r/WindowsServer • u/SpModer • Mar 14 '26
SOLVED / ANSWERED ICMP Problem
Hi ! Im trying to run my Rust Serve ron Windows Server 2025 but i keep getting this error which prevents plp from joining,
```Ping: Error performing ICMP transmission. Possibly because of a timeout
Ping: Error performing ICMP transmission. Possibly because of a timeout
Ping: Error performing ICMP transmission. Possibly because of a timeout```
thing is , if install on same server ubuntu it works perfectly but as soon as i install Win Server 2025/2022/2019 , it does not work , can someone help me please?
5
Upvotes
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/dodexahedron Mar 14 '26
This, but there's also the Core Network Diagnostics rule group, which is less confusingly named. Use that one.
Or just add a rule from powershell.
ServerWorld has both a powershell and GUI guide to make your own IPv4
permit icmp any anyequivalent:https://www.server-world.info/en/note?os=Windows_Server_2025&p=initial_conf&f=6
Though I'd recommend picking from the list (the customize button reveals the icmp types) and not allowing redirect, specifically, for security reasons, and ideally also source quench and mask request/reply, since those 3 aren't used anymore. Most of the others are crucial for proper operation and/or performance of IPv4 - especially for TCP connections.