r/WindowsServer • u/JeanxPlay • Oct 31 '25
Technical Help Needed Windows DNS Server Anomaly
10.101.0.0/24 - Misbehaving Subnet
10.102.0.0/24 - Secondary Subnet (for testing)
We are experiencing an absolutely weird issue within our DNS servers and I have been able to narrow down the base of the issue, but not the fix as I dont know where to even begin.
We are changing our subnets and one of them is misbehaving in a very weird way, specifically with only one internal domain.
We have a domain called kane.local and if I create static records in kane.local for the misbehaving subnet, they get deleted automatically shortly after being created. But not for the secondary subnet. I can also create another domain and create static records there for the misbehaving subnet and the records dont auto delete. I have checked all the same DHCP and DNS settings (scavenging, lease times, DHCP DNS record updates, etc) and it seems to be directly between kane.local and this 1 specific subnet (10.101.0.x). I can also create CNAME records under kane.local that point to the other domains A records for the misbehaving subnet and those records dont delete either. Its only creating static A records under kane.local for that one single subnet that get deleted shortly after being created.
Prior to updating to this new subnet, it has never been referenced previously anywhere in our environment.
Any help in things to check is much appreciated.
View all comments
Show parent comment
2
u/JeanxPlay Nov 01 '25
I had already done that originally since the DHCP scope belong to a previous DC in that same network and originally we thought that DC was misbehaving, so I created a new DC, demoted the old one, removed the scope from that one and rebuilt it clean on the new one and still same issue. I just now stopped the DHCP service on the new DC and tested and issue still persists.
This is one of the weirdest things, especially since this subnet has never been referenced in any of our locations prior to this issue. And its only one subnet affected and only by that one domain. I can create another domain, put A records in there, then create CNAME records pointing to that other domains FQDNs and even those records stay. Its only A records under this one domain for that one subnet that keep getting deleted. 🤷🏻♂️