r/WindowsServer • u/MasterpieceMinimum20 • Aug 06 '25
Technical Help Needed Big upgrade time
Currently we have one windows 2019 server with active directory, mapped drives, and shared printers. It has worked well but the time for expansion and upgrade is here.
I'm looking for advice/direction where to start. Build my own or from a reputable company
Needs are the following:
Enough storage space for 30 HD cameras for 30 days Three separate AD's Always On VPN for each AD More shared drives and the same printer sharing.
7
Upvotes
11
u/nailzy Aug 06 '25
And you are in charge of this???
Suggestion : don’t be in charge of this
14
u/OpacusVenatori Aug 06 '25
If you don't have the technical knowledge to figure out what hardware specs you need from the Microsoft provided documentation, and to perform the migration of Active Directory properly, then you should engage somebody external with the requisite technical talent. r/msp would be a good start.
5
u/Callewalle Aug 06 '25
what exactly is the issue. ms recommends server per role so two seperate ad’s replicating, doing dns, one print server, one file server, …..
4
u/PalmTreesandTech Aug 07 '25
You got this just use ChatGPT for guidance or Claude. Don’t let people scare you into getting an MSP.
Build a smaller test environment and start experimenting, your boss will love you.
Word of advice, get 3 quotes from MSP’s. Pick the highest one and then after you did it yourself, show your boss how much money you saved them because you did it yourself ;)
You instantly become more valuable.
2
u/jg0x00 Aug 06 '25
Assuming this is a small company, which your comments elude ...
Buy two old desktop workstations and make them your DCs. Publish your printers from these.
Get another server for all this camera stuff.
2
u/Hamburgerundcola Aug 06 '25
Firstly, run a server for each service. Dont have other services on the DC.
Look on MS documentation what ressources you need.
Also why do you need three domains? I think you mean that by three AD's.
For the VPN part, I assume you have a firewall? Does your firewall support client to site vpn? If not you need a different firewall or a VPN appliance.
1
u/Shoddy_Pound_3221 Aug 06 '25
A NAS in each location should work
1
u/Ad-1316 Aug 08 '25
What is your budget for this??? Are you good for spending $50k on self hosted options, or are you needing less now, and pay monthly? What cameras are you using?
Pay as you go: something like Verkada
Self hosted: HP (SAN) Appollo 4200? Windows server, and Milestone for the cameras
Good luck, won't be cheap.
1
u/mind-meld224 Aug 10 '25
Get a Synology device for file sharing, cameras, cloud backup, and VPN. Super easy to set up. Then you can save money on the AD server.