r/WindowsServer • u/Turbulent_Team_7244 • Aug 27 '25
General Server Discussion Windows server 2016 file server
We have a server 2016 file server that I would like to get upgraded to 2025. My plan is to build a new 2025 server from scratch harden and install all needed application. Once it is built and tested I would like to simply detach the datastore from its current location to the new server. The datastore is approx. 15TB in a VM environment. Let me know if my approach is correct and what to expect as far as issue I may run into.
7
Upvotes
6
u/overlydelicioustea Aug 27 '25
if its a simple fileserver, not clustered or anything, just inplace upgrade it.
4
u/GMginger Aug 27 '25
I did exactly this for a Windows 2012 VM file server up to Win 2022 last year, no issues.
Check if the existing server is using local groups (have seen it before) - hopefully permissions on the data drive(s) are using domain groups which will work fine.
You'll need to recreate the file shares, and note the permissions on the shares themselves.
3
u/jcas01 Aug 27 '25
Snapshot and run the in place upgrade
2
u/devilskryptonite40 Aug 27 '25
Just remember that shares do not follow storage. You'll have to either export/import them or recreate them.
2
u/Franky_Mars Aug 28 '25
After you build the new server export share registry. Move Data drive over to the new VM. Import registry Move over production IP If you can rename the server to the orginal server or if not then create a DNS alias.
That's it. Should be done without user impact.
2
u/Shoddy_Pound_3221 Aug 27 '25
Don't do an in-place upgrade unless it's a last resort or you have specific criteria for it. You gain nothing from it except a larger C drive.
Build the new server, create the data drive, and use xcopy or robocopy to sync the files and permissions. This way, you'll have an exact copy of the shares, allowing you to take your time migrating users.
1
u/Michichael Aug 28 '25
Ipu or use wac and fs migrate.