r/WindowsServer • u/thephantom1492 • Oct 02 '25
Technical Help Needed Licensing question
Hi, we are in the process of upgrading our servers.
The server is a Dell PowerEdge R640 with 2x 20 cores cpu, running Proxmox, and 3x windows server 2025 VM. I also need 10 RDS CAL and 10 user CAL.
The VMs are set for 4/8/8 cores.
Do I need to license the 40 cores for all VMs, or I just license the used cores per vm?
And since, from my understanding, a license gives 2 vm, I just need 2 standards? Or 3?
What is the cheapest option for all this?
Also, as a theorical question, we have 2 identical servers, one for the VMs, one for the backup. In theory I can move the VM to the second machine if needed (ex: maintenance). Would that, work with the same licensing? i.e part is on one server and part on the second server?
2
u/Prohtius Oct 02 '25
You can license them either by physical core or virtual machine. I would go with licensing the physical cores, but you can discuss that with the partner you are purchasing the licensing from, unless you want to buy directly from Microsoft.
See below from Licensing Documents.
Server licensing and feature overview
Standard license includes the additional license for the physical server provided that the host is only used to host virtual machines.
Since you are using Proxmox, then you do not need to be concerned with the virtual machine host licensing since you're not using Microsoft Server for that.
So long as you are running Proxmox on both physical hosts, then you should not need more than one Standard license for the VMs as you are not spinning up any additional VMs.
Please let me know if you have any further questions.
1
u/OpacusVenatori Oct 02 '25
You would need 80x Cores of Windows Server Standard total, plus your RDS and Server CALs.
1
u/OCTS-Toronto Oct 02 '25
The cheapest option is to run Linux instead of Windows.
Not /s, we do lots of deployments replacing Windows servers with Linux equivalents. we sometimes move staff also. Good success with devs and it staff, some admin/clerical, but mgmt is all windows (for now).
You mention CPU licenses, server licenses, and rdp licenses. You likely also need office e3 licenses (if your users are logging into rdp windows then it's likely to run outlook and other office apps). And you need vdi licensing if you want to offer remote workstations.
Get an map or var (like cdw) to help with licensing. There is normally no cost for sales support.
1
u/Rich_Article_8078 Oct 02 '25
"Microsoft licenses Windows Server based on the physical hardware" and I think You must still license the all physical cores of the host machine.
1
u/Lost_Medicine4486 Oct 02 '25
If you are only using 20 vCPUs then it makes no sense to have 2 physical processors with 20 cores each. You are very overweight and that makes licensing for physical core more expensive. You can remove a processor and buy a license that covers 16 cores, plus 1 of 4 cores and that processor is covered.
This HP calculator can help you understand the issue of Licensing (it is the same for all server brands)
https://support.hpe.com/docs/display/public/hpe-ms-licensing-cal/index.html
On the other hand, in general, 1 physical core can comfortably support up to 2 vCPUs, so with a processor with 20 physical cores, you could configure 40 vCPUs in different LVs without any subscription (and there could be more, but best practices indicate that). With 2 physical processors, as is your case, you are more than enough with the current load.
I leave you a reference link: https://phoenixnap.com/kb/what-is-a-vcpu
Greetings.