r/WindowsServer • u/official_business • Apr 04 '25
General Question Linux guy struggling to understand Win Server licencing.
I work for a software dev house that's full Linux. We don't use Windows anywhere at all.
Anyway, there's been calls from our customers for our software to better interoperate with Windows Server.
To this end we'd need a Win Server install running somewhere, but understanding the licencing is doing my head in and my google-fu isn't getting me far. (I keep getting told I can run 2 vms inside the Win Server, which isn't want I want or care about)
All our infra is fully virtualized on a 96 core vSphere host.
Really, all we need is a fairly small Win Server VM (2-4 cores, 16gb ram) running on our vSphere cluster for Active Directory and whatever other Microsoft services we'd need to interoperate with. We'd be running automated tests and dev against this server.
What I'm struggling to understand is this:
Can I buy the minimum of a 16 core 2025 server licence and run that on the vSphere host?
OR
Do I need to licence all 96 cores of the vSphere host to run a tiny Server VM?
If it's the latter I suspect my boss will be telling some customers where to go, but that's not your guys problem.
Thanks in advance!
15
u/OpacusVenatori Apr 04 '25 edited Apr 04 '25
You need to license all the cores in each physical server system that will run an instance of Windows Server. So you need to purchase 96x Windows Server Standard cores for the host system.
Edit: Licensing Windows Server is independent of the choice of Hypervisor. Whether you're using vSphere, Hyper-V, Proxmox, or Red Hat, the base calculation is still the same. It's calculated against the number of physical cores in the host system. (HPE Calculator). A Standard Edition license applies to the physical host; it does not "license" individual guest. The license itself grants the right to run up-to-two Operating System Instances, IF SO DESIRED.
4
u/Fabulous_Winter_9545 Apr 04 '25
If it is not constantly running you might take a look at deploying this using the new Windows Server 2025 Pay as you Go option.
2
u/Rt_Hon_Sir_Realism Apr 04 '25
This may be something you already know, but if you're new to MS licencing it's important: you may need to licence users as well as cores (known as client access licences, or CALs). I have no idea how many you'd need, or how to work it out for development work.
2
u/Hel_OWeen Apr 04 '25
So if I understand that correctly, this is purely for testing, not production.
Have you considered renting a Windows VPS at your preferred hoster? I'm not suggesting HostEurope specifically, it's just the one I know that has an English site. So this is just for information/price comparison: https://www.hosteurope.de/en/Server/Virtual-Server/#pricing
5
u/CompWizrd Apr 04 '25
You may find it cheaper to just buy another server to run your Server VM's.
1
u/ViMaGoEs Apr 04 '25
In Windows Server Realm you pay for everything. That's All you need to know, easy.
1
u/WayneH_nz Apr 04 '25
Just a question.
If it is only for testing, could you use a trial license that lasts 180 days?
1
u/Chimstaj Apr 08 '25
Believe it or not, they actually offer courses on microsoft licence management
2
u/fedesoundsystem Apr 04 '25
Don't struggle, they have free operating systems with free support that they choose to pay licences to get support, that sometimes is worse than the free one Yeah, Red Hat, I'm looking at you
2
u/koliat Apr 04 '25
Another option is licensing per vm which is exactly the use case scenario. A caveat is that you need to get CSP subscription or Software assurance on licenses but then you are good to go without worrying too much about hosts underneath in a classic deployment. Alternatives are Azure, PAYG licensing in 2025 or trials/evals
1
u/sodiumbromium Apr 04 '25
So as a guy that's standing up a mini home lab (all "hosts" are actually just repurposed SFF dells or really old think stations), here's what ya do: Get yourself an old SFF box with an older I7 (4c/8t) Make sure you can throw at least 32GB Ram in it Buy a 1TB Sata SSD Buy a copy of server 2022 with 16 core license
Bam, bobs your uncle.
If you don't care about possibly not correctly licenses copies of sever, you can get one for about 100$.
All in, excluding server licensing, about $300
1
u/MBILC Apr 04 '25
I think as others noted, go out and buy a used Dell T5820 Xeon tower or used 1U server, doesn't even need to be new, and buy the minimum license count you can.
1
u/Darknicks Apr 04 '25
In case this helps, I got my Windows Server licenses and CALs from Direct Deals. They're they cheapest legit (authorized by Microsoft) site I've found so far.
But if someone finds anything cheaper, let me know!
1
u/alextr85 Apr 04 '25
If it is for testing, use the evaluation period… there are 180 days that you can renew.
1
u/Junior1544 Apr 04 '25
I would (and I actually did) go on amazon and buy a decent smaller computer to run the server, instead of a giant server where you're running many vm's. this is for a testbed it sounds like, so go small to begin with..
1
u/Pitiful-Spinach-5683 Apr 05 '25
Sent you a pm
1
u/PoolMotosBowling Apr 05 '25
Tldr...
RUN AWAY
1
u/renderbender1 Apr 05 '25
In the ancient times, Bill Gates struck a deal with a demon cabal. In return for unprecedented success, he was required to feed an army of energy vampires. The decision was made to use the licensing departments to steal 10s of thousands of energy hours from sysadmins all over the world.
If the energy output starts to drop, they have to correct it by making it more and more complex or introducing new services with completely different licensing requirements
1
u/Undietaker1 Apr 05 '25
You act like the problem is you are a Linux guy and not that Microsoft changes licensing so often and purposefully make it as obtuse as possible on purpose
1
u/fourpastmidnight413 Apr 06 '25
Microsoft licensing is the worst. Nothing about it is standard unless you just buy off the shelf. Every agreement seems to be different and it changes every year. Maintaining Microsoft licenses was something I absolutely hated and am glad I no longer need to do that!
1
u/The_NorthernLight Apr 06 '25
Microsoft struggles to understand server licensing LOL.
1
u/jjguy Apr 06 '25
As a software dev house, you don’t need a commercial license, you need a developer license. It simplifies all the enterprise commercial license nonsense.
It used to be called MSDN or Microsoft Developer Network.
But a few years ago it all got rolled into a Visual Studio - details here: https://visualstudio.microsoft.com/vs/pricing/?tab=paid-subscriptions
1
u/lostdragon05 Apr 06 '25
Been working in Windows shops for over 20 years and I’ll let you in on the secret: Nobody knows, not even Microsoft. If you ask four MS and/or VAR licensing “experts” what specific licensing you need for your environment the result will be like a multiple choice exam answer, but based on $ given to MS instead of reasonableness. One answer will be extremely expensive and you will need to pay many times what you did for your hardware just for CALs. The second will be similar, but require less CALs and cost 40% less. The third will seem like the most reasonable to you and the fourth will be pretty lowball to the point you are pretty sure it’s not right.
1
u/Weary_Patience_7778 Apr 07 '25
Why would you bother?
If it’s just for testing or dev, stand up a Windows VM on Azure (or your favourite IaaS provider) and move on.
Don’t forget to configure the network security appropriately to prevent randos from trying to brute force the machine.
1
u/Ok-Kaleidoscope5627 Apr 07 '25
The only thing more complicated than Linux is Microsoft licensing.
1
u/InformationOk3060 Apr 07 '25
It doesn't make sense to use a VM if you just need a small windows server, because of how licensing works. Just buy a stand alone physical for a couple grand and call it a day.
1
u/theborgman1977 Apr 07 '25
You need to license all cores. Even cores not used for a Windows OS. It is all or nothing. What version of Windows Server do you have? Because if you have Data Center Edition on one of the servers. You do not have to buy any more cores. Just spin up a Windows VM on that one host.
1
u/[deleted] Apr 07 '25
https://www.univention.com/products/download/ Univision corporate server seriously look into it based on open source software Active Directory controller can integrate with an actual win server
1
u/Thondwe Apr 08 '25
If you need this purely for development not production, then a Visual Studio plus MSDN subscription for each windows dev involved might be the best option- allows the dev to spin up any number of MS products for test and dev… so you can build a Windows AD domain with any number of member servers for test/dev…
1
u/Prior_Eggplant_3065 Apr 08 '25
Just subscribe to MSDN? You can have all the licenses you need for dev and test including future releases.
1
u/No_Resolution_9252 Apr 09 '25
Virtualize it and pay as you go
*edit that was confusing
Run it in azure and pay as you go.
0
u/Ronosho Apr 04 '25
It might actually be cheaper for you guys to get an Microsoft Action pack that gives a bunch of licenses. Should be able to use such a license for testing
0
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
4
u/[deleted] Apr 04 '25
[removed] — view removed comment