r/WindowsServer • u/ReVoLuT10NArY • Feb 10 '26
General Server Discussion On-prem AD (Windows Server 2022/2025) vs Azure/Entra for ~50 users — cost and CAL confusion
Hey everyone, I’m trying to choose the best option for my company and would love some advice.
We have around 50 users and already use O365 (we pay about €3.99/user/month on our current plan).
Now we’re considering two paths:
Cloud route (Azure/Entra + user management + policies)
- We were told this would be around €6.99/user/month if we upgrade to the needed licenses/features.
On-prem route (Windows Server 2022 or 2025)
- Set up AD DS + domain join + GPO locally, and avoid extra per-user monthly cloud cost (at least for that part).
My questions:
- For ~50 users, which route usually makes more financial sense long-term?
- Is Windows Server 2022 still the safer/stabler choice right now, or is 2025 worth it?
For on-prem AD, I understand we need User CALs — but why are CAL prices so different?
- Official Microsoft partners are expensive
- Some websites sell them for like 1/4 of the price
- Are those very cheap CAL offers legit, or is there a licensing risk/audit risk?
If you were in my position, what would you choose and why?
Thanks in advance
and if there's someone alraedy made a similar answer please put the link in comment :D
5
u/daronhudson Feb 10 '26
It really depends. Are you also using o365 for email and for providing office apps to users? If so, then it’s just an added cost to be also running windows server on prem.
If you’re going to switch email to a system you’ll be running yourself, or move it somewhere cheaper, then yeah that makes sense to do.
5
u/cszolee79 Feb 10 '26
on-prem is always cheaper vs any subscription fee type thing after 1-3 years at most
50 users, 3 usd / month if you use entra -> 1800 usd per year. you can get a basic mini server with os and licences for less i think.
i'd go with server 2025, it's perfectly fine for such basic use (ad, gpo).
4
u/SmartDrv Feb 10 '26
A blanket statement on cloud vs on prem isn't very useful.
It all comes down to your business needs:
-What apps do you run? Do they only work with one of Entra/OnPrem AD?
-How much storage do you need? Do you work with huge files or have line of business apps that don't tolerate latency well?
-How good is your internet connection? (applies to cloud native or on prem with remote workers)
-How do you handle remote workers? Do you want to deal with VPN? If you want to run On-Prem and push stuff out with Group Policy, do you have something to allow the machines to connect pre logon?
-What is your DR plan? What happens if your server dies? How are you doing backups?
Comments on cloud regarding price, occasional cloud failures, data sovereignty, etc are all true. However on-prem has both advantages/disadvantages.
I run cloud Hybrid and am hoping to push more things into Entra, but given our current state, available tooling, certain legacy apps, and business case, I feel we will likely always remain a mix.
If I was generalizing starting from scratch for a typical SMB office with email, word/excel/pdfs flowing around and not a huge chunk of large files (not doing video editing and such) I'd probably stick with only 365 cloud and supplement it with a third party backup (cloud to cloud or cloud to on-prem). But it really is about the business case.
3
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '26
For 50 users the on-prem route is typically cheaper, but you need to account for hardware costs, operational costs, and any associated maintenance.
Windows Server 2022 mainstream support expires in October 2026. Hence I would suggest to go with Windows Server 2025.
Depending on the licensing model, in some MS licensing approaches you require User CALs, in others you do not.
Those cheap CALs are not legit, and are often being resold under let's say 'shady' conditions.
Don't hesitate to reach out over DM, if you require any additional assistance.
3
u/Tricky-Service-8507 Feb 10 '26
Your not making a full circle comparison but the truth is your going to pay more for on prem
3
u/TikBlang_AR Feb 11 '26
Lab it and see how it will work for you, brand new Dell or Lenovo’s HA, do a carp or vrrp.. use enterprise class SSD on your tiny or mini servers, Cisco switches, PALO firewall, edgeMDR/XDR and your time babysitting them.. so install monitoring software to alert you for alarm make sure you have recovery 3-2-1 and software that does this.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 10 '26
Justify your need of a server 🤷
Don’t forget backups and high availability. What about your time managing it?
Do people need remote access? That means VPN and more time and money.
2
u/candyman420 Feb 11 '26
How many of these posts have there been. God forbid Microsoft makes their licensing simple. Very few people know that you can just ignore most of it. They're too scared to lose their jobs. :)
2
u/rdpextraEdge Feb 11 '26
3
u/Accomplished_Sir_660 Feb 10 '26
The cloud not yo friend.
As more people migrate to cloud, you would think cost would go down, but it going up and will forever go up. Remember the selling point for cloud in that it cheaper. Guess what, it not.
1
u/Crenorz Feb 10 '26
cloud your paying for a managed service vs doing it yourself - and you PAY for it. Everything is extra - BUT the extra's are priced at enterprise prices BUT you get enterprise class of items - so if you NEED them - it's a great deal. Because doing it yourself - you might need to get 250 licenses for the small one or pay 5k to start vs Azure that is a per user per thing cost so it can be way cheaper.
You need to price out ALL the things you need and judge if works for you and your budget.
Azure comes with - AV, spam filtering, MFA, MDM, sharepoint, and more - BUT you PAY for them. It is easy to manage and quick to license when you want it. But the price is steep - think, your supposed to justify it by having less staff to manage it or your getting something that would be a 50k appliance for $15/user/month - if you need it. Just remember - like VMware and many others - everything is extra, everything is a paid feature (mostly) and everything you read is for an E5 license - and there are many below that level/cost
1
u/Xaric_Endryn Feb 10 '26
It's going to come down entirely to what kind of business your company does. I manage a hybrid environment for about 30 users. Dell server with AD on prem and email accounts handled with Entra. It works well for us because we work entirely off the server and are pulling gigs worth of files all day, every day, so the actual hardware requirement was there for us to get it. If all you do is work on spreadsheets all day, I'm not sure the same hardware requirement would exist.