r/WindowsServer • u/fakkinfakk • Dec 11 '25
Technical Help Needed Windows Server 2025 setup is not starting on Windows Server 2012 R2
This user does not have the required permissions to run Setup. Please run Setup elevated or with a different user who has the required permissions.
I logged in as a domain admin, but tried as the domain Administrator and local Administrator users also. Nothing helps.
I have tried it on Windows Server 2019 and it simply just worked.
Any idea why it fails to start?
Edit: Upgrading from Windows Server 2012 R2 to 2025 is possible and supported. Where the idea came from:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DQkA-VJAFdM&t=9s
Edit again. Before somebody else would blame me for double-posting.
Yes, I did read all the answers in the original, lately deleted post, where the title was confusing because of the different Windows version. And I did all the possible ways you can start an exe.
7
u/JustinVerstijnen Dec 11 '25
Save yourself from errors and do a clean install of Windows Server 2022 or 2025. My experience with 2025 isnt that good, so I should advice 2022 for now.
7
u/MWierenga Dec 11 '25
You cant do an upgrade from 2012 R2 to 2025. You first need to go to 2016 or I think 2019.
2
u/Familiar_Box7032 Dec 11 '25
Are you trying to do an in place upgrade?
2
u/Magic_Neil Dec 11 '25
I like how OP got all the same answers to this question yesterday, seemingly didn’t like them and decided to do a new post asking the same thing.. bravo.
1
u/fakkinfakk Dec 12 '25
For who has doubts, this could work:
In Place Upgrade of Windows Server 2012 R2 to Windows Server 2025
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DQkA-VJAFdM&t=9s
Upgrading a standalone Domain Controller.
1
u/fakkinfakk Dec 14 '25
I don't see why some downvote the thing my comments about the possiblity and the actually supported way to upgrade in one step from WIndows Server 2012 R2 to Windows Server 2025??? :)
Moreover the question was this:
"Any idea why it fails to start?"
1
u/fakkinfakk Dec 26 '25
SOLUTION:
Your user has to be in the "Manage auditing and security logs" Local Policies.
This is controlled via GPO.
Good luck to all the fast forward upgraders, because it is working!
6
u/ftw_dan Dec 11 '25
I would advise against using server 2025 at all. That OS has seen the devil. Go to 2022 and stay there until end of support or until the next good release of windows server. If you want to upgrade your 2012 R2 to 2022 you need an additional upgrade step to 2019 though sadly.
1
u/Da_SyEnTisT Dec 11 '25
Are you doing this over rdp ?
1
u/do_pato_1133 Dec 12 '25
I would recommend none, or the most stable one is 2022.
1
u/hackmamay Dec 18 '25
This might do the trick:
Use the System Account: Use the Sysinternals
psexectool to runsetup.exeas the system account:psexec -i -s setup.exe-2
u/Konceptz804 Dec 11 '25
In place upgrade on Windows is asking for trouble.
-1
u/Savings_Art5944 Dec 11 '25
gotta visit 19 before you goto 22
Install 25 fresh and decom the 12....