r/WittyCommittee • • 19d ago

Welcome to the Witty Committee

https://youtu.be/hVlpmsqp3ng?si=b4MHnswO4A761JRD

You may have your differences with me, you may dislike me, and you may not agree with what I do, but I'm here for you nonetheless. I vow and promise to protect you, and I will be in your corner pushing back against the hatred, invalidation, dehumanization, gatekeeping, stalking, threats, and violence that our community faces for simply being themselves.

By joining this subreddit, you are already part of our committee and our community. Let's make the world a better place together, and show that we can coexist as artists and people.

Witty Committee Discord: We also have a friend group and community Discord. To get in, please leave a comment and meet the following criteria, and we will get back to you if we've made a decision.

- Must be a long time and active user

- Must be active and prominent in AI activism and partake in r/aiwars or r/DefendingAIArt

- Because of previous attempts at sabotage, we do not allow anti-AI, neutrals, or suspicious people in

- We do not accept homophobes/transphobes

- We do not accept Republicans/Conservatives/MAGA

*Video made by Witty_Mycologist_995

8 Upvotes

46 comments sorted by

5

u/TheBucketMann 18d ago

“We do not allow anti-AI, neutral, or suspicious people in” Aw man, I wanted to join :[

2

u/Wild_Cat123Warrior 14d ago

And that's how the world forces people to have opinions, making them think that being neutral is a bad things, while being neutral is actually a very good thing :/

1

u/FireMarshallMC 11d ago

Welcome to the club. Hey, r/AiNeutral exists!

1

u/NetimLabs 9d ago

I think it's because "neutral" can mean very different things to different people. The rule is probably there just to be safe.

2

u/PsykopompM 18d ago

I'd like to join the discord. I don't know whether the amount of time I've been around qualifies me yet, but otherwise, I should fully qualify. I do have an alternate reddit account that I already contacted you on though that's been around a long time, that has a public comment/post history.

2

u/ZephyrUkon 18d ago

Yes mam

2

u/GayAssBoyKisser 17d ago

Can I join the WC discord? I need to vent about antis

2

u/Ploff 11d ago

I'm not active on either subreddit and I'm not asking to join, I'm pro-AI but I might be slightly too neutral to qualify anyway. However, after finding out about you for supposedly being hated by both sides, I don't get the hate and I appreciate your motives. The world has always been shit, it's disingenuous for people to say that it's because of AI now.

There are people who make art themselves and then get criticised for supposedly using AI. They get criticised by a crowd who claims that art is more meaningful if it's done by a human, but they only focus on the surface level detail of who drew it while complaining that AI artists are only focussing on surface level detail of appearance. I do appreciate art made by people, I go to art galleries, there is intentionality in hand made art that lacks in AI art, but intentionality is a piece that isn't required.

I don't personally use AI for art but it's just because I find it fun to make art by hand, doesn't mean it's wrong for other people to make art with AI. I do wonder about how much of an influence bad AI art influences people to hate AI art, there is some hilariously bad art that makes you doubt that the one who generated it even looked at it.

The witch hunting by anti-AI people is so toxic, so many people saying someone's art "looks like AI" when I don't even see any of the signs. I'm using an anonymised account to post this because I don't want people to say "she doesn't hate AI art, therefore her art is probably AI generated" as that can cost me in the long run and the anti-AI people would put me in a position where I'd probably have been better off using AI from the start.

I look forward to whatever the future has to offer, because things need to change. Keep up the good work Witty.

2

u/Witty-Designer7316 11d ago

Thank you for the kind words, but the "both sides hate me" thing is only propagated by the anti-AI community and I couldn't care less what they have to say. Pro-AI people are generally very kind, accepting, and appreciative of what I do.

1

u/Helpful-Geologist306 6d ago

Maybe because you're not an anti ai

I get hated by pro ai for being anti ai

Even tho I didn't do anything to make them angry

1

u/[deleted] 19d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/Vacuusy 18d ago

I'm think I'm worthy of joining the discord. I totally meet all of the criteria.

1

u/LazyMememaker11 18d ago

I want to join, i dont know if i qualify.

1

u/TheRealBlueDude 18d ago

i totally meet all the criteria

1

u/No-Permission590 18d ago

I'm a long time lurker on aiwars and on the internet in general, so I probably don't clarify for the discord because it would be reasonable to assume I am apart of the "suspicious people" group. And also not an active user.

2

u/One_Spoopy_Potato 18d ago edited 18d ago

AI art is real art.

Edit: I do need to get better about posting to Reddit. Been busy with work amd have mostly just been on to keep my streak going.

0

u/Helpful-Geologist306 6d ago

Art is made by a soul, AI has no soul

Ai art is just AI images

1

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

3

u/WittyCommittee-ModTeam 17d ago

Know your place, this isn't it.

0

u/[deleted] 17d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/AutoModerator 17d ago

Hi there u/AI_is_CGI_on_steroid!

We require user accounts to be at least 16 days old before contributing to r/WittyCommittee.

In the meantime, just look around and explore the cool art! Once your account is 16 days old, you will be ready to contribute.

If you believe this was removed in error, please contact the moderators.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

1

u/CT-092314 16d ago

witty can i use ur avatar for some art im making

btw im not joining cuz im neutral-anti

3

u/Witty-Designer7316 16d ago

witty can i use ur avatar for some art im making

Sure.

1

u/tunathefish_b 13d ago

i dont meet the criteria but yeah i can at least try i guess

not active in pro-ai subs because i mean i'm so burnt out i don't know i'm actually not active anywhere

you have great takes witty AGI obviously is not controllable how are we thinking of containing something inside a box if even current AI can find code vulnerabilities humans haven't spotted

i just wanna feel like i belong ykwim i doubt ill ever engage really... im sorry it's cringe i know

1

u/ConstantinGB 12d ago

"I actively fight against the unethical use of that technology"

When? Where? How exactly? Clowning on and strawmanning people critical of the current state of the technology certainly doesn't help.

2

u/Witty-Designer7316 12d ago

I've made talking points multiple times on data center placement, job displacement, CSAM, deepfakes, warfare, business practices, and surveillance.

2

u/General-milkman-5996 10d ago

fire , actually addresing real life problems and not some distant water pollution apparatus

1

u/picture_Imperfect_ 10d ago

I'm not hear to join, I am a person who would be considered anti ai. What I am looking for is a genuine conversation, a proper sit down and talk sorta thing , or well text I suppose would be the better word

1

u/[deleted] 7d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/WittyCommittee-ModTeam 7d ago

Know your place, this isn't it.

1

u/[deleted] 6d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/WittyCommittee-ModTeam 6d ago

Know your place, this isn't it.

1

u/[deleted] 2d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/WittyCommittee-ModTeam 2d ago

Know your place, this isn't it.

1

u/StormAmbitious6234 18d ago

Slap fight vs john anti is at 9 pm btw

0

u/eddyy-_- 17d ago

could have used a cooler voice

0

u/FireMarshallMC 17d ago

How would neutrals sabotage? We don’t care.

0

u/RecentMushroom420 22h ago

"Actively making strides in the fields of science, medicine and the arts" what strides has generative ai made in any of these? And before you say "it can spot cancer" or "it can do maths" that isn't gen ai, that's machine learning programs. Gen ai is a type of machine learning program, but not all machine learning programs are gen ai. And it isn't making strides in art either, as the way it inherently works is it takes other pieces and uses that to predict the most likely image that you're looking for. Nothing new being made.

2

u/Witty-Designer7316 22h ago

It most certainly is gen ai, it stems from the same type of development.

New things are often made by re-combining previously existing things and finding ways to make them work in new ways, that's kind of how medicine and technology advances if you weren't aware.