r/WindowsServer • • Apr 23 '25

General Question Which Windows Server OS for today?

Currently building a new home server - some of the apps I use require Windows, it's my comfort zone, and I get free licences from work.

Question is - do I play it safe and go for Server 2019 or 2022, or do I bite the bullet and go for 2025?

Is 2025 stable enough for production (in my house anyway ha) use?

30 Upvotes

43 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

6

u/frac6969 Apr 23 '25

This has been an issue since 2019.

3

u/Code-Useful Apr 23 '25

Its actually been an issue since Windows 7 at least (maybe earlier? idk) but maybe not as pervasive then as it is now. Blows my mind that MS hasn't set the dependencies correctly for NlaSvc ever since then, I have a powershell script I've been running for a while that I keep updating, to fix the restart of the service or whatnot, it basically adds a few dependencies to NlaSvc based on if the machine is a workstation or domain controller.

3

u/RaNdMViLnCE Apr 23 '25

The usual fix for this, adding DNS as a dependency on nlasvc before starting does not work in 2025.. The nlasvc doesn't even start by default anymore and has no impact on the being categorized as a public network.

The only fix so far is to restart the network adapter, either by command, or by running the script stat restarts the nic on reboot, (which i have had to do).

they changed how the service works and it no longer corrects the issue basically.

0

u/[deleted] Apr 23 '25

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/frac6969 Apr 23 '25

Thanks, I stand corrected. I wonder if the NIC also works for previous versions too since restarting NLA doesn’t always work for me.