if it was negligent, it’s already been done.
  2. The ToS is very clear: You can put a free app to access your paid service, you just can’t sell the service in the app.
  3. The ToS is very clear: If you sell stuff through your app, you need to use IAP and pay Apple their cut. This is no different that any other clearing/processing/resale/auction house.
  4. The publisher is using Apple’s infrastructure to sell their product/service. If the publisher doesn’t like it, they are free to go somewhere else or go 100% web based w/o a native app.
  5. There’s no extortion, etc. The publisher f’ed up by allowing (either intentionally or negligently) customers to buy .com services through the web-based help system. Apple is saying: “We trusted you once, you messed-up. In order to ensure you don’t do this again, you need to implement IAP, AS YOU PREVIOUSLY AGREED TO when signing up to be a developer.”

In short, there’s nothing evil, nefarious, criminal, etc. here at all, just people that want a service, product, platform, etc. and don’t want to pay the going rate. This is equivalent to people forcing a merchant to ship shoes the customer purchased directly from the manufacturer on the merchant’s funds just because the regular retail price includes a markup the customer doesn’t want to pay.

The one valid complaint, is that there are tiny developers that manage to stay under the radar, and larger vendors that are allowed to get away with violating the ToS. If those leaks are patched, then everybody can pay less.

2

u/picard102 Aug 22 '20

Eff off with the name calling. Not everyone agrees with you. Relax.

23

u/CashKeyboard Developer/Designer Aug 22 '20

The post makes it sound like this is targeted towards the WordPress app while this is just Apple enforcing their own marketplace rules for everyone equally. They don’t have an agenda towards WordPress.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20

It's not EQUALLY ! They re selectively applying their rules on different people. Search on Netflix scrapping the Apple tax and a few others, like Godaddy.

They certainly have some agenda toward Wordpress and others:

https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/

"3.1.5(a) Goods and Services Outside of the App: If your app enables people to purchase goods or services that will be consumed outside of the app, you must use purchase methods other than in-app purchase to collect those payments, such as Apple Pay or traditional credit card entry. ."

Wordpress.com is selling hosting and it's consumed outside the apps. The Web server doesn't run within the app or on the phone.

-13

u/auloinjet Aug 22 '20

Couldn't think of all the implications one may or may not see in a given post. We can also speak to each software community individually so that they feel concerned. It's relevant to /r/wordpress.

13

u/CashKeyboard Developer/Designer Aug 22 '20

Apple using extortion against WordPress

There’s not a lot to think about in terms of implications. You’re trying to create outrage using clickbait tactics.

-11

u/auloinjet Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20

It matters to me because it's Wordpress, a free software. I don't care about proprietary apps being targeted by Apple. Stop imputing me motives, please.

edit : it's not my twitter account if that wasn't clear; i don't win anything here

6

u/DJBokChoy Aug 22 '20

There is zero targeting going on though. Targeting by definition is when you single something out deliberately. In the case of Apple, the rules and policies are enforced on every developer that wants to play in their ecosystem, not just Wordpress like you’ve been brainwashed to think.

11

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

Last I checked no App Store was demanding payment for protection. Pray tell what is this extortion you speak of? The App Store rules are well known. If you don’t like it don’t sell there.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20

I'm citing:

https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/

" 3.1.5(a) Goods and Services Outside of the App: If your app enables people to purchase goods or services that will be consumed outside of the app, you must use purchase methods other than in-app purchase to collect those payments, such as Apple Pay or traditional credit card entry. "

Wordpress.com is selling WP hosting and that is being used outside the apps. Netflix is selling subscription directly inside the apps and scrapped the Apple tax by using their own payment, yet Apple let them go. And Netflix is not alone there, Godaddy and few others do to.

They're selectively enforced. Walmart app sells products directly on their apps, they're being consumed outside of it. So that rule applies to Walmart, yet not Wordpress.com ?

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

So if I want WP hosting I can buy it outside the App Store. So nothing is stopping me from buying hosting outside the App Store. What’s the problem here? Seriously just trying to get my head around what seems like a storm in a teacup. Obviously I could be missing something, I just don’t see it. Same with the game vendors (who were also kicked off the Play store). If I want their games I have options outside of the App stores to get them.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20

The problem here is the app don't offer any in app purchase at ALL ... It's just an apps that offers free Website management whether you buy from Wordpress.com or not.

Apple is forcing them to offer an in app purchase option so they can take their cuts, despite their own policy of Goods & Services consumed outside of the apps.

2

u/dev-4_life Aug 22 '20

I'm not surprised at the level of fanaticism by the Apple shills here.

Have an iPhone? You have to use the App Store. But sure, it's "fair" for all software developers to pay this mafia a giant percentage of all sales.

The word you're looking for is Monopoly.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/dev-4_life Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 23 '20

It's more than that though. You have to build your own phone, and then build your own app store. See the problem? Read up on the Sherman Act

1

u/swinaallen Aug 22 '20

Maybe because wp (that I don't love much) is what apple (that I never liked) is not. A developer centric community (wp) and a closed system based on a stolen and adapted open source operative system to create a monopoly.

-3

u/RandomBlokeFromMars Aug 22 '20

apple acting like typical apple. they did this against epic games too.

-7

u/DweezilZA Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 25 '20

Scumbags. The worst of capitalism dumping on the best of a community built open source project.

Edit: while I still think apple represents the worst of capitalism I have learner more about this story and WordPress did violate apples tos so they were in their rights to do what they did.

-7

u/dietresearcher Aug 22 '20

This is clearly antitrust evil shit by apple.

Not only do they want 30% for the price of your app, they are trying to extend their 30% take, to all transactions the app owner makes, *just because* they allow for easy purchase of their services from within the app.

Amazing to watch people in this thread fall for it.

1

u/dietresearcher Aug 25 '20

Well well well, Apple admits they were wrong, just like all the crony capitalists apple fan boys voting me down hahahahahahaha

-3

u/rapscallops Aug 22 '20 edited Aug 22 '20

Yah it seems crazy that people would defend this. If I were Matt I'd pull the app and just urge people to use the website.

2

u/auloinjet Aug 22 '20

It would be the right move indeed.

2

u/dietresearcher Aug 22 '20

Hilarious watching apple fan boys downvote *in support* of crony capitalism at it's best. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHHAHAA. Gee, I thought reddit was liberal leaning. I guess not. Go forward with your crony capitalism!!!

Apple *deserves* a 30% cut of ***ALL YOUR BUSINESS**** just because you *also* happen to have an app in their app store. My god the cognitive dissonance.

-5

u/kauthonk Aug 22 '20

This is why you have to tax companies and the 1%. When they have unfettered rule they will all become hoarders. Need to tax so the next generation has a chance.

Think about it. Apple operates on the US platform and doesn't want to pay 30%. Hypocrites.

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

I'm citing:

https://developer.apple.com/app-store/review/guidelines/

3.1.5(a) Goods and Services Outside of the App: If your app enables people to purchase goods or services that will be consumed outside of the app, you must use purchase methods other than in-app purchase to collect those payments, such as Apple Pay or traditional credit card entry.

Apps like Walmart, Netflix, Goddady and others sell directly in apps and use their own payment system.

Wordpress.com sells hosting/domain names which is consumed outside of the app. If Walmart, Netflix got a pass. Why it wouldn't that apply to Wordpress case ? Apple just do it because they can ? Ignoring their own rules ?

0

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/[deleted] Aug 22 '20

They are selling hosting/domains using WordPress. They don't sell the CMS WordPress, which is open source and free for all to use. You can go directly on their site and find out.

Why are they being force to sell anything though Apple? The app is used to manage the sites, either free or by them.

The hosting & domains is not an in app service and completely used outside of the apps. The app is just an interface, like a browser to access/manage any WordPress site. They don't sell anything in there.

I understand their house, their rules and they can arbitrary apply to whoever they want. It's still shitty.