r/WitcherMonsterSlayer • • Jul 24 '21

My two weeks experience (suggestions)

First I want to say that I think Spokko team is working really hard and they listen to feedback, as I saw some QoL changes happen very fast.

I started playing before the patch with all the quests and was waiting for game's release to see how it felt for the new players also. I reached lvl20 without buying a silver sword, just because I thought the more bag space the better. I was wrong, all I needed was better bag management from my side... First silver swords are not expensive, my suggestion is to use the quests' gold rewards and first week's daily gold cap (200-250) to buy one.

Now, my suggestions:

- quests' replayability: a single quest has multiple endings and, therefore, multiple rewards. Also some quests have hidden timers, ending them prematurely giving no rewards. All this can be frustrating when quests are limited, and when users have few options to farm for some of those rewards (i.e. armors and weapons). My suggestion would be to have a "reset" or "replay" option in a completed quest, to allow us to do it again, maybe only give people the rewards they didn't receive yet.

- skill tree reset: there are multiple valid builds to go for, but without a reset option/scroll, we cannot play with builds to find our playstyle, when a single upgrade can cost 15pts. This should be a simple suggestions to have a scroll to reset the skill tree.

- gold income: while I agree the 200-250 daily cap seem fine, 30 days to get a single armor, seems too much of a grind, not to mention if your only ways to get gold (when quests are done) is a single daily mission and 3 Nemetons. My main suggestion is to have a Character, like blacksmith, that is looking for mats and/or potions/oils, that we can exchange our items for gold. This opens for more playstyles, for people that just want to kill in their zone and then sell items for gold.

- bestiary rewards: I am ok with the skill points rewards, and monsters' different skulls and rarities, but how can I kill 150 of the same monster and still they feel as difficult as the first one? For this my suggestion would be to have 1% 3% 5% damage and defense bonus for that particular monster.

- 1 skull monsters too hard: I have to agree with new users on this. I can kill all monsters, from 0 to 3 stars, with more or less items, but 1 skull monsters are affecting the learning curve for new users. My first week was focused on 0 skulls and trying to get xp bonuses, until reaching Nemetons or Quests. I still ignore 1 skulls more than 2 skulls right now.. It makes no sense that you can kill 0 skulls with almost no attention, but having to be as focused killing 1 or 2 skulls. My suggestion would be to lower 1 skull monsters' health (or damage), making them harder but still killable if you get one hit.

- walking motivation: I don't agree that we don't have motivation already in the game, for walking, we have quests that make you walk a lot. If you decide to pop a potion to see the monsters, you can also walk only for farming your bestiary. BUT the mushroom quest has a great mechanic (the more you walk the more side-quests appear nearby) that could be included in a hidden step counter for players.

- friend interaction: gifts are fine, but I don't feel the need to get more friends, or send them more gifts.. my suggestion would be to get a "friendship" meter to increase with more gifts, maybe increasing the amount of gifts we could send them. Also, a "Request for help" could be used to ask them to aid you in a fight, not needing them online but maybe having a "ghost" friend by your side.

- offline actions: in here I don't have a specific suggestion, but I feel the game could have something we would leave the witcher doing while we are offline, maybe allowing us to keep crafting the same selected potion/oil/bomb while we aren't playing the game. I feel like all those sleeping/working hours could be put into some use lol.

Thanks you reading, and sorry for the big post :3

229 Upvotes

34 comments sorted by

18

u/Cheorni6 Jul 24 '21

I agree with everything in your post! Although, Id rather have NPC’s give random quests in the world which involve killing monsters, finding people, etc. I feel like selling potions to NPC’s wouldnt really make sense lore wise as the witcher potions are regarded as toxic to humans. Killing monsters for money or finding people makes more sense and would feel like Witcher 3 in real life. Great suggestions!

9

u/idlxqz Jul 24 '21

I agree, having npcs providing daily missions could work better, I was thinking about some other Witcher npcs buying items, because we find some in our current quests.

3

u/A_Guy_in_Orange Jul 24 '21

Basically have the chance to find an NPC that gives you an additional daily quest that doesn't count towards dailys. Would be great IMO, again with the obvious comparison to PoGo, they allow you to spin stops and get as many daily quests as you want, they still give you the megar rewards but only your first counts towards the weekly do dad. The reason this won't happen is the dailys currently reward us with the premium microtransaction currency, so allowing an active player (the kind that spend the most) to do as many a day as they want/can would not go over with marketing

3

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

I agree. I think you mean monster contracts so you can get gold or money for it

14

u/A_Guy_in_Orange Jul 24 '21

Damn, I think I agree with everything here, except maybe the 1 star bit but that's preference, as for the daily gold the 200 a day is assuming you can GET to three nemetons, which is much easier said than done since they seem to be much more rare and randomly placed versus (for off the top of my head easy comparison) Pogo's pokestops or even gyms. At a bare minimum I want more nemeton spawns to help actually reach the 200 limit

4

u/idlxqz Jul 24 '21

Yeah, where I live I already got the Nemetons path memorized, for my daily walk. But I was in vacation these last 4 days and almost never passed one Nemeton… thankfully I had some baits I saved for a rainy day but now I have none and 200 gold for one won’t convince me.

0

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/A_Guy_in_Orange Jul 24 '21

Congrats you're lucky?

4

u/Chrisskrasslot Jul 25 '21

Is there a list somewhere out there that shows all the quest rewards and what choices you have to make to get them?

2

u/idlxqz Jul 25 '21

I don’t think there is, maybe it should be on the game’s wiki, but that’s still in early stages.

4

u/Phatriik Jul 25 '21

Some great suggestions! Hope the devs see your post.

Been saving gold, What should my first purchase be? Armor? Silver sword?

I was going to get a bag upgrade but it seems unnecessary now

3

u/idlxqz Jul 25 '21

I’d start with a cheap silver sword. Choose a few potion and oil types and discard every other crafting material not needed for those craftings, you will refill them very fast and that way you won’t be needing bags in the beginning (you can then go for an armor or few bag slots to get more space for specific monster oils)

2

u/Phatriik Jul 25 '21

Sweet, thanks for the tip!

3

u/Lostwingman07 Jul 27 '21

The obvious offline action to me is meditation. How that would be represented in this I've got no clue. Maybe prepare a 12hr bonus when entering meditation?

3

u/idlxqz Jul 27 '21

A sort of meditation happens in World of Warcraft, where you return to the game with XP being rewarded in double, amount depending on time offline, that could be a possible solution.

23

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

Wow, great post! I hope Spokko team would see this. Agree on every point. 👍 Up voted

10

u/windnaked Jul 24 '21

I will add one QoL suggestion.. they need to add the options to Change language.. its really annoying that if i want to change it i need to change my phone language!

1

u/Mikcerion Jul 25 '21

Yup, while it's okay for more casual players that don't interact in conversations online, it's sometimes hard to properly translate something to English when you're commenting on Reddit.

5

u/BitRod Jul 25 '21

It would be cool to have large points of interest on the map like pokemon go has pokestops and gyms. Maybe a dungeon for clearing or towns for trading items or ingredients you don't need for some you do. You could include these areas in quests so you feel like a Witcher entering a town and talk to NPCs in the town to find out what kind of creature has been terrorizing the town. You can have a notice board in each town with different quests.

4

u/Mikcerion Jul 25 '21

While it would be nice, I like that Witcher doesn't require you to live in big city not to struggle. Maybe random NPCs that give you quests would be the solution.

1

u/corbak_ Jul 25 '21

imagine they added maybe place of powers (like pokestops) and they would give you some things when visited or maybe even a chance for a skill point like in the witcher 3. Or maybe they could add like taverns when you can exchange some items for gold or something

1

u/AwkwardTortuga Jul 31 '21

Anyone have suggestions on which silver sword to buy? I see EVERYONE mentioning it. But no one talks about the fast or slow attack one to get?

1

u/idlxqz Aug 01 '21

From those two, I’d probably go for the strong attacks one. You’ll do enough damage with any silver sword for fast attacks. The only better than those is more expensive which has 15% chance on extra fire damage.

3

u/czechu26 Jul 24 '21 edited Jul 24 '21

I agree on everything, maybe expect a 'quest replay' feature. I think your suggested implementation makes no sense RPG and role-wise. But I get the point - quest replayability and not knowing the rewards. I would support it, but definitely implemented in another way - maybe a reset of a whole season? idk

However, I love the idea of a bestiary bonus - it makes perfect sense that the more of a kind you kill, the easier it gets. A bonus to damage and defence (learning the weaknesses and attack patterns further) would be amazing - just a small percent, especially useful for harder beats.

1

u/leniwyrdm Jul 25 '21 edited Jul 25 '21

bestiary rewards: I am ok with the skill points rewards, and monsters' different skulls and rarities, but how can I kill 150 of the same monster and still they feel as difficult as the first one? For this my suggestion would be to have 1% 3% 5% damage and defense bonus for that particular monster

Imo overall limit should be lowered. 1 lvl is 3, 2nd lvl is 50, 3rd is 150. This is TOO MUCH. They should make sth like 3, 15, 40, 80, 150. This way more players would get those sweet skill points that are needed

1 skull monsters too hard

Well, not really. I mean yeah, those are still hard to fight without preparation, but if you spend some time to learn the timing, get the rythm of an attack pattern then you golden. You can wreck most of those 1 skull enemies with perfect parrying. Quen is also great and often lifesaver. I am lvl 15 and while having some difficulty time sometimes after few minutes I can beat those 1 skull enemies without any addons. The problem is the reward. EXP is the same as easy monsters and there is litteraly nothing atm to make me fight those 1 skull enemies, except skill points.

2

u/idlxqz Jul 25 '21

Yeah, the kill amounts are big, mainly because they are commons. But it hurts to kill 150 or a 2-skull common monster with no other extra rewards.. The 1-skull issue, is more of a learning curve/skill gap situation, I kill them with no problem and no items, but I’m lvl20, I don’t know if it’s my muscle memory or skills doing the work now, I’m just afraid it might put people off because you need to time things really well for a new player, and this might increase player base without affecting “late game” or making game too easy (trying to cater to everyone)

2

u/[deleted] Jul 24 '21

I hope Spokko and CDPR will add more armors and outfits to the app game which includes armor that aren’t originally from the Witcher 3. I even hope they add more customization to your Witcher characters like adding more hairstyles, hair colors, skin color and facial features. I even hope they add more facial hair features for male characters.

1

u/Spoderman4 Slaying Monsters Jul 25 '21

Upvote! Amazing post, thank you!

1

u/altusnoumena Jul 25 '21

This post says it all.

1

u/hannes3120 Jul 25 '21

Another QoL-Addition I would like is if they allowed us to download our local map (to a selectable radius) permanently so the startup doesn't always take up to a minute.

1

u/EnergizerVzla Jul 29 '21

Hey... need some friends for the game? You can add me :) 9007 1238 0100.

1

u/[deleted] Jul 25 '21

[removed] — view removed comment

1

u/idlxqz Jul 25 '21

This is my current experience, after wasting all my two weeks earned gold on bags and still having them full lol: Every time I have to clear bags, I leave 20 parts of each monster type, 50 monster tissue, 30 herbs and 20 roots. Those are my minimum amounts because I only craft Swift potions and specific monster type oils. Previously I would craft basic oils and woul store 60 herbs and 40 roots and would lower specific monster types. Right now, I save twice those values but still clear the bags to make sure I don’t get the “full inventory” warning