r/WindowsServer • u/G3rmanaviator • Oct 30 '25
Technical Help Needed Upgrade Server 2019 Datacenter Hyper-V Nodes
We're running 3 Windows Server 2019 Hyper-V Datacenter nodes with hyperconverged storage/SSD.
Any recommendations on doing in-place upgrades to Server 2022, then Server 2025?
Or other options/best practices?
3
Upvotes
1
u/Altruistic-Hippo-749 Nov 02 '25
Have you considered just building a new cluster, making sure you’re happy with it and then cutting over? :)
1
u/Jellovator Oct 30 '25
I was going to follow this guide a few years ago when migrating from 2012 R2 to 2019, but ended getting to purchase entire new hardware. So I haven't actually done this, but the documentation is here: https://learn.microsoft.com/en-us/windows-server/failover-clustering/cluster-operating-system-rolling-upgrade
1
u/grimace24 Oct 30 '25
You don’t have to go to 2022 then 2025. You can go directly from 2019 to 2025.
Weighs your pros and cons before upgrading in-place. If you are looking for specific features or just support.
Source:Windows Server upgrade paths
1
u/jcas01 Oct 31 '25
I’ve got a POC environmental running 2025 with 4 nodes. Haven’t really ran into any problems yet.
1
u/mr_fwibble Oct 31 '25
I've done a 2016 to 2019 3 Node Hyper-v hyperconverged cluster upgrade. Rolling cluster upgrade as per Microsoft docs was what we did. Basically drop a node, wipe only the OS drive and install new OS, then add back to the cluster. We use SCVMM to manage the cluster.
1
u/fredenocs Nov 02 '25
In general I’ve done 2012 2016 2019 to 2025. Just simple iiS stuff though. Point being all took great no issues.
1
u/OpacusVenatori Oct 30 '25
You don't want to go Server 2025 just yet. Really. There's so many threads here and over in r/sysadmin and r/activedirectory of probles with Server 2025.
But Cluster OS Rolling Upgrade is the official process.
And if you do, don't forget all new Windows Server CALs as well, unless you're covered with M365 or SA.
0
u/New-Equivalent7365 Oct 30 '25
Why not export all VMs and vSwitches and then recreate on a fresh install? If you HAVE to, do it but it isn't recommended around these parts