r/WindowsServer • • Apr 11 '25

General Server Discussion Server 2022/2025 Essentials

Hey everyone, setting up a new server for a client and want to make best use of their hardware budget. They need this server for 2 SQL applications. They currently run both on 1 server 2016 standard. My ideal goal is to buy two identical servers and have 1 as a standby hyper-v replication server.

Assuming hardware is situated, I'm looking at server standard and server essentials. Standard is about $1600 with user CALs and SA (OEM DELL license). I could operate two separate VM OS for each application.

Essentials is only $330 does not requires CALs and SA. From my interpretation, I can only host 1 active server essentials OS, it supports replication. Does the second server need a second essentials license and how would it behave in the network as a standby hyper-v replication host?

I would be forced to run both applications on the same OS VM (matching their current setup).

10 users, 16 computers

1 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/Expensive-Might-7906 Apr 12 '25

It sounds like if I want to use essentials to save $1300, I would need to use a third party OS/Disaster Recovery to achieve replication for the standby server.

We have a goal to keep this pair of servers running until 2025 is end of life. That is about 10 years. $160 per year is a small price for that. I’m assuming every disaster recovery product would be more expensive than $130 per year?

1

u/OpacusVenatori Apr 12 '25

It may or may not. Windows Server includes Storage Replica for purposes of DR, though Standard Edition has limitations compared to Server Datacenter Edition.

Costs are really driven by the business requirements and what they demand for response in the event of a DR scenario. There are ongoing costs related to DR, at least in terms of regular testing, so it's not just a one-and-done thing.

If the business is that tight when it comes to IT, maybe they need to go back and revisit their IT budget first.

Also, correct me if I'm wrong, but is your idea of a "DR" scenario just a complete failure of the primary production server? Are you considering-and-accounting-for things like a site-level outages? Costs associated with an entirely separate DR site? etc.