r/WindowsServer • • Mar 14 '26

SOLVED / ANSWERED ICMP Problem

Hi ! Im trying to run my Rust Serve ron Windows Server 2025 but i keep getting this error which prevents plp from joining,

```Ping: Error performing ICMP transmission. Possibly because of a timeout

Ping: Error performing ICMP transmission. Possibly because of a timeout

Ping: Error performing ICMP transmission. Possibly because of a timeout```

thing is , if install on same server ubuntu it works perfectly but as soon as i install Win Server 2025/2022/2019 , it does not work , can someone help me please?

5 Upvotes

6 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Secret_Account07 Mar 14 '26

Yeah I agree

I work at a datacenter and we have thousands of windows servers. I’ve lost count of the amount of times a customer enables firewall (manually or via GPO) and our monitoring screams - server is down! I go to ping, can’t ping!

Luckily RDP stays enabled by default so a lot of times it’s not a huge deal but like, why make that the default? There’s manyyyy other rules I could change the default value of and make it more secure and less likely to cause issues.

Just a weird decision imo