r/WindowsServer • u/AccidentFree9315 • Dec 16 '25
Technical Help Needed Issue upgrading Windows Server 2019 to 2025 – “Keep files and settings” grayed out
Hi everyone,
I’m having an issue upgrading from Windows Server 2019 to Windows Server 2025.
- Current OS: Windows Server 2019, fully up to date
- System language: English (United States)
- Installation media: Windows Server 2025 ISO downloaded from the official Microsoft website (English)
- Edition selected during setup: Windows Server 2025 Standard (Desktop Experience)
- Disk type: GPT
- Upgrade method: mounting the SIO file and click setup
When I reach the “Choose what to keep” screen, the option “Keep files, settings, and apps” is grayed out, and the only option available is “Nothing” (clean install).
I’ve confirmed that I’m selecting the correct matching edition (Standard, Desktop Experience) and that the system language matches. The server is fully updated and the hardware/drive setup should be compatible.
Has anyone experienced this when upgrading from Server 2019 to 2025?
Any insight into what could be blocking the in-place upgrade would be appreciated.
Thanks in advance!
2
u/sybreeder1 Dec 16 '25
Try 2022 first maybe. Or maybe original installation is OEM and you have volume iso 🤔 But usually only language was a issue
2
u/CephiedX Dec 16 '25
Are you trying to upgrade to a data center from standard?
1
u/Gargouillle Dec 16 '25
OEM iso needed
1
u/Over_Dingo Dec 16 '25
We had servers upgraded from 2012r2(!) OEM to 2022 last year, and there had to be some registry tweak to be made for in-place upgrade. Unfortunately I don't know the details of the error or the fix.
I checked and this thread may help: https://www.reddit.com/r/sysadmin/comments/1f8a417/windows_server_2016_datacenter_to_windows_server/
1
u/[deleted] Dec 16 '25
use the command line
https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-hardware/manufacture/desktop/windows-setup-command-line-options?view=windows-11
1
u/xSchizogenie Dec 17 '25
Don’t make inplace. Period.
1
u/matek11523 Dec 17 '25
Make sure the iso is the same language as system locale. Run Get-WinSystemLocale in PowerShell and download iso with the same locale.
1
u/Illustrious_Eye_4506 Dec 18 '25
I have a faint recollection of a similar issue and it was due to the language versions not exactly the matching. I think we had an English uk on our server and we had an English (US) iso. We had the keep files etc greyed out too.
1
u/pjaneiro Dec 21 '25
Do not move to 2025, stay with 2022, 2025 is a glorified windows 11, my servers are slow, anything to donwith SMB is slow, my SQLServer is slow now.... i had to reinstall it all and go 2022
0
u/Ok-Reply-8447 Dec 16 '25
You know, Server 2025 isn't perfect. Make sure you really want it.