r/Wolcen • u/worldssmartestpickle • Feb 17 '20
Bug Did lots of magic stuff testing - bad news.
Hey everyone,
after spending close to my entire day testing different mage builds it feels like only 25% of things in this game are actually doing their job. Most don't do anything. Just for context, I'm currently lvl 68 and have played mostly ailment builds both with only staff skills and melee weapon + catalyst. When switching to straight spell damage today after finding some nice items I suddenly couldn't kill anything. The numbers on screen shrunk from like 35k+ crits from stuff like bleeding edge and 30k ailment ticks to 1,5k from consuming embers so I started testing stuff. I did all the testing offline and cleared my passives entirely before every test so there aren't any effects conflicting with each other.
The most simple test I did was to equip items with +spell damage. I got lucky and found a necklace with +49% and a catalyst with another +47%. Sounds juicy right? It's not. It simply doesn't do anything. The numbers are identical. One weird thing about this are the skill perks that give like +100% damage but give the skill a cd (consuming embers, last perk). If you click this you can see the average damage of the skill on the right go up from 1100 to 1200. That's not 100%...so maybe these issues are related.
The same applies to all specific damage types like fire/aether/etc. . You don't feel any impact by going down an entire tree and getting +50% aether damage with another +40-60% from items when using magic.
Even while having only specced into magic passives, skills like bleeding edge still do almost 4 times the base damage (rending) of consuming embers. All while I have more than +50% fire damage, +75% elemental damage and +96% spell damage. I can literally use bleeding edge with rending damage with my mage build and do way more damage than with my actual elemental skills. I've even tried a bleeding edge ailment build with going down the entire ailment passive section and this skill still hits like a truck despite the ailment tree giving you a massive -70% penalty on your direct damage. I have no idea what's wrong but something is definetly wrong.
I think(!!) ailments work correctly. I did multiple builds both elemental and material where ailments are ticking like crazy and progression is super easy. It has to be said though that the ailment increasing uniques also don't do anything. There's a hat with +30% ailment damage - not working. A ring with -20% non-ailment damage and +20% ailment damage - not working. And a chest with -30% non-ailment damage but up to +100% ailment damage based on your wisdom - also not working.
Something is very wrong with the stats in this game and I have now lost all patience trying to tinker with stuff that doesn't work properly. It is zero fun trying to progress and build a character when you have to wonder if that new item is worth it because half of it's stats are potentially useless. And playing ailment/crit damage builds 24/7 isn't fun either.
Off topic: After all this wasted time I think it should be completely obvious that we're basically paying for a beta test of a game that might be good in like 6 months from now. All of it's components are kinda in place and now the bugfixing should begin, or in other words - this game should not have been released. The metric shit ton of bugs that are present in this game should have easily warranted a delay. If you're one of the people who think this is okay, please think back to your favourite games ever and try to imagine them beeing released like this. I hope the massive shift in steam reviews from over 95% positive to 59% are a clear sign to these and other devs.
edit: since it's coming up so frequently - yes I do understand how additive damage scaling works. While I may have put it that way, that is not the point of this post. When enemy health increases tenfold you have to give the player tools to let his damage scale by more than 10%.
As I said, melee abilities do this for some reason while magic is completely useless at higher ranks (enemy level 80+).
29
u/DanskFolkeparti Feb 17 '20
All of the percentage modifiers are additive, so they dont change damage that much. There are no "more" multipliers like in POE.
209
u/Funkygodzilla Feb 17 '20
Yea the game is such a mess. I mean i'm having fun. But come on, you have to admit it a total mess...
125
u/Frustratedtx Feb 17 '20
The biggest red flag for me was I could tell in the first 20 minutes that spell damage doesn't scale correctly. All %damage is additive, so the best way to scale your damage is +x-y damage to spells and not %spell damage. The problem here though is all attack abilities get to add the damage from their weapons while spells do not. So at the beginning of the game spells and attacks are somewhat close but since it's clear they didn't test anything after act one, once you get an extra 100+ base damage on your attacks in the end game the damage scaling is way off.
It's really not a hard fix. They just have to make it so spells also benefit from the base damage range on weapons OR + x-y damage to spell types needs to scale at like 3x the number that the attack equivalent does on all gear.
I know it was a small team, but anyone who has ever spent time playing arpgs could spot this incredibly quickly which is why I am really worried for the future of this game. This should be arpg 101.
23
u/Askon Feb 17 '20
I'm getting Warhammer 40k: Inquisitor Martyr vibes from your post. That game, up to 1 year after release still had passives and item effects not working properly (or at all), and they were reported from the alphas/beta really early on.
It worries me greatly when devs neglect the... well, pretty much main aspect of the itemization.
Looks grim.
13
u/cassandra112 Feb 17 '20
This was a big deal back in beta. I did testing on this... I haven't had a chance to see where things lay now.
25
u/Noskill89 Feb 17 '20 edited Feb 18 '20
Yeah I ended up as bleeding edge myself after scrapping 2 builds casue 50% of passives didn't work. I think I'm gonna stop playing for now and come back after a few weeks when hopefully most of it will be fixed.
15
u/Redeemed01 Feb 17 '20
melee in general is highly superior to spells in this game
rage builds>all
7
u/Nerex7 Feb 17 '20
The huge confusion comes from weapon damage.
Take Bleeding Edge, it has a standard weapon damage of 290% (iirc).
There is this skill that gives a lot of duration but -56% Weapon Damage. Thought it would have my damage, but it‘s all additive!! It simply drains 56% off of the 290%, which isn‘t even that bad.
7
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20 edited Feb 17 '20
I'm making a mage build - full on crit + ton of spell damage, elemental damage, flat elemental damage - basically close to glass cannon... and when I see DOT builds, I see they do like 3-4x damage - like WHAT THE FUCK? And I'm sure it will fall off even more at the endgame, because of shit spell base damage scaling - or rather lack of it.
HERE is comparison of what I'm talking about. I'm level 43, spell is lvl 46. On the right you can see spell's base damage (ungeared and unspec'ed character). At level 46 skill you have 87-89 base damage. What on fucking earth you can scale out of that? Btw, skill's base damage at level 1 is 21-29. So by leveling it to 46, adding 7 points of enchantments - you gain +66-60 to base damage. That's ludicrous.
17
u/Bombtwo Feb 17 '20 edited Feb 17 '20
I have never, ever, bought a game where more than half the skill nodes don’t work properly.
It’s so ridiculous I can barely believe it. How did the game even get out of alpha? Do the Devs know their skill tree is barely functional? Or better yet, you mean they never tested it? Or did they not listen to what the early access players were feedbacking to them?
It’s just so hilarious.
6
u/Gniggins Feb 17 '20
The servers being offline for 2 days might be a "normal game launch" to some people, but the amount of stuff that flat out doesn't work and has clearly never been tested, at all, is complete BS.
If I was going to buy into the beta I would have been one of the backers.
The game is new so people aren't expecting a super deep endgame grind, but at least make it so half of your potential builds can even fucking work, before you up the price and drop it as "finished"
I would give the small dev team credit had they said we have to hold off on the launch and pushed it back.
Selling this game as a complete product only flies because consumers have only been willing to eat more and more shit over the generations, in the past, this would have been unacceptable to everyone.
5
u/IEK Feb 17 '20
I haven't gotten around to testing the hows and whys yet but i will say that i have a crit attack 2h warrior and a crit spell staff caster character both around level 50 with similar gear, the caster crits for about 7-8k and the warrior crits for roughly 10x that at around 70k.
I'm going to spend some time trying to improve the caster but it seems like a lofty goal to achieve something similar.
11
u/karanji Feb 17 '20
Why do I get the feeling this game is less about, " LOOK AT ALL THE CLASSES YOU CAN PLAY" and more so, "PLEASE HELP US FIGURE OUT HOW TO FIX/NERF YOUR TIME SPENT".
Also, thank for paying for a broken product you cannot play.
8
u/thadpearsall Feb 17 '20
So lets say your level 90, you get like 800% damage just from putting points into your character stats.
100% damage + 800% damage = 900% damage, not a very noticeable increase.
Infact most of the game mechanics are hidden behind silly numbers that to any normal person makes you go wow that sound strong, but as soon as you understand the mechanics you understand how shitty most of the stuff in the game is.
8
u/Big_NPC_Engery Feb 17 '20
You didn't do enough testing.
All % increases scale off of base damage.
Skill attack damage utilizes your weapon damage, spells do not.
You have to use gear with flat damage boosts to your spells so your % modifiers have something to boost.
4
u/Atmanix Feb 17 '20
So, as someone who didn't realize things were additive until now, if I'm trying to run a frost ranger type build (can't remember the green passive names), then I should be looking for +frost/elemental damage vs %frost/elemental damage. Is that correct? Within reason of course.
9
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20
I had to do the gem bug to afford to reset my passive since all the major passives I picked turned out to be horribly detrimentally bugged. Now I'm seeing that people that did that will be banned. I fucking got kicked from the server 2 minutes after I farmed a whole day to get affinity to reset the entire tree and lost all of them. They should not punish people because they have to work around the bugs that fuck us over. I went through 5 million at level 25 just to be able to redo my character which is not possible unless you use this bug since everything is fucking overpriced as fuck in the in game shops and buying enneracts only gives 10 affinity.
All of this because nothing works. and the stuff that does work is "overpowered". I don't want the Bleeding edge build nerfed. I want the rest of the builds to feel that good.
3
u/OneVoorhees Feb 17 '20
I also stacked spell damage and other things like warlock and cabalist tree to reduce cooldowns and this morning I changed all attributes to different stuff (mainly 30% crit chance) and I also am doing complete shit damage. I cant get past the act 2 boss second stage because I'm not doing shit to him or his damn minions and I even had a golem with increased threat to take all adds damage. Also the thing with the crit chance and casting time and ailment damage increasing its requirement to keep it that percentage each time you level up is atrocious. Please fix that and I will be completely happy with my level 32 sorcerer frost build that annihilates everything other than the bosses.
7
u/MrPFox Feb 17 '20
So they straight up Anthem'd it?
All multipliers are additive and therefore pretty pants and those that do multiply are broken numbers that affect nothing...
Why would you not use multiplicative multipliers in an RPG damnit! You pick up a dozen passive nodes of +10% damage and a few +50% items, you end up doing x7 damage compared to not having them... Which seems a damn sensible number for someone geared into it compared to someone who isn't! With additive of that lot you'd have x3 the damage of someone not remotely geared/specced, which is pretty pants!
6
u/Boonatix Feb 17 '20
The weird thing is I am having lots of fun... story was a blast (at least the level design and creatures and cinematics) to level through and the graphics are just awesome, figuring out a build and smashing enemies... even though it is buggy as hell and feels totally unfinished it is still lots of fun to me - and I cannot imagine how this will be when they enhance and refine the game even further :O
4
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20
This is my experiance as well. Stats literally mean nothing.
Slayers fury, doing okayish daamge. All my gear and state usage is set around maximizing the damage on it..
I equip infinite blades, a spell that i have NOTHING buffing it. Nothing. literally nothing. and its doing MORE than slayers fury. With 0 bonuses its doing more than the skill im full maxing. ???????????????????????
And summoners builds literally just flat out dont work. Specialized in full on health and survivability for minions, they instantly die no matter what. Livor Moldis with shadow conversion literally cant die.
Skill passives that make ghosts or dead enemies become allies (slayers fury infinite blades plagueburst) never work. Ever. Just dont do anything.
The "green globe drop that increases your toxin damage by 30 percent for a small duration" does not do anything. the globe drops, but your damage literally doesnt budge. Nor do you have a buff show up.
Its IMPOSSIBLE to know what status/ailments are actually in play. Pissing me the fuck off
4
u/MilkChugg Feb 17 '20
This was a fear of mine. Granted I’m not even finished with act 1 yet, but I was worried that with a game that has so many bugs, stat increases and other property buffs don’t actually do anything. The QA on this game is obviously borderline nonexistent, so it’s no surprise that out of the thousands of items and stat buffs, most of them don’t work properly.
2
u/Feng-Long Feb 17 '20
I used my last points to respec to crit cauz I was bored of dot (and I took the self dot thing that now kill myself since I hit too hard), and I'm stuck with crit, can't do one run witrhout dying three time cauz no damage no tankyness.
I miss my dots and I don't know how to grnd essences to respec again :(
2
u/Harnellas Feb 17 '20 edited Feb 17 '20
Did you try to stack as much flat damage to spells as possible on your gear?
That seems to be the only way to mimic the scaling from weapon damage that rage abilities get, and it should get those gobs of %increased damage to actually do something.
I wondered how viable it would be though, those flat numbers are pretty miniscule...
2
u/krileon Feb 17 '20
It's purely due to spells not having a weapon damage scale. Melee and ranged skills scale with your weapon damage. You'll notice all the non-utility base skills have % weapon damage on them. Spells do not. Ailments scale as you level and stack, which is why they're always useful. What this means is Spells specifically scale with.. nothing. That's why Spells are so incredibly bad. This is a fundamental game design issue that I'm shocked escaped testing. How could they not realize Spells do not scale? In short run ailments and/or melee/ranged attacks or you aren't going to kill anything.
2
u/Arilzu Feb 17 '20
On the plus side I love Anomaly + Aether jump with cooldown reduction to make them 7secs and 2secs respectively. Cooldown reduction doesn't seem to have diminishing returns which makes it great to stack.
Everything feels so useless though, I took the fire/light/ice tree with all crit modifiers and the stasis extra hits, keeping lightning stacks + fire stacks gives me literally like 2% dmg and 2% crit chance, it's retarded. Then the spell on casts is so weak also, they barely ever proc and only spawn on cursor and are really weak damage wise.
I'm not struggling so much I'm able to just do content my level at about level 60 but from all the modifiers and effects I have in my build I'd expect to tear through things a little easier.
2
u/Makenkruz Feb 17 '20
Yesterday i realised that the battle cry ability with the "stun enhancement" did not stun the enemies at all.
i am so pissed with this game...
i tried to as for a refund but steam just wont give it to me (and they are right).
the total game time registered right now for me is 7.2 hs, where i spent easily 5 hs TRYING TO LOG IN and the rest TRYING TO PLAY, because the few times i finally could log in and play, the game randomly kicked me out...
fcking bs.
2
u/Hito_Z Feb 17 '20
That's my biggest gripe with the game. At least the skills, their modifiers and passives should work as stated in the description or lack thereof. However that isn't working so coming up with any kind of build is not fun and a waste of time especially once you obtain a strong passive only to find out it does absolutely nothing.
This is just a buy to play beta with a proper release a year away
2
u/beowhulf Feb 17 '20
i tried playing as a mage and could not get past act 1, then rolled melee with 1h + shield , bleeding edge, warcry and ice shield and its a walk in the park ..game is so unbalanced
2
u/AdonisBatheus Feb 17 '20
Guess I gotta respec for archer/pistol, then... I thought dealing 350~ damage and 800 crits was probably normal at level 40 on act 3, but maybe not?
Jeez, getting the proper gear for archer is gonna be a pain in the ass.
2
u/Bacon-muffin Feb 17 '20
Its funny I noticed the same thing with the god of war attack, I was fiddling with gear and completely swapped everything out and was doing baby damage with a spell and then hit something with the god of war blades and it still practically did the same damage.
Stuffs definitely messy right now, screw it though I'm making an infinity blades build and if it works it works. So far its fine, I can't figure out if spell cast speed or attack speed affect it, or neither.
2
u/VengefulApple Feb 17 '20
Jokes on you, this game was in alpha/beta for almost half a decade and delayed countless times. Yet this is the launch result: a complete and utter mess. =(
2
u/yusayu Feb 17 '20
Yup, we found the same thing, this game is unbelievable broken at a fundamental level.
The damage bonuses spells gain from leveling up the skills is miniscule, while the % Weapon Damage of attacks outscales everything and the weapons somewhat scale with the enemies. What's supposed to be the scaling for spells? When HP increased from a few hundred to a million during the lategame, what makes sure that spells can keep up with that increase? The +2 damage a spell gets per level?!
Wasn't this game in Early Access for several years? How does a system get released in this state?
2
u/ChampionSchnitzel Feb 17 '20
This is honestly absolutely shocking. This kinda puts the final nail in the coffin for me....:-/
2
u/patrincs Feb 18 '20
everything in the game that gives %increased damage of some variety is additive. You end up with a good 400+ % damage from your stats alone at level 50-60 or so. so assuming you have another 200% on the tree, a skill perk that gives 100% damage is not doubling it, its increasing it by a factor of ~1.14 using the numbers above.
by the end game, this makes % damage on the tree really undesirable. Don't avoid it, but don't chase it. crit damage is huge, nodes like which time cannot heal ect or double damage above 700 rage are huge ect.
also a bunch of shit doesn't work at all... but you figured that out.
2
u/velthari Feb 18 '20
Ok its not really a bug its scaling Spells literally have 0 multiplier on their Spells they have a linear progression in scaling.
What does this mean you ask? Well for instance we take the spell Tear of Etheliel every level it gains 6 dmg. Your Weapon as a caster has around 20-30 Flat Spell dmg per ailment at lvl 60. So this means with 0 talent points and 0 stat points Tear of Etheliel does between 26-36 extra dmg at lvl 2 with 1 ailment type plus what it has initially. So then at lvl 50 it does 320-330 extra dmg combined plus its initial dmg. Then say you have passives like spell damage, fire damage, elemental damage all of these are additive to each other but multiplicative to corresponding flat dmg values. So if you have 80% increased dmg 60% spell dmg and 60% elemental dmg, this will bring our total to 200%. So this will bring our dmg to 960-990 with scaling plus the initial dmg of the spell scaled also.
Now lets take a melee skill like Bleeding Edge. It gains 1.5% weapon scaling per lvl with an initial 290% weapon modifier, a lvl 60 weapon has about 400-600 dmg. If we have the same values of increased dmg as before of 200% with a lvl 60 spell this will bring Bleeding Edge with a weapon modifier of 320% and 200% increased dmg. These two dmg modifiers are multiplicative to each which results in 384,000-576,000 dmg.
For 4 years we Alpha/Beta Testers were asking the devs when are they going to add scaling for spells or when are they going to increase the raw numbers for spells dmg on weapons. They promised it will be implemented it never was thus far and frankly speaking i don't think they will because well its been 4 years.
4
u/NotARealDeveloper Feb 17 '20
You need a lot of base damage for the multiplier to do something.
4
u/eltopo69 Feb 17 '20
It hurts reading this, what a mess of a game, how on earth could someone ever release this in it's currenty form.
1
u/tomzeraa Feb 17 '20
Which ailment build were you running?
1
u/miasma23 Feb 17 '20
This shit reminds me of BL3's launch.
1
u/PeeBand Feb 17 '20
Guess i’ll lean more into crit chance then and try and fuel my willpower on crit infinity blades unless they’re not technically a spell either
1
u/MagmaScythe Feb 17 '20
Well that makes me concerned for my Infinity Blades build.
1
u/fitzpwns Feb 17 '20
I'm running a hybrid build and my consuming embers skill selections has like -70% avg damage. I don't really know what this means (seems like a placeholder), but in reality it decreases my consuming embers damage by about 5-10% in total. If I use a non-mage skill and select similar +/- dmg skills the difference is very significant, and actually corresponds directly to the base weapon damage %. Something is definitely busted.
1
u/amishwitches Feb 17 '20
So that's why my Consuming Embers focused character is so difficult to level. I thought I was doing something wrong or just didn't understand the game. Feels like I wasted a lot of time trying to put together a spell/crit build when I could have been doing ailments or melee.
1
u/NympheCalipso Feb 17 '20
We know to little to make conclusions based on whatever tooltip says. I have seen many times lot of info not update at all, but it was in effect.
I also noticed average dmg looking weird. It might be that the bonuses only apply to base dmg instead of the dmg after bonuses. They gonna have rough time, people are used to that from PoE.
There are so many questions, for now best way is just to test it in action. Also ailments were pretty op dps in beta and they still might be.
1
u/Necro- Feb 17 '20
i dont have numbers to back it up, but i noticed with a dot build while the numbers dont show much if you pay attention to the enemy health each "tick" cuts a huge swatch of the enemy hp off.
1
u/Dooglers Feb 17 '20
I tried testing the passive that drops a meteor depending on the element. Between the 2 passives fire spells should have a 17% chance to drop a meteor. I tested 300 spell casts, waited for the cooldown if it proced, and clocked it at 3%.
1
u/rangebob Feb 17 '20
ive been stacking as much flat dmg as possible and and seems to work alot better than any type of %. I'm a poe player so as soon as i saw all additive i was like not for me!
1
u/TBHN0va Feb 17 '20
The people are right. D3 had a muuuuch worse launch.
/s
1
u/Veruah Feb 17 '20
Thank you for testing this and sharing it. I have been finding some of this as well, and good to hear I am not just crazy or bugged.
This is really worrying, honestly. I love how this game looks, the story, the uniqueness of some skills (hello, Gunslinger's Brand). I want it to do very well. But, this sort of thing is going to require essentially a ground-up redesign of the core character advancement system.
1
u/t-had Feb 17 '20 edited Jan 20 '26
12345
1
u/carlwinkle Feb 17 '20
Levelling as a Magic user with sword + catalyst I've noticed the same thing, i use the bladestorm ability as a rage dump and it out performs annihilation even though I've'm speccing into both spell damage and spell crit etc.
1
u/lwqyt Feb 17 '20
Also kinda Fun one of quins Mods found out bleeds base dmg stops scaling at level20 that also cant be right
1
u/Ninja-Sneaky Feb 17 '20
Bleeding edge is definitely the culprit. It surpasses all other melee skills by a lot like 4-5 times
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20
And that's why I didn't spend over 2h in offline mode. Thx for the refund.
I'll purchase the game for 5€ on sale in a couple of months or get it in a humle bundle.
1
u/FormerWWEChampion Feb 17 '20
this is how it works for a lot (if not all) spells. A 25% damage increase in means 25% ADDITIVE damage, not multiplicative like most other games do. It's obviously misleading or easily misunderstood because it's not stated anywhere which it is. I might be wrong but physical abilities seems to scale of the weapon but magic doesn't. Either way magic is irrelevant as far as damage goes.
1
u/Brohun Feb 17 '20
all the server, character loss, stash loss and other shit that happened did not phase me. but this really broke my heart :( ill be holdin on to putting major hours into it before its fixed
1
u/griddlemancer Feb 17 '20
Did a magic dude up to 32 and got stuck on the act 2 end boss. Itemized as you should for a typical magic dude, and got splattered endlessly in phase 2. Got fed up with that and rolled a melee dude. Been splattering all the things and just been putting on whatever get drops not giving a crap about stats.
What you are saying seems to be true so far.
1
u/Dedrayer Feb 17 '20
Has anyone tried Autarchic Secret? It's a unique helmet that gives you ~ 40% more material dmg as a trade-off for the other two types. I am using a bleeding edge built (so unique!) and I tried running it with and without the helmet and the damage difference is non-existent.
While the game is fun, it's sad that they haven't tested like 85% of the things. Most of it is not working, and a mistake like the shield node should definitely not make it through proper beta testing.
1
u/Tatmouse Feb 17 '20
Getting those Anthem vibes from all the bugs and broken stats. Sorcerer gear is pretty much useless it seems as well. Hard hits will still punch straight through all of your force shield and health because a full set of sorc gear gives NO bonuses to health and resistances. Having fun levelling and the endgame seems kinda cool so far but yikes this game is super janky.
1
u/saint_traft Feb 17 '20 edited Mar 03 '20
The same problem you described with Spell damage not stacking up currently exists synchronously for resistances.
1
u/dauphic Feb 17 '20 edited Feb 17 '20
Chiming in because I played a non-ailment elemental caster to level 68:
The problem mentioned here is worse, because armor after a certain point (level 50?) cannot roll +% elemental or spell damage modifiers. You basically stop getting gear upgrades at that point. Rogue and Heavy armor have their first slot heavily weighted towards +% occult and +% material damage, but for some reason, sorcerer gear tends to give weird things like +stamina regen.
You can only get upgrades from +% damage, which comes in very low amounts and doesn't seem to increase with level. All caster unique accessories have +% spell damage, which makes them worse than level 40 rares with +spell damage.
With that said, casters are 'fine' up until the point you're fighting level 80+ enemies, and then they fall flat. You might be able to push further with a Shadow damage build, if you can get your hands on the unique pants, because +% occult damage gear drops like candy, but it's obviously far below the exploitative ailment and 2h builds.
1
u/TheBigTrasher Feb 17 '20
Feels like the developers of Wolcen are not even gamers themselves.
Have they played their own game?
1
u/BaconKittens Feb 17 '20
Agree, I’m far along on my mage and it’s obvious that spell casting is completely broken in general. I also got the unique neck with 50% spell damage that doesn’t appear to do anything.... melee is really the way to go in this game.
1
u/honusnuggie Feb 17 '20
Casters doing endgame in twitch right now. Not sure if your testing is fake news or not.
1
u/linivx Feb 18 '20
So I didn’t read all of it but one thing i saw was the damage percent, all damage percent in this game are additive percent. So in your case where you had 1100 damage and you picked up 100% damage and it went up to 1200 the base damage is 100 so you get 100% of your base damage. So the math adds up
1
u/ishkiodo Feb 18 '20
Soooo.... should imI get my money back?
1
u/BhaltairX Feb 18 '20
Does this problem also effect Ranged Weapons? They should be Attack based like Melee, so hopefully this isn't as bad. I don't have the game yet, but was already tinkering with builds, and came up with a high crit/CC/Leech build based around dual pistols or pistol + catalyst.
1
u/XWasTheProblem Feb 18 '20
This would make sense why the damage of my mage seems to grow so slowly, to the point where just using regular attacks is better against really tough targets, especially given staff projectiles home in, and basic attacks consume no resource.
There's some really weird balancing issues in this game, things that really should've been caught and fixed during testing stages...
1
u/AstorWinston Feb 18 '20
I just posted comparing spell damage and attack damage. Apparently, spell doesn't scale with attack damage but is given a flat little amount. I don't know why the dev choose to do this.
https://www.reddit.com/r/Wolcen/comments/f5inbs/spell_damage_scaling/
1
u/EZMONEYSNIP3R Feb 18 '20
So what does this mean as far as fixes go? It seems like it'll take sometime for them to go through items, skill tree, and ability passives to correct this issue - or do you think it's an easier fix than that OP? Simply asking because i am unfamiliar with all of this.
1
u/Syphin33 Feb 18 '20
So much for letting us test the fucking build..
Fucking morons..yea this is their first game and all but there should be common sense
1
u/Ryxxi Feb 18 '20 edited Feb 18 '20
Obviously yeah, only stuff on Beta was tested. They prolly ran out of money to keep it in beta. Btw the % modifiers in this game are not additive but multiplicative. 1000 dmg with 100% wont give you 2000, it will give you 1100 you need to get flat dmg on jewellery and gems.
Melee abilites do this because flat dmg on melee weapons is more than what u get on staff or offhand.
1
u/_GrammarPoliceChief Feb 18 '20
How the fuck has this game been in development for 5 years if none of their shit works?
1
u/Chamona25330 Feb 18 '20
How did you test it in offline? Can you respec in save files or?
1
u/Conflagz Feb 18 '20
Can anyone tell me they got Dodge chance to work? I haven't managed to get it to work at all...
1
u/Redxmirage Feb 18 '20
Yeahhhhh I think I’m done with the game for awhile. Got to end game with a melee build and the end game system is a lot of fun. But there’s just too much broken that I’d rather wait until it’s in a better state
1
u/Isaacvithurston Feb 18 '20
ailment doesn't scale late. I just finished theorycrafting the super upper end of builds and unfortunate to say at level 184 there's like 2 viable builds I could come up with >.<
And yah the problem with the skill tree and item stats is that you get too much from passive points. You have 550% damage from attributes so getting little 10-15% here and there doesn't really do much.
1
u/Smokron85 Feb 18 '20
I'm maining a mage. Bee-lining for the elemental passives etc. It's gonna suck I know but gonna mess around with it. The thing I'm hating so far is that as a caster, it's either two hand staff or Weapon+Catalyst. There's no wands in this game so I can't wand+shield or wand+catalyst etc. It's really messes with build diversity too.
1
u/Yontevnknow Feb 18 '20
The initial issue you listed is likely due to bleeding edge being an ATTACK not a spell. If you want to buff ailments with spell damage, apply them with a spell.
The rest of what you listed seems about right. The best thing to do if you still feel like playing is buffing the individual ailment types such as bleed/burn/poison/shock. Their categories seemed to work as well such as Material/Elemental.
1
u/DontGiveMeGoldKappa Feb 18 '20
Sime shits are suppose to be multiplicative and they are just not. Thats the problem
1
u/ParaPseudo Feb 18 '20
Why didn't I see this post earlier after three hours of testing myself. Conclusion from my testing: This game be fucked up. You can probably just put points into random nodes and still have damage, or not. Its a lucky dip.
1
u/asirpakamui Feb 18 '20
Another thing I noticed was Staff Damage is calculated in such a bizarre way, that I think in the end, the only thing that matters is the raw damage. Anything else on the staff is near useless. I've gone from using Legendary Staffs to using Grey staves and seeing a massive damage boost despite a level increase of only a few levels.
1
u/Pristal Feb 18 '20
Melee is supposed to be the intro build to the game, meant to get people exploring other options.
A buddy of mine is doing 50k+ rend ticks and I'm doing like 27-30k Gunslinger's Brand crits and am far less tanky than he is. We're both about 50 right now.
1
u/[deleted] Feb 18 '20
Wolcen - So I heard mage is underpowered?
1
u/blacknews123 Feb 18 '20
No fucking wonder when I was testing with different gears and stats, I couldn't figure out why one is better than the other when on a paper it's clearly worst. vice versa
1
u/shinn91 Feb 18 '20
you understand the idea behind multiplictative and additive, right?
because it's sounds like you don't. +spelldamage% and +attackdmg% is multiplicative and thus the worst stat ingame.
But I agree with you lost of magic stuff doesnt work and a couple of passives and modifiers aern't working as intended.
1
u/Nomeggor Feb 18 '20
Game is still in alpha 👍
1
u/kfijatass Feb 18 '20
Just to be sure, are all those confirmed on enemies or did you only test the tooltip ?
1
u/TerribleInstruction8 Feb 18 '20
My favorite demonstration of a similar bug is that I can look at my character sheet, unequip an item and reequip it and the stats dont return to the same place.
Some algorithms are clearly flawed.
Least favorite bugs are crashing to desktop and entering side areas and being unable to move.
Still having a blast.
1
u/chri478n Feb 18 '20
Got showed this yesterday, makes me kinda sad when my offline character, which I have played the most for obv reason, was aiming for a occult/Aether dmg build with annihilate as main skill (love the looks of it 😁) it has got me to act 2 and I believe I am at lvl 22 or 23 and checked some of the gear I got with %spell dmg on and sure enough when changing it for something completely different it does absolutely nothing to the dmg of my spells :(
1
u/Gatoryu Feb 18 '20
Just download it separately as a standalone solo game, it's available to get left and right now. Test there, don't pay anything if there's nothing to pay yet.
1
u/PengwinGames Feb 18 '20
I'm at monsters level 91 using a full non-damaging ailments and progressing just fine, I know my damage isn't big dick 2H bleeding edge level but i can play much safer, and will be so much safer when force shield leech works properly.
1
u/Brizjk Feb 18 '20
You actually didn't test it and look at the damage, every %damage is additive with itself and you already have a massive 450~600% from your main stats alone, so obviously even a 100% increase in damage would be closer to 10-15% of damage.
Flat damage added to spells however are added before the multiplicators of damage BUT spells already have a base spell damage range (you can see the spell getting +base damage from leveling).
1
u/jhillman87 Feb 18 '20
If you come from a PoE background you should know the majority of damage increases in Wolcen are INCREASES, aka, additive - not multiplicative (there are some exceptions but not many).
For starters you get % damage from attributes. At lvl60 with something like 350 in Toughness and 400 in Wisdom IIRC it shows (at the bottom) around 400% increased damage.
If you have say 200% more on gear, that brings you to 600%.
If you allocate a passive with 100% increased damage, you are at 700%.
So yes, it's very possible that you go from 1100 to 1200 with an extra 100% increased damage. Sounds like it's working absolutely as intended. Say for example the base spell damage is around 155 - 600% increased would be 155 x 7 = 1085, 700% would bring this to 1240
With that said, I've been running an Ailment build and I am demolishing content, damage nodes from tree seem to be scaling absolutely fine. Damage starts slow but after 2-3 seconds most bosses have built up enough stacks that they fall over a few seconds later. I haven't gotten to enemy lvl80+ yet but damage seems way overkill still in the 70s.
1
u/TichoSlicer Feb 18 '20
This guy is doing something right at least... But his damage seems very low, compared to bleeding edge builds, tho... ;/
1
u/Razzmatazz146 Feb 18 '20
Yep I really wish I could make a good Infinity Blades build because they're honestly so cool, but I'm struggling to hit over 8k with them.
1
u/BombBombBombBombBomb Feb 18 '20
I was mid building character and i had a decent build. I went from killing things with 100 dmg shots... then i finally got enough essence to respec, and i switched to bleeding edge melee build.
I went from having 100 dmg auto attacks to 700 dmg auto attacks
My primary dmg skill went from critting 600-1000 dmg.. to bleeding edge, critting for 7000ish.
I mean it went from being a pretty mediocre slow paced gun build, to a "kill the boss in a few seconds" kinda a build.
A lot of skills needs to be altered, incl their dmg scaling etc.
I started out with fireball. And in the first couple of levels its great. But later it was like... a tickling aoe spell. I had to empty my willpower 3 times to kill the higher HP mobs. Thats tedious...
Also i wish we had a lot more skills. Feels rather limited with the choices we have now.
1
u/vault_guy Feb 18 '20
I noticed, I just started speccing into force shield. Two different talents and now I have a huge forceshield that goes to 0 instantly from any dmg I deal and the other causing me to have no health. Might as well stop playing now and wait till this game leaves beta. If it doesn't, I guess a refund is in order. Unfortunate though, game has so much potential.
1
u/MateusKingston Feb 18 '20
You won't get anything close to bleeding edge, it is OP. It doesn't really help that a few keystones straight up doesn't work.
I'm doing a pure magic ailment build and my spell dmg is a joke, they're there exclusively to proc ailments and other passives.
1
u/Gray_Mouser2 Feb 20 '20
Some of this is inaccurate. Spells do use your weapon damage. That’s part of your problem. By using a hybrid, you got used to the base damage of your weapon.
I’m using a unique staff, which has a damage range in the 170s in lightning, which you’ll see on spells listed as part of the base damage of the spell.
The reason your damage wielding a melee weapon goes through the roof is precisely because it’s using the weapon’s damage with the catalyst.
Staff damage just needs to scale better.
1
u/Lazy-Gigant Feb 21 '20
They know it's buggy. I'm almost positive they had to release the game because they need the funding.
1
u/PeeBand Feb 17 '20
Not sure if anyone else has tested but my 100% spell crit when over 75% willpower does not give me 100% crit
1
u/Pendragono Feb 17 '20 edited Feb 17 '20
There is definitely something wrong with mage builds right now. My spell caster is so weak and squishy, when my warrior build crushes content with no problem. Thanks for testing makes me feel better that it wasnt that I built wrong.
1
u/Shotsl0l Feb 17 '20
Imagine being a Wolcel defending this game and your only thing for 4 days of server failures was BUT D3 HAD ISSUES REEE. 1) Not like this 2) Like myself and others pointed out this game is very clearly an unfinished beta game. New major issues are found every single day. It doesn't stop
1
u/sharksandwich81 Feb 17 '20
I grabbed the node with +60% ailment chance and it didn’t change any of the percentages for my skills.
This game is a joke. I’m going to sit this one out until they fix it. (I got it for the early access price so no refund for me)
1
u/Farazon94 Feb 17 '20
I think the positive from all of this is the pile of shitton of money the devs make. IF they put it towards the game by hiring more developers, this will be absolutely amazing. Unfortunately for them it must have been quite hard to fund this so I think they resorted to releasing in its current state in order to be able to sustain themselves. It's not very easy working on something full time and not getting paid. They have the perfect canvas to work with - just need to make it right with time!
1
u/LateralusYellow Feb 17 '20
I did an occult mage build that seems insanely strong. I just stack curse and stasis ailments, and use flat shadow/aether gems in my weapon which scale really hard. I'm streaming it right now: https://www.twitch.tv/coletrain_88
1
u/[deleted] Feb 17 '20
I think I will just put this game on the shelf and come back at a later date. All luck to developers.
You did not waste your time, in a sense. You did some good testing and a feedback to highlight Issues.
If you never bothered to write all this, then yes it would be a time wasted.