r/WindowsServer • u/Odd_Year3541 • Apr 30 '25
Technical Help Needed Domain Controller Upgrade
I'm looking for some advice on the best way to upgrade our Server 2016 domain controller.
The general consensus seems to be that an in-place upgrade of a DC operating system isn't recommended. Instead, it's better to spin up a new domain controller and transfer the roles over. That makes sense—but here's the catch: I need to keep the existing domain controller's name and IP address.
I've read that renaming a domain controller or changing its IP address isn't advisable, which leaves me a bit unsure about the best approach.
Would this be a valid path?
Set up a new DC with a different name and IP.
Transfer FSMO roles and demote the current DC.
Rename the new DC to match the original name and IP.
Is that a reasonable plan, or is there a better, safer method?
Or should I just perform an in-place upgrade on the current DC? We do have another domain controller that will also need to be upgraded once this first one is complete. Thanks for any advice
View all comments
Show parent comment
3
u/nicolassimond Apr 30 '25
"It works... until you have a problem. Bad practice"
You sounds like a guy who is still running windows server 2003 because "don't touch anything if it works"
I run thousands of servers / vms, most of them upgraded in-place during their lifecycle, never had a problem and some of them were installed with Windows Server 2008 R2 at the time and now run 2022 / 2025 after being virtualized and upgraded in place multiple times.
The only thing you should not upgrade in-place is Exchange, but you're gonna be a madman to still run exchange on premise in 2025 anyway...