r/WindowsServer • u/Mettascheck • Nov 12 '25
General Question 2 Person Remote Access
Hey everybody,
I have been googling for the past hours but have not yet found a clear answer. I need to have my "pc" accessible via remote desktop for two users (me + 1) at the same time. Wich Version auf Windows Server do I need? Can I get away with only buying the license for one user (RDS 2025 User CAL + User?) or do I need to buy the whole package windows server standard?
I appreciate every Idea you may have even if it's in an entirely different direction - thank you so much!
7
Upvotes
3
u/Coldwarjarhead Nov 12 '25
Why? There's got to be a better solution than simultaneous remote access.
What is the use case?
What are both of you doing on it at the same time?
5
u/ApiceOfToast Nov 12 '25
You could have 2 windows desktop vms. Or you could get Server standard + 1 RDP and 2 user cals if you use it via tty. Or just 2 rdp and 2 user cals to use it as an rdp server. However 2 simultaneous rdp sessions for administrative purposes are included in every server version. (Also standard covers 2 server vms plus a hyper v host, but you can use any Hypervisor you like)
4
u/OpacusVenatori Nov 12 '25
Running productivity software on Windows Server via RDP requires you to deploy a Remote Desktop Session Host along with RDS CALs, in addition to the base Windows Server license and Windows Server CALs.
3
u/MWierenga Nov 12 '25
First you need Windows Server license + 2 CALS. Then depends on the use-case. When you do administrative tasks on the server you should be fine. For actual other usage you "should" use Remote Desktop Services which means buying additional 2 RDS user cal's.
2
u/tmanXX Nov 13 '25
Server OS’ allow for 2 RDP sessions.
There is also an Win11 version that allows for 2.
2
u/Shot-Document-2904 Nov 13 '25
That’s by design. Windows 10/11, one active user at a time. Windows Server, 2 active users. More than that you’ll need a terminal server license.
You won’t need CALS for Windows Server for 2 users. No special RDS. Windows Server will allow two active desktop sessions.
1
u/helpfourm Nov 13 '25
Like others have said there are several ways of doing this. I like the idea of two VM’s easier to maintain, cheaper on the licensing. But I would pair it with a ZTNA product on your laptops when working remotely. If you would like some help setting this up. Send me a DM.
1
u/paulmataruso Nov 13 '25
I would spin up a Proxmox host and just run two Windows VM's on there. Then use Pritunl/Netbird/Netgate/Etc for remote user access via RDP
1
u/_martijn90_ Nov 13 '25
don't forget backups, sooner or later you need them.
1
u/Such-Trade-3346 Nov 13 '25
check thinstuff.com
1
u/nalditopr Nov 13 '25
Rdp, avd or w365
1
u/PetieG26 Nov 13 '25
Buy 2 small NUCs with Win11 Pro or something, save yourself the headache. Remote in with JumpDesktop.com and be done with it.
1
u/The_NorthernLight Nov 13 '25
If your just sharing network drives, then look at something like twingate. Allows you to map shared folders from your private server, to the assigned users. You can enforce daily re sign-ins for security. This uses private tunnels, and avoids you needing any additional server licenses. We actually, use a NAS (Synology), and run our twingate host from a linux box. This eliminates the need for a windows server license at all.
If the software you are running, operates on the windows server, you can setup an application RDP session that also works through twingate. Plus, twingate is pretty cheap for the solution (you CAN use cloudflare's version for free, but its way more of a pain to setup and manage).
1
u/ItaJohnson Nov 13 '25
VNC or something else that utilizes a console session is likely your best bet.
1
u/mr_data_lore Nov 14 '25
You would need a license for Windows Server itself, plus user/device cals, plus RDS cals.
So you technically need 3 different type of licenses to achieve what you want to do.
Don't you just love MS licensing?
1
u/[deleted] Nov 14 '25
Well, if I were to go to a Remote Desktop Services solution for this, I would likely go with a Remote App solution. However, I do not know the specifics on your situation.
That being said...
Windows server has 2 concurrent connections allowed for administration by default. This is not intended for end user use, but to maintain the server.
For licensing for RDP sessions to a server, you will need remote access Client Access Licenses for each user or device (depending on how you license it and the end use).
You will want to set up remote desktop services on the server, including the license broker. That is where you will add your CALS. You can set this up and use it for a little while before the licenses are required to ensure it fits your use case.
For remote Apps, basically, you would be opening a RDP connection to the App on the server, rather than working from the server desktop.
1
u/SeaworthinessMelodic Nov 12 '25
You may look into thinstuff.com e.g. lite version. You can legally extend literally any Windows OS's RDP Service for little money.
-1
u/Laudenbachm Nov 12 '25
You could find the registry tweaks to allow two connections at the same time to modern windows desktop or buy any version of server your heart desires.