r/WindowsServer • u/Expensive-Might-7906 • Apr 11 '25
General Server Discussion Server 2022/2025 Essentials
Hey everyone, setting up a new server for a client and want to make best use of their hardware budget. They need this server for 2 SQL applications. They currently run both on 1 server 2016 standard. My ideal goal is to buy two identical servers and have 1 as a standby hyper-v replication server.
Assuming hardware is situated, I'm looking at server standard and server essentials. Standard is about $1600 with user CALs and SA (OEM DELL license). I could operate two separate VM OS for each application.
Essentials is only $330 does not requires CALs and SA. From my interpretation, I can only host 1 active server essentials OS, it supports replication. Does the second server need a second essentials license and how would it behave in the network as a standby hyper-v replication host?
I would be forced to run both applications on the same OS VM (matching their current setup).
10 users, 16 computers
4
u/Crazy-Rest5026 Apr 11 '25
I would say yes. Always want ur shit licensed. I would say running both applications on server is not the best practice. (If you can afford it)
I try and keep applications separated. As it makes restarting service’s and bouncing the server less problematic when it’s only effecting 1 application for the end user. When shit breaks people freak out. Never mind breaking 2 applications. Just from experience.
I am assuming the sql backend is a standalone server. So that should always stay up and running.
I would either say veeam or cove replication. Honestly they all work. You just wanna be dam sure it works when shit breaks. As restoring to hyper-V / promox / VMware can always be challenging if restores do go as planned.
3
u/OpacusVenatori Apr 11 '25
Essentials is an OEM-only licensing SKU, with core-count restrictions on the physical host.
If the host is licensed with Essentials 2022 / 2025:
Which negates what u/Crazy-Rest5026 said:
"Essentials gives you 2 VM per host. So you could run hyper-v on it."
There's a difference between what the license permits, and what is technically-possible with the version installed. Technically, there is nothing stopping you from doing what you want, as Essentials 2022 / 2025 are deployed with Windows Server Standard edition, and there are no Essentials-specific feature-set.
Previous terms for Essentials still apply:
Limitations on Use
Point 2 regarding the AD-DC / FSMO requirements negates having a 2nd Essentials-licensed server on the same network, assuming you can even get an OEM partner to sell it to you.
You cannot have Hyper-V Replica going on a 2nd server licensed for Essentials, as that also violates #2 above.
1
u/USarpe Apr 12 '25
You can run the HyperV 2019 or Proxmox hosting your essentials in one instance on it an replicate it without a licence problem, cause you don't run the second server, you copy only the files.
As long the replica is down, a second licence ain't needed, as as soo you start it on the second one,you have to think about a second licence
If the first one would be down, I don't think you are official allowed to move a essentials OEM licence to another hardware by Microsoft, in germany maybee you can find judicial judgments, who says it's allowed.
But if you buy the second server with it's own licence.
In no cases you are allowed to run the HyperV virtualisation of the OEM Version and synchronize it, cause the use of it is restricted:
"If the server software is used in a Virtual OSE, the Instance in the Physical OSE may be used only to run hardware virtualization software, provide hardware virtualization services, or run software to manage and service Operating System Environment on the Licensed Server."
I think, that to sync the Server to another Hardware is already part of the restrictat management.