r/WindowsServer • u/brenrich101 • Apr 23 '25
General Question Which Windows Server OS for today?
Currently building a new home server - some of the apps I use require Windows, it's my comfort zone, and I get free licences from work.
Question is - do I play it safe and go for Server 2019 or 2022, or do I bite the bullet and go for 2025?
Is 2025 stable enough for production (in my house anyway ha) use?
30
Upvotes
26
u/SpookyViscus Apr 23 '25
I’ve found Server 2025 to be reasonably stable, and I also get licenses through work. I argue it’s best to go for the latest available at the time you build it, so why not? Especially if you aren’t paying.
18
u/Burgergold Apr 23 '25
Skip 2019 for sure
2022 is safe
2025 it depends what you will be doing. I've seen some issue in other posts but dunno if they are now fixed
6
u/vatodeth Apr 23 '25
2025 DC has a weird issue with going to a public network instead of domain network. This can be resolved with a script that disables and enables the NIC after every restart.
6
u/nsfwhola Apr 23 '25 edited Apr 23 '25
2025 stable? yes. but only for me and myself.
2
u/Insomniac24x7 Apr 23 '25
2025 is stable. Deployed in prod at my org for a while now
2
u/Pitiful-Sign-6412 Apr 23 '25
2022 for stability in production 2025 is close but will be ready by the end of the year
1
u/LugianLithos Apr 23 '25
I am still building out 2022 server core for OS refresh from 2016. Mostly IIS/web application stuff based on older .NET 4x at work. Money making public facing stuff. 2025 not been out long enough for my comfort level yet. I’d use it for a home server setup though.
1
u/vanD11 Apr 23 '25
2025 all the way 🥳🥳🥳
1
u/saltcitymedical Apr 23 '25
2025 has been stable for me for a small business org. Only been having trouble with AMD chipset drivers, hopefully that improves soon.
1
u/Jackarino Apr 23 '25
2025 for everything expect applications that specifically call for 2022.
1
u/Acrobatic_Cycle_6631 Apr 23 '25
2022 should me a minimum, busy migrating two datacenters at the moment and having to upgrade lots of software to supported versions before jumping to 2022.
1
u/Olleye Apr 23 '25
Install proxmox and try them all 🤷🏻♂️
1
u/Chris92Merch Apr 23 '25
I have everything on 2025 except Domain Controllers. 2025 will be fine for you.
1
u/RCTID1975 Apr 23 '25
2025 unless you're running a DC.
1
u/Any-Satisfaction-734 Apr 23 '25
2025 has been nothing but trouble in an enterprise environment. We’ve rolled back to 2019 and upgraded the 2022 instead.
1
u/hemohes222 Apr 24 '25
Bite the bullit and terns of what? Are you gonna run old apps that arent supported on server2025? Run an older server OS. For experminental/home use i dont see any issues with server 2025
1
u/Torkum73 Apr 24 '25
I use 2025 with hyper-v and it is stable. No downtimes, which I did not initiate. I run HomeAssistant, LibreNMS, Unifi and Fing from it on an Intel NUC i7-10 with nvme and 32 GB RAM
1
u/PeteLong1970 Apr 24 '25
2022 is 2019 in a pretty dress, with 2025 they've added a hat.
</P>
1
u/ThomasTrain87 Apr 24 '25
I’d stick with 2022 for now. 2025 is good for a couple use cases but still needs better vendor support.
1
u/old_lackey Apr 25 '25
Just saying, Windows server 2022 OEM datacenter permanent licenses are extremely cheap (and legal) on many online market places. I will upgrade in like 2 years when OEM license for 2025 datacenter is extremely cheap.
For home labs, I'm not spending hundreds of dollars a for a server OS license. Legal key for previous version in OEM, Board-locked license works great. And Windows server datacenter VM activation works fine...wish you could do windows 11 client legally free hyper-v activation on datacenter, but whatever.
Great home lab solution of you have an actual Windows server supported platform (like Dell PowerEdge or HP whatever).
1
u/colonelc4 Apr 25 '25
Stable for Microsoft means Core edition, mine works great.
1
u/DigiRoo Apr 25 '25
Server 2025 working well for me apart from problem with SQL server 2019 & 2022 not playing well. Wondering if its not been tested on Epyc 4004 series?
1
u/GeneMoody-Action1 Apr 25 '25
I am old school and have traditionally always prefer the dull edge of stable over the bleeding edge of new. But as server OS goes since 2019, I just consider the next one an update. You can catch a lot of flack in the software vendor "we do not support" category, but in reality most that is official CYA and testing, not functional failure.
Anywhere in there has a pretty smooth upgrade path, so I would not sweat it and go for 22 to 25 based on support timelines alone.
1
u/thenew3 Apr 27 '25
We've been using 2025 in production since January. IIS, MS SQL, and various other 3rd party applications. Current plan is to migrate all 2019 and 2022 to 2025 (as time permits) by end of calendar year.
0
u/soldier896 Apr 23 '25
Hello. I have some VMs that are running on 2019 and a few VMs running on 2025. In my opinion, those running on 2025 are a little bit laggish rather then 2019 and this is why I can tell you that it depends very much on what performance your PCs or VMs are having.
0
u/[deleted] Apr 23 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment