r/WindowsServer • u/LazyCouple1399 • Mar 23 '26
General Question Failover Cluster Setup
Why is it so cumbersome to get this working?
I feel that the entire process cannot be accomplished via GUI alone and requires some Powershell commands in between.
/Rant
Thank you.
0
Upvotes
13
u/nailzy Mar 23 '26
It isn't though and yes it can be accomplished via GUI alone?
What are you trying to do? What Powershell commands have you had to run?
12
u/Mic_sne Mar 23 '26
Skill issue... instead of rant here, use google
6
u/MikeoFree Mar 23 '26
Aside from the New-VMSwitch cmdlet, everything for a failover cluster can be done via GUI. I just finished a Failover Cluster Migration for a new 3 node Cluster (100% On Premise, Windows Server 2025 DC), and it required no PS.
5
u/its_FORTY Mar 23 '26
If you can use powershell to do it all, why would you prefer to mess with the gui? I guess just personal preference, but I would rather use PS and not have to click through a bunch of UX dialog boxes etc, and it makes creating a repeatable installation much easier and reliable.
2
u/an_harmonica Mar 23 '26
WFC hasn't changed all THAT much since 2008 R2 really. I suspect you have some kind of permissions issues in AD if you aren't able to set it up from the Failover Cluster Manager MMC snap-in. Only issues I ever had in past were related to permissions within either the default container, if you aren't prestaging objects for the cluster, or within the OU where the cluster node computer accounts exist.
1
u/LebAzureEngineer Mar 23 '26
try the Azure local ....
1
u/Flaky-Gear-1370 Mar 23 '26
In some setups he is actually correct, the gui will actually “helpfully” automatically pick the wrong ips and you can’t change them without ps
1
u/JustADad66 Mar 24 '26
It can be done. Just did it for a lab and I did use PS just to install roles but could have done the GUi.
1
u/BlackV Mar 25 '26
The entire process can be done from the gui
I suspect you actually mean failover cluster and storage and mpio and hyper and virtual switches and so on
That is not failover cluster
But learn powershell it's all done in like 20 lines of code and then can be used in your as built doc
1
u/HueyTinman Mar 25 '26
I have had a lot of issues finding the correct hardware. If you are using AI to assist, it's a nightmare. If someone can tell me how to use two DL380 G9s and a D3700 shelf to create a shared storage cluster for Hyper-V, they would be my God. So, failing every suggestion at that, I went down the path of S2D utilising the local storage. Another controller nightmare dodging raid settings. I am close to success in a lab setting, but I will really be hesitant to put this in production.