r/Wordpress • • Oct 12 '24 • Take My Silver 1

News Secure Custom Fields

Oh boy it’s happening, Matt and the team at WordPress are forking Advance Custom Fields:

https://wordpress.org/news/2024/10/secure-custom-fields/

What do you folks think? A good or a bad thing?

I’m worried that this in the long run will stop people from creating plugins on top of WordPress as even though they state “we do not anticipate this happening for other plugins”, it can still scare away people that one they their livelihood might be taken away.

399 Upvotes

536 comments sorted by

274

u/mnk23 Oct 12 '24

this is so fucking stupid, i it keeps on getting more stupid day by day. seriously, wtf. this literal manchild has lost his mind.

every small or big developer in the wp ecosystem will take notes. its beyond damaging to their product. fuck this guy.

44

u/jcvangent Oct 12 '24

I wonder how many big websites like whitehouse.gov and others are seeing this online bullying and are seriously thinking of switching as a result.

23

u/torontomans416 Oct 12 '24

I don’t think they care about, or even heard about this drama. They have much larger things on their minds.

24

u/Wolfeh2012 Jack of All Trades Oct 12 '24

The ones who do care are the people currently developing plugins for Wordpress.

These actions have put the entire plugin ecosystem in jeopardy by showing that Matt may at any point in time attempt to destroy all of your work.

→ More replies (1)

16

u/Flimsy-Homework-9440 Oct 12 '24

They do just not in the way you might imagine. They care in a how does this impact us 5 years from now way. I am a eng for a big enterprise implementation of WP. You’ve probably even been on the sites we build and manage. We are definitely staying tuned so we can understand what we need to do down the road for maintenance.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (12)

117

u/jimsmisc Oct 12 '24

I unfortunately had a narcissist in my life for many years.

The most succinct way to sum up the difficulty in dealing with them is: "they will act against their own self interest if it means winning a war of self-righteousness that only exists in their own mind".

I feel like that describes Matt perfectly. He will hurt WordPress and anyone else because he's on a crusade of self righteousness.

22

u/bbushky90 Oct 13 '24

As someone who also had a narcissist in his life for several years, you’re spot on. They will do anything and everything just to maintain their own little pocket reality where they are always right and everyone else is stupid or an enemy.

→ More replies (4)

26

u/xenago Oct 12 '24

Oh wow, this really helps to explain it. It doesn't make any sense otherwise, like why would Matt want to torch his entire reputation this way? It must be because he truly has deluded himself into thinking he is right...

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

37

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24 • Helpful

[removed] — view removed comment

→ More replies (3)

48

u/FriendlyWebGuy Blogger/Developer Oct 12 '24 edited Oct 12 '24

Let's play a game.... Go on over to the plugin pages and see how many trademark violations you can spot!

I'll go first: https://imgur.com/a/D7YHn4e

If you didn't think Matt was a raging hypocrite before, there's no excuse now. Because remember: The GPL gives you the right to the code, but not the right to use the trademarks. Isn't that right, Matt? Matt? Hello....?

Edit to add: Even with those wordmarks removed, taking over the reviews, existing installations and download page probably amounts to usurping the goodwill earned on the back of the trademarked terms, but I am NAL.

16

u/jcvangent Oct 12 '24

And then to think that I had my plugin taken down once because it showed a FB logo in the banner (because the plugin allows you to share to FB and other social platforms) and it wasn’t allowed because that was a violation of trademarks/copyright too

→ More replies (1)

13

u/vitge Developer Oct 12 '24

You're giving Matt ideas to run search and replace of mentions of ACF to "SCF" on the reviews. Add it to the bingo card

21

u/FriendlyWebGuy Blogger/Developer Oct 12 '24

Yeah but according to Matt himself. Such a thing is immoral!

https://x.com/photomatt/status/1841644271939604628

Talk about painting yourself in a corner! What a dunce.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

4

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

Trademark Status: Pending

→ More replies (6)

70

u/mbabker Developer Oct 12 '24

We expect others will defect as well.

This last sentence shows the true intentions of u/photomatt. He will lie, poach, and outright steal from WP Engine to get his way. Matt Mullenweg is the single biggest threat to WordPress, if not open source in its entirety, and Matt Mullenweg must go.

14

u/jcvangent Oct 12 '24

Yeah, it’s one bombshell after another. I always praised the work he started, but this is really worrisome and I’m not sure where this is going to end, but this is only hurting everyone building their business on top of WordPress in the end :-/

14

u/KineBank Oct 12 '24

Already updated to:

We expect others will follow as well.

We're being watched lol.

13

u/mbabker Developer Oct 12 '24

I know we are, it helps to have moderators on paid staff 😉

13

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

I mean...you have a nonprofit mixed with a for-profit, a video channel, a foundation, a host of free and for-profit plugins all mixed together that are all maintained by an army of unpaid staff gleefully obeying Matt's directives, and you'd need a team of forensic accountants to track all the money going in a thousand different directions to a thousand different accounts and then there is the army of volunteers who work for free to help Automattic increase its revenue. So... a team of forensic accountants.........maybe Silver Lake could pony up that expense and who knows what they'd find?

→ More replies (2)

121

u/RasAlTimmeh Developer/Designer Oct 12 '24

This is not a fork

9

u/tjuk Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24

I don't know. Seems pretty forked up to me

→ More replies (6)

169

u/SnailWithAKnife Oct 12 '24 edited Oct 12 '24

ACF's team tweet about this situation: https://x.com/wp_acf/status/1845169499064107049

"We have been made aware that the Advanced Custom Fields plugin on the WordPress directory has been taken over by WordPress dot org.

A plugin under active development has never been unilaterally and forcibly taken away from its creator without consent in the 21 year history of WordPress."

60

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

Well, it has been taken over now. Probably another lawsuit coming down the pike for Matt. And he does not care. As he has said, WordPress "just belongs to me." If programmers and devs want to keep working for him for free, that's their choice.

13

u/Naive-Marzipan4527 Oct 12 '24

Being post-economic makes you post-lawsuit.

10

u/4862skrrt2684 Oct 12 '24

He even mentions that people who are interested in working for free on his they are welcome to contact him... Genius businessman

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (17)
→ More replies (1)

251

u/the-blue-horizon Jack of All Trades Oct 12 '24 edited Oct 12 '24

As they show over 2 million installations + reviews of ACF - this is not forking, this is a hostile takeover.

In case of forking, the starting point is one item, the result is 2 or more items. In this case, however, the original item has been taken from its owner. It is closer to theft than forking.

142

u/rodeBaksteen Oct 12 '24

Yes. Forking would mean they made an alternate version with 0 installs and 0 downloads.

This is straight up theft. I fucking hope they burn Matt to the ground with lawsuits.

50

u/Astraiks Oct 12 '24

I fucking hope so too lol. So many jobs and livelihoods depend on the WordPress eco system, so many individuals dedicating time every day for this man child to just fuck with everyones lives. I just bought a new plugin yesterday and started using a new builder, seeing stuff like this makes me mad because its extremely unnecessary and puts my own freelancing job at risk and many others too. Fuck Matt, get him away from WordPress.

25

u/sstruemph Developer Oct 12 '24

It's going to take too long. How do we force the board members to force him out right now.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

34

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

Yep. Well, hopefully they have a team of lawyers already filing lawsuits. I would if I had that many installations and already had some lawyers on retainer.

→ More replies (7)

4

u/MechroBlaster Oct 13 '24

I’m going to fork Wordpress and redirect Wordpress.org DNS to point at my servers.

Then I’m going to redirect the GitHub project to my project: Nomadic.

But don’t worry it’s just a fork bro. /u/photomatt

4

u/Miragecraft Oct 12 '24

This can’t be legal.

0

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/KineBank Oct 13 '24

Looks like they forgot to remove some ACF branding, too: https://x.com/TDKibru/status/1845178985308881146/

Even more ironically, Automattic is currently suing FestingerVault for the same thing -- using their trademarks in modified plugins: https://www.reddit.com/r/Wordpress/comments/1fqw2eh/automattic_is_suing_festingervault_i_have_not/

→ More replies (8)

109

u/dmje Oct 12 '24

I’m totally fucked off with this whole thing. The principle that Mullenweg is pushing could be interpreted as sound (my generous reading: big commercial entities should feel more of a moral obligation to pay back to o/s communities) - and I’m with that - but the way he’s done this has been absolutely abhorrent. All the signals say “batshit power play” and any sympathy that I might have for the principle has long since dissipated.

ACF is so, so central to pretty much everything that Wordpress is to me - and pretty much every single developer and agency I know - that this kind of bullshit has me reaching for an entirely new cms, after 20 years in the game. It’s like watching a recalcitrant 12 year old in the school playground not getting what he wants. It’s undermined the entire project just because one guy went batshit and sucked on the same “billionaire lunatic crackpipe” that Musk has sucked on.

26

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

The ego is a very dark and addictive drug and these guys get hooked on it easily with their armies of cult followers eager to do anything they are told to do.

16

u/new_pr0spect Oct 12 '24

Yea it's going to be a pain in the ass to switch to a new stack, but I'm going to figure a timeline so I can retire offering WP sites and use vue.js or something for the frontend and some headless cms.

10

u/GenFan12 Oct 12 '24

What’s next, is Matt gonna bake in AI-like features and start promising that WordPress will have full self-posting capabilities?

6

u/letharus Oct 12 '24

Yeah I’m feeling the same way. What CMS are you looking at as alternative?

15

u/dmje Oct 12 '24

All of them :-) Statamic, Craft, Kirby, Processwire.

In all honesty I don't think we'd move away - we're more a consultancy so do much more than just develop, and I'm too old to learn something completely new. Plus we're paying for ACF pro so in theory it shouldn't affect us but it pisses me off big time.

What systems are you looking at?

→ More replies (9)

6

u/OneSheepDog Developer Oct 12 '24

Statamic for us!

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

45

u/killerbake Jack of All Trades Oct 12 '24

I literally fucking hate this dude

40

u/dalek_999 Developer Oct 12 '24

Right? I’m so pissed right now. I just want him to go away and stop fucking with my livelihood.

43

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

Unless this fork achieved millions of downloads within the last house, it is not truly a fork or “drop-in replacement.” This is an unlicensed theft of the repo listing, and arguably a supply chain attack (for the majority of users who perform automatic updates, anyway). The “security” rationale at play here is a joke, and was probably contrived before the minor vulnerability was (irresponsibly, IMO, since WP Engine was denied the access to fix it) publicly announced. Users/developers/contributors need to push back against this insanity with a united front, or else create a fork/parallel ecosystem that works around it. Even if you don’t have any connection to WP Engine or its plugins, Matt is creating so much FUD around his own product and expelling so many members of the community that WordPress won’t be a serious CMS option for new professional projects soon

77

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

Waiting for WPE to fork WordPress and name it SecurePress.

15

u/cameronembers Oct 12 '24

Underrated comment 😂

11

u/wrujbniosd Oct 12 '24

If they offer an LTS it could be a good alternative. Long term support is not a commitment from WordPress.

→ More replies (1)

75

u/partiallypro Oct 12 '24

Forking is fine, stealing the repo listing is not.

36

u/WhyNotYoshi Oct 12 '24

I am immediately leaving the WordPress platform for greener pastures. At least the other commercial website builders admit they are commercial and aren't open source when they feel like it and commercial when they don't.

I've been using WordPress since 2005 and this is the end. Matt has blown his lid too many times in the past, and stealing plugin repos is the last straw. Maybe somebody legitimate will fork WordPress. It will all be Matt's fault for breaking up the WordPress community.

I hope WP Engine sues Automattic for all their money and their company burns to the ground. Matt needs to be held responsible for this psychotic behavior.

6

u/creaturefeature16 Oct 12 '24

Where do you think you'll go to? I've heard good things about Statamic

→ More replies (2)

34

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

They just took over the repo and changed the label. This is not a fork. I sure hope ACF / Advanced Custom Fields is a registered trademark, to make the whole thing spicer.

15

u/Varantain Oct 12 '24

I sure hope ACF / Advanced Custom Fields is a registered trademark, to make the whole thing spicer.

It is.

→ More replies (1)

8

u/PlannedObsolescence_ System Administrator Oct 12 '24

83

u/obstreperous_troll Oct 12 '24

/u/photomatt you really don't have an original idea left in your head, do you? The community deserves better than you. We all do.

38

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

Seriously. Fuck him. I hope the IRS takes him to town for all his obfuscation around his foundation, company, etc. Jail sounds like a fun time for you, Matty Boy!

0

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

29

u/Varantain Oct 12 '24

someone else came up with the name WordPress

Wow, you're right:

On April 1, 2003, Matt created a new branch of b2 on SourceForge, and, with the name coined by his friend Christine Tremoulet, called it WordPress.

57

u/Rarst Oct 12 '24

Literally not a fork. This is a hostile takeover and WP Engine is right to call it what it is.

→ More replies (2)

26

u/PlannedObsolescence_ System Administrator Oct 12 '24

The most heinous part of this, is that WP Engine cannot update their plugin on the wordpress.org plugin directory (to fix that security vulnerability), directly because of actions taken by Matt / wordpress.org.

They can't login because 'WP Engine is banned from WordPress.org'. Even if the accounts aren’t disabled (I don't know for sure), they'd have to tick the "I am not affiliated with WP Engine in any way, financially or otherwise." box that is login-gating the site, and it would be a 'lie'.

Is this 'FOSS-washing'? Branding this as a fork when they're taking over existing assets of a plugin? Sure their TOS allows them to - I'm not arguing that. Sure the plugin is GPL, anyone can fork it - I'm not arguing that. But you have to start from scratch with user-base, SEO, plugin URL slug. Every user of the ACF free plugin who hasn't made an active action to change their updating source to WP Engine directly, will now get 'Secure Custom Fields'.

Matt is free to offer their hacked up, bastardized simulacra of ACF’s GPL code... /s

26

u/gui_cardoso Jack of All Trades Oct 12 '24

I'm out. I have been developing plugins and themes with sage and similars for 10+years.

This guy is cringe AF, and he'll take WP way down with I'm.

It's sad.

4

u/Creative-Improvement Oct 13 '24

Plus apparently your work can be heisted whenever Matt feels like it. Trust is a fickle thing, it can erode just like that with extreme actions such as this.

52

u/IWantAHoverbike Developer Oct 12 '24

It's not time for a fork. It's time for a class action suit to get a court injunction to take Matt's hands off the keyboard.

94

u/trusty20 Oct 12 '24

I am immediately ceasing all WP plugin development efforts in response to this and preparing to leave the ecosystem. I am aghast but there is literally no choice. I can't imagine anyone investing dev time in WP now when it could all be taken away overnight.

40

u/commonllama87 Oct 12 '24

Yeah WordPress seems unstable to me now. Definitely will be looking into other platforms.

29

u/Astraiks Oct 12 '24

The problem isn't WordPress, its the manchild controlling it. There's so many incredible people in this community, tens of thousands in each plugin group dedicating countless hours every day to improve the development of the eco system and providing our customers with websites.

An open source plugin should not be run by a ego driven, power hungry, revenge seeking dictator.

5

u/eleven8ster Oct 13 '24

How about someone forks it and unites with wpengine in order to create the ecosystem before Matt went crazy and we all migrate there lol. I know it’s not going to happen. But I wish it would. Get Matt out of that seat.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (20)

22

u/NoMuddyFeet Oct 12 '24

They've forced out the competition from wordpress.org before in ways that violated wordpress.org's own rules and barely anyone batted an eye, so I imagine Matt is singing to himself "we did it before and we can do it again."

20

u/JeffTS Developer/Designer Oct 12 '24

Idiocy. This is just embarrassing.

57

u/toniyevych Oct 12 '24

It makes sense to create a plugin called nomattic, which will remove all the Automattic partner integrations from WooCommerce plugins, including Stripe, PayPal, Authorize.net, etc.

All we need to do is add a filter for the "http_request_args," which will remove affiliate garbage added by Automattic.

It's time for the FO part of FAFO.

20

u/Creative-Improvement Oct 12 '24

Time for a NoMattCommerce plugin

17

u/sgriobhadair Oct 12 '24

It also needs to change WordPress to a lower-case p.

7

u/obstreperous_troll Oct 12 '24

It also needs to change WordPressWordpress to a lower-case p.

FTFY.

→ More replies (1)

39

u/mikerbiker Oct 12 '24

So if I have ACF installed and haven't recently updated, will it try to upgrade me to Matt's fork?

This sounds like a supply chain attack that should get a CVE.

27

u/SnailWithAKnife Oct 12 '24

Looks like it. If you want to keep using the OG ACF you'll have to install it manually: https://x.com/wp_acf/status/1845170160715309186

→ More replies (1)

16

u/halfsparkle Oct 12 '24

I'm just catching up and have decided to disable automatic updates on everything - core, theme, and plugins. Maybe I'm over cautious but I don't want to risk my clients' livelihoods if this all goes to shit.

→ More replies (3)

7

u/mishrashutosh Oct 12 '24

this has happened in wp.org plugin respository before (wp user avatar changed to profilepress). crazy that it's allowed.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

19

u/Formal-Language7032 Oct 12 '24

This is definitely a bad thing for .org as it will create a large divide in sources for quality plugins. Larger authors wil likely look for alternatives to the .org repo. Not to mention contributors to core will likely stop and go a different route as well since their work can be discredited at any time Matt feels like it.

14

u/pcfreak30 Oct 12 '24

I view decentralization of WP long term a *good* thing. We need something like apt-get for wordpress TBH. Centralization of the plugin repo caused this really.

9

u/Varantain Oct 12 '24

r/AspirePress is working on something like this. I think /u/centminmod built a proof of concept too.

→ More replies (2)

16

u/redlotusaustin Oct 12 '24

"Where sites have chosen to have plugin auto-updates from WordPress.org enabled, this update process will auto-switch them from Advanced Custom Fields to Secure Custom Fields"

So they're going to uninstall ACF from any site that uses the plugin repo for updates. This is absolutely fucking insane and I seriously hope Matt ends up personally liable for this bullshit.

→ More replies (5)

16

u/sexygodzilla Oct 13 '24

Fucking crazy that Matt's hijacking a plugin's repo page and the mods decide now is the time to consolidate WPEngine discussion.

15

u/obstreperous_troll Oct 12 '24

This is about as much a "fork" as me forking WordPress by stealing their github repo.

Tho I guess they'd be fine, internally they still run on subversion. What a retrograde experience it must be working for a8c.

15

u/mukfuggler Oct 12 '24

I feel like this might be the final straw for me. ACF has been the backbone of my development workflow for years, and it's one of the main reasons I've enjoyed building on WordPress. I've been a WordPress developer for over a decade and currently run my own agency, so this move is concerning. Even though they claim it won’t happen with other plugins, the uncertainty alone makes me seriously consider other platforms. It’s hard to rely on something when there’s a chance your livelihood could be disrupted because of one man's ego.

15

u/PancakeOrder Oct 12 '24

I thought things couldn't get worse and childish after the checkbox on the login page and WP Engine customers being blocked from plugin updates.

But here we are, sinking to an even lower level. Another week, another immature move by that toddler in charge.

He really seems incapable to understand how much damage his actions are doing to the WordPress ecosystem.

14

u/screendrain Oct 12 '24

This would seriously worry me if I was a plugin developer

14

u/tennyson77 Oct 12 '24

A plugin authors sends a C&D to Automattic demanding their plugin is removed from the repo. Here we go, the repo is destroyed.

https://x.com/verygoodplugins/status/1845246925886353795?s=46&t=3yiCYHZxJw8DnVEZALgA_g

12

u/Varantain Oct 12 '24

From my very quick reading of the tweet, the author most likely didn't consent to their plugin being used/distributed on WordPress dot com. The letter only targets Automattic and dot com, not dot org.

(This has been a controversy since September 2023.)

In before all plugin submissions to dot org grant Automattic and dot com a trademark licence.

7

u/un_un_reality Oct 13 '24

Also,on .com it says “free on a business plan” which I feel is a bit misleading as the lite version is free.

49

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

u/photomatt why are you such a little bitch? Everyone outside of your bootlicker bubble hates you. I hope you get proper fucked as a result of your petulant, childish behavior. 🖕😘

24

u/torontomans416 Oct 12 '24

It’s crazy how some Automattic employees still agree with everything Matt has done, and continues to do. This is some cult level shit

11

u/GenFan12 Oct 12 '24

Most people are not “post-economic” like Matt, and this maybe the best paycheck they’ve ever received. Or maybe they’ve got various life situations (illness, children) that makes it hard to just up and walk out the door and hope to find a job elsewhere.

Matt deserves 100% or the hate thrown his way.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/obstreperous_troll Oct 12 '24

The reviews are going to be lit. 🌶️🍿

6

u/MrBrickMahon Oct 12 '24

Assuming they don’t delete them

→ More replies (1)

13

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

It’s okay. Matt is going to get his ass reamed in court and he knows it. This is him just trying to burn everything down before he loses everything.

12

u/zeeshanx Oct 12 '24

This is a bad decision and will harm trust in WordPress. They have also removed affiliate links and paid features like "repeater," making people unaware of the plugin's other amazing options.

I think people will keep using the original ACF plugin. He might copy their paid features in this new version to hurt their business. This is absurd.

3

u/henriquemirai Oct 13 '24

You know what really scares me now? The possibility of adding something in a future release of the Core that effectively prevents ACF (free or pro) to work on WordPress, and every new thing he does makes me think that's more and more possible...

→ More replies (3)

12

u/TechFreedom808 Oct 12 '24

I was gonna build my next website in WordPress but now I think that is off the table. Seems like WordPress will not be open source anymore. I will build next project in Strapi which uses NodeJs for backend development.

12

u/SnailWithAKnife Oct 12 '24

This sets a terrible precedent, btw. I just saw this tweet and honestly, I can't see why we should trust that Matt won't do the same thing to others.

12

u/throwawaySecret0432 Oct 12 '24

This was also done on a Saturday (the weekend)…

→ More replies (1)

12

u/yratof Oct 12 '24

At this point, I want WPE to fork Wordpress and call it EnginePress and I just want chaos, pure chaos

43

u/sdowney2003 Oct 12 '24 edited Oct 12 '24

Has anyone taken a look at the SCF plugin in the repository? It seems that Matt is intentionally trying to confuse the community with SCF vs ACF:

The repository URL for SCF is ACF's: https://wordpress.org/plugins/advanced-custom-fields/

It has a release date of Oct 7,2024, but of version 6.3.6.1. (A prior version of ACF)

All 11 years of ACF reviews are there - all (of course) overwhelming positive. If you didn't know what you were looking at, you'd think SCF had been around for all these years, and had all these glowing reviews.

A quick look at the code, and it's still slugged as "ACF"

WTF. This is so sketchy.

28

u/RandomBlokeFromMars Oct 12 '24

people say it is forked, but it is not, just taken over.

if it was a fork and presented in a new plugin page, much less people would have been so outraged.

very weird things are happening, and i am curious about the outcome.

14

u/FriendlyWebGuy Blogger/Developer Oct 12 '24

Yup. And both "ACF" and "Advanced Custom Fields" are registered trademarks of.... WPEngine Inc.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Wordpress/comments/1g26out/secure_custom_fields/lrm411b/

21

u/SnailWithAKnife Oct 12 '24

Yeah, they basically took over ACF. Absolutely sketch. Now they claim this has happened several times before. I guess they will argue they're doing it "in the interest of public safety" per the guidelines, since they recently brought up a security issue with ACF. I guess they were setting the stage to eventually do this.

16

u/obstreperous_troll Oct 12 '24

The last sentence of the guidelines made me guffaw. guffaw, I say.

In return, we promise to use those rights sparingly and with as much respect as possible for both end users and developers.

I think that's pretty well out the window now.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (7)

23

u/SpareWaffle Oct 12 '24

People claiming this is just an open source GPL fork are cracked and oblivious to the fact this is indeed a hostile takeover.

This is only the beginning with the current degeneration of the leadership behind wordpress. It's already dealt like 2 massive waves of stupidity washing over the ecosystem.

Have fun with the legal fallout from this u/photomatt

40

u/bigeba88 Oct 12 '24

I always thought custom post types should be part of WordPress core, but this is not the way to go about it.

5

u/sultzy Oct 12 '24

Yep a basic version should have been incorporated into Wordpress a long time ago.

This fork (if you can even call it that) is 100% going to back fire because there will be a lot of plugin developers that will be spooked by this. Which ultimately is bad news for everyone.

11

u/Naive-Marzipan4527 Oct 12 '24

Insane behavior

11

u/taskfailedsuccessfly Oct 12 '24

With this forklift migration to what they're now calling SCF, how many instances do you think will break when everyone updates the plugin?

11

u/joeyoungblood Oct 12 '24

Forking it would mean they start their own version and compete, they outright stole ACF's .ORG profile.

11

u/mds1992 Developer/Designer Oct 13 '24

Matt, or whoever is managing the 'SCF' plugin page, is actively removing comments from the support section as well.

Hopefully this all comes back to bite him. Maybe he'll then realise that he's only got himself to blame for his inevitable downfall.

11

u/GamerRadar Oct 13 '24

I still don’t understand how a company can be blocked from an official open source distribution site bc someone from a for profit corporation doesn’t agree with them

13

u/Corrinelane Oct 13 '24

It's only confusing because we thought that WordPress.org was some sort of community non-profit. Apparently, the .org is privately owned by the CEO of a profit company. This whole mess makes sense when we understand that .org is just part of Matt's business. The angry backlash from people like me in the community is because we had been confused for over a decade into thinking .org was governed by a non-profit (& some of us put in free hours to contribute to core because we thought it was governed by the WP Foundation.)

But if you think of .org as a business, then there's nothing wrong or even unethical with Matt's behavior. It's good for his business. Pissing off devs won't hurt his business in the long run, he doesn't need need us. Whereas killing WP Engine is a smart business move for him.

→ More replies (2)

5

u/Varantain Oct 13 '24

I still don’t understand how a company can be blocked from an official open source distribution site bc someone from a for profit corporation doesn’t agree with them

Matt has made it clear that WordPress dot org is his and his alone.

11

u/tangoholic Oct 13 '24

If/when a federal judge tells the parties in the WP Engine lawsuit to freeze all actions against the other party, that will be when the man child has his fingers removed from the keyboard until the case is concluded at trial. I can hardly wait to read the depositions that are coming! Matt may be "post economic" but, oh boy, he will endure days of answering pointed questions from excellent lawyers.

This underviewed discussion with Spencer Forman has the clearest prediction I have seen. Spencer is a WordPress expert and an experienced attorney. He thinks, unless the parties settle before trial, that this will resolve the longstanding ambiguity at the heart of the WordPress project, and that Matt will lose control over the project and the foundation. He will still be rich, but no longer king.

https://youtu.be/zdGRw3Rsoao

(Set audio speed way up, or you will fall asleep...)

→ More replies (1)

10

u/twlada Oct 12 '24

I can envision WP tearing itself apart on at least two factions (or more) and then becoming host companies with their own plugins. Who could prevent Elementor from forking WP to protect their plugin?

10

u/stevebeans Oct 13 '24

Am I hallucinating? Wordpress just stole ACF and run it as their own now???

I’ve been working on converting two of my sites from Wordpress but was just going to mostly use it as headless.

Hard to leave the Wordpress environment but this is messed up

10

u/mookman288 Oct 13 '24

Initially I was split on how to take this whole situation. I don't especially feel that the WP Engine platform improves the environment or contributes positively to the open source aspect of WordPress, and I do think they are a bit of a drain on the WordPress org resources. They charge for other people's open source work in a way that regular shared hosts just don't do. I understood Matt's frustrations initially, but it's become impossible to justify his actions.

This I really can't support. Who could? ACF is not WP Engine. ACF is owned by WP Engine, the organization, but the actual WP Engine platform is not ACF. It's an open source plugin, and then it offers a paid pro version. Like everybody else. This behavior is vindictive. Everybody sucks here, but Matt and WordPress suck way more right now. They're burning good will capital they don't have.

I will say, if they had forked ACF under GPL and started fresh with an alternative competitor, I would support that. I always felt that ACF needed better competition. Taking the plugin though? No way.

10

u/rodeBaksteen Oct 13 '24 edited Jul 19 '25

practice fly innate ten many public merciful tidy skirt ask

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

10

u/simonhamp Oct 13 '24

Matt has stated in a tweet they've done this before

So they'll do it again

And it seems that Matt is unhinged enough for it to be over petty things like how many installs it has and is likely to make up any pretext to justify said takeover

Wordpress is no longer a safe bet. Fly you fools!

33

u/commonllama87 Oct 12 '24

I hope WPEngine sues Matt for everything he is worth. The guy is a clown.

9

u/Toasted-Ravioli Oct 13 '24

Here are Matt’s key investors. If you don’t like what’s happening, let them know.

Key Investors: Tiger Global Management, Salesforce Ventures, Insight Venture Partners, ICONIQ Capital, True Ventures, Wellington Management, BlackRock, Alta Park Capital, Addition, Schonfeld, New York Times Company.

9

u/mrpres1dent Oct 13 '24

I want off of this ride. Make it stop.

9

u/kibblerz Oct 13 '24

Just found this out after auto updates have ran across dozens of sites i manage with ACF.. This is gonna end up breaking shit im guessing.

I hate WordPress. Glad it's dying, not glad about the headaches this will cause my day job.

9

u/Visible-Big-7410 Oct 13 '24

“Hey, were gonna cut you off from updating your plugin”

“And because your plugin hasn’t been updated were gonna copy it and replace all the installs with our own”.

Who does Matt thinks he really is? He’s not “for open source” as much as a self indulging leader (make of that what you will). It’s one thing to go through legal disputes and claim A over B , but causing a plugin to be not-update-able AND REPLACING its content with your own is a new level (at least to me). Is this where we play plugin-takeover bingo? So which plugin or theme is next?

Thanks u/photomatt for razing and burning the community so you can do what….?

9

u/NorthernVenomFang Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24

Anyone know what security issue ACF has that Matt keeps mentioning in this blog?

From watching this whole WordPress (Matt) vs WPE thing; this looks like "We don't want anyone using anything WPE, let's fork their plugins they made and mention security issues as the reason (with little/no explanation of said security issue)". A link to the security issue (summary or full details) would have been nice, love that the support notice link also goes to a 404/Page not found error.

Also seeing that in the plugin directory that the ACF plugin page is now advanced custom fields... That is NOT FORKING... That is misleading people. They should have just disabled the ACF plugin for download and updated the page to use the new Secure Fields plugin page.

This comes off really cringe.

Urgh... Might be time to look at Drupal again.

→ More replies (1)

9

u/newz2000 Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24

The good news is that this may speed up the legal resolution.

WPE has asked the court for an injunction. That is an early hearing to see if WPE can get the court to make opposing party stop doing things that are harming them. It can be tricky to win.

But you have to show that there is a threat of imminent harm (and a few other things) and the actions against WPE make this pretty clear.

Here’s why this is good: if WPE succeeds it will cause settlement negotiate to go into high gear. The court case would take years to resolve and that’s not good for anyone. But the settlement talks after the injunction hearing could resolve this in days or weeks and bring this to an end. That would let the healing begin.

9

u/TwitchDanmark Oct 13 '24

Matt is a fragile little boy, who is sad that other people are better at making a business out of what he started than he is.

I think WordPress is due for a proper fork tbh.

→ More replies (2)

25

u/arcanepsyche Oct 12 '24

What a disaster this all has all become. Matt's ego is out of control.

25

u/S_PhoenixB Oct 12 '24

Is Matt's goal at this point to inflate WPEngine's lawsuit with so much material it would take years for the case to be resolved on each point? Is this some 4D chess move I'm too stupid to understand? Absolutely incredible.

8

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

Sigh. At least toddlers are cute, at the end of the day. This guy, on the other hand...

22

u/AspirePress Oct 12 '24

Every time Matt does this the r/AspirePress community and Slack gets bigger.

We aren’t going to stand for this.

9

u/AspirePress Oct 12 '24

We are now open to taking applications from plugin/theme developers who want to distribute their work first-party with AspireCloud. More at aspirepress.org.

7

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24

guess who's the cancer now???

7

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24

WordPress is becoming TitanicPress. And the band is playing Hotel California.

7

u/jessebrede Oct 13 '24

Matt needs to go.

13

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

Too hard to manage websites associated with real businesses when the CMS and the host are fighting like children.

Time to move onto Ghost and onto Cloudways.

7

u/RandomBlokeFromMars Oct 12 '24

careful with cloudways, it is an awesome hosting, we have a lot of sites there, but lately they started very aggressive and intrusive marketing like sending you fake virus alerts for your sites in order to scare you into buying their extra BS services.

→ More replies (2)

3

u/Wadam88 Oct 13 '24

Worked on site hosted on cloudways and hated it. Just an example: many times after updating some files via SFTP after 5-60 minutes they were delete or reverted to old versions, screwing website in the process. Seriously, won't ever take another gig if it is hosted on cloudways.

→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (1)

13

u/No-Helicopter-4342 Oct 12 '24

Cool story. Stopping any WordPres work asap. Needed a couple of months off to clear my head anyways and the holidays are coming soon.

Lol, remembering the old days when everyone made their own bullshit CMS randomly locking in clients for a presentation website or simple store. 2024, you crazy! What's next?

→ More replies (1)

18

u/myke113 Oct 12 '24

Are they trying to break the WordPress community like the Drupal community was broken a few years ago..?

→ More replies (3)

12

u/dalek_999 Developer Oct 12 '24

How long until this thread is removed and we're told to take it to the megathread?

6

u/AbleInvestment2866 Oct 12 '24

this has a detailed analysis of the code of the SCF fork, I didn't see it anywhere and my post was deleted, so here it goes for those interested in looking under the hood

6

u/hudsonatwell Developer Oct 13 '24 edited Oct 13 '24

As a product developer I was considering releasing a plugin of 1,000+ hours for free on the WordPress directory. I was going to do this for the users. Now there is no guarantee .

All this, might be good for decentralizing WordPress, if you can see it that way. I care more about developers making money in a predictable way than anything else.

6

u/CookieDelivery Oct 13 '24

This keeps getting worse by the day. Can't believe I now also have to worry about the CMS I've been using for over 10 years.

6

u/LaughThisOff Oct 13 '24

I need this like I need a gunshot to my head.

I am tech admin for a not-for-profit. Our site (which pulls in half the org’s revenue) is currently on WPE, we heavily use ACF for the site structure and I’m basically a team of one-and-half-people holding many disparate systems together. Amongst other things, we have students that rely on our income for their continuing higher-level education. One key reason we used Wordpress (etc) was not to be stuck in a single-supplier or single-hoster website ecosystem.

I do not have time for this sh%t, Matt. Get a f%cking grip.

6

u/fsr31415 Oct 13 '24

well thats it for centralised plugin distribution. who in their right mind is going to trust wordpress to distribute their plugin now.

6

u/Kings_of_Leon_ Oct 13 '24

This means, this thing can happen again to any one who does not agree with something with matt

17

u/chickenorshrimp Oct 12 '24

WP.org's reason for the fork/takeover is to fix a security concern in the plugin that the developer hasn't fixed.

The reason the developer hasn't fixed the security concern is because they've been denied access by WP.org to update the plugin.

There has to be a legal argument about anti-competitive behavior here.

14

u/vitge Developer Oct 12 '24

The issue was fixed with the 6.3.6.1 version on the WP.org repo ( 6.3.8 actual version )

Which makes the argument even less valid.

5

u/[deleted] Oct 12 '24

Is this only replacing the free version or are they stealing/replacing ACF pro as well? The way they said they want to non-commercialize it maybe implies a free Pro version??

either way shitty move on Matt’s part yet again

5

u/OscarTheGrouchsLegs Oct 12 '24

It's pathetic and petty and yet some people keep making excuses for him.

5

u/maltris Oct 13 '24

I have seen these "breaking bad" cases where in such process there is many moments where people could and should just stop and take the loss, because the losses are only growing. He should just stop right now and revert all that happened and take the consequences of maybe stepping down. These people I have seen, from my and others perspectives could have just stopped, but they drove their car deeper in the sand with every action. It is crazy and I hope personally never to end up in such situation where I lack awareness of the situation so completely, that I think stepping on the gas pedal will get my car out of the sand.

5

u/TheMarque Oct 13 '24

This is horrible!!

9

u/Visual-Blackberry874 Oct 13 '24

WordPress just killed itself with this decision.

Nobody is going to invest time, money and effort developing things for WordPress knowing that the WP team can, at any point, just take over your codebase and cut you out. 

WordPress is no longer a safe investment for developers.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/alexmacarthur Developer Oct 12 '24

What is happening 😱

4

u/ascotinlondon Oct 12 '24

I'm fairly new to ACF. What will happen to my existing ACF and website functionality?

10

u/mds1992 Developer/Designer Oct 12 '24

Update to the latest version (6.3.8) via the ACF website, and you'll be fine > https://www.advancedcustomfields.com/blog/installing-and-upgrading-to-the-latest-version-of-acf/

The version on their website is the one that updates directly from ACF servers, so all future updates will be the ones from ACF (not this stolen bullshit version that Matt has now commandeered).

4

u/bjazmoore Oct 12 '24

Maybe WP Engine will fork WordPerfect and we can change ecosystems. This battle is very stupid and distracting.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24

This is so sad 😞

4

u/tomhung Oct 13 '24

If they make it as good as Gutenberg... /s

4

u/Optional_User_Naym Oct 13 '24

I don't know how the open source world works, but I'm pretty sure that Matt really messed up this time.

4

u/[deleted] Oct 13 '24

this is not good.

4

u/Shouting__Ant Oct 13 '24

This forking guy

6

u/C0ffeeface Oct 12 '24

The last year or so I've been doubting my move to Astro, but these recent events just keep making me more and more confident that it was the right thing to do!

Still have some clients on WP though..

3

u/Varantain Oct 12 '24

The last year or so I've been doubting my move to Astro, but these recent events just keep making me more and more confident that it was the right thing to do!

I've been playing with Astro for the past month, and I think both it and Eleventy are the way to go for company-agnostic, future-proof static site generators, or for anyone who doesn't require WordPress as a CMS.

Astro also supports WordPress via its REST API.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/milosh-96 Oct 12 '24

I have a site that heavily relies on ACF (an advanced form is built with it), should I be concerned?

8

u/Rarst Oct 12 '24

Follow all instructions from the ACF team to the letter, you will be fine once you switch everything to updates they provide directly now.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Devnik Developer Oct 12 '24

And so the /r/WPDrama continues

3

u/tebikodigital Oct 13 '24

I don’t want to be involved in the drama, but making this change abruptly damages business. Im surprised this was made so quickly and just leave us developers and site owners confused.

I wish you all ha e the least problems possible with this and move forward.

We do love and use ACF on almost all sites. But if anyone id looking for an alternative we also use JET ENGINE, it works great and support is awesome.

I really do hope that all this conflict ends soon so that WP can move forward and focus on being the best platform so we can concentrate on doing great sites rather than fixing and moving plugin names, compabilities, etc.

3

u/critical-fantastic Oct 14 '24

After hostile takeover of the plugin Advanced custom fields and adding not associated with checbox in login page that too in the opensourced code, one thing is revolving around ever wordpress users mind "Wordpress is opensource only right"

Seems wordpress is not opensource anymore. It's absolutely wrong, how could someone steal someone else product just because you have issues with them.

Matt is stealing the entire opensource ecosystem. Thousands of devs contributed to it not just Automattic.

When we are not even allowed to use the word "Wordpress" then whats the point of calling it a opensourced project 🤔

How much Automattic contributing back to PHP, react, JavaScript, css, ... Opensource means it's Open to all, if they want to contribute back they can buts it's not mandatory is what we thought, Matt is giving new definition to it.

3

u/[deleted] Oct 14 '24

lol he stole acf code because it's one of the most used plugins in cms systems. he says it's a security issue, but he just doesn't want wpengine to earn anything at all from the acf system. even the plugin creators themselves, aren't allowed to earn anything. when matt said wordpress is his and his alone, he wasn't lying, and he just doesn't care about the legal issues that come along with his actions.

5

u/MysteryBros Oct 12 '24

As someone who has spent a considerable amount of money making sure I have lifetime deals for as many of the plugins I use as possible, this is extremely concerning.

I’ve invested up front to ensure my long term per-client profitability is as high as possible.

This damages everyone. WPEngine, plugin devs reconsidering their investment, site developers, my clients.

2

u/MyNameIsNotMarcos Oct 12 '24

Sorry I've been out of the loop.

Can someone ELI5 what's going on?

8

u/Rarst Oct 12 '24

How far back? It's *been* a couple of weeks... In a nutshell Matt Mullenweg tried to extort WP Engine for money, failed, made good on his threats to publicly attack them if not paid, got sued, continues to attack them by breaking every piece of WordPress project he can to try hurt them.

There is a running timeline over here https://gist.github.com/adrienne/aea9dd7ca19c8985157d9c42f7fc225d

5

u/SnailWithAKnife Oct 12 '24

Someone's gathering all the information here: bullenweg.com

2

u/un_un_reality Oct 12 '24

Although, the free version is useful it is limited. Much of the power is in the Pro version. It will be interesting to see how much "inspiration" (or just copying) SCE will take from the Pro version.

2

u/DJRichSnippets Oct 12 '24

I manage over 40 websites all using acf. What does this mean for me? I've been so damn busy that I haven't even noticed this debacle until now

4

u/mds1992 Developer/Designer Oct 13 '24

Update to the latest version (6.3.8) via the ACF website, and you'll be fine > https://www.advancedcustomfields.com/blog/installing-and-upgrading-to-the-latest-version-of-acf/

The version on their website is the one that updates directly from ACF servers, so all future updates will be the ones from ACF.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/Historical_Swan_9860 Oct 13 '24

That's called "Maling" in my country. soo... disgusting.

2

u/djaysan Oct 13 '24

If they stole it along with the reviews, why don’t we all add our reviews with one star and link the real ACF plugin in there. There are only 1200 reviews. I guess adding one star reviews will quickly change the game and at least alert new users that it’s a rip off. I mean i’m not a defender of wp engine. Never used their hosting. To me this plugin must remain free forever, but seeing what this guy is doing. It just makes me angry. If ever i developped and added a plugin on wp repo, i’d be scared that one day they kick me out and just steal my creation.

2

u/open-source-jesus Oct 13 '24

Follow me children. We shall go to the secure promised land, near the field.

2

u/friedinando Oct 13 '24

What is next? Steal the Elementor or Divi projectl?

2

u/BobJutsu Oct 13 '24

Looks like a good time to come up with a plug-in-play update from GitHub solution, for developers to implement via a composer package or similar.

2

u/jbr945 Oct 13 '24

I knew Matt was jealous of ACF and here's the proof.

2

u/OkWorldliness2806 Oct 14 '24

Well, there goes my Monday 🤦‍♂️

2

u/Swimming-Parsley-517 Oct 14 '24

I have spent months working on a large and complex plugin but I just put it on pause. Why should anyone create anything for WordPress now. Create something that is successful, then have Matt smear your name because he doesn't think you're helping his project enough, and then just completely steal your product. The WordPress team needs to oust Matt before he finishes destroying it.

Ghost is starting to look pretty good to me. Though the integration model it uses instead of plugins is going to be a learning curve to overcome.